Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't want to be in contact with friend who is having ex marital affair but being made to feel guilty

211 replies

MrsPatrickDempsey · 02/01/2022 08:07

V close friend has admitted to an affair of 6 months (married for a considerable period of time with children).

Friend is currently splitting time between living with their own family and other man. Friend is in turmoil; is distraught with guilt regarding the impact of her actions. Wants to be with other man but is committed to children (older teens).
Friend told me all of the details as affair became uncovered. I just listened with no judgement but have not been in contact since as I am angry about her actions because of the hurt she has brought on her family.
A mutual friend who also knows about the circumstances suggested to me that I should contact affair friend and support her, implying loosely that I am mean for not doing so and adding to affair friend’s distress as she is upset that I haven’t been in touch since her disclosure. I feel guilty but Aibu in not wanting to be in touch? A) it’s not really any of my business B) I can’t be supportive/empathic/sympathetic of her actions
C) don’t know what to say and don’t want to listen to the details again or about problems she has created.
If she contacted me I wouldn’t ignore her and would respond accordingly but I want to keep out of it. It is the only thing consuming her at the moment and there would be nothing else to talk about.
Would appreciate some clarity.

OP posts:
whiteroseredrose · 02/01/2022 09:18

People in happy marriages don’t have affairs.

I disagree. FIL adored MIL from the minute he saw her. Still does.

His short affair was during a major life change and health scare.

Beautiful3 · 02/01/2022 09:15

People aren't perfect, they make bad decisions/mistakes. She's your friend, you shouldn't judge her. Just continue being her friend.

LostForIdeas · 02/01/2022 09:15

IMO there's nothing wrong with judging someone for making selfish choices that hurt a lot of people, repeatedly, every day, and then whining about how much they themselves are suffering.

Except that most people make at some point choices that are selfish/stupid and then are struggling with it.
You could argue that a woman who is staying with an abusive man is doing exactely that, hurting her dcs etc…
Same with smoking, being overweight/obese, unhealthy relationships. The list is endless really.

That’s a hell of a lot of people that should be refused support form their friends tbh….

SarahJessicaParker1 · 02/01/2022 09:14

I judge my friends on what they do in relation to me. Not how they deal with their private lives.

I bet it's both to a point, you just haven't had a friend do something you find truly abhorrent yet. I personally don't find affairs to be the worst thing anyone can do by a long way, so a good friend doing it for understandable reasons, yes I'd support them too. But op feels how she feels and I bet there are other circumstances. You can't make a blanket rule either way. Your blanket rule "I would support them" is as silly as the reverse.

Womencanlift · 02/01/2022 09:14

It comes down to each persons values and standards. Personally I don’t value the type of person who has an affair (like a pp I had my childhood torn about because of one) so therefore I do judge and have cut off people who have made that choice…. and yes it is a choice.

As the saying goes you make your bed you lie in it and if that means you lose friends who don’t want to be part of your circus then so be it. Consequence of having an affair I guess

So OP I don’t blame you for wanting to cut this person and their drama out of your life. Your own life is far too short to be dealing with friends like this

Springlikely · 02/01/2022 09:12

Life is complex, unpredictable and messy. You never know what's going on in other people's relationships, not really. As per the OP people in the relationship don't know what's going on half the time. It's nice to believe that people shouldn't behave like this but it is naive to think they don't, and that you will never know some of the reasoning behind it, especially if you don't want to find out. Judemental people make these situations worse, so if you can't be there for her I'd bow out honestly. If I were you I'd also be wanting to understand my own stance on this, blanket judgements are often based on insecurity and fear.

HopelesslydevotedtoGu · 02/01/2022 09:12

I would have a no nonsense talk with a good friend about what they are going to do now. I don't think sympathetic "support" is going to be helpful to them, as it may encourage them to continue with the ridiculous situation of being emotionally "in turmoil" but continuing to divide their time between their family home and the other man.

What I'd say is, you've created a situation which is bad for you, your kids, your DH. Rather than wallowing in your upset, you need to make decisions about what to do next. Letting this situation continue is harming everybody, and it won't improve on its own.

If you want to try and stay with your family, you must cut contact with the other man, and start proving to your DH that you are committed to restoring the marriage. If you want to end your marriage, you need to have a mature conversation with your DH about doing this, and how to minimise harm to your teens. Don't assume the affair relationship will necessarily last - make a decision about your marriage in itself, not choosing between the two men.

You can't continue with the current situation, you need to make decisions. And you need to think about how to reduce the harm to your kids of whatever choices you make.

I'd not cut a good friend off completely.
People do get themselves into stupid situations. I'd hope if I made bad decisions that a good friend would talk to me in a caring but challenging way, to get me to sort myself out. But I'd not want to be full of "oh poor you" sympathy, I don't think that would help your friend in the long run.

blablablablablablablabla · 02/01/2022 09:11

@twominutesmore

"Life can get messy and complicated and judgemental people make it worse."

I don't know why 'judgmental' is thrown around like a dirty word. IMO there's nothing wrong with judging someone for making selfish choices that hurt a lot of people, repeatedly, every day, and then whining about how much they themselves are suffering.

I don't blame you for keeping out of it op. That way you will be able to look her dh and dc in the eye when it inevitably implodes.

Just as we don't have to forgive our partners, parents, siblings every bad behaviour, not do we have to forgive our friends. It's fine to find this behaviour repugnant, narcissistic, deal breaking.

I judge my friends on what they do in relation to me. Not how they deal with their private lives.

That's not what friendship is about, for me.

I would and have supported a friend through something like this and I would do it again. No judgements.

KarmaStar · 02/01/2022 09:11

Yabu.You are not being a friend,you are judging her,finding her guilty and condemning her.
She's probably better off without you there as she needs a true friend to support her without the silent,passive aggressive behaviour.

Boombastic22 · 02/01/2022 09:08

Gosh you’re very judgy OP. A lot of people have affairs. Sounds like you’re not a very supportive friend so she’s definitely better off without you. You have no real idea if the impact on her husband, very easy to point the finger. I suspect your friend has been very unhappy for a long time. People in happy marriages don’t have affairs.

twominutesmore · 02/01/2022 09:07

"Life can get messy and complicated and judgemental people make it worse."

I don't know why 'judgmental' is thrown around like a dirty word. IMO there's nothing wrong with judging someone for making selfish choices that hurt a lot of people, repeatedly, every day, and then whining about how much they themselves are suffering.

I don't blame you for keeping out of it op. That way you will be able to look her dh and dc in the eye when it inevitably implodes.

Just as we don't have to forgive our partners, parents, siblings every bad behaviour, not do we have to forgive our friends. It's fine to find this behaviour repugnant, narcissistic, deal breaking.

SarahJessicaParker1 · 02/01/2022 09:05

Also, beware that you may get caught in the crossfire if and when it all comes out.

Again, this is from experience with dickhead family member who crucified me for not telling her something (not even to do with her or her relationship). Teenagers are probably more reasonable than my family member, but they aren't known for being measured. I'd avoid the whole situation tbh, unless you know it will resolve itself without major drama (ie the married couple are all but separated)

Flingingmelon · 02/01/2022 09:00

What @DrSbaitso said. Good luck OP - it's hard when a friendship is tested.

gogohm · 02/01/2022 08:59

Kind of depends on the circumstances, was she in a loveless marriage or simply staying together for the kids/appearances? Does her husband have affairs? Was the marriage falling apart anyway? My ex left me but I did quite quickly meet dp, I split my time between my home (exh had a separate room we decided not to sell until they left university) with my then young adult kids and my Dp's place then moved in with him properly, one dd decided to move in with me Confused

Lucked · 02/01/2022 08:58

You say she is splitting time between her family and the man. Does that mean her husband is currently accepting the situation? How does she keep it secret if she is at the other mans house?

KiloWhat · 02/01/2022 08:56

I personally would go with something like @DrSbaitso suggests. But if you really can't then that's fine too.

