Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect a 5 and 8 year old to be able to pack their own overnight bag?

491 replies

CrumpledCrumpet · 02/01/2022 11:25

I’ve asked 8 and 5yo DS’s to pack PJs and a change of clothes in a bag about half an hour ago. Despite increasingly stroppy reminders from me to stay on task, no progress is being made. AIBU to expect children of their age to be able to do this? I’m exasperated!

OP posts:
multivac · 02/01/2022 14:10

I mean, iirc, 'being able to follow a 2-step instruction' (get your PJs and put them in this bag') is something you would expect, developmentally, from around 24 months. I think people are confusing what the OP actually described happening with a situation in their heads whereby the OP said to her 5-year-old 'right, we are off trekking through the rainforest for three weeks; get everything you'll need and find a sturdy rucksack!'

liveforsummer · 02/01/2022 14:10

@bubblesbubbles11

way too young to expect this. The 8 year old MAYBE, but assuming the bag and clothes they need are very near at hand and the 8 year old knows where they all are at the time you set the task.
The Op has left for her stay. The dc packed their bags. The ability wasn't the issue, the messing around was.
liveforsummer · 02/01/2022 14:09

I honestly think parents underestimate what their young dc are capable of . Even 5 year olds who get everything done for them at home will be packing their bag at the end of the school day. The ones not used to it will struggle at first but learn very quickly.

bubblesbubbles11 · 02/01/2022 14:08

way too young to expect this.

The 8 year old MAYBE, but assuming the bag and clothes they need are very near at hand and the 8 year old knows where they all are at the time you set the task.

llantwitminor · 02/01/2022 14:05

Eight year old yes, not necessarily the five year old.

G5000 · 02/01/2022 14:03

to her, wearing a wedding dress & wellies every day & a bikini for the beach... in mid winter UK, was perfectly acceptable

Again, OP did not say that they need to figure out what to pack for a weeks holiday. She gave them an exact list of very limited number of items.

Whattochoosenow · 02/01/2022 14:02

This is so interesting- children today seem to be able to do less and less for themselves. When my two went on their p7 trip they had to show their roommates how to put a duvet cover on. I remember once sitting in a parent council meeting discussing packed lunches, and parents were still cutting up apples for 10/11 year olds!
A 5 year old should be quite capable of putting pjs and a change of clothes in a bag, in the same way they should be capable of laying out their school uniform for the next day, or packing a school bag.

ListeningButNotHearing · 02/01/2022 14:01

I think it's really good that you are training them to do this.
But I would say the 5 year old is a bit too young and would need your guidance.

BeardieWeirdie · 02/01/2022 14:01

Yanbu, packing pjs, knickers, new top/bottoms and a toothbrush isn’t difficult - especially if given that list verbally. I think it’s really important to foster independence in children. At 4, mine could get their own breakfast but I imagine that’s tantamount to child abuse on MN.

Confrontayshunme · 02/01/2022 14:00

My kids are hugely more independent from experiencing other children all the time at work, but my 9yo can only just pack a bag herself. If it doesn't matter what the clothes are, the 5yo can do it, but she forgets pants. A pictorial list would probably enable this earlier.

G5000 · 02/01/2022 14:00

What they consider essential is very different to what an adult knows they need.

OP told the children exactly what they need to put into the bags. Bags that she also provided.

RockinHorseShit · 02/01/2022 13:59

@G5000

Of course it's about teaching them, that's why you help,them & don't just tell them what you expect & leave them too it, they learn by you doing it with them & explaining why you pack certain things & how to pack them properly. The average 5 yo cannot manage that alone that's not how a 5 yo brain works.

