Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Don't want to be in contact with friend who is having ex marital affair but being made to feel guilty

211 replies

MrsPatrickDempsey · 02/01/2022 08:07

V close friend has admitted to an affair of 6 months (married for a considerable period of time with children).

Friend is currently splitting time between living with their own family and other man. Friend is in turmoil; is distraught with guilt regarding the impact of her actions. Wants to be with other man but is committed to children (older teens).
Friend told me all of the details as affair became uncovered. I just listened with no judgement but have not been in contact since as I am angry about her actions because of the hurt she has brought on her family.
A mutual friend who also knows about the circumstances suggested to me that I should contact affair friend and support her, implying loosely that I am mean for not doing so and adding to affair friend’s distress as she is upset that I haven’t been in touch since her disclosure. I feel guilty but Aibu in not wanting to be in touch? A) it’s not really any of my business B) I can’t be supportive/empathic/sympathetic of her actions
C) don’t know what to say and don’t want to listen to the details again or about problems she has created.
If she contacted me I wouldn’t ignore her and would respond accordingly but I want to keep out of it. It is the only thing consuming her at the moment and there would be nothing else to talk about.
Would appreciate some clarity.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rubyupbeat · 06/01/2022 08:18

@frazzledasarock
I totally agree with every word you have written.

AuntieStella · 06/01/2022 07:15

I agree DysmalRadius - it's not about the person and changing them. It's about your own standards and boundaries

DysmalRadius · 06/01/2022 01:15

The thing is, none of those with 'a strong moral code' who would shun this person will achieve the ultimate desire, which is to end infidelity.

I think it's a bit of a reach to assume that anyone expects to 'end infidelity', especially in the case where the infidelity had anyway happened.

There are plenty of reasons not to be friends with someone and intentionally hurting their kids, physically or emotionally, is just one of them. I've similarly cooled a friendship with someone who was planning to move their child in with a partner after a matter of weeks and someone who was working 'off the books' in the family business to avoid paying child support.

I'm not arrogant enough to believe that the lack of my support or friendship would change their minds about what they were doing, but it became harder to have any meaningful relationship with them when it became apparent that our values differed so greatly.

I don't understand how someone deciding to leave a relationship with their partner is simply 'how humans work', but a friend deciding not to pursue a friendship is a 'social punishment'.

SW1amp · 05/01/2022 19:43

@sofato5miles

The thing is, none of those with 'a strong moral code' who would shun this person will achieve the ultimate desire, which is to end infidelity. It is not how humans work. Infidelity has been around forever and will always be. Some cultures have killed and still do because of it. Ultimately, they are doing it to personally protect their marriages and ensure that it is totally taboo. But that is because they believe they would never do it and want to keep social punishment in place.

I believe that just adds to the distress of the circle of those affected by affairs. They are deeply unpleasant and can certainly be traumatic but shutting down conversations, cutting off friendships adds to the colateral damage. I am not saying skip up merrily and congratulate adulterers but the lack of nuance baffles and frightens me.

Replace ‘infidelity’ with ‘domestic violence’ or ‘murder’ or ‘paedophilia’ and the rest of the post still stands though

I’m not trying to directly compare them, but it’s perfectly acceptable to cut people out when they do things that cause horrific harm to people around them, and I’m definitely including affairs in that

hivemindneeded · 05/01/2022 14:08

@sofato5miles

The thing is, none of those with 'a strong moral code' who would shun this person will achieve the ultimate desire, which is to end infidelity. It is not how humans work. Infidelity has been around forever and will always be. Some cultures have killed and still do because of it. Ultimately, they are doing it to personally protect their marriages and ensure that it is totally taboo. But that is because they believe they would never do it and want to keep social punishment in place.

I believe that just adds to the distress of the circle of those affected by affairs. They are deeply unpleasant and can certainly be traumatic but shutting down conversations, cutting off friendships adds to the colateral damage. I am not saying skip up merrily and congratulate adulterers but the lack of nuance baffles and frightens me.

