Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Having a baby your husband doesn't won't

233 replies

PullItUp · 01/01/2022 20:33

Has anyone been through this?

Pregnant with a baby that wasn't planned that your husband doesn't want but you do? What do you do?

OP posts:
youvegottenminuteslynn · 02/01/2022 19:53

@ThymeTravel

You're implying that men don't matter, and that's so so wrong! You have to consider both sides and how both feel.

Not sure how you can say this when I specifically said I would feel terrible for the guy in your hypothetical situation and my empathy would be with him...

That empathy just doesn't mean I think he gets the final say over a pregnancy. Which you now say you agree with!

HelenGraham2121 · 02/01/2022 19:52

But he always said he absolutely categorically was done with children after that as he had 3 and didn't want anymore.

Then he should have had a vasectomy.

(With the caveat thry are not 100% foolproof and he's responsible for any baby conceived if it fails .... he could use condoms as well.of course, but these men are often not keen on condoms, their sensation and pleasure shouldn't be affected; their wife however can suffer through a termination if she falls pregnant).

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 19:51

@GalacticGoddess

Emotional pain can be much worse than physical.

I have to say though, you don't seem sympathetic to the men in these hypothetical scenarios, only the women. I find that very disturbing.

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 19:49

[quote GalacticGoddess]@ThymeTravel 'Let's say that a man was trying to be safe and wore condoms. Behind the scenes his DP/DW is poking holes in the condoms.

She gets pregnant. The man doesn't want it but she does.

Are you saying that the woman ultimately gets to decide to bring his child into the world against his will after what she done?'

Yep, they get no say at all. Because they can walk away with no physical damage. Women cannot. Women either go through the damage (emotional and sometimes physical) of abortion or the damage and potential fatality of childbirth. Men get no say. Nor should they ever. The only final say they should get re a woman's pregnancy is having a vasectomy to ensure they don't have kids if they don't want them! [/quote]
No physical damage, yes. What about the emotional damage he'll have to suffer?

I think the opinion of "No say at all" is incredibly cruel and selfish.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 02/01/2022 19:49

@ThymeTravel

You've communicated your point of view poorly then, as that's not at all what you've suggested so far.

You literally said, in the poking holes in the condom example: "Are you saying that the woman ultimately gets to decide to bring his child into the world against his will after what she done?" as if it was a gotcha and you didn't think it was right to say she would ultimately get to decide that.

Now you're saying that you too would fundamentally agree that yes she absolutely would get to decide that...

Glad you agree after all!

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 19:46

@youvegottenminuteslynn

But if you could make laws *@ThymeTravel* why wouldn't you make them align with what you genuinely believe to be morally right?

Or is it the case that you do in fact know it would be wrong to give men an equal say over a pregnancy being continued or not?

I don't understand your assertion it should be equal coupled with you saying you wouldn't make that the legal state of play.

Because it would be incredibly cruel and immoral to enforce that. Therefore, I wouldn't.

My point, is that a man should have equal say (between himself and his sexual partner) in the matter from a moral perspective, and his opinions and feelings should absolutely be considered by the woman, who would then make the final decision.

It can't just be "Do what's right for you, not him" regardless of the situation. You're implying that men don't matter, and that's so so wrong!

You have to consider both sides and how both feel. Men very much matter too in these situations, not just women.

HelenGraham2121 · 02/01/2022 19:44

Many years ago my lovely friend had a surprise 3rd child . Her husband was not happy

Makes it sound like she, herself, had a child.

As for husbands being unhappy with pregnancies they 50% caused (and contraception can fail anytime), they can can less than thrilled, but if they pressure theur wives then abort; they are excuses for men, excuses for human beings

LondonQueen · 02/01/2022 19:44

It would be a divorce for me. Is DH happy to keep the baby or is he wanting you to have an abortion. That would be the deciding factor for me.

GalacticGoddess · 02/01/2022 19:44

[quote GalacticGoddess]@ThymeTravel 'Let's say that a man was trying to be safe and wore condoms. Behind the scenes his DP/DW is poking holes in the condoms.

She gets pregnant. The man doesn't want it but she does.

Are you saying that the woman ultimately gets to decide to bring his child into the world against his will after what she done?'

Yep, they get no say at all. Because they can walk away with no physical damage. Women cannot. Women either go through the damage (emotional and sometimes physical) of abortion or the damage and potential fatality of childbirth. Men get no say. Nor should they ever. The only final say they should get re a woman's pregnancy is having a vasectomy to ensure they don't have kids if they don't want them! [/quote]
On a further note, you might well feel sorry for the man but ultimately, he still has no say in what the woman does with her body.

