Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Having a baby your husband doesn't won't

233 replies

PullItUp · 01/01/2022 20:33

Has anyone been through this?

Pregnant with a baby that wasn't planned that your husband doesn't want but you do? What do you do?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ImustLearn2Cook · 04/01/2022 00:43

@ThymeTravel Equality has never ever been about taking away another persons self governance aka autonomy.

We all have autonomy, it’s actually part of our human development. Developmentally our stages of autonomy as we age does not differ between the sexes.

So, just as a woman ultimately has no equal say in a man’s choice to have a vasectomy because it is his body. A man has no say in whether a woman continues or discontinues with pregnancy because it is her body. Neither does a man have a say in how or where or with whom she gives birth because it is her body and giving birth is biologically happening to her body, her health risks and yes women still die in child birth in modern times.

Equality does not ever mean that people have an equal say in what happens to our bodies, to our personal lives.

It is immoral to take away people’s freedom of choice, their autonomy. No one should morally have that right over another person, not a husband or a wife. The only exception would be of reduced capacity or because of their age and stage of development they are not able to make certain decisions. And even there we should tread carefully and seek to allow as much freedom of choice as possible and where appropriate.

So, in conclusion I disagree with you that morally a man has a right to a say in the decision about ending or continuing a pregnancy.

He does have the right to not participate, the right to leave.

ClaudiaJ1 · 03/01/2022 22:17

What have you decided to do, @PullItUp ?

me4real · 03/01/2022 21:47

@RobertaFirmino Unless the woman wants one. (Not that I'm suggesting OP did this deliberately.)

RobertaFirmino · 03/01/2022 15:04

Man has unprotected sex with woman, knowing he does not want any more children.

Woman has unprotected sex with man, knowing he does not want any more children.

Both parties are equally foolish.

mrkramps · 03/01/2022 14:39

@SleepingStandingUp

If a man lies about wearing a condom it's considered rape in some places. Yet, if a woman lies about contraception and falls pregnant the man has no rights. How is that fair? I find your views highly disturbing, as you're implying that men have no rights in these scenarios. It's disgusting. So what rights would you give men? Many is pregnant, she told Steve was in the pill. She wasn't. She's pregnant. She wants it. He doesn't. What rights should Steve have beyond a right to an opinion?

Lying about contraception is messed up regardless of the liar's sex. It seems like you're implying it's ok (it's not)

Different if a man knowingly has unprotected sex with a woman not on contraception/open to pregnancy, then it's his problem, unfortunately

CriminalOrator · 03/01/2022 14:35

Goodness me, ThymeTravel’s viewpoints are confused and concerning. The lack of understanding and blind determination to fight logic is textbook MRM.

I would say this, TT, don’t waste your breath fighting for ‘men’s rights’, they don’t need you…

Shallwegoforawalk · 03/01/2022 00:27

[quote youvegottenminuteslynn]**@ThymeTravel

So it's OK to remove the rights from the man, but not the woman? You can't have it both ways. It's about equally.

You can't have absolute equality when two parties cannot experience the same thing.

If men could carry babies then they would get the 'deciding vote', for want of a better phrase, on the baby they were carrying in their body. Rightly so.

Men do not have the "right" to decide if a woman carries and delivers a baby.

Women do have the "right" to decide whether or not they want to carry and deliver a baby with their own body.

I'm gobsmacked that instead of acknowledging that it's offensive to suggest women shouldn't have the final say as individuals when it comes to pregnancy, you've doubled down.

If you genuinely think that when it comes to a baby being carried and born, men and women get an EQUAL vote when one of them will be doing the carrying and birthing while the other doesn't, then I honestly don't think you could describe yourself as having feminist values.

Because an "equal" vote simply means men having autonomy over their own body AND that of women. And because there is no equivalent (you can't force a man to be pregnant) the same would never be true if the sexes were reversed. [/quote]
Was trying to articulate a reply to the scary nonsense of @ThymeTravel but @youvegottenminuteslynn has done it perfectly.

Shallwegoforawalk · 03/01/2022 00:20

@ClaudiaJ1

But he always said he absolutely categorically was done with children after that as he had 3 and didn't want anymore.

