Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Having a baby your husband doesn't won't

233 replies

PullItUp · 01/01/2022 20:33

Has anyone been through this?

Pregnant with a baby that wasn't planned that your husband doesn't want but you do? What do you do?

OP posts:
iamjustlurking · 02/01/2022 17:02

Happened to me 2 previous DC fertility treatment. Total surprise DC3 He was adamant marriage wouldn't survive.
Heard heartbeat and decided risk worth taking

He was right it we didn't make it but not because of DC3 but because he was an arse. 19 years later I'm happy with my choice ☺

IncompleteSenten · 02/01/2022 16:48

@ThymeTravel

Really?

If a woman becomes pregnant and lied about being on contraception that is a fact that means she loses the right to make the decision whether or not to proceed with the pregnancy?

So you are saying she would be taken against her will to a clinic and have a forced abortion?

That is your view?

Crikey. That's rather disturbing.

mcmooberry · 02/01/2022 16:16

Often I feel bad for the man on these threads, especially when relationships are recent and I get the impression the pregnancy may not be truly accidental. Maybe there's an element of this here but it can be terrifying having the financial responsibility for multiple children so I do understand why your DH may have wanted to stop at 3. However, if you always wanted more than one child and it's only because of your DH already having 2 before you met that you agreed to stop at one then I think if you terminate you will probably always regret it and your relationship won't survive it. You haven't said the reason for your DH only wanting 3 children, is it financial, time, age?

Bucanarab · 02/01/2022 15:58

What precautions was HE taking to prevent pregnancy - assuming he hasn’t suddenly decided post-conception that he doesn’t want another child and this was actually a planned pregnancy that he’s ‘changed his mind’

So he already has 3 children, doesn’t want more but hasn’t had a vasectomy ???
I am fed up with men like this. If they know for sure they do not want more kids they need to take responsibility for that and get the snip.
He is an adult. He knows that every form of contraception has failures.
His failure to act has put you in this situation.

Why so many posters feeling so desperately sorry for this ‘poor’ man?! If he desperately didn’t want another child he could have taken steps to ensure that. As is his right. Or did he just expect the OP to be the one to sort contraception as the woman?

If he was 100% sure he didn't want any more children then he should have booked himself in for a vasectomy or abstained from PIV sex.

Just last week there was a thread where the ops husband didn't want anymore children, had taken responsibility and had a vasectomy. The OP was outraged he'd "taken the choice away from her" and more than half the posters agreed with the op, saying they'd leave their partners if they did this. So looks like it doesn't matter what a man does he will always be wrong.

WhereYouLeftIt · 02/01/2022 15:44

"But he always said he absolutely categorically was done with children after that as he had 3 and didn't want anymore.

I have been struggling with hormonal contraception so have been swapping and changing a few things lately so not actually been on anything for a little bit (which he knew)."

So he was 'categorical' but still made you the person taking responsibility for contraception? Not. Good. Enough. If he 'categorically' didn't want more children he should have had the snip. Or, I believe there's these things called 'condoms' that are available. But no, he lets you mess your body around with hormones. Anything rather than take responsibility for his 'categorical' decision.

Your husband needs to grow the fuck up and take responsibility for his having taken no steps whatsoever to prevent conception.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 02/01/2022 15:32

That was meant to say This isn't Gilead, not Giles's, in my recent post!

Hankunamatata · 02/01/2022 15:27

So you have both been having unprotected sex?

Marvellousmadness · 02/01/2022 15:24

Both didnt make good decisions here tbh..
And your marriage might break over it. Not sure if I would wanna put my kid through it ..

Stuffragette · 02/01/2022 15:24

@PullItUp this happened to me. I had come out of a period of depression. I found out I was pregnant and dh didn't want me to keep the baby, nor did his horrible family (but that's another thread). There was a lot of arguing and tears. I went for abortion counselling and eventually booked a termination.

