Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Having a baby your husband doesn't won't

233 replies

PullItUp · 01/01/2022 20:33

Has anyone been through this?

Pregnant with a baby that wasn't planned that your husband doesn't want but you do? What do you do?

OP posts:
ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 21:47

*should have got a vasectomy

Apologies!

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 21:46

*women

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 21:46

@youvegottenminuteslynn

I can't help noticing that nobody has argued with anyone who has claimed that it's ok for a woman to demand a man has a vasectomy, but not that a woman should have an abortion. It feels as though "your body, your choice" only applies to women, because men don't matter. Therefore proving my point even more.

Eh? I don't think it's ok for a woman to demand a man has a vasectomy. Demanding a man has a vasectomy is wrong.

I absolutely ALWAYS think it should be 'your body, your choice' for both men and women. HTH.

Many people on this thread have said that the OPS DP should have got an abortion.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't believe you called them out on it? You only called me out because you thought I was saying that it's OK for men to demand woman have abortions, which I wasn't.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 02/01/2022 21:39

I can't help noticing that nobody has argued with anyone who has claimed that it's ok for a woman to demand a man has a vasectomy, but not that a woman should have an abortion. It feels as though "your body, your choice" only applies to women, because men don't matter. Therefore proving my point even more.

Eh? I don't think it's ok for a woman to demand a man has a vasectomy. Demanding a man has a vasectomy is wrong.

I absolutely ALWAYS think it should be 'your body, your choice' for both men and women. HTH.

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 21:33

@youvegottenminuteslynn

I find that you have sympathy for men who want to make women have abortions they don't want, very disturbing.

Well said! I can't tell if the poster is being disingenuous or just 'what about the menz' but I agree not fair on OP to keep derailing so I'm going to leave it there too.

Her comment wasn't well said though, she simply agreed with you, and you're happy about that Confused what she said was completely false, as I never once said that men can "force" women to have abortions. I said the opposite 🙄

It's ok to be on both sides. I empathise with both genders in these scenarios, nothing wrong with that.

I can't help noticing that nobody has argued with anyone who has claimed that it's ok for a woman to demand a man has a vasectomy, but not that a woman should have an abortion. It feels as though "your body, your choice" only applies to women, because men don't matter. Therefore proving my point even more.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 02/01/2022 21:27

I find that you have sympathy for men who want to make women have abortions they don't want, very disturbing.

Well said! I can't tell if the poster is being disingenuous or just 'what about the menz' but I agree not fair on OP to keep derailing so I'm going to leave it there too.

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 21:25

@me4real

I don't want to get too much into a more abstract debate as IDK if that helps the OP.

I have to say though, you don't seem sympathetic to the men in these hypothetical scenarios, only the women. I find that very disturbing.

I find that you have sympathy for men who want to make women have abortions they don't want, very disturbing.

Of course it is OPs decision, but aside from whether she wants the child enough to potentially be a single parent, she should also consider the impact that having a father who actively does not want you could have on the child. I was the child in that situation and it was damaging, to an extent I've only fully realised as an adult. I think there's a tendency to forget in some situations I read about here that there's a whole other human involved in these dilemmas, who has no say at all but whose entire life will be shaped by their parent's decisions and actions.

@ImInStealthMode Would you rather you'd never been born? I like to think you've got some pleasure from life at times.

If someone has one parent that loves them that's not so bad. So sorry you had that experience with your dad/parents. Sad I like to think most men aren't so nasty that they would be cruel or ignore a child to their face once they're born.

Even if they split with their partner or whatever. It's better they don't stick around than be abusive/neglectful.

@me4real

Sorry, would you mind quoting where I said that I sympathise with men who want to force their partners to have abortions? I'm a little confused by your comment.

In actual fact, I sympathise with men who have absolutely zero say in whether or not they have a child, and I'm allowed to sympathise with them. We don't have to hate men to be right in this situation.

me4real · 02/01/2022 21:20

I don't want to get too much into a more abstract debate as IDK if that helps the OP.

