Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Standing by your spouse when SC are involved

219 replies

Sweetchillidiphigh · 01/01/2022 20:33

I know mumsnet is generally anti step parent and pro step child. No matter what. Now everything I’ve seen with regards marital advice with blended families is that your spouse must be number 1. Now I can understand how that may be extremely hard when your DC are still children but when they reach adulthood, should SC expect to be prioritised over their step parent? And should a parent stand by their spouse or child?
YABU = Spouse comes first
YANBU = Adult child comes first

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 04/01/2022 16:30

*The posters who are disagreeing with the majority opinion seem to struggle to understand that people are entitled to have an opinion that doesn't match theirs.

That's my take anyway.*

Speak for your bloody self, your take is miles off.

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 04/01/2022 16:23

[quote Willyoujustbequiet]@SleepOhHowIMissYou

I've dipped in and out of this thread so may have missed parts but I think you're getting a hard time for saying essentially what I think most people believe - kids come first.

I couldn't be with someone who hated my dc either.They aren't perfect and certainly there will be times I disagree with them but I will always stand by them (heinous crimes aside). Its unpalatable to some but spouses are replaceable. Children are not.[/quote]
I'm on the App so can't see the poll but I believe we are in the majority opinion. I'm (fairly absolutely bloody) certain that someone will correct me if I'm wrong though. 😀

The posters who are disagreeing with the majority opinion seem to struggle to understand that people are entitled to have an opinion that doesn't match theirs.

That's my take anyway.

Disclaimer: your mileage may vary 😀

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 04/01/2022 16:04

[quote RedWingBoots]@SleepOhHowIMissYou my "ridiculous" scenarios as you call them are things that have happened to rl people who live in the UK.

The one I linked to is recent conviction so the circumstances around the case are in the public domain, and I stated:
"Yes it is an extreme case but for some adult children parents simply can't do enough."

Interestedly you have changed your opinion from:
"Ultimately though. Given the choice, me or your child. The non narcissistic choice is the child. Spouses are replaceable. Children are not. He has clearly moved on from one marriage, why wouldn't he do so again."

to:
"As many, many posters have said, it's not a black and white choice. It depends on the situation whether a child should be put out in the snow. We don't know the OP's situation, I am guessing no-one's been maimed or murdered though."

So I guess the debate has worked.[/quote]
It hasn't moved on. I have not changed my opinion. I would still choose my children, I would not disown them, even if they did what Kevin did in "We need to talk about Kevin". I emphasise with the mother's position and recognise her actions.

However, I also recognise and accept that some people would. I can accept that people are different and have formed different opinions according to their different life experiences.

That's the part you're missing.

You do know it's okay for people to have different opinions to you don't you?

twominutesmore · 04/01/2022 15:52

Oh op please come back and tell us what she did, if only to stop the bickering.

Can't you lot just shake hands or something?

aSofaNearYou · 04/01/2022 15:32

[quote Willyoujustbequiet]@SleepOhHowIMissYou

I've dipped in and out of this thread so may have missed parts but I think you're getting a hard time for saying essentially what I think most people believe - kids come first.

I couldn't be with someone who hated my dc either.They aren't perfect and certainly there will be times I disagree with them but I will always stand by them (heinous crimes aside). Its unpalatable to some but spouses are replaceable. Children are not.[/quote]
No, she's getting a hard time for being ridiculously defensive when her opinion was questioned.

Willyoujustbequiet · 04/01/2022 15:30

@SleepOhHowIMissYou

I've dipped in and out of this thread so may have missed parts but I think you're getting a hard time for saying essentially what I think most people believe - kids come first.

I couldn't be with someone who hated my dc either.They aren't perfect and certainly there will be times I disagree with them but I will always stand by them (heinous crimes aside). Its unpalatable to some but spouses are replaceable. Children are not.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 04/01/2022 14:31

Very much case by case. Generally speaking, blind loyalty to one person no matter what is a bad idea

RedWingBoots · 04/01/2022 14:27

@SleepOhHowIMissYou my "ridiculous" scenarios as you call them are things that have happened to rl people who live in the UK.

