Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't want to be in contact with friend who is having ex marital affair but being made to feel guilty

211 replies

MrsPatrickDempsey · 02/01/2022 08:07

V close friend has admitted to an affair of 6 months (married for a considerable period of time with children).

Friend is currently splitting time between living with their own family and other man. Friend is in turmoil; is distraught with guilt regarding the impact of her actions. Wants to be with other man but is committed to children (older teens).
Friend told me all of the details as affair became uncovered. I just listened with no judgement but have not been in contact since as I am angry about her actions because of the hurt she has brought on her family.
A mutual friend who also knows about the circumstances suggested to me that I should contact affair friend and support her, implying loosely that I am mean for not doing so and adding to affair friend’s distress as she is upset that I haven’t been in touch since her disclosure. I feel guilty but Aibu in not wanting to be in touch? A) it’s not really any of my business B) I can’t be supportive/empathic/sympathetic of her actions
C) don’t know what to say and don’t want to listen to the details again or about problems she has created.
If she contacted me I wouldn’t ignore her and would respond accordingly but I want to keep out of it. It is the only thing consuming her at the moment and there would be nothing else to talk about.
Would appreciate some clarity.

OP posts:
LetHimHaveIt · 02/01/2022 11:23

'I’ve stayed friends with someone who has been in prison for 4 years for a non violent crime.'

Me too. And I've even listened to a friend when her affair ended. What I didn't do was support his criminal enterprise whilst he was engaged in it, nor support her while she was fucking someone else's husband.

MarshmallowSwede · 02/01/2022 11:21

I don’t blame you for cutting contact. Why would you want to be involved with someone who is blowing up their life?

For those saying you’re a bad friend for not supporting your friend while she screws around on her husband.. well I argue that you don’t owe your friendship or your support to a friend when they are engaging in toxic, damaging behaviour that is hurting others.

Boundaries . You’re allowed to have them. You don’t approve of her behaviour and yes it’s none of your business, but you don’t have to be friends with someone or have contact with people who themselves don’t respect the boundaries of others. She’s cheating on her husband and lying to her family.

I would judge someone who is doing this and anyone being friends with someone who screws around on their spouse.

It always amuses me when the “stick by them” brigade comes out. No.. you don’t have to have any relationship with cheaters. The cavalier attitude to rubbing your genitals against any and everyone is why STDs are rampant. She’s putting her husbands health at risk which is selfish and dangerous.

1forAll74 · 02/01/2022 11:21

I would probably stay in touch . up to a point, with a person who is having an affair. but not in a supportive roll, and would not wish to know about all her woes concerning her affair, she needs to get real, and sort her own problems out.. She should be aware, that affairs can mess up your life, and the lives of others..

thinkingaboutLangCleg · 02/01/2022 11:21

I think of a fairweather friend as one who wants to be there for the good times and not the bad. So, for example, someone who is a friend when you're fun, and attractive, and wealthy, and popular - but deserts you if you put on four stone because of your depression medication, or your house is repossessed, your get alopecia, or your child turns out to have SEN. Having an affair isn't something that happens to you. You're making a choice. A bad one. And no-one has to support that.

Yes. OP is not being a fair-weather friend.

WhatAHexIGotInto · 02/01/2022 11:19

People have just said what they would/might do, or have done.

And told her that she's not a good friend @brogueish, so not quite.

BreakfastClub80 · 02/01/2022 11:18

My friend has done this and two years on I still struggle with it. I’ve stayed friends with both of the original married couple, with the aim of supporting their child through this, but it hasn’t been easy. Being supportive, I have had to have discussions about the affair partner and the mess it all was but it was hard to be sympathetic in the circumstances and I had to take time out. In the end this eased somewhat as I couldn’t condone it and gradually she talks about it less. The real difficulty though was that during the initial 12/18 months, she literally had zero interest in my life and I’ve found that hard to come back from. We’re still friends but it will never be the same, I don’t think.

