Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance

315 replies

anonforpost · 01/01/2022 18:45

I pay my x 570 PCM for child maintenance as per CMS calculator. AIBU to expect not to pay anything on top of the amount. I believe 570 should be enough to cover all expenses of my 2 year old child.

OP posts:
RandomLondoner · 02/01/2022 17:54

@Internetio

The Cms calculator tells you the legal minimum level of child support you are liable to pay.

If you are morally happy that you are paying the bare minimum towards your child then you have your answer.

This comment is bollocks, though it's only repeating what many posters say in threads like these, so I'm not especially having a go at this poster.

The fact that something is the legal minimum does not mean it's the "bare minimum", or that it's an insignificant, insuficient or morally repugnant amount. It's perfectly possible for it to be considerably more than a reasonable amount.

The law could order people to hand over 100% of their income, and they'd still be paying the legal minimum.

The law is a blunt instrument, it prescribes an amount it thinks is right, sometimes this will be too little, sometimes it will be too much, there's no reason to think it errs more one way than the other. By definition it is what society thinks is a reasonable amount, if you can only base you calculation on a few easily-available facts, rather than a detailed financial analysis of every affected household.

Excitedforthefuture · 02/01/2022 17:26

I missed where “massive debt” was mentioned?

3mealsaday · 02/01/2022 17:20

Really the sensible thing to do is to have a conversation with your ex with what you think reasonable expenses for your DC are.

If you agree with your DC being in childcare 5 days a week to enable you both to work and you don't object to the nursery which has been chosen for him, then the decent thing to do is to pay 50% of the nursery costs (plus a fair share of his day-to-day costs to cover the uneven split of time you have him).

If your new work schedule means you can do 1-2 days childcare a week and maybe some evenings, then you'll be saving both you and your ex a large chunk of childcare and other expenses and so it would be fair for you to pay a hugely reduced amount of maintenance.

The starting-point should be that you and your ex are both equally responsible for paying for and caring for your joint child. If she's paying for most things and doing most of the day-to-day care, there's an imbalance.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 17:09

@HugeAckmansWife

quattro whether or not private school is worth it is a totally different thread and not as black and white as you seem to think. I'm not going to say more as it's not relevant to the op.
I never said it was black and white. It's entirely your choice to put yourself into debt to pay for it. No, it's not relevant to the op. It was you who brought it up.
HugeAckmansWife · 02/01/2022 17:07

quattro whether or not private school is worth it is a totally different thread and not as black and white as you seem to think. I'm not going to say more as it's not relevant to the op.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 17:06

@Waxonwaxoff0 definitely and it's something that needs to change. We need to stop accepting that women are the default parent. We should be equal parents with equal responsibility. Ok 50/50 won't work for everyone but it's a better starting point than eow

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 17:03

[quote Excitedforthefuture]@Getyourarseofffthequattro

In all likelihood the child would be attending private school before the divorce.
As was my case.
To pull the child out of private schooling AND have them deal with their parents divorcing - horrendous.
So it really isn’t just as easy as… well, don’t pay[/quote]
Well no but is putting yourself into massive debt benefiting your child? It's not as simple as just continuing to pay either is it?

TheCatsKilledTheGonks · 02/01/2022 16:53

Do you think £570 per month equates to 50% of the cost of housing, feeding, clothing and raising your child? I highly doubt it. If not, then no, morally you are not paying enough (assuming the child lives with the other parent). CMS is not the recommended payment but a legal minimum to force deadbeat non-resident parents to at least pay something. If that's the type of parent you want to be then crack on.

HugeAckmansWife · 02/01/2022 16:49

Thanks for coming back. OP.. Apologies if your original q gets derailed.. Some of us on here have been round this debate circle a fair few times. It does matter exactly what you plan to do with your additional free time in terms of the impact I'm your ex and child. In short, they should not take a hit because you choose to decrease your earnings. Good luck.

anonforpost · 02/01/2022 16:44

Thanks for all points of view. I will talk to my ex and try to make a compromise. I will show her this thread.

OP posts:
Excitedforthefuture · 02/01/2022 16:29

@Getyourarseofffthequattro

In all likelihood the child would be attending private school before the divorce.
As was my case.
To pull the child out of private schooling AND have them deal with their parents divorcing - horrendous.
So it really isn’t just as easy as… well, don’t pay

Waxonwaxoff0 · 02/01/2022 16:23

@Getyourarseofffthequattro

I see *@Waxonwaxoff0* again I am lucky enough not to have to live with an arsehole like that.
That's good. One of my work colleagues is a grandmother and she was saying the other week that her grandson was poorly and her DIL's work was being really arsey about her having time off to care for her poorly child. No mention of dad taking a day off to help with the childcare. When I suggested that the response was "well babies want their mum when they are poorly." Hmm

It just seems to be a common theme in my experience that the woman is always the one that has to do all the juggling.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 16:18

I see @Waxonwaxoff0 again I am lucky enough not to have to live with an arsehole like that.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 16:18

@Graphista

How is half of school holidays any good when most jobs offer only 20 days and bank hols?