The one I linked to is recent conviction so the circumstances around the case are in the public domain, and I stated:
"Yes it is an extreme case but for some adult children parents simply can't do enough."

Interestedly you have changed your opinion from:
"Ultimately though. Given the choice, me or your child. The non narcissistic choice is the child. Spouses are replaceable. Children are not. He has clearly moved on from one marriage, why wouldn't he do so again."

to:
"As many, many posters have said, it's not a black and white choice. It depends on the situation whether a child should be put out in the snow. We don't know the OP's situation, I am guessing no-one's been maimed or murdered though."

So I guess the debate has worked.

aSofaNearYou · 04/01/2022 14:04

@SleepOhHowIMissYou

What it shows *@RedWingBoots* *@aSofaNearYou* *@BurntToastAgain* is that you are unable to cope when someone else has a different viewpoint to you. Perhaps you are triggered by the situation described by OP? Maybe you are all hard done by step mums preyed upon by evil step children, who knows?

You diagnose me as having low comprehension skills because you have explained why my opinion is wrong but yet I am still not agreeing with you. What's wrong with me? You've told me I'm wrong and you are right and yet still I insist on telling you my children come first and spouses are replaceable. Stupid, stupid me! How can I not see your opinions are the correct ones to have? Clearly, I am very, very stupid, yes?

Oh, and regarding your ever increasing ridiculous scenarios as you struggle to prove my opinions are wrong, I empathised with the mother's actions in "We Need To Talk About Kevin" at the end of the film. I don't want to spoil it if you haven't read the book or seen the film (but would recommend it).

Can you stop lumping us in like we are one person? You're really wasting my time here. I haven't said you have low comprehension skills. I haven't failed to accept that you have a different opinion to me, I've just disagreed with it.

What is your problem? You seem really upset by the fact the three of us all criticised your comment at a similar time and don't seem able to let it go.

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 04/01/2022 14:02

What it shows @RedWingBoots @aSofaNearYou @BurntToastAgain is that you are unable to cope when someone else has a different viewpoint to you. Perhaps you are triggered by the situation described by OP? Maybe you are all hard done by step mums preyed upon by evil step children, who knows?

You diagnose me as having low comprehension skills because you have explained why my opinion is wrong but yet I am still not agreeing with you. What's wrong with me? You've told me I'm wrong and you are right and yet still I insist on telling you my children come first and spouses are replaceable. Stupid, stupid me! How can I not see your opinions are the correct ones to have? Clearly, I am very, very stupid, yes?

Oh, and regarding your ever increasing ridiculous scenarios as you struggle to prove my opinions are wrong, I empathised with the mother's actions in "We Need To Talk About Kevin" at the end of the film. I don't want to spoil it if you haven't read the book or seen the film (but would recommend it).

ShinyHappyPoster · 04/01/2022 13:55

It's impossible to say. There's no hard and fast rule and you're being vague about why her behaviour is so 'terrible'. Lots of adult DCs have points where they are rude to their parents. Lots of step-parents treat SDCs horrendously. No-one here knows whether you or your SD are in the wrong.
Your DH has already told her she's out of order and you've said you don't want her in your house. Is it your house or is it you and your DH's house? Because if the house belongs to both of you then I wouldn't be making DH choose. I'd let him have her to visit when you're not there.
As a PP pointed out, you seem determined for there to be a competition between you both for your DH. That's quite an immature attitude.

aSofaNearYou · 04/01/2022 13:52

Oh, and in terms of gaslighting, we can add paranoia to my growing list of MN Diagnosed conditions.

FGS, I said you sounded paranoid because you keep throwing out terms like gaslighting where they do not fit in the slightest. I'm not diagnosing you with anything. The other thing you think people have diagnosed you with is narcissism, and it's odd that you've focused on that so much as if it's a shocking thing to say about someone, when it was YOU who brought it up.

Time to stop feeding the troll now, I think.

IncompleteSenten · 04/01/2022 13:50

It can't be 100% either.

