Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

'You'll never do that' -AIBU to hate people saying this?

38 replies

Cejvs · 02/01/2022 10:34

It really gets my goat when people dismiss what I'm saying with an airy you'll never do that/ you won't do it.

Latest example, and I know this is completely petty, I was sitting in the living room saying to DP that I was really pleased with how I'd arranged our Christmas trees/ decs this year and was going to take some photos so next year I could have that as a reminder to do it the same way. Oh you'll never do that was his response.

I found this massively irritating and told him so. He then said oh well I shouldn't say anything/ pardon me for speaking which is his default whenever I don't automatically agree with what he says.

I tried to explain why this annoys me, I've had a lot of people over the years tell me I won't or can't do things. Worst one was when I was in an abusive, shitty relationship years ago and my then closest friends, when I used to talk about how unhappy I was and was desperate to get out (but was financially trapped), used to say you'll never leave him. I did leave, no thanks to my friends though.

DP just doesn't get it, and just went down the he was only making a comment because I WON'T do it, and I'm the one being unreasonable.

So am I?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CloverGreen · 03/01/2022 17:45

I do know a lot of people who are "all talk and no action" but yet like to tell me what I'll never do ie. I join in conversation about tattoos as I'm interested in the subject and they say "oh but you'd never get a tattoo". It's very tempting to pull my trousers down and show them my 4 tattoos!

Excitedforthefuture · 03/01/2022 17:28

I don’t think I can ever recall anyone ever saying this to me! Ever

IncompleteSenten · 03/01/2022 17:22

Maybe try replying really? Why do you think that? And see what they say.

Cejvs · 03/01/2022 17:16

It does feel a bit dismissive. He doesn't do it all the time, he'd be an ex if he did!

I think I've probably always had big ideas and plans, and a lot of the people I know don't. I'm sure some of them thought I had 'ideas above my station' - it started at school when I wanted to go to uni (not the norm at my school) and do what was seen as a competitive degree...and its gone from there. Jobs I've applied for, working full time when my DC were small, even stupid stuff like decorating my house, there's always been someone saying oh you'll never do that.

That at least is an improvement on my Ex who spent years telling me that I was incapable of most things, not just that I wouldn't do them but that I couldn't.

OP posts:
GreenWhiteViolet · 03/01/2022 13:07

YANBU.

I have a family member that does this all the time. As a young person I had no confidence and usually when they said it to me, I believed them and didn't even try.

Now I tend to respond with 'yes I will' and what I get back are reasons why I shouldn't do it, why I wouldn't succeed, and strong suggestions that I should do alternative things which I have no interest in. I tune most of it out. 'You'll never go to the gym' with a little laugh, and then when I did 'you shouldn't lift weights at the gym, it's not good for you, you should just use the treadmill instead' Hmm

I think sometimes we do recognise that a person declaring they're going to do something probably won't persevere with it or is unlikely to enjoy it - but unless there are significant consequences for failing or quitting whatever it is, it's much better to say nothing than to be negative. Taking photos of decorations to use again definitely doesn't fall into that category, even if he genuinely does think you won't do it.

RobotValkyrie · 03/01/2022 12:47

It's rudely dismissive and entirely unhelpful, quite frankly you'd be a bit mad if you enjoyed being put down for no good reason.

Your DH sounds like a twat.

Aburg163 · 03/01/2022 12:40

Yanbu! I think it's so rude when people say this. Even if there's a history, like my mum talks a lot about courses she's going to do or fields she will train in and often doesn't begin ( think we are all guilty of this sometimes ) but I would never dream of saying you'll never do that. It is so rude and actually quite hurtful if you think about it. It's like saying 'whatever you're declaring to me I can see through and for whatever reason I don't believe you're capable of achieving that'. Rude rude rude don't blame you for being annoyed.

BillMasen · 03/01/2022 12:18

@lottiegarbanzo

Why so snippy?

Because I find the behaviour of people who talk as if their only reference point is themselves and their own experience, who cannot seem to believe that others truly experience things that they have not experienced themselves, or that such experiences could be just as authentic and important as their own, tedious and conversation-blocking.

It happens rather a lot on MN.

And yet you’re the one explaining how most people think out loud and don’t do everything they say they will.

I’m suggesting different personalities might act differently

lottiegarbanzo · 03/01/2022 12:11

Why so snippy?

Because I find the behaviour of people who talk as if their only reference point is themselves and their own experience, who cannot seem to believe that others truly experience things that they have not experienced themselves, or that such experiences could be just as authentic and important as their own, tedious and conversation-blocking.

It happens rather a lot on MN.

oneglassandpuzzled · 03/01/2022 12:02

@Cejvs

It really gets my goat when people dismiss what I'm saying with an airy you'll never do that/ you won't do it.

Latest example, and I know this is completely petty, I was sitting in the living room saying to DP that I was really pleased with how I'd arranged our Christmas trees/ decs this year and was going to take some photos so next year I could have that as a reminder to do it the same way. Oh you'll never do that was his response.

I found this massively irritating and told him so. He then said oh well I shouldn't say anything/ pardon me for speaking which is his default whenever I don't automatically agree with what he says.