Deisogn · 02/01/2022 11:14

Well I guess if you're entirely sure that you would never do anything beyond reproach then fine but it doesn't make you much of a friend. I

Gensola · 02/01/2022 11:11

I wouldn’t cut a friend off for this - maybe a sensible friend can help her see sense? She may be having some sort of breakdown or crisis? Is she being taken advantage of?
There’s no point in judging others, it’s a toxic mindset imo. I’ve stayed friends with someone who has been in prison for 4 years for a non violent crime and I don’t condone their actions but if all their friends and family cut them off then how are they supposed to rehabilitate? It’s not constructive. Obviously you don’t have an obligation to keep her in your life but I couldn’t cut someone off over something like this, especially if an old or close friend.

LetHimHaveIt · 02/01/2022 11:10

'You can be her friend without approving of what she's doing.

She came to you for support. Not judgement.'

The difficulty being, I'm not sure that she can stipulate that. You might want support (again: for what? What are all these friends supposed to be supporting?) and not want judgement, but you're doing a pretty shitty thing, so you have to expect that support isn't going to be especially forthcoming.

This whole thing is bullshit. OP did listen. She didn't care for what she heard, and now she's gone quiet. (So we might assume this woman isn't having an affair because her husband beats her, or is emotionally abusive, or is having an affair himself). That's not especially 'judgy' (such a stupid fucking adolescent word, btw. Only equalled by 'grabby'). She hasn't told the husband (or wife). She hasn't sent her friend cross-stitched passages from the Bible about colourful punishments for adulterers. She just isn't especially anxious to listen to how awful this friend's situation is for her. And who can blame her?

I think of a fairweather friend as one who wants to be there for the good times and not the bad. So, for example, someone who is a friend when you're fun, and attractive, and wealthy, and popular - but deserts you if you put on four stone because of your depression medication, or your house is repossessed, your get alopecia, or your child turns out to have SEN. Having an affair isn't something that happens to you. You're making a choice. A bad one. And no-one has to support that.

Walkaround · 02/01/2022 11:05

I couldn’t just cut off a very close friend over this, tbh. That doesn’t mean I would unquestioningly support them in behaviours I thought were wrong - true friends, imvho, are willing to listen to each other, try to understand each other, but also tell each other when they think they are doing the wrong thing and talk through alternative choices that might have less emotionally harmful consequences in the long run. True friends help support each other in thinking things through when their emotions are making it hard for them to think clearly by themselves. Your friend already knows, or needs to be told, she is doing the wrong thing by absolutely everyone at the moment - herself, her children, her dh and the new partner - hence the emotional turmoil. She has to make some unpalatable decisions, now, and live with the consequences. You, as her close friend, ought to be there to help her with that. It is not the law that friends have to approve of each other’s fuck ups, but they shouldn’t just forget why they are friends the minute they disapprove of their behaviour.

MissMinutes24 · 02/01/2022 11:02

Really needed to read this thread today as I'm in a very similar situation with a friend. I'm amazed she can't see the pain this is causing her family and I'm finding it really difficult to listen because all she talks about all the time is the man she's obsessed with. Sadly I fear our long friendship will not survive this.

OP you absolutely do not have to support someone who's morals do not align with your own and I find it extraordinary people are suggesting you do.

I liked the comment someone made up thread about not having to support people's drama of their own making. I think that's right.

brogueish · 02/01/2022 11:02

That includes friendships. No-one should feel obliged to, or pressured into supporting a friend who is behaving in a way that goes way against ones own values and beliefs.

Fully agree with this. If OP decides that on balance, she doesn't want to continue that friendship, that's entirely her prerogative. I don't think there's been much suggestion that she should do otherwise though to be fair. People have just said what they would/might do, or have done.

SarahJessicaParker1 · 02/01/2022 10:59

And op, as you see from this thread, even as an innocent bystander, you get dragged in when there is drama of this kind. I've been there too with extended family and have been had some downright aggressive behaviour towards me for first of all not being judgemental enough about a family member's affair and then for being too judgemental of the guy who got caught out using sex workers. This aggression all came from the same person which makes it even more ridiculous!