It depends on the situation.

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 04/01/2022 13:47

[quote RedWingBoots]**@SleepOhHowIMissYou* so if your child left you severely disabled and killed your spouse, who your other children had no issue with/loved, you wouldn't "abandon" your adult* child?

I actually know of situations in rl, including my own family, where adult children have had to be "abandoned" to make them realise that they need to treat their parent(s) and other family members appropriately. In some cases their parents have new partners/spouses, in other cases they don't. The new partner/spouse only serves to highlight the dreadful behaviour of the individual adult child.

Oh and can you tell me how you send group PMs on MN.[/quote]
How do I send Group PMs? No idea. So when you say "me and others who have read the thread" who were you talking about?

Oh, and in terms of gaslighting, we can add paranoia to my growing list of MN Diagnosed conditions. 😀

As many, many posters have said, it's not a black and white choice. It depends on the situation whether a child should be put out in the snow. We don't know the OP's situation, I am guessing no-one's been maimed or murdered though.

Out of interest, are you familiar with the term reductio ad absurdum?

RedWingBoots · 04/01/2022 12:53

@SleepOhHowIMissYou so if your child left you severely disabled and killed your spouse, who your other children had no issue with/loved, you wouldn't "abandon" your adult child?

I actually know of situations in rl, including my own family, where adult children have had to be "abandoned" to make them realise that they need to treat their parent(s) and other family members appropriately. In some cases their parents have new partners/spouses, in other cases they don't. The new partner/spouse only serves to highlight the dreadful behaviour of the individual adult child.

Oh and can you tell me how you send group PMs on MN.

aSofaNearYou · 04/01/2022 12:53

@BurntToastAgain

I love the idea that I’m part of a secret PM group conspiring to gaslight a poster. Can you even do group PMs on MN?
Me too, it's news to me if you can!

I love the idea that three posters seperately disagreeing with a poster and repeating views they just shared and stood by over the course of several comments, constitutes a conspiracy to gaslight.

BurntToastAgain · 04/01/2022 12:28

I love the idea that I’m part of a secret PM group conspiring to gaslight a poster. Can you even do group PMs on MN?

aSofaNearYou · 04/01/2022 12:14

@SleepOhHowIMissYou

You replied to tell me you can't be bothered to reply? And I'm the one embarrassing myself? 😀

Tragic. Truly.

More defensive, reactionary statements that make absolutely no sense that you for some reason think everybody must agree with you on.

If you listen closely you'll hear the sound of tumble weed going by...

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 04/01/2022 11:50

You replied to tell me you can't be bothered to reply? And I'm the one embarrassing myself? 😀

Tragic. Truly.

aSofaNearYou · 04/01/2022 11:14

[quote SleepOhHowIMissYou]@aSofaNearYou ...and yet I am the one with poor comprehension skills? 😀 I have given the context of my statements. If you cannot understand that when I say that I couldn't love someone who hated my children then I am directly referring to the OP's situation (where an adult step daughter is banned from her father's home for bad behaviour) then I really can't help you further. I also gave the context to the behaviour I have observed in some men, which also didn't fit your agenda.

Throughout you have jumped to conclusions about me, gaslighting and trying to twist my words to fit your own mindset (this person doesn't agree with me, but they are wrong because they are a narcissist, have low levels of comprehension and lack empathy, therefore I am right). You seem incapable of accepting any point other than your own so seek to discredit instead.

I repeat, I pity you.[/quote]
Oh FGS, I can't even be bothered to reply to your paranoid nonsense.

You very obviously said the things you said, which you would be perfectly entitled to stand by but now you're for some reason backtracking, and bizarrely accusing people of gaslighting you for repeating the things YOU said. You're embarrassing yourself.

RedWingBoots · 04/01/2022 11:02

@SleepOhHowIMissYou I went to bed.

While I do sometimes post late at night/early in the morning I actually went to sleep.

In your own posts you were stating that no matter what your children did they were your number one priority and should be placed above anyone else in your life particularly a spouse.