Then why doesn't he have a vasectomy then??? He can't be too worried about having another child if he (and he is the one that causes the pregnancy) won't take the permanent solution. Especially as you're not getting on with hormonal contraception. He's got a cheek to be upset or 'not want' it. He should have had a vasectomy so it's his own fault. You've done your bit. Birthed his children. Took hormones and contraception. Time for him to step up. Tell him unless he has a vasectomy then he needs to accept the risk you will become pregnant again even after this one. I can't be doing with men who won't take responsibility. It's his sperm. It's his responsibility to have a vasectomy or use condoms and accept the risk with that.

Yes this!

👏👏👏

ImInStealthMode · 02/01/2022 22:56

@me4real Yes (on the whole) my life has been fine, aside from 20+ years of wondering why I wasn't good enough but my half-sibling was, and all the damage that did to my relationships with Men as an adult.

But if I'd never been born I wouldn't have 'missed out', I'd just never have been, like every other unfertilised egg. Bit of a moot point.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 02/01/2022 22:49

Fair enough, my apologies. I'm not back tracking though, I just wasn't clear at all and I apologise for that.

Thanks.

The right should never be "removed" from the woman. But morally, if a woman lies and tricks a man in such a manner, she should DEFINITELY consider the feelings and needs of the man before her own

So close!

I give up, it's all there above so no point keeping on repeating your verbatim words to you and you then saying words have been put in your mouth. It's bizarre.

SleepingStandingUp · 02/01/2022 22:47

[quote youvegottenminuteslynn]@ThymeTravel

You say 'morally?' so let's say for arguments sake you could literally make laws.

You would therefore make a law that reflected what you believed to be morally right - that Steve gets an equal say in whether or not Mary continues the pregnancy, because she lied about being on the pill?

Would you really make that the legal precedent? [/quote]
And how does equal say work? He says abort
She says keep. Now what? Court? A judge to pass an order to pin down Mary who's now 14 weeks gone and force an abortion?

HesJustAPoorBoy · 02/01/2022 22:40

I wouldn't call just copying and pasting your own replies "putting words in your mouth"

IncompleteSenten · 02/01/2022 22:32

Just give it up.
You were clear and you were consistent. These were all your words.

IncompleteSenten · 02/01/2022 22:30

😂😂😂😂😂

I quoted your responses. See the post directly above the one you're responding to.

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 22:24

@IncompleteSenten

Look. If you're holding these views at least have the balls to own them.
I'll decide what my views are, thank you very much. Putting words into my mouth does not I'm saying what you're telling me I'm saying. It's It's very weak argument to decided off your own back what someone means, rather than actually listen to them.

Never once did I mention a forced abortion, as you'll see if you follow my responses.

HesJustAPoorBoy · 02/01/2022 22:20

The equality comes from having the option to do what you want with your own body. Just because those options are not exactly the same for men and women doesn't mean that is not equal.

Men have the option to prevent pregnancy, they can have a vasectomy.

Women have the option to proceed or abort a pregnancy.

Equal.

HesJustAPoorBoy · 02/01/2022 22:18

It's literally impossible for men and women to be completely equal in all things, especially when it comes to biology.

A man cannot have an equal say in regards to a pregnancy because his experience of that pregnancy is not equal to the woman's and never can be.

Just as a woman cannot have an equal say in regards to a vasectomy because her experience of it is never going to be equal to his.

You can't have equality where it's literally impossible for it to actually exist.

Pregnancy is up to the woman because physically she is the only one going through it.

Vasectomy is up to the man because physically he is the only one going through it.

TueWed · 02/01/2022 22:08

@ThymeTravel

Question - why is it OK to say a man should have a vasectomy, but not that a woman should have an abortion?

Their body their choice, but only when it comes to a woman?

Well it does work for both, if you dont want children and you are male have a vasectomy (or be very very careful with condoms etc), if you are a female who doesnt want to be pregnant have an abortion.

No one is forcing either to do something they dont want to - the man has autonomy over his own body and so does the woman

IncompleteSenten · 02/01/2022 22:03

Look. If you're holding these views at least have the balls to own them.