The night before the abortion, I decided I couldn't go through with it and decided to keep the baby. Nobody was happy about my decision. But once she was born she was utterly adored by everyone. She is very special and now about to have her 10th birthday, I don't regret my decision. I utterly adore her.

Things took a while to go back to normal. What I was surprised by was the anger I felt towards my dh and his family that they hadn't wanted her.

I know people say the father must count but please please go with your gut, with what you want. You are the one who has to live with what happens after that decision. Please feel free to pm me. I've been where you are. Take care of yourself

youvegottenminuteslynn · 02/01/2022 15:20

@ThymeTravel

Someone asked you:

Give me one single fact that would remove the right to make the decision from the woman.

And you answered:

One single fact (not relates to this thread) would be if the woman lied about being on contraception.

So you think that if a woman lied about being on contraception, that would "remove the right to make the decision from the woman."

Blimey.

If a hypothetical woman lied to her husband about contraception and got pregnant on purpose I would absolutely think she was incredibly selfish.

I wouldn't think it would remove her right to make a decision about her pregnancy. This isn't Giles's.

Newmum738 · 02/01/2022 15:13

Been through this and yes, it's awful. My DH did come round and then I miscarried anyway. It took me/us a while to get over what happened but we are there now. It is likely that your DH will fall in love with the baby once born but not a guarantee I guess. You have to do what you want to do. It's your body and your choice. Whatever happens from here, it will affect your marriage. Sending lots of love & hope everything works out for you xx

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 15:08

@me4real

Both sides matter. "Sod your husband, don't consider his feelings, and do as you please" shouldn't be an option.

@Thymeout I imagine having a termination of a wanted baby has to be one of the most distressing things a woman could experience, especially if it's due to her husband.

I think it's kind of unthinkable it would be so awful and distressing. I mean, it's not unthinkable but it's pretty dreadful.

I don't think it's something that can be compromised on- killing a potential child which she wants.

Women can do it but it doesn't tend to make them happy.

Other abortions might be a bit less devastating (if the baby is unwanted, or the financial circumstances aren't right) but this particular situation is a particularly grim one in which to lose a wanted child.

I really think the person's feelings towards their husband wouldn't be the same.

I apologise, as I haven't explained myself well.

I am absolutely NOT saying to abort the baby. I'm saying both sides matter and should be empathised with.

It is ultimately up to the woman, of course! I'm just saying empathy needs to be with both parties, because both of their feelings matter.

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 15:05

@IncompleteSenten

Because the opposite of "do what's best for you not him" is "Do what's best for him not you"

Which brings us right back round to her body her choice v man decides forced abortion or forced birth.

Well, unless we're going to go with a Soloman solution and she can have half a baby. That's always an option I guess.

Would you recommend top/bottom or a split right down the middle?

Right down the middle, of course Confused
ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 15:04

@IncompleteSenten

"People jumped on the bandwagon of "Do what's best for you, not him" before even knowing the full facts regarding contraception."

Interesting.

What "facts" would alter whose decision it is?

Give me one single fact that would remove the right to make the decision from the woman.

One single fact (not relates to this thread) would be if the woman lied about being on contraception.
Outlyingtrout · 02/01/2022 14:57

@gofg

Why do men who do not want children not take some bloody personal responsibility and get a vasectomy.

They probably want to avoid the "I want a baby but my DP had a vasectomy - what will I do?" threads on MN. The answers of course would be "how dare he, it's your right to have a baby, LTB".

Honestly, men really can't win. There are a large number of women on MN who seem to see them as little more than sperm donors, while women have "rights".

Men don’t have a right to a relationship with a woman. Of course a woman can leave her partner if she wants children (or more children) and he doesn’t. Sometimes people are incompatible. That’s life. The fact remains that a man who doesn’t want children needs to be honest about that and needs to take responsibility for his fertility.
ittakes2 · 02/01/2022 13:02

This happened to my friend. Her husband even made her promise to visit an abortion clinic which she did but it just strengthened her resolve to continue. They already had two children so stayed together but it took 5 years for their relationship to recover.

me4real · 02/01/2022 12:55

Both sides matter. "Sod your husband, don't consider his feelings, and do as you please" shouldn't be an option.

