Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you protect your son?

111 replies

Christmascardsontheshelf · 02/01/2022 05:47

I was thinking about the queen and Prince Andrew.
I think he is guilty, but I do feel bad for the Queen.
It reminded me of desperate housewives when Bree / Brie (How do you spell it when its a name?)
protects her son, Andrew (Shock) when he runs over and kills a neighbours mother.

I was thinking about it and I don't know if I could let my son go to prison, especially if he was a Prince. But then again, I don't think my own sons would be pervy, rapey men when they're older, but who knows!
I would probably protect my children if they accidentally killed someone, but if they were raping girls in a big sex gang I think I'd be disgusted enough to let them face the music. But then if they told me they didn't know and it was all a misunderstanding, then I know I'd want to believe them and I probably would clutch at any straw i could.

So aibu?
YABU - I wouldn't protect my adult child if I had the means
YANBU - I would protect them.

Disclaimer- I am not the parent of an adult, I don't know yet how the relationship grows from parent + child to parent + adult

Also I don't support Prince Andrew in anyway, I just know I'm not perfect and I don't blame the Queen for burying her head in the sand.

OP posts:
hownowpurplecow · 02/01/2022 22:05

If it was rape or child abuse, no I couldn’t support him and I would make him own up to what he’d done and face the consequences if I was able. But I’d cover for him in a situation like the desperate housewives hit & run scenario.

MyGreenTutu · 02/01/2022 22:01

On another note, someone from the Queen's generation wouldn't think of the girls as being that young and would apportion some blame towards them

Yes, exactly this. The queen was corresponding with Prince Philip from the age of 13 (he was 18).

RosesAndHellebores · 02/01/2022 22:00

I have told my grown-up children many times that I will love them whatever they do but there may be things they do that would make me dislike them.

Someone will come out of this very badly.

lljkk · 02/01/2022 21:57

I wouldn't protect my child who had murdered someone.

I would like anyone who abused Virginia to face justice but if I never know another fact about who that was -- that would be great. I just don't care if it was PA or anyone else famous.

Laiste · 02/01/2022 21:52

I don't have any sons, so will never be in this exact scenario myself.

A shocking situation arose in our family a while ago which meant that some aged parents had to face their son's crime. He admitted it, so there was no insisting of innocence. They jumped through massive hoops to come up with excuses for him though. It's left a lot of family members angry and bewildered. Shook up the whole family and hard decisions had to be made.

I feel sorry for them even so. Horrible position to be put in.

The point is, to answer the actual OP, I don't think you can say how you'll react unless it happens to you.

NichyNoo · 02/01/2022 21:51

@Nanny0gg So being devil’s advocate - anyone who sleeps with someone that is around 25 years younger should be prosecuted for taking advantage? So Paul McCartney can’t have obtained consent from Heather Mills, nor can most of the Rolling Stones? Whilst I vomit in my mouth at the thought of all these older, powerful men shagging young women, I don’t think the argument of rape or coercion can be used. Andrew was a prince who has had women fall at his feet all his life (rightly or wrongly). One 17 year old blonde is the same as the last few and he can plausibly argue that he has no idea she did not consent. It kills me to say it as I never defend men but in this case I don’t see how ‘legally’ he has done anything wrong.

knobblykneesandturnedouttoes · 02/01/2022 21:44

All those saying they would disown their child, I hope you would wait for them to be proven guilty first.

Please remember so far nothing has been proven.

Not that I don't believe it, I just think as a parent it's best to let the courts decide whether or not a child is guilty before publicly disowning or condemning them.

Nanny0gg · 02/01/2022 21:40

[quote NichyNoo]@Nanny0gg yes but surely in your life you have had sex with a man who was older or who was more powerful than you? I slept with a 36 year old when I was 18, I’ve slept with a man who was rich when I was a poor student. As much as I’m a radical feminist, you cannot expect men to ask for proof of socio-economic status as part of obtaining consent. Otherwise Prince William could be said to have taken advantage of Kate at uni as he was a prince and thus more powerful than her?![/quote]
William and Kate were at Uni together and are not vastly different in age.
Andrew was 41 when Virginia was 17!

My DH is more that 10 years older than me but we didn't meet till I was 25.

So I am sorry, I wouldn't support any son of mine doing what he did

Autumndays123 · 02/01/2022 21:39

It's a difficult question but I don't think I could support my child (son or daughter) if they were a sex offender. There really isn't any excuse for it and I think being in the public eye you need to make even more of an effort to denounce the offender to send a message to victims that no one is above the law. It's a shame the queen is getting tarnished for it though, Drakefords son is a convicted rapist (who did some really depraved things to his victim) and alleged peadophille and yet no one seems to have a problem with that. I do wonder if it is because Drakeford is a man in power though, compared to the Queen.

JohnSmithDrive · 02/01/2022 21:24

@thinkbiglittkeone

My mum always told my brother, if he did anything that warranted the police coming for him, they could have him. We absolutely believed if we did wrong we accepted the consequences of that.

I will raise my son to believe I would do the same. Depending on the crime, I think it may depend, but violence or anything kids related I just couldn't help him go free.
Saying that I hate thieves so he would need to take responsibility for that also, so yes maybe, I really would make him face the time for anything.