I remember mine at 6, once packing a dress up wedding dress, 4 pairs of wellies & a bikini. She had the correct number or pants & socks though, but to her, wearing a wedding dress & wellies every day & a bikini for the beach... in mid winter UK, was perfectly acceptable

G5000 · 02/01/2022 13:58

For people who for some reason do not want to read OPs posts:
I didn’t just say ‘pack your bag’, I’d given them both an empty bag and asked them to put PJ’s, joggers, t-shirt, pants and socks in it

Yes an average 5yo can follow instructions if you tell them: 'take this bag and put your PJs in it.' They would not be able to manage at school otherwise.

pitterpatterrain · 02/01/2022 13:58

My DC (8,5) managed to pick clothes out for a 2 week holiday so yes I would expect them pretty easily to get an overnight bag ready

For the youngest I would check and likely add a few bits and pieces in case they splat their outfits with food

Eldest I don’t bother checking anymore

On the same page as liveforsummer

shouldistop · 02/01/2022 13:57

I have a relatively independent 5yo and he would choose what to take with promoting and physically put the things in the bag but I'd need to be in the room with him reminding him what he'd need.
Your expectations are too high.

SmallOrFarAway · 02/01/2022 13:57

My 5yo could and does regularly pack her own bag for her overnight at her dads. But I always check it. Generally she's pretty reliable at it but not always. Once she'd packed only pj tops and umpteen soft toys. Another time she had exactly everything needed. So hit and miss! My 7yo would get distracted and just pack Lego so I help him do his.

knittingaddict · 02/01/2022 13:56

My grandchildren (6 and 7) seem to live in a suitcase these days, for unavoidable reasons. No way would I expect them to pack their own bags. What they consider essential is very different to what an adult knows they need. They would end up with lots of toy dinosaurs and no underpants.

liveforsummer · 02/01/2022 13:51

You're a teacher and yet you've never realised that DCs starting school might try to do as little as possible or be overwhelmed with a new environment? The fact they don't do it automatically for you in school doesn't mean they aren't doing those exact tasks at home.
But also if you expect 5 and 8 yr-old siblings to pack with no guidance and not distract each other, then I'd assume you've not actually worked with DCs for that long.

You'd assume wrong. And OP gave them guidance. One pair of pyjamas and one outfit. On top of that I have dc of the same age gap as OP who have been packing their bags for a long time. My 8 year old is so methodical about it now- she really enjoys it. (Although she was younger than 8 last time she packed for more than a few days - thanks covid).
As I already said I am not a teacher. The teachers are far stricter about doing these things independently than I. They like to get it established ASAP but of course allowances are made at the start of term. I disagree the ones that struggle are doing it all independently at home. I believe as do all the teaching staff I've ever worked with, that there is a direct link between the ones who have everything done for them at home and the ones who struggle with basic routines and instructions at school. (Asn aside of course)

NannyGythaOgg · 02/01/2022 13:47

When my were that age the 5 year old (girl) would do it straight away, The 8 year old (boy) wouldn't stand a chance and the 5 year old would have ended up doing it for him.

Gingerbreadrules · 02/01/2022 13:47

I wouldn't trust my 11 year old to pack sensibly without supervision. If I ask him to pack a bag I would tell him what he needs, and then afterwards I would run through a list again, have you packed pants, socks etc. Even my 15 year old forgets underwear if she packs on her own!!

5 and 8 you could do it with them but no way would I expect them to do it alone without any help.

SmellyNelliey · 02/01/2022 13:46

We do things by lists in our home so I've children of the same age they can both read so would both be able to do this, I've also a 3 year old and we would do this together with a picture list.

dannydyerismydad · 02/01/2022 13:43

DH once went away for a weekend with no pants or socks. If I can't trust an adult I certainly wouldn't trust a child.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 02/01/2022 13:42

I had this with 14 year old…. But little ones- no😂

liveforsummer · 02/01/2022 13:41

@timeisnotaline

Now that my 6yo can read I wrote him a list for the holiday we are just back from, and had him put them out in piles so I could check them. I had to keep him on task- ‘now look at the list again, have you got one pile for every line?’ The list was like 3 x tshirts, 1 x long sleeve tshirt, 2 x shorts, 1 x trousers etc . Before that no, he couldn’t do it.
It's not a holiday though. It's an over night trip with one set of pyjamas and one outfit so list isn't really needed
NellieBertram · 02/01/2022 13:40

I love that the responses to this are 50%
Don't be ridiculous! Of course these tiny ikkle babbies can't pack a case!
and 50%
What's wrong with you? If your 5yo can't pack a case then there's either some problem with him or you!
Grin

Swipe left for the next trending thread