Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Standing by your spouse when SC are involved

219 replies

Sweetchillidiphigh · 01/01/2022 20:33

I know mumsnet is generally anti step parent and pro step child. No matter what. Now everything I’ve seen with regards marital advice with blended families is that your spouse must be number 1. Now I can understand how that may be extremely hard when your DC are still children but when they reach adulthood, should SC expect to be prioritised over their step parent? And should a parent stand by their spouse or child?
YABU = Spouse comes first
YANBU = Adult child comes first

OP posts:
PinniGig · 03/01/2022 21:36

@SleepOhHowIMissYou That's not what's happening. The daughter is already banned from her father's home. He is not happy with her "bad behaviour".However, it seems he is maintaining a relationship with her (because she is his daughter and he loves her) and the OP feels this is a betrayal of her, that he should take her side of the argument and disown her

That's not what I meant or thought was happening. OP said her adult stepdaughter was awful to her and then expected her father to prioritise and side with her as well.

Can't say I'm particularly on board or supportive of any ultimatums and pressure to pick a side of the fence and sit on it - not in any situation like that to be honest. Step families can be a nightmare at the best of times but I have always drawn the line at being expected to tolerate bollocks and nonsense on the grounds that they're technically family and so should be given a bit more leeway.

My point was it's not acceptable for any grown adult to treat you appallingly regardless of who they are and whether it's a relative or otherwise. There is no doubt a much bigger story but my reply was solely in response to the first post, that's all.

RedWingBoots · 03/01/2022 21:31

@SleepOhHowIMissYou myself and other people who have just read the whole thread can see you don't understand the nuances in the discussion you are having with other posters.

They aren't attacking you or calling you names.

ancientgran · 03/01/2022 20:50

@LublinToDublin

It's not a generic question with a single answer.
Well put, it really isn't straightforward and cases will vary.
SleepOhHowIMissYou · 03/01/2022 20:26

@BurntToastAgain

One of us is making lengthy posts and jumping to conclusions.

One of us has suggested the other is a narcissist and lacks basic comprehension skills, oh, and has no empathy (let's not forget that personal attack).

You suggest I am overly invested.

Do you see what YOU'RE doing?

(Don't worry if you don't, everyone else can see it).

twominutesmore · 03/01/2022 19:57

This thread is rather circuitous.

Nobody is saying the sd should be allowed to behave badly with impunity.

But whether being banned from her fathers home forever, and 'never forgiven', is a reasonable response rather depends on the crime. And we don't currently know what that is.

So all a bit moot really, unless op comes back I suppose.

BurntToastAgain · 03/01/2022 19:28

@Stompythedinosaur

Characterising your adult sd's insecurity in her relationship with her father as "bad behaviour" is infantilising, and I wonder if, if you were being honest, might understand where her insecurity has come from? I cannot believe her father had no role in their relationship developing into one where she does not feel secure in his affections.

You seem determined to see her as an enemy to compete with rather than a family member you want to get along better with. Can you try to find things to like about her?

Arguably, insisting that it’s ‘insecurity’ or whatever euphemism might be appropriate for a 7 year old who is behaving badly seems more infantilising than just saying that she is behaving badly.

As an adult, you go to counselling and deal with that insecurity. You don’t expect the world to make allowances for you and to put up with abusive behaviour (which is what bad behaviour in an adult often is).

BurntToastAgain · 03/01/2022 19:26

You're starting to embarrass yourself now. You've tried diagnosing me as a narcissist and making personal attacks on what you think you know about me but this just shows who you are and what tactics you employ.

I haven’t tried diagnosing you as a narcissist. you brought up narcissists. And the (deeply ironically) made several points that were more like narcissism than the ones you were claiming to be narcissistic.

What I will say is that I think you feel very strongly about this and that your responses on here suggest that you might not have sufficiently robust comprehension skills to follow the discussion with any nuance. Do you know what a personal attack actually is?

