Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance

315 replies

anonforpost · 01/01/2022 18:45

I pay my x 570 PCM for child maintenance as per CMS calculator. AIBU to expect not to pay anything on top of the amount. I believe 570 should be enough to cover all expenses of my 2 year old child.

OP posts:
Jessie75 · 02/01/2022 11:19

I believe that the children are entitled to the same standard of living that they would’ve enjoyed have their parents stay together for example we had a joint income of an excess of £100,000 a year together which has now obviously been cut as a result of my not being able to maintain my career at the level that it ought to have for several years needless to say he is has rocketed because he no longer has any family responsibilities so one way or the other and I don’t care how it happens my children should still be receiving and inflationary adjusted lifestyle that was at the same level as their parents gave them when they were together .

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 11:19

[quote Graphista]@Getyourarseofffthequattro respectfully I disagree

Op benefits from the childcare even IF he had no input (which we don't know) and how much he's paying still doesn't cover half the basics of the costs of a 2 year old based on national averages and the prices I looked at local to me which as I said is a VERY cheap part of uk. Rent and council tax here eg are very low among lowest in country, as are grocery prices etc

No I never said dad shouldn't see dc more I said mid week contact I don't think benefits the child. This is I think even more so as the child hits school age.

Kids need consistency and certainty

2 nights for his eow and half all "school holidays" I can see being a good way for op to have more time with dc

and the vast majority if cms payments do not come close to 50% of costs

Exactly!

especially if you factor in all the hidden longterm costs the RP incurred in lost wages and pension contributions if they work anything less than full time.

Not even just less than full time, single parents are also limited with what full time roles they can take on. I hold 2 degrees but because I had to work around childcare availability (which in most cases is mon - fri 7-7 at most!) I couldn't take any roles that required long hours, evenings or weekends so that meant lower paid roles with fewer benefits etc

Exactly demanding half of everything is not realistic

Maybe not for every family - but I do think it should be the starting point that calculations are made from.

Anything HAS to be better than the current system which is very poorly calculated and enforced.

[/quote]
How is half of school holidays any good when most jobs offer only 20 days and bank hols? He's not going to able to be present for half of school hols. So what you're saying is, whilst he has a parent at home he'll have to pay for childcare, which presumably he won't be able to claim back half of, plus paying half of childcare for every week where perhaps he could be there, but you think it's best if he's not in the name of routine.

I don't think 50% is any better at all. Theres more room for ambiguity and it would be a hell of a lot more work to work out and to check essentially. You could say anything so it would have to be verified. The cms are shit as it is. It wouldn't work.

Piggyk2 · 02/01/2022 11:17

@Getyourarseofffthequattro that's life though. What would happen if the mother died?? OP would have more than £570 a month to worry about!!

I think your example is off track Confused we could all get knocked over or develop a life changing condition forcing us out of work. That's not the case at present for OP.

Graphista · 02/01/2022 11:10

@Getyourarseofffthequattro respectfully I disagree

Op benefits from the childcare even IF he had no input (which we don't know) and how much he's paying still doesn't cover half the basics of the costs of a 2 year old based on national averages and the prices I looked at local to me which as I said is a VERY cheap part of uk. Rent and council tax here eg are very low among lowest in country, as are grocery prices etc

No I never said dad shouldn't see dc more I said mid week contact I don't think benefits the child. This is I think even more so as the child hits school age.

Kids need consistency and certainty

2 nights for his eow and half all "school holidays" I can see being a good way for op to have more time with dc

and the vast majority if cms payments do not come close to 50% of costs

Exactly!

especially if you factor in all the hidden longterm costs the RP incurred in lost wages and pension contributions if they work anything less than full time.

Not even just less than full time, single parents are also limited with what full time roles they can take on. I hold 2 degrees but because I had to work around childcare availability (which in most cases is mon - fri 7-7 at most!) I couldn't take any roles that required long hours, evenings or weekends so that meant lower paid roles with fewer benefits etc

Exactly demanding half of everything is not realistic

Maybe not for every family - but I do think it should be the starting point that calculations are made from.

Anything HAS to be better than the current system which is very poorly calculated and enforced.