IncompleteSenten · 02/01/2022 22:02

I asked you
"Give me one single fact that would remove the right to make the decision from the woman."

And you replied
"One single fact (not relates to this thread) would be if the woman lied about being on contraception"

You said that one situation that in your view would remove from a woman the right to decide to continue a pregnancy would be if she lied about being on contraception.

Those were your words. So you clearly do think that there are situations where a woman should have a forced abortion. Otherwise why did you say that?

When someone else asked you if you actually meant your reply, you said "So it's OK to remove the rights from the man, but not the woman? You can't have it both ways. It's about equally."

Yet again confirming that yes, you believe there should be situations where a woman has a forced abortion.

Then you compared it to rape "If a man lies about wearing a condom it's considered rape in some places. Yet, if a woman lies about contraception and falls pregnant the man has no rights.

How is that fair? I find your views highly disturbing, as you're implying that men have no rights in these scenarios. It's disgusting"

Saying that it is morally wrong that a man has no right to force an abortion. Clearly, again, this is confirming you think he should have that right

Next it was"

"Morally? Equal say in the matter, and the woman should respect that.

Again. Equal say. How does that work when it is something there can be no compromise on? What form would his 'equal say' take?

Then your hypothetical poking holes in the condom argument

"She gets pregnant. The man doesn't want it but she does.

Are you saying that the woman ultimately gets to decide to bring his child into the world against his will after what she done"

Yet again sounds exactly like you think she should be forced to have an abortion.

"But, in some circumstances it isn't ok to force a man to become a father against his will"

Hello again. Isn't ok to force a man to become a father against his will = woman should be forced to abort

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 21:59

[quote youvegottenminuteslynn]@ThymeTravel

You only called me out because you thought I was saying that it's OK for men to demand woman have abortions, which I wasn't.

You're rewriting history now. As a reminder...

Someone asked you:

Give me one single fact that would remove the right to make the decision from the woman.

And you answered in response, specifically, word for word:

One single fact (not relates to this thread) would be if the woman lied about being on contraception.

So you stated clearly that you think that if a woman lied about being on contraception, that would "remove the right to make the decision from the woman."

You later tried to backtrack but your words are there in black and white so I've no idea why you're claiming otherwise, it's all very odd![/quote]
Fair enough, my apologies. I'm not back tracking though, I just wasn't clear at all and I apologise for that.

The right should never be "removed" from the woman. But morally, if a woman lies and tricks a man in such a manner, she should DEFINITELY consider the feelings and needs of the man before her own.

ClaudiaJ1 · 02/01/2022 21:59

@ThymeTravel Saying if a man didn't want any more children then he should have had a vasectomy is common sense. It's not a 'demand'.

ThymeTravel · 02/01/2022 21:56

[quote IncompleteSenten]@ThymeTravel
I've gone back and yes, I apologise. You did indeed clarify several times that you believe that there are situations where a woman should undergo a forced abortion.

Again, my apologies. That is indeed your clearly stated view.[/quote]
No, I didn't state that any women should undergo a forced abortion. I have no idea where you're getting that from, I'm afraid.

I simply stated that a man's view should matter, and therefore should be considered.

People then decided that I was saying that women should be forced to have abortions when the man doesn't want the child - a stance I have never once taken. Simply a strawman argument from PP.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 02/01/2022 21:56

@ThymeTravel

You only called me out because you thought I was saying that it's OK for men to demand woman have abortions, which I wasn't.

You're rewriting history now. As a reminder...

Someone asked you:

Give me one single fact that would remove the right to make the decision from the woman.

And you answered in response, specifically, word for word:

One single fact (not relates to this thread) would be if the woman lied about being on contraception.

So you stated clearly that you think that if a woman lied about being on contraception, that would "remove the right to make the decision from the woman."

You later tried to backtrack but your words are there in black and white so I've no idea why you're claiming otherwise, it's all very odd!

IncompleteSenten · 02/01/2022 21:48

@ThymeTravel
I've gone back and yes, I apologise. You did indeed clarify several times that you believe that there are situations where a woman should undergo a forced abortion.

Again, my apologies. That is indeed your clearly stated view.

Swipe left for the next trending thread