That's a really good, fair post. I suppose I have seen a fair few adulterers being fawned over and supported during this difficult narcissistic time in their lives while their trashed spouses are left lonely and trying to deal with the fallout for bewildered, distressed children. My heart goes out far more to the person left holding the fort not the one who had to follow their groin heart.
sharksarecool · 05/01/2022 09:25

She feels guilty because she's done something wrong and her actions have caused harm to others. Guilt is a natural human emotion. Sometimes guilt is misplaced, but often it's not, as sounds like the case with your friend.
It's overwhelmingly selfish for her to expect anyone else to help her feel better about her guilt, when feeling guilty is exactly the right way to feel in her situation. I hope she is not also expecting her teenaged children to rally round her and help her feel less guilty. She is not the victim here

sofato5miles · 05/01/2022 04:38

The thing is, none of those with 'a strong moral code' who would shun this person will achieve the ultimate desire, which is to end infidelity. It is not how humans work. Infidelity has been around forever and will always be. Some cultures have killed and still do because of it. Ultimately, they are doing it to personally protect their marriages and ensure that it is totally taboo. But that is because they believe they would never do it and want to keep social punishment in place.

I believe that just adds to the distress of the circle of those affected by affairs. They are deeply unpleasant and can certainly be traumatic but shutting down conversations, cutting off friendships adds to the colateral damage. I am not saying skip up merrily and congratulate adulterers but the lack of nuance baffles and frightens me.

snowdropsandcrocuses · 03/01/2022 16:40

@twominutesmore

"In answer to the question, what support does she need, well that would depend wouldn't it. She may just need to know she still has a friend."

Well she's confided in other friends too, who do seem supportive, so how many people need to listen to her whining now?

"Here's a scenario for you. Friends DH is an arse. He is threatening to leave her homeless and penniless because of her actions. She is scared that she will lose everything and friends with it."

She's already confided the whole story to op. If there were mitigating factors, I think op would know.

I suspect that it is not support she needs as such, but rather a desperate need to repeat the same story, details snd justifications to anyone willing to listen - she needs people to convince her she's not behaving like a shit and she hasn't fucked up her family, and probably a little tear-mopping because after all she probably genuinely thinks that she is really, really suffering more than anyone else in this awful situation is or ever will.

All of your post is based on assumptions. None of us know what this friend is like or what's she's done.

Op described her as a 'v close friend'. She also said friend has confessed everything and is torn up. Now you might not be sympathetic to what she's done, but anyone with an ounce of empathy can accept that situations like these come with some serious distress for all parties.

I keep reiterating, nobody has to approve of what she did, but if it is a very close friend, do you throw away that friendship because of actions that have no effect on you? I wouldn't. You might.

My response was for the op. If she considers her to be a genuine good friend, does she really want to shun her? Clearly you are of the opinion that it is worth ending a friendship over. I however am not. I think good friends are vital and very hard to come by. Think carefully before you sacrifice such friendship.

twominutesmore · 03/01/2022 16:24

"In answer to the question, what support does she need, well that would depend wouldn't it. She may just need to know she still has a friend."

Well she's confided in other friends too, who do seem supportive, so how many people need to listen to her whining now?

"Here's a scenario for you. Friends DH is an arse. He is threatening to leave her homeless and penniless because of her actions. She is scared that she will lose everything and friends with it."

She's already confided the whole story to op. If there were mitigating factors, I think op would know.

I suspect that it is not support she needs as such, but rather a desperate need to repeat the same story, details snd justifications to anyone willing to listen - she needs people to convince her she's not behaving like a shit and she hasn't fucked up her family, and probably a little tear-mopping because after all she probably genuinely thinks that she is really, really suffering more than anyone else in this awful situation is or ever will.

snowdropsandcrocuses · 03/01/2022 15:48

@LetHimHaveIt

'What support does she need? If shagging someone else is upsetting her, she can stop cant she?'

Don't bother. I've asked that question two or three times, and none of the 'Not much of a friend, are you?' brigade can answer. For glaringly obvious reasons.

Wow. That's a bit strong!

Look, I'm as anti affairs as the next woman on here. They destroy families and lives. This I understand. And as far as I can see, the OP is not being asked to be involved in the affair, only considering whether she will support her friend.

In answer to the question, what support does she need, well that would depend wouldn't it. She may just need to know she still has a friend.

Here's a scenario for you. Friends DH is an arse. He is threatening to leave her homeless and penniless because of her actions. She is scared that she will lose everything and friends with it. Now, the few closest friends I have are like family to me. Even when my family totally fuck up, I still love them and I'm still there for them. Even when I completely disagree with their actions. I cut them some slack because I love them. I'm not a doormat. I'm not agreeing with them. I'm just still there for them, listening to them, offering advice when asked for, and practical help when required.