GalacticGoddess · 02/01/2022 19:43

@ThymeTravel 'Let's say that a man was trying to be safe and wore condoms. Behind the scenes his DP/DW is poking holes in the condoms.

She gets pregnant. The man doesn't want it but she does.

Are you saying that the woman ultimately gets to decide to bring his child into the world against his will after what she done?'

Yep, they get no say at all. Because they can walk away with no physical damage. Women cannot. Women either go through the damage (emotional and sometimes physical) of abortion or the damage and potential fatality of childbirth. Men get no say. Nor should they ever. The only final say they should get re a woman's pregnancy is having a vasectomy to ensure they don't have kids if they don't want them!

youvegottenminuteslynn · 02/01/2022 19:43

Are you saying that the woman ultimately gets to decide to bring his child into the world against his will after what she done?

I would think she was incredibly selfish and I would feel absolutely terrible for the man who had his trust betrayed. My sympathy would be entirely with him but despite that I could never and will never sanction the idea that once a woman is pregnant, a man has the right to compel that woman to abort.

It is too much of a slippery slope when it comes to the bodily autonomy of women.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 02/01/2022 19:40

But if you could make laws @ThymeTravel why wouldn't you make them align with what you genuinely believe to be morally right?

Or is it the case that you do in fact know it would be wrong to give men an equal say over a pregnancy being continued or not?

I don't understand your assertion it should be equal coupled with you saying you wouldn't make that the legal state of play.

ClaudiaJ1 · 02/01/2022 19:38

@ThymeTravel That's a strongman argument. I'm arguing that men have a right to say whether or not a pregnancy should be continued, morally, not legally.

Men might have a right to a say, in whether the pregnancy should be continued, but not the final say. As it is not his body, doesn't affect his body, and doesn't involve him. They can have 'a' say, but not "the" say.

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 19:37

*specified

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 19:37

[quote youvegottenminuteslynn]@ThymeTravel

You say 'morally?' so let's say for arguments sake you could literally make laws.

You would therefore make a law that reflected what you believed to be morally right - that Steve gets an equal say in whether or not Mary continues the pregnancy, because she lied about being on the pill?

Would you really make that the legal precedent? [/quote]
No, which is why I specifically that he should have a say morally, not legally 🙄

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 19:35

[quote youvegottenminuteslynn]@ThymeTravel

So it's OK to remove the rights from the man, but not the woman? You can't have it both ways. It's about equally.

You can't have absolute equality when two parties cannot experience the same thing.

If men could carry babies then they would get the 'deciding vote', for want of a better phrase, on the baby they were carrying in their body. Rightly so.

Men do not have the "right" to decide if a woman carries and delivers a baby.

Women do have the "right" to decide whether or not they want to carry and deliver a baby with their own body.

I'm gobsmacked that instead of acknowledging that it's offensive to suggest women shouldn't have the final say as individuals when it comes to pregnancy, you've doubled down.

If you genuinely think that when it comes to a baby being carried and born, men and women get an EQUAL vote when one of them will be doing the carrying and birthing while the other doesn't, then I honestly don't think you could describe yourself as having feminist values.

Because an "equal" vote simply means men having autonomy over their own body AND that of women. And because there is no equivalent (you can't force a man to be pregnant) the same would never be true if the sexes were reversed. [/quote]
Let's say that a man was trying to be safe and wore condoms. Behind the scenes his DP/DW is poking holes in the condoms.

She gets pregnant. The man doesn't want it but she does.

Are you saying that the woman ultimately gets to decide to bring his child into the world against his will after what she done?

youvegottenminuteslynn · 02/01/2022 19:32

@ThymeTravel

You say 'morally?' so let's say for arguments sake you could literally make laws.

You would therefore make a law that reflected what you believed to be morally right - that Steve gets an equal say in whether or not Mary continues the pregnancy, because she lied about being on the pill?

Would you really make that the legal precedent?