I have to say though, you don't seem sympathetic to the men in these hypothetical scenarios, only the women. I find that very disturbing.

I find that you have sympathy for men who want to make women have abortions they don't want, very disturbing.

Of course it is OPs decision, but aside from whether she wants the child enough to potentially be a single parent, she should also consider the impact that having a father who actively does not want you could have on the child. I was the child in that situation and it was damaging, to an extent I've only fully realised as an adult. I think there's a tendency to forget in some situations I read about here that there's a whole other human involved in these dilemmas, who has no say at all but whose entire life will be shaped by their parent's decisions and actions.

@ImInStealthMode Would you rather you'd never been born? I like to think you've got some pleasure from life at times.

If someone has one parent that loves them that's not so bad. So sorry you had that experience with your dad/parents. Sad I like to think most men aren't so nasty that they would be cruel or ignore a child to their face once they're born.

Even if they split with their partner or whatever. It's better they don't stick around than be abusive/neglectful.

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 21:17

@HelenGraham2121

But he always said he absolutely categorically was done with children after that as he had 3 and didn't want anymore.

Then he should have had a vasectomy.

(With the caveat thry are not 100% foolproof and he's responsible for any baby conceived if it fails .... he could use condoms as well.of course, but these men are often not keen on condoms, their sensation and pleasure shouldn't be affected; their wife however can suffer through a termination if she falls pregnant).

Question - why is it OK to say a man should have a vasectomy, but not that a woman should have an abortion?

Their body their choice, but only when it comes to a woman?

Teaandtoastedbiscuits · 02/01/2022 21:17

Keep the baby. Your body your choice. If you don't you will probably break up anyway through the trauma of not going through with a wanted pregnancy Chances are he will love the baby when it comes It is always best to do what you feel is the right thing for you.

unluckyinlife · 02/01/2022 21:06

I had this. Our relationship was awful the entire pregnancy and although he loved her he resented everything in the beginning. We are still together, very much in love but for a long time I didn't think we would make it through x

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 21:04

@TractorAndHeadphones

Exactly!! It's not a case of all or nothing e.g. the woman can do as she pleases with her body, therefore the mans feeling don't matter in the slightest. There has to be give or take, and the man has to be considered, as well as the rest of the family.

TractorAndHeadphones · 02/01/2022 21:00

*'just' whether she wants the baby.

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 21:00

@TueWed

My point, is that a man should have equal say (between himself and his sexual partner) in the matter from a moral perspective, and his opinions and feelings should absolutely be considered by the woman, who would then make the final decision.

How is it an equal say if the woman makes the final decision.

I think I get what you are trying to say, that the woman should talk to the man, and come to a decision together. That does make sense, but overall fundamentally, a woman who is pregnant doesnt have to do that, and that is ok

You're right, she doesn't have to do it. But, in some circumstances it isn't ok to force a man to become a father against his will.
TractorAndHeadphones · 02/01/2022 20:59

@ThymeTravel

Please don't put words in my mouth, thank you. Our stances are not the same, at all.

I come very much from an equality perspective, whereas yours is all about the woman's perspective.

I also said multiple times that I believe men should have a say from a MORAL perspective, not a legal perspective as you can't force a woman to do something with her body that she wouldn't want.

Bottom line - the men in these situations matter as much as the women.

@ThymeTravel People are being deliberately obtuse which sadly proves your point! Of course you can't 'legally' give men a say in what a woman does to her body. But it's not wrong to say that the baby's father's opinion should listened to.

In practical terms it's not just the matter of the father's opinion. It's the impact on the whole family. Including children who already exist. In terms of finances, juggling time and busyness.

In the end it IS up to the woman whether or not to keep the baby. But it's not a question of whether she 'wants' the baby. She has to accept the impact it will have on her whole life.

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 20:58

[quote IncompleteSenten]@ThymeTravel .

No. A man has absolutely no right to decide whether a woman continues with a pregnancy or not.

You are skirting around the fact that if you give the father "a say" then you are surely saying that a woman should in certain circumstances be made to have an abortion against her will.

