Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance

315 replies

anonforpost · 01/01/2022 18:45

I pay my x 570 PCM for child maintenance as per CMS calculator. AIBU to expect not to pay anything on top of the amount. I believe 570 should be enough to cover all expenses of my 2 year old child.

OP posts:
ancientgran · 03/01/2022 11:15

[quote liveforsummer]@ancientgran surely she only has responsibility for half the child maintenance though compared to your son having full responsibility so the same amount is fair? [/quote]
If she thought £x was not enough for his fathers support why would she think that is now more than sufficient for her contribution? Why should my son have had 100% responsibility. Don't you think the RP should also be contributing financially?

So when GS was with his mother his father was paying and mother (who earns more) should also have been contributing to his costs. I'm his grandmother why shouldn't I get finance from both of them? If I went to CMS she'd be paying more than his father would due to her income. She works in public sector so I know what she earns due to her level and years in the sector as I used to be public sector so know how it works.

Mellowyellow222 · 03/01/2022 11:15

I was wrong it shouldn’t be less - sorry - fuzzy logic

HugeAckmansWife · 03/01/2022 11:13

quattro if an NRP chooses to reduce his income and passes that reduction on to the RP with no benefit in terms of reduced childcare costs or more child free time so they can work themselves, that is clearly wrong. You are raising a totally different scenario where the nrp is in reduced circumstances not by choice. In that scenario I would expect them to bust a gut and reduce all other outgoings as much as possible before cutting cms and not, as any do, just cut it and leave the RP to pick up the slack or have the child lose out (which they rarely see the consequence of as they aren't the ones on the spot). As for 50% costs, Ive agreed there are practical difficulties in that but the current situation, with cms so low in most cases is also unsatisfactory. You seem happy with current unfair status quo. I'd rather see one that is fair, but if thats not possible, I'd absolutely rather the nrp was pinched than the RP and child. If it can't be fair, les have it unfair to the grown adult who can work two jobs if needed, not the child or the adult who is keeping everything spinning.

Mellowyellow222 · 03/01/2022 11:13

@ancientgran I assume it is a very difficult and sad situation for the child of neither parent is able to care for him and only parent can contribute financially.

As others have said in normal circumstances both parents would be paying you child support so the mothers contribution would probably be less than your son used to pay.

ancientgran · 03/01/2022 11:11

[quote liveforsummer]@Excitedforthefuture I think she's saying that as a grandparent who now cares for the dc she is getting the same amount in maintenance from dil that dil previously received when she cared for the child and complained about not being enough. What isn't clear is why her son isn't also contributing[/quote]
He is, he gives me more than the mother does so I do get financial support, the puzzle is that say he was giving her £x and she felt it wasn't enough although she is his mother and should also be contributing to costs, I now get £x times 2 (with a bit more from dad due to inflation) and she thinks that is more than enough.

I can only assume she didn't think she should contribute or she thinks as he lives with me I am now responsible for any costs she was covering.

I don't think I'm explaining it very well although it is clear in my head, think I'm tired.

liveforsummer · 03/01/2022 11:07

@ancientgran surely she only has responsibility for half the child maintenance though compared to your son having full responsibility so the same amount is fair?

ancientgran · 03/01/2022 11:06

[quote Mellowyellow222]@aceintgran have you gone to cams for child support?[/quote]
I haven't and I know I would get alot more financial support if I did but it is a difficult situation and I am trying to do the best for a child who has been through alot. But thank you for the suggestion, in other circumstances it could be the answer.

liveforsummer · 03/01/2022 10:58

@Excitedforthefuture I think she's saying that as a grandparent who now cares for the dc she is getting the same amount in maintenance from dil that dil previously received when she cared for the child and complained about not being enough. What isn't clear is why her son isn't also contributing

liveforsummer · 03/01/2022 10:42

While it seems like a lot it's a significant cut and if her present outgoings are based on the original amount it may leave her (and dc) in trouble. How much, for example, is childcare? It could be double what you are now paying

Mellowyellow222 · 03/01/2022 09:51

Cms not cams

Mellowyellow222 · 03/01/2022 09:51

@aceintgran have you gone to cams for child support?

Excitedforthefuture · 03/01/2022 09:46

@ancientgran

I find it quite strange that my exDIL has always complained that my son didn't pay her enough for my GSs maintenance. She now pays me the exact same amount although she earns more than him, inflation has increased and he is bigger and older and has more expenses. Hard to get my head round.
Huh?
Getyourarseofffthequattro · 03/01/2022 09:40

@HugeAckmansWife

quattro that is a separate issue. RPs denying or reducing contact for whatever reason is a valid and real issue, but not relevant to this discussion. The op has said nothing about being denied greater contact.
No, the op hasn't but others have. And apparently he is only allowed to reduce his maintenance if he has the child more (and not because of any actual finance related issues) But what if he can't? Should he have to pay x amount because mum says no?