No one has diagnosed you as anything. There’s a difference between pointing out that the claims you are making are more like narcissism than the people you are calling narcissistic for not seeing their children as extensions of themselves and saying that you are a narcissist yourself.

Just as (to be clear) there is a difference between calling you stupid and saying that your responses here look like you’re struggling to understand the points that @aSofaNearYou was making, in particular. She was perfectly clear (I’m willing to believe that I was not).

This is the same problematic logic you would apply where you take any (legitimate) criticism of your children as a personal slight. And you said you would. It’s not. It’s a comment on their behaviour or something else about them.

There may be ‘two sides to the story’. But you appear to be siding with the other one automatically. And making extremely emotive and judgemental comments about anyone who might feel differently to you.

Do you realise that’s what you are doing?

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 03/01/2022 19:16

@PinniGig

I wouldn't put up with anyone – adult relative or step relative or complete stranger for that matter – come into my home, treat and speak to me like shit and expect that somebody, somewhere is going to have their back and say it's OK and they have done nothing wrong.

Step-child or not you shouldn't be treated like crap and have a grown ass woman behaving like a brat stamping and pulling a hissy fit.

That's not what's happening. The daughter is already banned from her father's home. He is not happy with her "bad behaviour".

However, it seems he is maintaining a relationship with her (because she is his daughter and he loves her) and the OP feels this is a betrayal of her, that he should take her side of the argument and disown her.

PinniGig · 03/01/2022 18:54

I wouldn't put up with anyone – adult relative or step relative or complete stranger for that matter – come into my home, treat and speak to me like shit and expect that somebody, somewhere is going to have their back and say it's OK and they have done nothing wrong.

Step-child or not you shouldn't be treated like crap and have a grown ass woman behaving like a brat stamping and pulling a hissy fit.

Stompythedinosaur · 03/01/2022 18:49

Characterising your adult sd's insecurity in her relationship with her father as "bad behaviour" is infantilising, and I wonder if, if you were being honest, might understand where her insecurity has come from? I cannot believe her father had no role in their relationship developing into one where she does not feel secure in his affections.

You seem determined to see her as an enemy to compete with rather than a family member you want to get along better with. Can you try to find things to like about her?

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 03/01/2022 18:31

@Cherrytart23

Step child or not at the age of 30 they surely know how to be respectful and civil if she can not then I would cut her lose. If dh can not understand his adult daughter is being a mare then you have dh problems.
Would you cut your own child lose if they were being disrespectful?
SleepOhHowIMissYou · 03/01/2022 18:29

@BurntToastAgain

That’s not the response you’d give if it were her MIL, is it? Because it’s an adult child, you insist the OP must be in the wrong.

It’s an online discussion forum. You only ever get one person’s side.

Where have you ever seen me slag off someone's mother in law? I'll tell you, nowhere, because it's never happened.

The reason for this is because I recognise that there are always at least two sides to every story, just like there is here.

You're starting to embarrass yourself now. You've tried diagnosing me as a narcissist and making personal attacks on what you think you know about me but this just shows who you are and what tactics you employ.

Why can't you simply accept that someone may have a different opinion to you?

twominutesmore · 03/01/2022 17:20

"It’s an online discussion forum. You only ever get one person’s side."

Tbf the op does usually explain what's happened so some sort of informed opinion can be made.

IMO, not doing so does make op look like she's overreacting to something she doesn't want to tell mn about.

BurntToastAgain · 03/01/2022 17:13

That’s not the response you’d give if it were her MIL, is it? Because it’s an adult child, you insist the OP must be in the wrong.

It’s an online discussion forum. You only ever get one person’s side.

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 03/01/2022 16:52

@BurntToastAgain

To be clear, in the scenario set out here, the ‘yeilding’ would be to the 30 year old daughter. It would be her father saying: yes. You’re more important to me. I’ll leave my wife because you don’t like her. Even though I think you’re behaving dreadfully.

No child should have that kind of power over their parents. Whatever age they are.

The OP's take is that a 30 year old woman is saying to her Dad "you must leave your wife".

Is that actually happening?

