Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't want to be in contact with friend who is having ex marital affair but being made to feel guilty

211 replies

MrsPatrickDempsey · 02/01/2022 08:07

V close friend has admitted to an affair of 6 months (married for a considerable period of time with children).

Friend is currently splitting time between living with their own family and other man. Friend is in turmoil; is distraught with guilt regarding the impact of her actions. Wants to be with other man but is committed to children (older teens).
Friend told me all of the details as affair became uncovered. I just listened with no judgement but have not been in contact since as I am angry about her actions because of the hurt she has brought on her family.
A mutual friend who also knows about the circumstances suggested to me that I should contact affair friend and support her, implying loosely that I am mean for not doing so and adding to affair friend’s distress as she is upset that I haven’t been in touch since her disclosure. I feel guilty but Aibu in not wanting to be in touch? A) it’s not really any of my business B) I can’t be supportive/empathic/sympathetic of her actions
C) don’t know what to say and don’t want to listen to the details again or about problems she has created.
If she contacted me I wouldn’t ignore her and would respond accordingly but I want to keep out of it. It is the only thing consuming her at the moment and there would be nothing else to talk about.
Would appreciate some clarity.

OP posts:
M0rT · 02/01/2022 10:33

The thing is what kind of support are you supposed to be providing?
If your friend or her family member were sick, lost a job, suffered a trauma you would know what to do based on your friendship.
Provide a listening ear, help with money or paperwork, clean the house/bring some cooked meals etc.
But what support does someone having an affair need other than an alibi or to be listened to? You already know you don't want to listen.
Years ago I listened to a single friend having an affair with a married man. She was always having relationship drama, unsuitable men etc and I felt sorry for her.
I stopped listening after she brought him to a party as a friend and he showed pictures of his new baby to someone else at the party.
I didn't drop her but told her I couldn't listen anymore as the pain they would cause if his wife found out had become too real for me.
She dropped me, because all she wanted was an audience.
So I would refuse to talk about her with anyone else as that's just gossip, and if your really worried about her meet up telling her in advance you don't want to hear one word about her affair partner. She may decline to see you in that case but if she doesn't then you can maybe be a help by giving her a break from the drama and talking about less emotionally intense subjects for a while.
As an aside a lot of men don't lose friends after having affairs because they don't expect their friends to listen to them talk about it or offer support.

Shimmyshimmycocobop · 02/01/2022 10:31

I've been in a similar situation quite a few years ago, at the time I was young and newly married and felt very disapproving of my friend as she was also using me as a cover for seeing this man who was also married.
However she was, and still is, my oldest friend and I could see she was desperately unhappy at the time. I now look back and wish I'd been a bit less judgemental and more supportive and have said as much to my friend despite having been on the receiving end of infidelity myself.
Life is difficult and messy at times, if she is a good friend I'd say you can be supportive without condoning her actions.

SarahJessicaParker1 · 02/01/2022 10:29

@Dozer

‘ Life is complex, unpredictable and messy’ ‘people aren’t perfect’

Irrelevant generalisations. OP gets to decide whether or not she wants to remain friends with her friend who has done this specific thing, affecting other specific people.

A PP claims a friend would ‘bury a body’ (commit a crime) for her. Seems unlikely!

Agree.

All very quick with the "don't be so judgey - be a WONDERFUL non judgemental person like me" comments, while nastily coercing another person to act in a way they aren't comfortable with.

chaosrabbitland · 02/01/2022 10:28

@BlondeDogLady

You sound like a fair weather friend. And really judgy to boot.

In my experience, it takes a long time for a married woman to jump ship. You have no idea what has led her down this path. She must have been extremely unhappy in her marriage to do this.

I discovered who my fair weather friends were, when I left my ExH. My friends of 20 years, didn't stand by me. They didn't even ask why I was leaving. If they had, I could have told them that my H had cheated on me with 10 women, and occasionally beat me up. But no, they didn't ask, no doubt talked about me with pursed lips. Ironically, the one friend who was an absolute rock, had only known me for about 5 years. She was amazing.

I also found that some people (my parents) wanted to keep me in the marriage box. Anything else was too uncomfortable. But you can't confine an unhappy person to a marriage that they don't want to be in any more, just because she thought 20 years ago that was what she wanted. Her H may have changed, she may have changed, as people do. She is allowed to leave him and start a different life if she wants! I certainly did just that and I am very happy with my 2nd DH.