Well that's the point isn't it! Why should it all be on the rp to juggle/pay for childcare and/or time off work!

That's what lone parents have to manage!

Plus I'd be VERY surprised if op only got 20 days leave given he's a high earner

There's also parental leave (while unpaid - again the op is well paid pretty sure he COULD actually manage)

This stopped me dead in my tracks

Well quite! As if!

Every choice has an impact on your kids if you're a parent

As an rp you have more protection.

There speaks someone with little experience of UC/benefits!

to do neither of those is absolutely despicable and frankly is what most non-resident parents get away with

Totally agree - but then all the laws around contact and cm in uk are appallingly ill thought out and barely enforced EXCEPT when it's to the detriment of the rp (in most cases women!) and therefore massively sexist

We need widespread and significant changes and have for some time

My dd is now 20 almost 21 and things really haven't improved since I split from her dad in most ways.

The only thing that has changed for the benefit of Rps is that cm is no longer deducted from benefits (whether the nrp paid or not!) that was a huge problem for me in the early years and led to me literally going without food and other basics so dd could eat/live.

Most? Have you got any evidence for that?

I don't believe that to be true at all.

That most nrps don't want more contact

86% of single parents are mothers

20% of fathers have no contact with their dc from previous relationships at all

A further 31% have irregular/infrequent contact with their dc from previous relationships

Both these figures increase as the length of separation increases and then of course once the dc turn 18 they drop off the stats.

That's also not including where the nrp is abusive but still allowed contact which is wrong imo, also doesn't inc Disney dads who yes have contact but make a pigs ear of it!

300,000 pay zero cm at all

Can't find figures on those who don't pay every month or have been made to pay via earnings - if someone else can find this info great!

So yea...statistically generally speaking nrps - who are mostly men - are pretty poor parents!

Also worth noting on this query and something I was shocked to learn when going through multiple contact hearings with ex - the rp can neither stop NOR make the nrp have contact with the child!

AND the bar for how bad things have to be for courts to stop contact is horrific! I was told of a case where the father had been CONVICTED of raping the child, served a prison sentence and was then awarded UNsupervised contact! The mother was apparently going out of her mind with worry and the child was in a suicidal state.

CMS rates simply do not reflect anything like a fair proportion of what that costs the RP in direct fees or lost earnings and pension.

Totally agree

So if there was no childcare (child older, mother not working, gran doing it for free) do you think £90 pcm is enough?

If that = half the costs of raising that child then yes - but that's rarely the case! Older dc are more expensive in other ways ime

The point is the nrp should be paying their half

This RP (the one which we are taking about) is a teacher. Who exactly does it benefit her ex having the child (or putting them in childcare) half the holidays?

Nobody. Definitely not the child.

In general, where both parents don't only work term time, there's an argument for it, of course. But that's not what were talking about is it?

How do you calculate half and who decides what goes into that calculation?

Waxonwaxoff0 · 02/01/2022 16:16

[quote Getyourarseofffthequattro]@Waxonwaxoff0 I wasn't suggesting you were?

You mentioned your husband's very important job which clearly must pay well...[/quote]
I was being sarcastic, because a lot of men seem to think their job is more important than their wife's or ex wife's.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 16:16

@HugeAckmansWife

You seemed to suggest that as I pay school fees I shouldnt need or expect my ex to pay a decent amount of maintenance. In some cases the fees are necessary as it is the only way to secure the educational provision required and significant sacrifice and debt are incurred. I am 'hard done by' in that my kids' upbringing is left largely to me in all respects.. Not something I planned on or want.
No I didn't suggest that at all. I suggested perhaps you shouldn't be getting yourself into debt for school fees.

I also never suggested you planned or wanted your current circumstances. Just that you didn't have to pay school fees, as you know, most people don't

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 16:14

@Waxonwaxoff0 I wasn't suggesting you were?

You mentioned your husband's very important job which clearly must pay well...

Waxonwaxoff0 · 02/01/2022 16:11

@Getyourarseofffthequattro

Most ex husbands I know can't possibly do 50/50 because their job is Very Important

Well that's a shame. I suppose I'm lucky I don't know anyone like that and therefore am not rich

I'm not rich. I earn £9.50 an hour.
Graphista · 02/01/2022 16:04

How is half of school holidays any good when most jobs offer only 20 days and bank hols?

Well that's the point isn't it! Why should it all be on the rp to juggle/pay for childcare and/or time off work!

That's what lone parents have to manage!

Plus I'd be VERY surprised if op only got 20 days leave given he's a high earner

There's also parental leave (while unpaid - again the op is well paid pretty sure he COULD actually manage)

This stopped me dead in my tracks

Well quite! As if!