HugeAckmansWife · 02/01/2022 11:08

If the RP works full time the childcare costs are massive, even with any UC contributions and the free hours. A full time teacher could easily require 45-50 hours a week childcare. Would you agree the nrp should meet half those costs on top of any cms? If not, why not? If the RP works only part time then they will inevitably rely on the maintenance and some form of benefits. What's the alternative?

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 11:08

@Piggyk2

Maintenance isn't a reliable form of income and shouldn't be treated like one.

I don't agree with this at all. Of course maintainance should be treated as a reliable income. Its bloody neglect for a start! It's a parents duty not an option of the menu this is why some men don't pay or whenever they like. How could you support such a thing? Who ever the child lives with... there outgoings need paying each week/month regardless.

But it's not is it. He can't still pay if he's dead, or he's hospitalised on sick pay, or he becomes permanently disabled can he?

What would you actually have him do there?

I'm not saying it's an optional payment. I'm saying it's not guaranteed until your child is 18 at the same rate because it's based on one person and unfortunate things can happen and often do.

Fireflygal · 02/01/2022 11:08

Percentage wise you are contributing circa 10% which leaves you with 90% to yourself.

I think that's a pretty good deal. CMS should have childcare as a separate line.

Piggyk2 · 02/01/2022 11:06

Maintenance isn't a reliable form of income and shouldn't be treated like one.

I don't agree with this at all. Of course maintainance should be treated as a reliable income. Its bloody neglect for a start! It's a parents duty not an option of the menu this is why some men don't pay or whenever they like. How could you support such a thing? Who ever the child lives with... there outgoings need paying each week/month regardless.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 11:03

For instance childcare will go down when he's 3 and then again when he's at school, again when he's a teen. I can't imagine anyone agreeing maintenance should reduce at the same rate but by the 50% argument it should.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 11:02

@HugeAckmansWife

But there's a middle ground between fillet steak and fuck all and the vast majority if cms payments do not come close to 50% of costs, especially if you factor in all the hidden longterm costs the RP incurred in lost wages and pension contributions if they work anything less than full time. I agree no system is fair but I would much rather see one that was biased in favour if the child and RP doing all the grunt work than an eow nrp. In this scenario if the op wants a nicer work life balance by reducing his income, thats fine, but unless he is going to actually use that time to alleviate some of the costs and childcare burden of his ex, he should be absorbing the income drop himself, not passing it on to his ex and child.
Of course there is. What this man is paying isn't "fuck all" is it? Nobody's suggesting £7 a week and nothing more. I'm just explaining why demanding 50% doesn't work.

I don't think you demand hidden costs either, tbh. You don't have to give up work or go part time as a mother. As a separated couple the other partner would have absolutely no say in that so I don't think they should pay for it.

He quite clearly said he wanted to see his child more, didn't he?

I don't think he should absorb the costs because he can't pay money he doesn't have. Maintenance isn't a reliable form of income and shouldn't be treated like one.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 02/01/2022 11:01

I get £600pm for one child. I manage fine on that. I'm on a low income so I get about 70% of childcare costs paid for by tax credits and it's not a lot as DS is school age. He does expensive hobbies so maintenance covers that.

Piggyk2 · 02/01/2022 10:59

[quote Getyourarseofffthequattro]@graphista I think you're being a bit one sided there.

What if he wasn't allowed any input with the nursery? Or mum insisted on EOW and nothing more?

I don't think you can demand half of everything because it's impossible to work out fairly and is dictated by the RP.

If the RP chooses a particularly expensive rental, has the heating on 30 degrees 24/7 and feeds the child fillet steak for every meal should they be able to demand half? Personally I don't think so.

CMS is a bit of a shit system yes. But there is currently no better way to work it out and demanding half is just as ambiguous and shitty.[/quote]
Exactly demanding half of everything is not realistic there's no point going on about ifs and buts. Everyone's out goings vary and rent/mortgage is a huge outgoing alone
Depending on where exactly you live.

There has to be a reasonable arrangement.

HugeAckmansWife · 02/01/2022 10:59

But there's a middle ground between fillet steak and fuck all and the vast majority if cms payments do not come close to 50% of costs, especially if you factor in all the hidden longterm costs the RP incurred in lost wages and pension contributions if they work anything less than full time. I agree no system is fair but I would much rather see one that was biased in favour if the child and RP doing all the grunt work than an eow nrp. In this scenario if the op wants a nicer work life balance by reducing his income, thats fine, but unless he is going to actually use that time to alleviate some of the costs and childcare burden of his ex, he should be absorbing the income drop himself, not passing it on to his ex and child.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 10:54

And you've just basically had a massive do about finance and how it's all on mum and then said oh maybe you shouldn't see your child more.

So only dad's money matters.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 10:53

@graphista I think you're being a bit one sided there.

What if he wasn't allowed any input with the nursery? Or mum insisted on EOW and nothing more?

I don't think you can demand half of everything because it's impossible to work out fairly and is dictated by the RP.

If the RP chooses a particularly expensive rental, has the heating on 30 degrees 24/7 and feeds the child fillet steak for every meal should they be able to demand half? Personally I don't think so.

CMS is a bit of a shit system yes. But there is currently no better way to work it out and demanding half is just as ambiguous and shitty.

Graphista · 02/01/2022 08:53

Seriously? You've come on mn to post this?!

Talk about not reading the room!

I believe 570 should be enough to cover all expenses of my 2 year old child.

How much do you THINK this costs?!

At 2 there's not only furniture, furnishings, equipment, clothes, linens, toys, books, food etc which are direct costs - many of which need replacing on quite a regular basis

There's also childcare - I'm guessing from the amount you work full time? How much do you think half that time in childcare costs?

In the uk average cost for a 2 year old in full time childcare is around £270 A WEEK so even just half of that is £135 A WEEK

That's £585 a pcm for half the childcare alone!!!

There's also the necessity for the parent with care to have a home of a suitable size for the child to have it's own room which means a larger mortgage/rent, higher council tax, higher utility bills etc

So yea overall £570 probably isn't enough!

It may seem a good amount in comparison to what others get but frankly cms amounts are crap! The equation used to calculate them is pathetically inadequate and it is only the MINIMUM legislated for cm

Why should ex reduce their outgoings? It's up to you to pay half your child's costs ex pays the other half in fact in most cases (and I suspect is true here too) the parent with care is usually paying out a lot more for child related costs than the nrp

Op says nothing about ex being on UC

I pay for everything while he stays with me

Which is how it should be

So a brief back of the envelope calculation and admittedly imo :

PCM half of each item

Childcare £585

EXTRA rent (based on prices where I am which is a very cheap part of uk) £30

EXTRA council tax £15 (even with single person discount)

Direct costs (food, groceries, clothes, furnishings etc) £30

EXTRA utility costs £15 (and I think I'm being kind there! This is of course without the upcoming price hikes)

Total pcm half of the costs of raising your child = approx £675 pcm

And that's area dependant as I said based on costs where I live which is very cheap

I've also just done a wee calculation on the online calculator and based on info here and even including I ticked having dc 1 or more nights a week that works out to you're on around £75 k far as I can tell!

So even after you've paid cm you've still got £5680 pcm to live on! Hardly on your uppers!

Even if you were to pay what you imo SHOULD be paying which is the ACTUAL half of all child related costs (based on my local prices) you'd still be fine financially unless you're a spendthrift!

Is op defo @lonelydad2021 ? Name change fail?

Your ex must earn around £50k. Why couldn’t he afford to pay £600 to raise his children?

I agree on this one too! Total nonsense he can't pay what he should!

He lives in a one bed flat. Doesn't seem to be living it up particularly.

1 he could be spending in other areas

2 - there are one bed flats...and one bed flats! Penthouses can have one bedroom! Plenty of luxury one beds up the road from me! I see a pp has posted a link to one prob near them

I think considering she has to use childcare

They BOTH benefit from the childcare only nrp isn't paying for their half totally!

bearing in mind it will be term time only if she’s a teacher

Not necessarily - lots of nurseries you have to have non term time booked too to keep a place

ALSO teachers aren't off in the school holidays they have to cover school trips, cpd, lesson prep etc in this time too. I used to lodge with a primary teacher who wasn't even a dept head or anything and she used to always be busy in holidays, friends and family that are teachers esp those that are dept heads etc have tons of background work to do when schools are closed - I really thought people knew that was a myth by now?