Your post reminded me of the recent conviction of this adult son who killed his step-father and paralysed his mother -
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-dorset-59725874

A further google revealed more detailed info e.g.
www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/dec/17/how-alcohol-and-seething-resentment-turned-thomas-schreiber-to

Yes it is an extreme case but for some adult children parents simply can't do enough.

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 04/01/2022 10:42

@aSofaNearYou ...and yet I am the one with poor comprehension skills? 😀 I have given the context of my statements. If you cannot understand that when I say that I couldn't love someone who hated my children then I am directly referring to the OP's situation (where an adult step daughter is banned from her father's home for bad behaviour) then I really can't help you further. I also gave the context to the behaviour I have observed in some men, which also didn't fit your agenda.

Throughout you have jumped to conclusions about me, gaslighting and trying to twist my words to fit your own mindset (this person doesn't agree with me, but they are wrong because they are a narcissist, have low levels of comprehension and lack empathy, therefore I am right). You seem incapable of accepting any point other than your own so seek to discredit instead.

I repeat, I pity you.

aSofaNearYou · 04/01/2022 09:01

@SleepOhHowIMissYou have you considered that we haven't replied because we were in bed, or simply doing something else, rather than that we were stunned to silence by the brilliance of your answer?

You've accused me of a lot of things I haven't said there. I am not part of a hive mind with the two other posters, we are three seperate people who all disagree with you. It's all a bit dramatic talking about people "seeing my gears working". I haven't done anything, I've just disagreed with you.

As to your actual points, it's a bit odd that you're now trying to claim you were just talking about what other, narcissistic men do in regards viewing their relationship as replaceable and superficial, when you quite clearly said YOU think it is narcissistic to prioritise dinner on your table and sex. They were your views.

You also quite clearly said you view your children as a part of you, so hating them would be hating you. Posters aren't gaslighting you, you said that. You seem intent on reframing the debate to focus on situations where it's your spouse treating your children badly, which is very obviously different. There is a huge difference between "I would hate someone that disliked my children and treated them badly" and "I would hate someone that disliked my children because they treated them badly". The first is very logical, the second is wildly unreasonable.

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 03/01/2022 23:52

@RedWingBoots @BurntToastAgain @aSofaNearYou

No reply? Or perhaps you think your answer will go over my head too?

Shall we add gas-lighting to the personal attacks too now?

To clarify. I have been accused of not viewing my children as separate to myself, therefore I must be a narcissist. Of course my children are separate to me. In fact, if you look at my posting history (as I guess Burnt Toast has as they seem to know me so well) you will see that I posted previously that Kahlil Gibran's poem "On Children" is my favourite because it sums up exactly how I feel about my kids. However, as individual as they are, my children remain my priority, even as adults. Therefore, I could not love a person who hated and treated my children badly. In short, make an enemy of my children, make an enemy of me too.

As for spouses being replaceable. I believe the stats show that over 2 in 5 marriages end in divorce. To expand on the gas-lighting, Sofa and BurntToast have decided that my observation that some men will take the easy (narcissistic) route to ensure they get regular sex and dinner on the table is a reflection on how I see marriage myself. To clarify, it's an observation of behaviour I have actually observed in some men.

And you plowing in RedWingBoots, mentioning "others" like there's some big PM group discussing me and you're all in agreement that I am indeed lacking in comprehension skills.

I pity you all. Don't kid yourself that people reading this can't see your gears working.

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 03/01/2022 21:48

[quote RedWingBoots]@SleepOhHowIMissYou myself and other people who have just read the whole thread can see you don't understand the nuances in the discussion you are having with other posters.

They aren't attacking you or calling you names.[/quote]
Perhaps you would be so kind as to explain to me what I'm missing.

My understanding of the situation is that the OP's step daughter has done something that means she is barred from her father's home. We don't know what. OP hasn't said.

However, OP feels that he is betraying her by continuing a relationship with someone so disrespectful to her. She feels he should take her side over his own daughter.

And that's it. There's no further info from the OP, just conjecture from other posters.

So, in small words please, what do I not understand?