Every choice has an impact on your kids if you're a parent

As an rp you have more protection.

There speaks someone with little experience of UC/benefits!

to do neither of those is absolutely despicable and frankly is what most non-resident parents get away with

Totally agree - but then all the laws around contact and cm in uk are appallingly ill thought out and barely enforced EXCEPT when it's to the detriment of the rp (in most cases women!) and therefore massively sexist

We need widespread and significant changes and have for some time

My dd is now 20 almost 21 and things really haven't improved since I split from her dad in most ways.

The only thing that has changed for the benefit of Rps is that cm is no longer deducted from benefits (whether the nrp paid or not!) that was a huge problem for me in the early years and led to me literally going without food and other basics so dd could eat/live.

Most? Have you got any evidence for that?

I don't believe that to be true at all.

That most nrps don't want more contact

86% of single parents are mothers

20% of fathers have no contact with their dc from previous relationships at all

A further 31% have irregular/infrequent contact with their dc from previous relationships

Both these figures increase as the length of separation increases and then of course once the dc turn 18 they drop off the stats.

That's also not including where the nrp is abusive but still allowed contact which is wrong imo, also doesn't inc Disney dads who yes have contact but make a pigs ear of it!

300,000 pay zero cm at all

Can't find figures on those who don't pay every month or have been made to pay via earnings - if someone else can find this info great!

So yea...statistically generally speaking nrps - who are mostly men - are pretty poor parents!

Also worth noting on this query and something I was shocked to learn when going through multiple contact hearings with ex - the rp can neither stop NOR make the nrp have contact with the child!

AND the bar for how bad things have to be for courts to stop contact is horrific! I was told of a case where the father had been CONVICTED of raping the child, served a prison sentence and was then awarded UNsupervised contact! The mother was apparently going out of her mind with worry and the child was in a suicidal state.

CMS rates simply do not reflect anything like a fair proportion of what that costs the RP in direct fees or lost earnings and pension.

Totally agree

So if there was no childcare (child older, mother not working, gran doing it for free) do you think £90 pcm is enough?

If that = half the costs of raising that child then yes - but that's rarely the case! Older dc are more expensive in other ways ime

The point is the nrp should be paying their half

Excitedforthefuture · 02/01/2022 15:58

@Jessie75

That’s exactly my situation my ex-husband can’t even commit to every other weekend because he has a very important job that involve him being away for conferences. He has absolutely no intention of putting himself out or indeed being flexible around his work to the benefit of his child. And yet somehow despite these very important jobs you would think he would get paid more and therefore his contribution would be greater but somehow it all seems to have vanished into his pension its a disgrace thats allowed. £40,000 a year he saves in order to deprive his son of £8,000
That is so unfair I think pension contributions should be disregarded in calculations above £10k a year

I know my very very well paid ex pours money in to his pension

But it’s never at the children's (i am the RP) expense thank goodness.

Good, rich NRPs are out there!!

HugeAckmansWife · 02/01/2022 15:55

You seemed to suggest that as I pay school fees I shouldnt need or expect my ex to pay a decent amount of maintenance. In some cases the fees are necessary as it is the only way to secure the educational provision required and significant sacrifice and debt are incurred. I am 'hard done by' in that my kids' upbringing is left largely to me in all respects.. Not something I planned on or want.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 15:49

@HugeAckmansWife

quattro off the point but you seem to have a big chip about being 'rich'. You had a nasty dig at me about school fees and just now had a little comment to make. The numbers on each side are irrelevant. Both parents should make an appropriately level contribution, regardless of the figure. If an RP was a millionaire, it would still be right for the nrp to contribute. Being 'rich' (however subjective that term is) doesn't let either party of any kind of hook or make life necessarily easy.
I don't at all, im quite happy my oh doesn't have an important job. As such I don't share these issues! I do think saying you pay school fees and saying you're hard done to in the same sentence is a bit much. Private school isn't mandatory.

In some places the numbers on both sides are relevant and perhaps that's how it should be. Focused on the actual child.

Although I have never suggested someone shouldn't pay because the rp is rich. I don't quite know where you've got that from.

HugeAckmansWife · 02/01/2022 15:46

quattro off the point but you seem to have a big chip about being 'rich'. You had a nasty dig at me about school fees and just now had a little comment to make. The numbers on each side are irrelevant. Both parents should make an appropriately level contribution, regardless of the figure. If an RP was a millionaire, it would still be right for the nrp to contribute. Being 'rich' (however subjective that term is) doesn't let either party of any kind of hook or make life necessarily easy.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 15:23

Most ex husbands I know can't possibly do 50/50 because their job is Very Important

Well that's a shame. I suppose I'm lucky I don't know anyone like that and therefore am not rich

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 15:21

@Mellowyellow222 nope

Swipe left for the next trending thread