Contrary to Mumsnet opinion, people are not black and white. There are myriad shades of grey in between. Nobody is all good or all bad. You can be a good person doing shorty things or a bad person doing good things.

So yes, I would stand by my friend without condoning/approving/liking their actions. It would take a lot more than an affair for me to change that. If you were talking murder here or serious criminal activity then I would be reviewing those friendships. That's just where my personal bar is.

Op asked for advice. Asked what we would do. So that is what I would do.

twominutesmore · 03/01/2022 14:35

I think I would save all of my supportive energies for her husband and children, when they find out. I think they'll be more upset than op's friend currently is. To be honest, I suspect op's friend has a lot more hurt ahead of her but she orchestrated it herself so really can't be surprised if people view her differently when they learn that she can lie to loved ones for months and months.

LetHimHaveIt · 03/01/2022 14:33

'What support does she need? If shagging someone else is upsetting her, she can stop cant she?'

Don't bother. I've asked that question two or three times, and none of the 'Not much of a friend, are you?' brigade can answer. For glaringly obvious reasons.

twominutesmore · 03/01/2022 14:31

"But at no point does the friend say she is asking op to lie or cheat. She is only asking for a supportive friend."

What support does she need? If shagging someone else is upsetting her, she can stop cant she?

She has also told several friends, so presumably is getting the required drama - or support - from elsewhere.

And as she confided in op, and op knows the full story while we do not, I think we can trust op's judgement on how deserving of support her friend is.

And she is asking op to lie by omission, every time she sees her friend's husband and children. She is asking op to tacitly take her side by keeping the secret. She doesn't care how her husband and children will react when they find out op, and other friends, knew all about it and did nothing.

snowdropsandcrocuses · 03/01/2022 14:17

@twominutesmore

"My role as close friend is to listen to their shit, be supportive yet honest and be supported when I need it. What is your opinion of friendship? Sunny days only?"

I would be thinking - if my friend can lie to her dh and dc, every day, about her whereabouts and so on, and cheat on someone she is supposed to love, and put herself first so spectacularly, she would not hesitate to treat me similarly if it benefited her to do so.

Furthermore, friend has now embroiled op in this and put her in a difficult situation - how does she chat to friend's husband and kids, knowing what she knows, and what will they think of her when it comes out?

It is possible to support friends through all manner of tough situations - bereavement, illness, divorce - but draw a line at prolonged, intentional hurting of people you should prioritise and love, people who trust you.

Why judge op more harshly for dropping a friend, than the friend who is fucking someone other than her husband and then crying about it?

But at no point does the friend say she is asking op to lie or cheat. She is only asking for a supportive friend. We do not know any of the friend's circumstances as to why she had an affair or why she has done what she has done.

I can be a supportive friend without agreeing with their actions. That's what friendships mean. We don't get to be judge jury and executioner or at least that's not what I would expect from my closest friends. My Friendships have latest longer than any relationships.

FestiveFlavours · 03/01/2022 12:40

@twominutesmore

"My role as close friend is to listen to their shit, be supportive yet honest and be supported when I need it. What is your opinion of friendship? Sunny days only?"

I would be thinking - if my friend can lie to her dh and dc, every day, about her whereabouts and so on, and cheat on someone she is supposed to love, and put herself first so spectacularly, she would not hesitate to treat me similarly if it benefited her to do so.

Furthermore, friend has now embroiled op in this and put her in a difficult situation - how does she chat to friend's husband and kids, knowing what she knows, and what will they think of her when it comes out?

It is possible to support friends through all manner of tough situations - bereavement, illness, divorce - but draw a line at prolonged, intentional hurting of people you should prioritise and love, people who trust you.

Why judge op more harshly for dropping a friend, than the friend who is fucking someone other than her husband and then crying about it?

This.

A married friend provided emotional support to her single friend who was having an affair with a married man. The single friend later made a pass at the married friend’s husband. I don’t know why the married friend was surprised, as the single friend had already shown her true colours.

WhatAHexIGotInto · 03/01/2022 09:15

But you're making this about you. You need to decide whether you still want to be a friend to her.