If it is actually happening, what's the story behind it?

We're getting one side here. The wife's. So far she's reluctant to outline the behaviour that led to her husband's child being barred from his home.

There's always more than one side to a story.

Tigertigertigertiger · 03/01/2022 16:46

YOU NEED TO TELL US WHAT HAPPENED/ WHAT THINGS SHE HAS DONE.

SHOUTING BECAUSE YOU HAVE BEEN ASKED SEVERAL TIMES AND NOT GIVEN AN ANSWER

Cherrytart23 · 03/01/2022 16:39

Step child or not at the age of 30 they surely know how to be respectful and civil if she can not then I would cut her lose. If dh can not understand his adult daughter is being a mare then you have dh problems.

Luredbyapomegranate · 03/01/2022 16:19

I think a lot of people have missed she’s an adult, it’s a bit buried. Also, a bit of context would be helpful - what’s happened?

BurntToastAgain · 03/01/2022 16:08

To be clear, in the scenario set out here, the ‘yeilding’ would be to the 30 year old daughter. It would be her father saying: yes. You’re more important to me. I’ll leave my wife because you don’t like her. Even though I think you’re behaving dreadfully.

No child should have that kind of power over their parents. Whatever age they are.

BurntToastAgain · 03/01/2022 16:05

What the OP has said is:

“I’ve never asked him to [stop seeing her]. However she is creating a situation where she’s demanding his loyalty lies with her when she’s the one being out of order. I don’t think she will be happy unless he leaves me.”

“my adult (30s) step daughter thinks her father should prioritise her despite her being absolutely awful to me. He is really not happy with her behaviour and she’s furious with him for “taking my side”

So she’s not the one making ‘her or me’ demands. The 30 year old daughter wants rid of her stepmother. She doesn’t like her father challenging her on her behaviour or their being consequences so she’s trying to pull rank.

Yes the OP hadn’t told us exactly what had led to her feeling that she’s completely done with the stepdaughter. But she’s actually asking whether her spouse should give in to his daughter’s demands or stand by his wife in the face of an adult child who is throwing her toys out of the pram.

gogohm · 03/01/2022 16:04

Dp does put me first and vice versa to a point, kids are adults after all but we both help them out when we can, and each other's kids too i should add. Back in 2020 I dashed across the country picking up and dropping off including dsd so everyone got home for lockdown - but he'll tell dsd we are doing x or y and she's not invited if appropriate

twominutesmore · 03/01/2022 15:41

"If that's all there is to it, yes, but people don't only do this because they don't like each other, there's generally more to it than that."

We may never know. 150 posts in and op still won't say what she did. It does make me wonder whether, written down, it simply isn't really that bad.

aSofaNearYou · 03/01/2022 15:38

Because if the OP's husband did yield and say, "okay, you win, I am disowning my daughter because she doesn't like you and you don't like her, I choose you" then ultimately she would be in a relationship with a man who puts his own needs above his own child.

If that's all there is to it, yes, but people don't only do this because they don't like each other, there's generally more to it than that.

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 03/01/2022 15:33

[quote aSofaNearYou]@SleepOhHowIMissYou but why are you talking exclusively about narcasstic relationships where the children are the ones being treated poorly, rather than normal relationships faced with hostile and abusive adult children, which is the actual subject of the thread?[/quote]
Because if the OP's husband did yield and say, "okay, you win, I am disowning my daughter because she doesn't like you and you don't like her, I choose you" then ultimately she would be in a relationship with a man who puts his own needs above his own child.

As it is, the daughter is banned from the house. My reading of this is that that is not enough. The OP thinks that the daughter should be set adrift and no relationship should exist between father and child because she says so. So yes, OP you ARE being unreasonable if this is the case.

aSofaNearYou · 03/01/2022 15:22

@SleepOhHowIMissYou but why are you talking exclusively about narcasstic relationships where the children are the ones being treated poorly, rather than normal relationships faced with hostile and abusive adult children, which is the actual subject of the thread?