GalacticGoddess · 02/01/2022 19:32

@DeepaBeesKit Don't feel bad for the DH - he's the one who chose to risk having another child by not having a vasectomy. It's his business, tough sh*t I say. Look after the child or pay for the upkeep. 🤷🏽‍♀️

@sst1234 I think OP has said she's pregnant. She hasn't tricked him - also he has 3 other children so he knows how sex works and the potential outcomes 🤦🏾‍♀️

TOO MANY (presumably) women on here feeling sorry for a man who:

1.) is a grown adult who knows how sex works
2.) could have chosen a vasectomy if he really didn't want any more children
3.) is making OP feel bad about something they both did together

OP - the decision is yours and yours alone. I really hope he comes around to the idea but for me personally, I'd do as many PPs say and keep the baby not the guy

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 19:27

@SleepingStandingUp

If a man lies about wearing a condom it's considered rape in some places. Yet, if a woman lies about contraception and falls pregnant the man has no rights. How is that fair? I find your views highly disturbing, as you're implying that men have no rights in these scenarios. It's disgusting. So what rights would you give men? Many is pregnant, she told Steve was in the pill. She wasn't. She's pregnant. She wants it. He doesn't. What rights should Steve have beyond a right to an opinion?
Morally? Equal say in the matter, and the woman should respect that.
SleepingStandingUp · 02/01/2022 19:21

If a man lies about wearing a condom it's considered rape in some places. Yet, if a woman lies about contraception and falls pregnant the man has no rights.
How is that fair? I find your views highly disturbing, as you're implying that men have no rights in these scenarios. It's disgusting.
So what rights would you give men? Many is pregnant, she told Steve was in the pill. She wasn't. She's pregnant. She wants it. He doesn't. What rights should Steve have beyond a right to an opinion?

youvegottenminuteslynn · 02/01/2022 19:18

@ThymeTravel

So it's OK to remove the rights from the man, but not the woman? You can't have it both ways. It's about equally.

You can't have absolute equality when two parties cannot experience the same thing.

If men could carry babies then they would get the 'deciding vote', for want of a better phrase, on the baby they were carrying in their body. Rightly so.

Men do not have the "right" to decide if a woman carries and delivers a baby.

Women do have the "right" to decide whether or not they want to carry and deliver a baby with their own body.

I'm gobsmacked that instead of acknowledging that it's offensive to suggest women shouldn't have the final say as individuals when it comes to pregnancy, you've doubled down.

If you genuinely think that when it comes to a baby being carried and born, men and women get an EQUAL vote when one of them will be doing the carrying and birthing while the other doesn't, then I honestly don't think you could describe yourself as having feminist values.

Because an "equal" vote simply means men having autonomy over their own body AND that of women. And because there is no equivalent (you can't force a man to be pregnant) the same would never be true if the sexes were reversed.

BasicDad · 02/01/2022 19:16

Don't agree @ThymeTravel once a woman is pregnant the only rights between the baby and the mother, is the mother's.

The father has the right to leave the relationship though.

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 19:14

[quote IncompleteSenten]@ThymeTravel

Really?

If a woman becomes pregnant and lied about being on contraception that is a fact that means she loses the right to make the decision whether or not to proceed with the pregnancy?

So you are saying she would be taken against her will to a clinic and have a forced abortion?

That is your view?

Crikey. That's rather disturbing.[/quote]
That's a strongman argument. I'm arguing that men have a right to say whether or not a pregnancy should be continued, morally, not legally.

If a man lies about wearing a condom it's considered rape in some places. Yet, if a woman lies about contraception and falls pregnant the man has no rights.

How is that fair? I find your views highly disturbing, as you're implying that men have no rights in these scenarios. It's disgusting.

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 19:10

[quote youvegottenminuteslynn]@ThymeTravel

Someone asked you:

Give me one single fact that would remove the right to make the decision from the woman.

And you answered:

One single fact (not relates to this thread) would be if the woman lied about being on contraception.

So you think that if a woman lied about being on contraception, that would "remove the right to make the decision from the woman."

Blimey.

If a hypothetical woman lied to her husband about contraception and got pregnant on purpose I would absolutely think she was incredibly selfish.

I wouldn't think it would remove her right to make a decision about her pregnancy. This isn't Giles's.[/quote]
So it's OK to remove the rights from the man, but not the woman? You can't have it both ways. It's about equally.

It affects both parties.

Outlyingtrout · 02/01/2022 18:39

Just last week there was a thread where the ops husband didn't want anymore children, had taken responsibility and had a vasectomy. The OP was outraged he'd "taken the choice away from her" and more than half the posters agreed with the op, saying they'd leave their partners if they did this. So looks like it doesn't matter what a man does he will always be wrong.

Yet another complete misrepresentation of that thread to suit an agenda. People commenting on the thread were generally not critical of the husband’s choice to have a vasectomy. People were critical of the fact he had a vasectomy in secret after having previously discussed the potential for further children.