My advice to you would be to support your friend. She needs you now, more than ever. If you can't do that, she will never really see you as a friend when this is over.

but this woman has not jumped ship though , shes spent six months living with her unknowing family , screwing another man behind their backs , its not like seperated from him first before then embarking on this relationship , if she had none of this would be as bad , i expect its the deceit and lies that are causing all the pain and shes still carrying it on by staying there to live with her family , dragging out the pain
Dozer · 02/01/2022 10:27

‘ Life is complex, unpredictable and messy’ ‘people aren’t perfect’

Irrelevant generalisations. OP gets to decide whether or not she wants to remain friends with her friend who has done this specific thing, affecting other specific people.

A PP claims a friend would ‘bury a body’ (commit a crime) for her. Seems unlikely!

Gargellen · 02/01/2022 10:27

I agree with your actions OP. While people like this are supported, they carry on.

HumpreyDowny · 02/01/2022 10:27

You sound very judgmental. Do you know much about your friends emotions that led to the affair? There are two people in a relationship and only they are living that relationship. You cannot judge what's going on and unless any of them opens up to you, you shouldn't. Your role as a friend is to support emotionally. Are you really actually friends or just superficial acquaintances?

GiltEdges · 02/01/2022 10:26

@blablablablablablablabla

Well, you're not really a good friend if you're not willing to support your friend through this, sorry.

People make mistakes in life. Get off your judgemental high horse. Your friend knows how much she's messed up. She doesn't need your judgement.

She's better off without you to be fair. Just keep doing what you're doing, but you'll lose a friend. It doesn't sound like you care if that happens because of how disgusting you think she is anyway. So it's a win win for you both.

🙄

OP, it's fine. Sometimes people turn out to be something other than what we thought they were. Your friend's moral compass no longer aligns with yours and it's perfectly reasonable for you to want some distance from her.

SarahJessicaParker1 · 02/01/2022 10:23

Affairs are nothing like killing anyone. "I didn't think that needed to be said ummmmmm" Hmm

But the op isn't sure she wants to support friend through this. The coercion on here is pretty bad actually "if you were a good friend you'd support her". No. Shut up. Sorry to be so rude, but really.

AnotherVice · 02/01/2022 10:23

OP you don't say anything to her, she doesn't need your input. I have been in her situation and had a close friend drop me when I told her about my affair, I understand she couldn't condone it. Luckily I had better friends who listened to what I was going through with my (now ex) husband and supported me through everything.

chaosrabbitland · 02/01/2022 10:22

@DrSbaitso

if shed got pissed and driven her car and hit a child and was due up in court for it i wonder how many of the same people would still be saying you should suspend your moral judgement and support her

This is not the first time I've seen people on here equate affairs with killing children.

in not saying its anywhere on the same level , i just used it as an example , i think its odd that some replies have been harsh on the op as in shes got to put aside her moral judgement , how she feels about the pain her friend is causing family and support her anyways , this is an affair , not a hard pressed single mother who was so desperate shes been caught shoplifiing a load of stuff and has been caught , its an affair , no one gets desperate or needs to have one , there really is no need to do it other than lack of self control and lust really
SarahJessicaParker1 · 02/01/2022 10:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

cushioncovers · 02/01/2022 10:21

I was in the same situation as you op. Friend having an affair wanting me to be her alibi. I refused, she started being hostile towards me so after a few months I decided to end the friendship of 25 years. I haven't seen or spoke to her now for 9 years. Her affair didn't last and she is still unhappily married to her husband apparently.

ChristmasFluff · 02/01/2022 10:20

Good friends do not mindlessly support people as they throw themselves off cliffs or under busses. Or as the do the same to other people.

It's not about judgement, it's about discernment - understanding what aligns with your values and truths and whatr doesn't.

So if it were my friend, I would tell her that I love her but she's behaved really badly, and that is why she is feeling guilty. It is appropriate guilt, and the only way to change it is to put the situation right - end the affair, or tell her husband.