@CouldThisReallyBe It IS about her. It's about what SHE finds acceptable, and that's perfectly fine. What exactly do you believe that her friend needs right now while she's shagging someone behind her husband's back? What support do you believe she 'really' needs?

LetHimHaveIt · 03/01/2022 09:07

'Well you certainly find out who your real friends are when you really need them.'

Why does OP's really need her right now? She's not in extremis. She's fucking someone behind her husband's back. What does she really need?

CouldThisReallyBe · 03/01/2022 09:01

Well you certainly find out who your real friends are when you really need them.

OP "listening without judgement" means....not judging. You're absolutely judging her - and she's crossed what is a personal red line for you. Which is fine. But you're making this about you. You need to decide whether you still want to be a friend to her. As PPs have said...life is complicated and messy and not everyone/everything is going to fit into a nice neat box of what we want/think should happen.

WhatAHexIGotInto · 03/01/2022 08:58

A friend would help you move house.
A good friend would help you move a body.

What fucking bullshit.

SW1amp · 03/01/2022 08:56

@Riapia

A friend would help you move house. A good friend would help you move a body.
This might make a pithy little slogan for a birthday card but it’s absolute bullshit

And it’s actually quite fucking offensive to the actual families of murder victims who struggled to get justice for their loved ones, because some scumbag murder managed to rope in friends and family to help cover up their crimes

twominutesmore · 03/01/2022 08:55

"My role as close friend is to listen to their shit, be supportive yet honest and be supported when I need it. What is your opinion of friendship? Sunny days only?"

I would be thinking - if my friend can lie to her dh and dc, every day, about her whereabouts and so on, and cheat on someone she is supposed to love, and put herself first so spectacularly, she would not hesitate to treat me similarly if it benefited her to do so.

Furthermore, friend has now embroiled op in this and put her in a difficult situation - how does she chat to friend's husband and kids, knowing what she knows, and what will they think of her when it comes out?

It is possible to support friends through all manner of tough situations - bereavement, illness, divorce - but draw a line at prolonged, intentional hurting of people you should prioritise and love, people who trust you.

Why judge op more harshly for dropping a friend, than the friend who is fucking someone other than her husband and then crying about it?

WhatAHexIGotInto · 03/01/2022 08:54

@snowdropsandcrocuses that's great, for you. It doesn't mean that the OP should go against her own personal values if she feels she can't support this.

My two closest friends are 40 year friendships, my others generally 15 years plus so my friendships are important to me too, but I believe there should be a mutual respect there; I would never deliberately put a friend in a difficult or awkward position as the OPs friend has done here.

I did lose someone who I had considered a good friend once, as I mentioned up thread, but I could not forgive what they had done, deliberately, so I'm ok with that.

snowdropsandcrocuses · 03/01/2022 08:45

Well I don't have many friends but the ones I have are genuinely lifers. I have known them for over 30 years and we have weathered many storms, divorces, break ups, children and yea affairs. I can genuinely tell you I would be there for them in this situation or any other.

That doesn't mean I wouldn't call them out and tell them my opinion of what they are doing. Nor would I be an alibi for lies about their whereabouts. But I absolutely would be there for my friend whom I love, regardless of their shitty actions.

But then my friendships, the few I choose to keep and cultivate are incredibly important to me. It is not up to me to judge what they do or how they live their life. My role as close friend is to listen to their shit, be supportive yet honest and be supported when I need it. What is your opinion of friendship? Sunny days only?

ElectraBlue · 03/01/2022 08:44

I think there are two different thing.:

  • you don't have to condone the fact that she is having an affair. It is perfectly normal to think that what she has done is not acceptable. It is not being 'judgemental'. it is simply stating what your values are
  • you might still be able to stay in touch with her. You can make it clear that you don't like the choice that she has made, that you think she will eventually get hurt and that you won't join in any 'bitching' about this man's family. But that you want to continue to be her friend and support her as long as she understand that does not involve agreeing with the affair.

The best outcome is that she will realise that she has made a mistake sooner than later and will appreciate you standing by her and being straightforward about your misgivings.

If she is only looking for 'yes' people who will tell her that what she is doing is OK then she is the one who is causing this friendship to end, not you...

Toocooltoboogie · 03/01/2022 08:33

I think Yabu. If your worried about her and a genuine friend be there to support her but be honest and tell her you don't want the details of the affair. Don't drop her when she needs you. Life is messy at times and no one is perfect.