It's bizarre that people think the OP would be justified in not meeting his fair share of his child's expenses just because there are some truly shit parents out there who never see their kids and pay £25 per month.

That argument comes up EVERY time on such threads - race to the bottom!

My ex barely paid cm at all! Had to be chased and chased and chased and would pay only frequently enough so as to avoid court! Upshot being over the years he paid a pittance!

This does not make me think or feel that other Rps should be grateful if their ex pays at all nor jealous if like in ops scenario the amount is a large amount!

The op is still as far as I can make out not paying half the costs of raising THEIR child which he should be!

And even if he was it kinda still wouldn't be enough cos the rp is ALSO doing most of the drudge of parenting

So often Nrps merely "Disney dad" which causes problems for the rp and the child too

(Not saying op is doing this but just that it's very common)

Childcare costs SHOULD be included in the calculation imo

This is the major cost for most parents raising a child. If the nrp works too then they need to cover their share of childcare costs as well as the other child related costs

Once again I am depressed by how low most women will set the bar for men

Yep!

Can I also say op WANTING to see the child in the week isn't necessarily what's good for the child especially at such a young age.

It seems more fair but can be very disruptive and unsettling for them

KiloWhat · 02/01/2022 08:17

@Mellowyellow222

I was referring to *@Piggyk2* who commented that this man is willing to do childcare.

She also didn’t think it was realistic for OP to pay half the childcare bill.

I saw red with the low bar set for men

Ah I see sorry.

I don't see why it's unrealistic. The childcare cost for all the days OP or the other parent cannot look after their child should be split between them.

Mellowyellow222 · 02/01/2022 08:11

I was referring to @Piggyk2 who commented that this man is willing to do childcare.

She also didn’t think it was realistic for OP to pay half the childcare bill.

I saw red with the low bar set for men

timeisnotaline · 02/01/2022 08:04

The op hasn’t said anything about planning to take on more of the parenting burdens, or standard working hours care that the mum has to pay childcare for, just that he wants to see his child more.
When the child starts school will the op pay half of the uniform and other costs? Does the child do any classes/sports and does the op pay half for those? Basically child maintenance is a joke and any half decent dad who can afford it contributes more to support children’s activities etc on top of the extremely basic maintenance, and decent dads would recognise all the costs they are free of by not having their children at times that don’t suit them, so the mum is left having to pay through the nose from her single income to have the same privilege of holding down a job as her ex.

KiloWhat · 02/01/2022 08:00

@Mellowyellow222

It’s really not childcare.

Child care means attending to the needs of infants, toddlers, preschool children, and school children outside of school hours by persons other than their parents.

I think it's just shorthand for "parenting time that means less childcare is required" in the context of this thread?
Mellowyellow222 · 02/01/2022 07:56

I think we are entering a deeply depressing chapter in society if we don’t consider a no resident dad as a parent and if we consider the time he spends with his child as childcare.

And he hasn’t said he wants a full day during the week. Just that he wants to see his son during the week. That won’t necessarily mean a reduction in days of childcare required.

Mellowyellow222 · 02/01/2022 07:54

It’s really not childcare.

Child care means attending to the needs of infants, toddlers, preschool children, and school children outside of school hours by persons other than their parents.

girlmom21 · 02/01/2022 07:51

@Mellowyellow222

It’s not childcare if the child is yours!

And he hasn’t said he wants to parent for a full day a week- he just said he wants to see the child during the week. That won’t necessarily mean one less day of childcare will be required.

Considering everyone here is discussing the paid for childcare, it's childcare...
KiloWhat · 02/01/2022 07:22

Just that is not fair to reduce because I want a more flexible job. I don't think she is struggling. It is more about the principle. My choices shouldn't affect our son. well they will and so will hers she needs to get used to that. She's allowed to change jobs too.

Mellowyellow222 · 02/01/2022 07:21

It’s not childcare if the child is yours!

And he hasn’t said he wants to parent for a full day a week- he just said he wants to see the child during the week. That won’t necessarily mean one less day of childcare will be required.

Swipe left for the next trending thread