I would be there to support her whichever she chooses - but I would not be aorund if she continued the affair for a proloinged period - for me that would be about a month - others may feel differently. And during that month I would not be willing to discuss the other man and that relationship at all, outside of how to end it if that was the decision.

saraclara · 02/01/2022 10:20

It's so weird to read all these posts saying ' everyone makes mistakes'...'you don't know what the state of their marriage was'...'don't be so judgmental'...'you're no friend if you don't support her'

Normally the MN attitude to anyone having an affair is as judgmental as it gets, and abuse is rained upon their head. But of course that's if the culprit is a man. Or the OW.

The hypocrisy of this place beggars belief.

minipie · 02/01/2022 10:18

I don’t think the whole “she made a mistake, support her” thing applies here.

OP’s friend is not someone who had a “moment of madness” has now finished the affair and is regretting it.

OP’s friend is still having the affair and wants to continue seeing OM. The only thing she is feeling bad about is the effect on her DCs.

That’s not someone who thinks they have made a mistake.

LetHimHaveIt · 02/01/2022 10:16

I see no-one's particularly anxious to detail the kind of support an adulterer apparently needs . . .

LetHimHaveIt · 02/01/2022 10:14

'In my experience, it takes a long time for a married woman to jump ship.'

But she hasn't jumped ship, has she? She couldz But she hasn't. And until she does, she's still on it, and just fucking another married person in a sleazy sex hotel every time the ship docks.

Springlikely · 02/01/2022 10:14

:59DrSbaitso

if shed got pissed and driven her car and hit a child and was due up in court for it i wonder how many of the same people would still be saying you should suspend your moral judgement and support her

If it was a close friend I'd support a friend through this. Of course I wouldnt condone her behaviour, Id never drunk drive myself but i accept that im as capable of making mistakes as the next person- but I'd support her as she would need it and that's what friendship is about to me.

GoodbyePorpoiseSpit · 02/01/2022 10:11

You don’t have to condone someone to support them even if you passionately abhor what they have done. We are human!
Ummm @SarahJessicaParker1 well yes I don’t think a friend would abuse my children - I think violent sexual crimes go without saying???? that’s not really in the realms of everyday friendship more a weird thought experiment. But in the real work people do make mistakes like affairs and I don’t think a friend should be judgemental. I might have a view on it but that’s not really the point.

SarahJessicaParker1 · 02/01/2022 10:11

My benchmark isn't just an affair. I've already mentioned it, but the family member I've all but cut out didn't have an affair and had some veeeeeery strong views on other people having affairs. But she has behaved so appallingly in a different way. No, not to me (although she has done that too, but the straw that broke the camel's back was not to do with me really).

It is not the brag people seem to think it is when they say "I'd stay mates with my mates whatever they did"

ImInStealthMode · 02/01/2022 10:09

@BlondeDogLady I'm sorry for your situation, but it's different to the OP's. You left a marriage made intolerable by your Husband.

OP's friend has been shagging someone behind her Husband and children's backs for months. She's your Ex in the situation, not you.

If she was unhappy in the relationship and had simply left my view/advice would be completely different.

sassbott · 02/01/2022 10:09

@BlondeDogLady you left a marriage where you were abused.

Did you embark on a 6 month affair in order to do so?

The two are poles apart. One is leaving a marriage. The other is a 6 month affair.

twominutesmore · 02/01/2022 10:08

"I discovered who my fair weather friends were, when I left my ExH. My friends of 20 years, didn't stand by me. They didn't even ask why I was leaving. If they had, I could have told them that my H had cheated on me with 10 women, and occasionally beat me up."

I'm sure you have sufficient imagination to know that all women and all affairs are different. Friend confided her story to op and op listened. If she failed to mention his physical abuse and string of affairs, she can't be surprised if it isn't taken into account.

SpookyScarySkeletons · 02/01/2022 10:07

@WhatAHexIGotInto

I would love to live in the black and white world that so many PPs do. It must be so simple.

@brogueish some people just have a very clear benchmark of behaviour on what they find acceptable. 🤷

This times 100!!

Maybe I will be accused of being judgemental but I don't like spending my free time with someone who's behaviours and morals are low enough to actively chase and sleep with somebody else's husband... repeatedly. (In my case I mentioned previously it was made even worse by the fact the married man and his unsuspecting wife were going through IVF and ex-friend would laugh about how funny it would be if she fell pregnant)