So my advice would be do what YOU want. You said you do not want to be in contact with her. Do not let holier than though 'liberal' Hmm minded people coerce you into supporting or contacting her if you are not comfortable doing it.

If you do want to support her though, that's also fine. But you are not a bad person or a bad friend if you don't want to. Nobody on here but you knows the exact circumstances of your friendship

RedBonnet · 02/01/2022 10:58

I think perhaps you need to work out why you are ignoring her, are you punishing her?

WhatAHexIGotInto · 02/01/2022 10:55

‘ Life is complex, unpredictable and messy’ ‘people aren’t perfect’

That includes friendships. No-one should feel obliged to, or pressured into supporting a friend who is behaving in a way that goes way against ones own values and beliefs.

All this 'I would support a friend no matter what' is nonsense. I consider myself a good friend but when a friend of almost 20 years put a teenager in hospital because she chose to drive her car after a liquid lunch, no, I did not support her. I am not an enabler of shit behaviour.

LetHimHaveIt · 02/01/2022 10:54

@TheGreatATuin

I suspect the answers on this thread are split solidly between those who've had affairs and those who have personal experience of just how much pain they cause.
Fully agree. Particularly enjoying the PP who identified her 'better' friends as being those who endorsed her adultery. Hilarious.
Frankola · 02/01/2022 10:51

You can be her friend without approving of what she's doing.

She came to you for support. Not judgement.

I've been there myself with a friend. Her marriage was a joke, she was staying in it for her young kids and she was having an affair. I didnt approve of her actions but I made sure to be there for her as a friend. She really needed me as she was in a total mess. My only stipulation was that I never wanted to be used as a cover story and she kept that promise.

I think your actions say more about you than her situation to be honest.

SarahJessicaParker1 · 02/01/2022 10:51

@GoodbyePorpoiseSpit

It’s just a different opinion to you *@SarahJessicaParker1* there’s no need for personal attacks?
I didn't personally attack you. Feel free to report if you disagree!

It actually isn't just a difference of opinion. You and others have tried to manipulate the op who has clearly stated that she does not want to be in contact with this woman. Why is that so difficult for you and others to accept without resorting to manipulation? If you don't like my tone, tough luck. I don't like the way you tried to manipulate the op. It was extremely poor behaviour from you and a number of others. Don't try to manipulate me into backing down as you already are - I can see it.

TheGreatATuin · 02/01/2022 10:51

I suspect the answers on this thread are split solidly between those who've had affairs and those who have personal experience of just how much pain they cause.

GoodbyePorpoiseSpit · 02/01/2022 10:47

It’s just a different opinion to you @SarahJessicaParker1 there’s no need for personal attacks?

Kshhuxnxk · 02/01/2022 10:46

Oh and I would also tell their DH.

Kshhuxnxk · 02/01/2022 10:44

Me, I'm harsh, I wouldn't have anything to do with them every again. Judgy - yes, absolutely and no issues with having standards and expecting others to have them too.

thinkingaboutLangCleg · 02/01/2022 10:42

Some posters are being very judgemental of OP, who has done nothing except hesitate to support her friend’s affair. That shows we all make value judgements, including people who say “don’t be judgemental”.

RockinHorseShit · 02/01/2022 10:42

Don't feel guilty, she gave away any right to sympathy when she started having an affair, you shouldn't have to put your own morals to bed, because it suits your friend. Would she expect support if she'd committed murder too, would you still feel guilty not giving it? I doubt it.

I've been in this situation, friend was set on starting an affair with another friends DP. I ripped her a new arsehole when she thought it was okay to discuss her excitement at his visits to her place of work & told her in no uncertain terms that I was not going to be her friend if she did this.

You do not have to adjust your own morals to accommodate someone else's shitty behaviour. Do not feel guilty for having a good moral compass. Your other friend is an arse for expecting otherwise

SarahJessicaParker1 · 02/01/2022 10:34

And to add that a lot of people (including me) have managed to say that they would or have supported some friends through similar without telling op to do the same.