I tried to explain why this annoys me, I've had a lot of people over the years tell me I won't or can't do things. Worst one was when I was in an abusive, shitty relationship years ago and my then closest friends, when I used to talk about how unhappy I was and was desperate to get out (but was financially trapped), used to say you'll never leave him. I did leave, no thanks to my friends though.

DP just doesn't get it, and just went down the he was only making a comment because I WON'T do it, and I'm the one being unreasonable.

So am I?

Three times I have done things after being told I’d never do them:

. Never be a writer. Now nine times published. Publishers didn’t seem to agree with person who said this.

. Never get a playground built in our village. Done.

. Never express milk and freeze it. Done for both babies.

Tell me I won’t be able to do something and you are lighting a touch paper.

BillMasen · 03/01/2022 12:02

@lottiegarbanzo

Um, she's already answered that point BillMasen as I've already told you...

Maybe read the thread?

Why so snippy?

I have and it’s not clear if she does this a lot with other people too. I was also just “thinking out loud” about different personality types…

lottiegarbanzo · 03/01/2022 11:58

Um, she's already answered that point BillMasen as I've already told you...

Maybe read the thread?

lottiegarbanzo · 03/01/2022 11:56

Also I find that most people who say 'you'll never do that' are talking about themselves, projecting. It's comforting for them to think that no-one else will ever do anything either. It justifies their own laziness, lack of ambition or joie de vivre.

BillMasen · 03/01/2022 11:54

@lottiegarbanzo

OP has already answered that question BillMasen.

The thing is, most people think out loud a bit, as a way of discussing ideas with the people they live with, or discovering whether they make as much sense when said out loud, as in their head. I wouldn't expect anyone to do everything they say they'll do. Unless it is only those things about which they say 'I will do this right now', then fail to get up out of their chair.

Perhaps op is the sort who frequently “thinks out loud” with plans that never happen whilst her partner tends to think quietly and only announce a plan when it’ll definitely happen. To him, it seems like she never follows through.

I still wonder if lots of people say to her that she’ll not follow through that she does this a lot? Like I say, it’s never happened to me (I must be an internal planner not a thinker out loud)

lottiegarbanzo · 03/01/2022 11:51

Sometimes it's great just to do things, with no discussion. Follow your own thoughts with no regard to others. (Only works for individual projects that don't affect others, obviously!). It can help when you live with negative nellies, as they don't get the chance to drag you down or pollute your beautiful idea.

Then it just emerges that actually, you already do something.

Most people have lots of ideas, try a number of things and stick with a few. That's normal.

You can talk yourself out of things though, or allow yourself to be talked out of them. Too much thought can inhibit action. Sometimes taking the plunge then thinking by doing works really well.

lottiegarbanzo · 03/01/2022 11:45

OP has already answered that question BillMasen.

The thing is, most people think out loud a bit, as a way of discussing ideas with the people they live with, or discovering whether they make as much sense when said out loud, as in their head. I wouldn't expect anyone to do everything they say they'll do. Unless it is only those things about which they say 'I will do this right now', then fail to get up out of their chair.

BillMasen · 03/01/2022 11:42

@Rockbird

Ugh, getting this now. I have wanted to learn bass guitar for years. So last week at the age of 50 I thought sod it and bought the one I'd been hankering after. A very cheap one btw but gorgeous and a solid beginner instrument. The amount of ridicule and complete denial that I'll ever play a note on it are starting to completely piss me off. It's arriving in about an hour and I can't bloody wait to get started and shut them up!
You go for it Bass is great, I’m pushing 50 and been playing 20 years.
BillMasen · 03/01/2022 11:40

My partner has a habit of saying she’ll do something then it never happens. It can be really hard sometime to not say “no you won’t” when something gets suggested or promised.

Do you have a tendency to say you’ll do things then not? I can’t say anyone has ever told me I won’t do something but it happens to you lots?

billy1966 · 03/01/2022 11:35

Negative people are very draining to live with.

If he is like that, re think the relationship.

Rockbird · 03/01/2022 11:32

Ugh, getting this now. I have wanted to learn bass guitar for years. So last week at the age of 50 I thought sod it and bought the one I'd been hankering after. A very cheap one btw but gorgeous and a solid beginner instrument. The amount of ridicule and complete denial that I'll ever play a note on it are starting to completely piss me off. It's arriving in about an hour and I can't bloody wait to get started and shut them up!

lottiegarbanzo · 03/01/2022 11:31

...and that he has a choice about whether and how he does this. He could choose to keep his thoughts to himself. He could make careful choices about what he says out loud, what he says to you.

lottiegarbanzo · 03/01/2022 11:29

I think the thing to reflect back to him is how his negative behaviour makes other people feel. That he isn't just expressing his own feelings into a void, or in a harmless way. Rather, that he has a power to affect other people, their feelings and experiences, that is real, outside him and that he might not fully recognise.

Cejvs · 03/01/2022 11:12

He doesn't enjoy Christmas at all (he objects to the excess of it all) so that is probably a factor.

OP posts:
lottiegarbanzo · 03/01/2022 09:23

Yes, well you do sound quite normal and he sounds like a Debbie Downer.

Cejvs · 02/01/2022 23:43

I did the pictures later in the day (it was daylight at the time so I waited till it was darker). I didn't make a big point of telling him I'd done them though.

OP posts: