Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't want to be in contact with friend who is having ex marital affair but being made to feel guilty

211 replies

MrsPatrickDempsey · 02/01/2022 08:07

V close friend has admitted to an affair of 6 months (married for a considerable period of time with children).

Friend is currently splitting time between living with their own family and other man. Friend is in turmoil; is distraught with guilt regarding the impact of her actions. Wants to be with other man but is committed to children (older teens).
Friend told me all of the details as affair became uncovered. I just listened with no judgement but have not been in contact since as I am angry about her actions because of the hurt she has brought on her family.
A mutual friend who also knows about the circumstances suggested to me that I should contact affair friend and support her, implying loosely that I am mean for not doing so and adding to affair friend’s distress as she is upset that I haven’t been in touch since her disclosure. I feel guilty but Aibu in not wanting to be in touch? A) it’s not really any of my business B) I can’t be supportive/empathic/sympathetic of her actions
C) don’t know what to say and don’t want to listen to the details again or about problems she has created.
If she contacted me I wouldn’t ignore her and would respond accordingly but I want to keep out of it. It is the only thing consuming her at the moment and there would be nothing else to talk about.
Would appreciate some clarity.

OP posts:
BoodleBug51 · 02/01/2022 10:06

My Dad had an affair, and it completely shattered my family apart. Mum had a nervous breakdown and tried to kill herself. Dad was happy with his shiny new young partner (she was 22, Dad was 46) and didn't care that my sister and I were bounced from relative to relative until Mum was well enough to come out of the psychiatric unit she'd been placed in a year later. And I then had to become her carer as she was in no fit state to look after herself let alone two kids.

When a close friend in a group of school mums confided in me she was having an affair with another mums DH, I was horrified.... because I knew the other mum really well and they had a child with complex medical issues. She was such a kind gentle person, and when she sobbed on my shoulder about how absent her DH had become, I was nearly sick. I stopped all contact with the mum having the affair, but I was still caught in the crossfire when it all came out...... it was horrible.

There is never an excuse for having an affair. Never. If you're that unhappy, end the relationship you're in and move on. The devastation from that is nothing to the devastation that an affair causes.

SarahJessicaParker1 · 02/01/2022 10:05

@GoodbyePorpoiseSpit

I stand by my friends whatever they have done as that’s what I think true support is. You can’t support her atm op because you are judging her. That’s the fact of it. but how YOU feel about her actions is obscuring you offering love and friendship. You don’t actually have to condone her, you could just accept her.
That literally cannot be true. What if your friend abused your child? Or their child? Or their partner. I simply don't believe that anyone would be silly enough to stand by their friends no matter what. Reminds me of Fergie coming out in support of her vile exh. Your limit isn't an affair, but I do not believe you have no limits as to what you would support in a friend
GoodbyePorpoiseSpit · 02/01/2022 10:03

I stand by my friends whatever they have done as that’s what I think true support is.
You can’t support her atm op because you are judging her. That’s the fact of it. but how YOU feel about her actions is obscuring you offering love and friendship. You don’t actually have to condone her, you could just accept her.

BlondeDogLady · 02/01/2022 10:03

You sound like a fair weather friend. And really judgy to boot.

In my experience, it takes a long time for a married woman to jump ship. You have no idea what has led her down this path. She must have been extremely unhappy in her marriage to do this.

I discovered who my fair weather friends were, when I left my ExH. My friends of 20 years, didn't stand by me. They didn't even ask why I was leaving. If they had, I could have told them that my H had cheated on me with 10 women, and occasionally beat me up. But no, they didn't ask, no doubt talked about me with pursed lips. Ironically, the one friend who was an absolute rock, had only known me for about 5 years. She was amazing.

I also found that some people (my parents) wanted to keep me in the marriage box. Anything else was too uncomfortable. But you can't confine an unhappy person to a marriage that they don't want to be in any more, just because she thought 20 years ago that was what she wanted. Her H may have changed, she may have changed, as people do. She is allowed to leave him and start a different life if she wants! I certainly did just that and I am very happy with my 2nd DH.

My advice to you would be to support your friend. She needs you now, more than ever. If you can't do that, she will never really see you as a friend when this is over.

hivemindneeded · 02/01/2022 10:02

YANBU. It is very hard for her to take, but she has to accept that part of the fallout of her spectacularly selfish behaviour is that some people will see her in a new light and choose not to be involved with her.

I don't feel compassion for someone who trashes their teenage children to scratch an itch and stir up a bit of drama in their dull life. If her marriage was in trouble she should have either tried to save it or left, taking her children with her and divorced before embarking on an affair. She can;t play 'poor me, I'm in such agony' when she has created such pain for her children and spouse.without prioritising their wellbeing.

BertramLacey · 02/01/2022 10:01

For me it would depend very much on the individual circumstances of the friendship and the affair. A close friend who has otherwise shown themselves to be a good person I would be more forgiving of than a recent friendship with someone I was a bit less sure of. Also, is the man she's having an affair with also married? Thus there are two partners being cheated on. Or is her husband in some way abusive, and this is her way out?

We are complex, fallible and stuff up at times. I've never had an affair but I've done some things which seemed like a good idea at the time and afterwards wondered wtf I was on. So if it were a good friend, I might just listen and see if I could get to the bottom of it, point them towards Relate, try to find out how they'd got themselves into that situation. But if they persisted in being self-deluded, blinkered and hurtful, then I'd be cutting contact.

DrSbaitso · 02/01/2022 09:59

if shed got pissed and driven her car and hit a child and was due up in court for it i wonder how many of the same people would still be saying you should suspend your moral judgement and support her

This is not the first time I've seen people on here equate affairs with killing children.

chaosrabbitland · 02/01/2022 09:55

she knowingly had an affair knowing the hurt and pain it would cause if it became known ,
lets face it when it comes to judgeing , we judge other people all the time , i dont think its cruel or wrong to feel the way you do and not want to become embroiled in it all , at the end of the day this is a mess of her own making and i dont think its unreasonable not to want to prop her up and support her through it if you feel what shes done and is doing is morally wrong .
im not really sure why there are replies along the lines of your a bad friend for not wanting to be involved in it as if shed got pissed and driven her car and hit a child and was due up in court for it i wonder how many of the same people would still be saying you should suspend your moral judgement and support her , very few i imagine ,

i think its important to stay true to your beliefs and not be swayed by others views , if you cant stay true to what you believe then its all a bit lost in my opinion

sassbott · 02/01/2022 09:54

If it’s not clear, I think she’s incredibly self centered and selfish. The fact that she has done this to her own family tells us all that. Her entitlement is now spreading to her friends who she feels should support her. Sounds like a narcissist to me. Stay out of it, a decent human being would not be doing this in the first place and then expecting to be able to pull her friends into it with her.

WhatAHexIGotInto · 02/01/2022 09:53

I wonder what the responses would be from those sympathising with this woman would be, if a man posted that he was cheating on his wife and family with a married woman. You can bet your life he'd be called all the names under the sun.

sassbott · 02/01/2022 09:52

There’s plenty people on here can say about loyalty to friendships and ‘shit happens’. Yes shit does happen, but this isn’t part of it. This is a woman (with her own children) deciding to play games because she wants her own excitement/ to feel loved again/ potentially is miserable in her own marriage (the list is long).

For 6 months she has made an active choice to lie to her children, her partner, her friends. She has chosen to prioritise this man over her family. She has chosen to get naked and get her end away. And for 6 months continued to justify it. She has repeatedly done what she wanted despite the fact that her actions (if found out) could rip her family apart and break the hearts of her children.
Now? She is seeking to share her burden with those around her and make them implicit in her actions by seeking support in some fucked up validation of her actions.

She’s having an affair that could destroy her family. These are her choices. And she needs support? Fuck me I’ve heard it all.

LetHimHaveIt · 02/01/2022 09:48

An affair isn't 'a mistake' - it's a continuing act. She's making that mistake every day. That's fine, but it's on her (and him) and precisely no-one else. And, like a PP, I'm confused as to precisely what kind of 'support' a person shagging around on her husband with a similarly attached man, needs? Whatever it is, she can look to her AP for it. I think what you've done is fine, OP. You're not ending your friendship- you just don't want to hear about it be party to, this aspect of her life. Good for you.

For reference, I also think 'I only judge my friends in relation to what they do to me' is a very fucking sad brag.

WhatAHexIGotInto · 02/01/2022 09:47

I would love to live in the black and white world that so many PPs do. It must be so simple.

@brogueish some people just have a very clear benchmark of behaviour on what they find acceptable. 🤷

beastlyslumber · 02/01/2022 09:46

You can support your friend with compassion whatever you decide. You could decide to continue the friendship but have an honest conversation about the kind of support you are able to give at this time and be clear on your boundaries. E.g. "I don't feel comfortable hearing the details of your affair, but I'm happy to give you a hug when you're tearful." Or, "I don't want to hear the details of your affair, but I can see you are suffering and I'd like to help you find a supportive counsellor." Or, "I don't mind discussing with you the impact on your family and your plans to resolve the situation. But if the conversation strays into your feelings of limerence and self-pity, I will need to step away."

If all you are feeling towards your friend is judgement and disapproval, I think it's fine to say, "I don't feel we can be friends while this situation is going on. I do care about you, but hearing about your situation distresses me and makes me feel negatively towards you. I can't support you through this, so it's best that we are not in touch."

It doesn't make you a bad person if you can't support your friend, but be as honest and compassionate as you can, whatever you decide.

Returnoftheowl · 02/01/2022 09:46

Don't support her if you'd don't want to, but don't say that you're her friend.

Also to say you listened non-judgementally, then immediately cut her off seems a bit of a contradiction.

If you don't feel comfortable supporting her that's fine, but don't expect to remain friends afterwards. If the lost of a friendship isn't an issue then that's fine.

Glowtastic · 02/01/2022 09:44

With a very close friend I would be supportive but would be honest I couldn't lie for her. Humans are messy creatures and relationships and feelings are messy too.

I have ended a friendship however with someone who I know doesn't declare all her income and thus avoids paying tax. She's a thief and stealing from the rest of us. In my mind it makes her a liar and I can't stand being around her.

brogueish · 02/01/2022 09:44

I would love to live in the black and white world that so many PPs do. It must be so simple.

OP, you say that she's a v close friend. But you didn't know about the affair until everyone else did. Are you really that close? I'm also interested in your relationship with her more generally. You don't want to be friends now, so was your friendship based on the fact she was similarly married, kids etc. rather than as a real person? You obviously weren't aware of some aspects of her life so how clued up were you on her marriage? Could well have been a unanimous LTB if we'd heard from her perspective.

I guess the key issue for me would be whether she (as a person, context aside) is someone you want to continue a friendship with, or whether it's disposable. I mean, having an affair isn't award-winning behaviour but neither is it genocide.

Your A, B and C suggest that you don't really want to continue the friendship. As you're taking the moral high ground on this, the fairest thing for you to do is to tell her.

IloveRitaConnors · 02/01/2022 09:35

[quote WhatAHexIGotInto]@blablablablablablablabla a mistake is when you accidentally buy the wrong brand washing powder. You don't accidentally shag another man and carry on an affair. She's made a conscious decision so let's not pretend it's all a romantic mistake.

People can't help how they feel about someone else, but they absolutely can help their own actions in response to that.[/quote]
Exactly this.