@Thymeout I imagine having a termination of a wanted baby has to be one of the most distressing things a woman could experience, especially if it's due to her husband.

I think it's kind of unthinkable it would be so awful and distressing. I mean, it's not unthinkable but it's pretty dreadful.

I don't think it's something that can be compromised on- killing a potential child which she wants.

Women can do it but it doesn't tend to make them happy.

Other abortions might be a bit less devastating (if the baby is unwanted, or the financial circumstances aren't right) but this particular situation is a particularly grim one in which to lose a wanted child.

I really think the person's feelings towards their husband wouldn't be the same.

ClaudiaJ1 · 02/01/2022 12:49

But he always said he absolutely categorically was done with children after that as he had 3 and didn't want anymore.

Then why doesn't he have a vasectomy then??? He can't be too worried about having another child if he (and he is the one that causes the pregnancy) won't take the permanent solution. Especially as you're not getting on with hormonal contraception. He's got a cheek to be upset or 'not want' it. He should have had a vasectomy so it's his own fault. You've done your bit. Birthed his children. Took hormones and contraception. Time for him to step up. Tell him unless he has a vasectomy then he needs to accept the risk you will become pregnant again even after this one. I can't be doing with men who won't take responsibility. It's his sperm. It's his responsibility to have a vasectomy or use condoms and accept the risk with that.

IncompleteSenten · 02/01/2022 12:39

Because the opposite of "do what's best for you not him" is
"Do what's best for him not you"

Which brings us right back round to her body her choice v man decides forced abortion or forced birth.

Well, unless we're going to go with a Soloman solution and she can have half a baby. That's always an option I guess.

Would you recommend top/bottom or a split right down the middle?

IncompleteSenten · 02/01/2022 12:35

"People jumped on the bandwagon of "Do what's best for you, not him" before even knowing the full facts regarding contraception."

Interesting.

What "facts" would alter whose decision it is?

Give me one single fact that would remove the right to make the decision from the woman.

Thymeout · 02/01/2022 12:28

Of course it has to be the woman's choice. But in making that choice, the woman needs to take into consideration other factors than simply wanting the baby.

Her DH's feelings are extremely relevant. It sounds as if it was agreed that they should have only one dc together. That may have been a compromise on his part, since he already had dcs from a previous relationship.

He doesn't want another baby. Op has to consider how it will affect their relationship. He may find it impossible to accept the child, leading to marriage breakdown with life-changing emotional and financial problems for all involved, including the step-children and new baby.

No point in the blame game, talk of vasectomies, shoulda/woulda/coulda. It's done now. Op has the right to choose, but also the responsibility to own the consequences of her choice.

BasicDad · 02/01/2022 12:18

@diddl

But surely they both took the risk knowingly?
They did. But only one gets to choose if they keep the baby or not.
diddl · 02/01/2022 12:07

But surely they both took the risk knowingly?

BasicDad · 02/01/2022 12:02

Definitely no sympathy for your DH now we know that he knew there was no birth control.

He knew the risks, so he has to be responsible for the outcome. And he can't expect you to terminate the pregnancy. As many others have said. It's your body.

It's his choice if he leaves because of it. But I think he would be unreasonable considering that he knew full well about the lack of birth control.

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 11:46

[quote GroggyLegs]@ThymeTravel - I'm interested to know what compromise you think they could come to here?

What are you advocating for?[/quote]
I'm not advocating for either, as I'm not involved in their relationship. I'm very much on both sides.

Both sides matter. "Sod your husband, don't consider his feelings, and do as you please" shouldn't be an option. Yes, it's an awful situation, but both sides matter regardless.

People jumped on the bandwagon of "Do what's best for you, not him" before even knowing the full facts regarding contraception.