But this is isn't the police, this is a woman who was of age when she had consensual sex with your son and has seen an opportunity to make some money by suing him for something he didn't do. Or at least that's what your son would be telling you. Would you really hand him over to a foreign court?
GrandmasCat · 02/01/2022 21:21

I think the main problem for the Queen is that whatever changes they do with regards to Prince Andrew, they would be perceived as an admission of “being guilty” and what “being guilty” may mean can be interpreted in multiple ways from “yes, he did sweat and danced with Virginia Guiffre” to “he was as active in the abuse of children as Epstein was”… so I guess that’s why the Queen is still finding cover behind the “say and do nothing” strategy.

I do think however, that Andrew should have accepted to discuss the issues when he was asked to rather than kicking the can down the road form years on end, and it is unfortunate the Queen just brushed the issue under the carpet, as I assume as she could have certainly pressured Andrew to cooperate… unless she knows something that we don’t.

NichyNoo · 02/01/2022 21:21

@Nanny0gg yes but surely in your life you have had sex with a man who was older or who was more powerful than you? I slept with a 36 year old when I was 18, I’ve slept with a man who was rich when I was a poor student. As much as I’m a radical feminist, you cannot expect men to ask for proof of socio-economic status as part of obtaining consent. Otherwise Prince William could be said to have taken advantage of Kate at uni as he was a prince and thus more powerful than her?!

Nanny0gg · 02/01/2022 21:16

@NichyNoo

It’s tricky - if my son said he had sex with a 17 year old woman who verbally consented and smiled in photos then I would probably believe him. And therein lies the crux of the Andrew problem. The woman was over the age of consent in UK law and you could conceivably believe that he didn’t know she was trafficked/coerced. Do they prosecute every man who visits a prostitute who has been trafficked? No they don’t because the man can say he reasonably had no idea she was trafficked. They prosecute trafficker.
He was in a position of power (an actual prince!) and considerably older.

It's hardly the same as a couple of teenagers having sex.

thinkbiglittkeone · 02/01/2022 21:16

My mum always told my brother, if he did anything that warranted the police coming for him, they could have him.
We absolutely believed if we did wrong we accepted the consequences of that.

I will raise my son to believe I would do the same. Depending on the crime, I think it may depend, but violence or anything kids related I just couldn't help him go free.
Saying that I hate thieves so he would need to take responsibility for that also, so yes maybe, I really would make him face the time for anything.

JohnSmithDrive · 02/01/2022 21:15

@Lolamento

Out of the man that surrounded JE why is only PA being prosecuted? What about Clinton and all of those involved?
He isn't being prosecuted, he's being sued
JohnSmithDrive · 02/01/2022 21:14

I think in the Queen's shoes I'd either have convinced myself that it couldn't possibly be true/ he'd done nothing wrong (the women were of ag, this is how royal men have always behaved) or I'd feel a lot of guilt that I'd given him the upbringing and background to be so entitled and have such a sense of being untouchable and no responsibility for his actions.

The Queen has known about her "Playboy Prince" for years, so she much have condoned this behaviour from her favourite son, to an extent at least.

Therefore, I don't think it's surprising that she'll do what she can to keep him out of prison. If I had her wealth I'd be using it to get him the best possible defence, for example. I'd like to think I wouldn't do anything unethical using my position though.

NichyNoo · 02/01/2022 21:06

It’s tricky - if my son said he had sex with a 17 year old woman who verbally consented and smiled in photos then I would probably believe him. And therein lies the crux of the Andrew problem. The woman was over the age of consent in UK law and you could conceivably believe that he didn’t know she was trafficked/coerced. Do they prosecute every man who visits a prostitute who has been trafficked? No they don’t because the man can say he reasonably had no idea she was trafficked. They prosecute trafficker.

Thatsplentyjack · 02/01/2022 21:05

Actually murder, maybe, it would depend on the circumstances. Crimes against children, absolutely not, they would be on their own. I would greive the child I had raised, but ultimately I would disown them.

Emerald5hamrock · 02/01/2022 21:04

@Santahatesbraisedcabbage That took courage, I'd do the same.
I have seen and heard unthinkable things local lads have done where the family will attempt to cover it up or stand by them sympathetically.

PGSTesting123 · 02/01/2022 21:03

@RantyAunty

I've been through a situation where my son was facing a lot of prison time but not for an offense like mentioned. There were no victims. US laws like to pile on charges.

So what did I do? I paid off the prosecutor and judge. It cost me £50,000 and it was worth it.
That said, my son hasn't been in any kind of trouble since.

10:57RantyAunty Which country was that in?
Lolamento · 02/01/2022 21:00

Out of the man that surrounded JE why is only PA being prosecuted? What about Clinton and all of those involved?

Essexmate · 02/01/2022 20:57

I’m honestly shocked at some of the responses on here. I could never support a rapist son let alone cover up/help them avoid trouble. You hurt someone intentionally, you’re on your own.

That said, I’d like to think I am raising my kids to be decent humans

Maddiemoosmum0203 · 02/01/2022 20:41

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

LondonQueen · 02/01/2022 20:27

Accidental killing eg running someone over, yes I probably would protect both my son and daughter. Rape/sexual crimes, absolutely not, they can face the music and I would probably have to disown them.

StoneofDestiny · 02/01/2022 20:19

The number of people on here who would protect their rapist/paedophile sons is shocking. Do you also sympathise when someone here posts that they've been raped, or are a victim of DV, or their partner has abused their kids?

Yes - and I'm a mother of sons too.
We all need to stand consistently against perpetrators of vile abuse - or we are saying the law should only apply to some of us.

Swipe left for the next trending thread