People can't then expect others to carry them, through the rough times after they have created the situation either.
I suppose the difference would be if they acknowledge the damage they have caused and asked for help in trying to rectify the damage caused by the affair then I would consider helping as would then have more respect for them owning the mess they've made and their desire to face up to it and put things right. I'd be more likely to give a second chance.
Unless this is the case then I wont entertain it at all.

twominutesmore · 02/01/2022 09:32

"I judge my friends on what they do in relation to me. Not how they deal with their private lives."

I judge people for intentionally and repeatedly hurting other people.

I wouldn't want a friend who hits her kids, for example.

Presumably, as the friend confided fully in op, op has a good handle on the situation. Lots of people are saying that you don't know what's going on behind closed doors, she must have been very unhappy and so on. I think friend would have told op, when confiding, if there were mitigating circumstances.

DrSbaitso · 02/01/2022 09:30

@3scape

Some excellent blaming of the OP. Marriage falling apart is of course upsetting. But the friend turns out to be the sort of person to cheat and has been withhold ing this information anyway. So they're not open, they're not honest etc. I'm not sure why the op is getting so much for being a "bad" friend when it's the cheat who hasn't shared until they HAD to and now expects to dump a load of emotional baggage AND get support AND use other friends to apply guilt to the situation. It's a cheat who is now manipulating how people have to act about the situation. Very much the behaviour of cheaters that they consider themselves to be some sad victims total narcissist behaviour. So .... Not really a friend worth having op
The cheat isn't posting here.

Are you saying she'd get a sympathetic hearing if she did?

TheBestofTimesTheWorstofTimes · 02/01/2022 09:27

@blablablablablablablabla

Well, you're not really a good friend if you're not willing to support your friend through this, sorry.

People make mistakes in life. Get off your judgemental high horse. Your friend knows how much she's messed up. She doesn't need your judgement.

She's better off without you to be fair. Just keep doing what you're doing, but you'll lose a friend. It doesn't sound like you care if that happens because of how disgusting you think she is anyway. So it's a win win for you both.

Wish you were my bank manager when I accidently got myself into debt, and then accidently went on a spending spree and maxed out my credit cards - ooh then accidently didnt pay my mortgage for 6 months...... none of the above is true

Wasnt me guv!! Blame everyone else for my mistakes Hmm and how very dare we be judged for crappy decisions that we are STILL making

@MrsPatrickDempsey I wouldnt ignore her, but would tell her how I feel

3scape · 02/01/2022 09:26

Some excellent blaming of the OP. Marriage falling apart is of course upsetting. But the friend turns out to be the sort of person to cheat and has been withhold ing this information anyway. So they're not open, they're not honest etc. I'm not sure why the op is getting so much for being a "bad" friend when it's the cheat who hasn't shared until they HAD to and now expects to dump a load of emotional baggage AND get support AND use other friends to apply guilt to the situation. It's a cheat who is now manipulating how people have to act about the situation. Very much the behaviour of cheaters that they consider themselves to be some sad victims total narcissist behaviour. So .... Not really a friend worth having op

SarahJessicaParker1 · 02/01/2022 09:26

bury*
that*
friend*

SarahJessicaParker1 · 02/01/2022 09:24

@Slobberstops

My best friend would bury a body for me - having made our friendship a great thing it comes with trust. She would either trust that I needed this or believe I was struggling so would be around either way. I would call her or accept the friendship is over. Your friend is obviously fraught even if you see it as self inflicted.
Not quite Bury a body, but I have friends I'd support through most things. If this was thay sort of friendship, I don't think op would be struggling. It would be an easy decision. So don't tell her to call her. She isn't you and her friend isn't your friendship, with respect
Slobberstops · 02/01/2022 09:21

My best friend would bury a body for me - having made our friendship a great thing it comes with trust. She would either trust that I needed this or believe I was struggling so would be around either way. I would call her or accept the friendship is over. Your friend is obviously fraught even if you see it as self inflicted.