SarahJessicaParker1 · 02/01/2022 08:55

Strong *

blablablablablablablabla · 02/01/2022 08:55

If you want to cut her off or back off as people here are suggesting you do, then that’s fair enough, but it’s not what real friendship is about.
If your sibling or your child behaved like this, would you cut them off? Of course not - so you don’t do it to a proper friend either.

This

SarahJessicaParker1 · 02/01/2022 08:54

I actually don't think op should be encouraged to check in on her.

I think, as I said earlier, although I'd probably support some friends doing similar, you feel how you feel. If you can't be around her, do not be. You do not owe her support or friendship. She is the one who has created the problem, so she can deal with it.

Only thinking this, as, putting myself in op's shoes, if someone said "aw if you love family member, you should check how she's doing" I'd probably find that pressure a little unfair. Why should an innocent bystander be pressured into caring for someone who is in a drama of their own making? BUT, depends on the history. My family member is a nasty piece of work in other ways too. If it was someone I normally adored and had a string friendship with, I'd probably feel differently

KiloWhat · 02/01/2022 08:54

Up to you. No one is perfect. You could help her talk through her feelings and support her and encourage her if she wants to tell her husband.
Or you could walk away.

It's up to you 100% but remember she is a human nor a robot and people screw up.

notanothertakeaway · 02/01/2022 08:53

I think it's reasonable to re-assess friendships, when people show that they don't share your values

I like the wording suggested by @DrSbaitso at 08.44

whiteroseredrose · 02/01/2022 08:51

@blablablablablablablabla

Imagine a man losing all his friends because he had an affair.. wouldn't happen.
Actually it does. Friend's DH had an affair with his first girlfriend when they bumped into eachother. They have since split up and he is no longer included. My friend is.

In OP's situation I'd say that nice people can do stupid and unpleasant things sometimes. I'd contact her, say friend has suggested that you do, and that you will support her in giving up the affair and then trying to work things out with her DH, even if it leads to a split. But you refuse to talk about OM.

FWIW we are currently dealing with the fall out from MIL just discovering that FIL had an affair 25 years ago. It is bloody awful. They are in their 80s and this should have been addressed at the time. She feels that all those years have been a lie and is distraught at having to split up at 87.

ImInStealthMode · 02/01/2022 08:51

I don't blame you OP. Affairs are a deal-breaker for me in either relationships and friendships, having had my childhood completely ripped apart by two.

Some year ago a single friend of mine was seeing a married Man. I tried very hard not to let it affect how I viewed her to begin with, but when she stayed with him despite knowing that his wife was pregnant I couldn't do it any more. I can't be friends with someone I have no respect for so I walked away.

I think the idea that you can ignore one flaw in a person's character when it's such a grating one for you is a strange one. I couldn't be friends with a racist because 'they're a good person otherwise' no more than I could be friends with someone prepared to willingly (never 'by mistake') gamble with their partner and children's happiness and emotional security.

saraclara · 02/01/2022 08:50

@blablablablablablablabla

Imagine a man losing all his friends because he had an affair.. wouldn't happen.
I'm not sure what that's got to do with anything.

However, quite apart from the fact that this woman hasn't lost ALL her friends (just OP) you're wrong. I do know of a man who lost at least two of his friends because he had an affair.

anon12345678901 · 02/01/2022 08:50

@MrsPatrickDempsey

Thanks everyone. I really appreciate your replies and I think the differing responses actually confirm the complexity of my feelings. God it so hard.
It's a very difficult decision. I guess you need to think and decide is she a good friend that you would like in your life in future? Have you missed speaking to her? You can say to her you don't agree with her behaviour and don't want any part in it, including talking about it and the other man. Ultimately it's up to you, she hasn't gone into this blindly, it's not a mistake as she's been doing it for 6 months, she knows what she's doing will hurt people and is carrying on. Tbh you did judge by not speaking to her, but I think most people would judge someone in this situation. Even if they don't mean to. So don't be hard on yourself for finding it difficult to know what to do, as you see from here, there's several posters who wouldn't either. Could you explain to her that you don't support her actions? Thing is, if you continue your friendship as is, she may start to give these details and if it implodes, come for sympathy.