You aren't being very clear so I will ask you a very simple question.

Do you think that a woman should ever be taken to a clinic against her will and have an abortion performed on her without her consent if the father does not want the child.

A simple yes or no.

One word.

No dodging.

Yes.

No.[/quote]
Sorry, I think you need to follow the conversation a bit closer. This was all clarified.

TueWed · 02/01/2022 20:55

My point, is that a man should have equal say (between himself and his sexual partner) in the matter from a moral perspective, and his opinions and feelings should absolutely be considered by the woman, who would then make the final decision.

How is it an equal say if the woman makes the final decision.

I think I get what you are trying to say, that the woman should talk to the man, and come to a decision together. That does make sense, but overall fundamentally, a woman who is pregnant doesnt have to do that, and that is ok

WonderfulYou · 02/01/2022 20:48

But he always said he absolutely categorically was done with children after that as he had 3 and didn't want anymore.

Then it would be unfair to expect him to stay with you or be involved with the child.

Yes he could have had a vasectomy but seeing as you were using contraception yourself then you made it seem you don’t want a baby yourself.

I know there are PPs who’ve said their partners came around to the idea but they are rare.

You need to be prepared that you will be bringing this child up alone if you go through with it - that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t keep the baby though if you really want it.

IncompleteSenten · 02/01/2022 20:24

@ThymeTravel .

No. A man has absolutely no right to decide whether a woman continues with a pregnancy or not.

You are skirting around the fact that if you give the father "a say" then you are surely saying that a woman should in certain circumstances be made to have an abortion against her will.

You aren't being very clear so I will ask you a very simple question.

Do you think that a woman should ever be taken to a clinic against her will and have an abortion performed on her without her consent if the father does not want the child.

A simple yes or no.

One word.

No dodging.

Yes.

No.

Nikkic2123 · 02/01/2022 20:13

If you’re replying to me, I’m saying what I would do.
Thank you!!

GalacticGoddess · 02/01/2022 20:10

@ThymeTravel Of course it can be?
I only have so much sympathy really because too often women bear the brunt of child rearing after men have decided they don't want to stick around.

If OPs partner didn't want to have another baby he should have sorted his vasectomy out after child no3. Again, it's his business ...🤷🏽‍♀️

youvegottenminuteslynn · 02/01/2022 20:01

@ThymeTravel

Please don't put words in my mouth, thank you. Our stances are not the same, at all.

I come very much from an equality perspective, whereas yours is all about the woman's perspective.

I also said multiple times that I believe men should have a say from a MORAL perspective, not a legal perspective as you can't force a woman to do something with her body that she wouldn't want.

Bottom line - the men in these situations matter as much as the women.

Your stance is unclear as you say one thing is your moral position but that it's not something you'd want to happen in reality... meaning you know it's not a morally sound stance. Otherwise you'd be happy to see it in reality.

Agree to disagree I guess!

ImInStealthMode · 02/01/2022 19:58

Obviously if he didn't want more children he should have had a vasectomy or worn a condom, but too late for that now so no point taking it into account.

Of course it is OPs decision, but aside from whether she wants the child enough to potentially be a single parent, she should also consider the impact that having a father who actively does not want you could have on the child. I was the child in that situation and it was damaging, to an extent I've only fully realised as an adult.

I think there's a tendency to forget in some situations I read about here that there's a whole other human involved in these dilemmas, who has no say at all but whose entire life will be shaped by their parent's decisions and actions.

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 19:56

Please don't put words in my mouth, thank you. Our stances are not the same, at all.

I come very much from an equality perspective, whereas yours is all about the woman's perspective.

I also said multiple times that I believe men should have a say from a MORAL perspective, not a legal perspective as you can't force a woman to do something with her body that she wouldn't want.

Bottom line - the men in these situations matter as much as the women.

Nikkic2123 · 02/01/2022 19:55

I'm so sorry ur in this situation- I'd have it if it were me.
If he left me carrying his child he couldn't have loved me that much in the first place xx