This is the issue with the demand to pay half isn't it? Too many variables.

HugeAckmansWife · 03/01/2022 00:11

quattro that is a separate issue. RPs denying or reducing contact for whatever reason is a valid and real issue, but not relevant to this discussion. The op has said nothing about being denied greater contact.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 23:39

@HugeAckmansWife

Oh I can, but it involves a complete overhaul of cms, folding it in with hmrc and a fleet of specially trained judges to hear each individual case and review properly every 12 months. But there's no political will or money for that so we leave the deeply flawed and institutionally sexist system we have in place because the vast majority of the 'victims' are children who are invisible in that they can't vote and women who can quickly be gaslighted and dismissed as greedy lazy cows who want their nails done in the nrps dime. Of course the other solution is to bring men up to think it's not OK to fuck off and abdicate 98% or 100% of parenting.
I mean I am doing that... I don't think most parents intentionally don't do that.

But when people think children shouldn't have more contact in the name of routine we're never going to get to that are we?

ancientgran · 02/01/2022 21:47

Oh and she doesn't give me anything for extras, like school trips, sports equipment etc that my son always went halves on so I'm really getting less than she was five years ago.

ancientgran · 02/01/2022 21:45

I find it quite strange that my exDIL has always complained that my son didn't pay her enough for my GSs maintenance. She now pays me the exact same amount although she earns more than him, inflation has increased and he is bigger and older and has more expenses. Hard to get my head round.

Jessie75 · 02/01/2022 20:38

How do you think the percentage of income works in terms of the numbers it’s in enforcement, that doesn’t work. And unless it’s punishable in the same way as benefit fraud is punished then nothing ever happens.
People get away with evading taxes in their thousands every year, God help a single mum though if she over Claims a couple of grand they practically roll out the stocks.

HugeAckmansWife · 02/01/2022 19:43

Oh I can, but it involves a complete overhaul of cms, folding it in with hmrc and a fleet of specially trained judges to hear each individual case and review properly every 12 months. But there's no political will or money for that so we leave the deeply flawed and institutionally sexist system we have in place because the vast majority of the 'victims' are children who are invisible in that they can't vote and women who can quickly be gaslighted and dismissed as greedy lazy cows who want their nails done in the nrps dime.
Of course the other solution is to bring men up to think it's not OK to fuck off and abdicate 98% or 100% of parenting.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 19:18

@HugeAckmansWife

I'm not talking about more money less contact. I'm talking about CMS rates being laughable when compared to the real costs incurred by RPs but there's no point going toe to toe with you again - we've had this exact argument on at least one other thread.
How is it "laughable" though? For some it is, for other it's a significant some of money.

You can't say all CMS is laughable because it's not is it?

Equally everyone's lifestyle is different. So £500 odd for my child would easily cover everything, not just half of everything. For others it wouldn't, but that doesn't change what the other person earns.

Yes the system is shit, but you clearly can't come up with any kind of better solution so what do you suggest except just saying "more"

HugeAckmansWife · 02/01/2022 19:11

I'm not talking about more money less contact. I'm talking about CMS rates being laughable when compared to the real costs incurred by RPs but there's no point going toe to toe with you again - we've had this exact argument on at least one other thread.

Rummikub · 02/01/2022 19:02

@Mellowyellow222

There is strange phenomenon on mumsbet where if a man comes on and says he is paying a reasonable amount of childcare there is almost outrage. Attacking the mother and stating she should live on much less. They compare it to what they received and argue this unknown lady should be delighted to have such bounty.

It’s really odd

Yes I’ve noticed this too

It’s not a race to the bottom.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 02/01/2022 18:59

@HugeAckmansWife

We've agreed elsewhere that it's a blunt instrument and not for purpose but the balance of 'unfair' is almost always at the cost to the RP. I'd far rather see a capable adul who has 26 days a month to themselves somewhat short changed than an RP who works full time, does basically all the real parenting and pays for childcare outwith any maintenance that rarely comes close. If it can't be properly and individually assessed, let's have it swayed in favour of the child shall we?
But more money less contact isn't always swayed in favour of the child is it?
HugeAckmansWife · 02/01/2022 18:56

We've agreed elsewhere that it's a blunt instrument and not for purpose but the balance of 'unfair' is almost always at the cost to the RP. I'd far rather see a capable adul who has 26 days a month to themselves somewhat short changed than an RP who works full time, does basically all the real parenting and pays for childcare outwith any maintenance that rarely comes close. If it can't be properly and individually assessed, let's have it swayed in favour of the child shall we?

BasicDad · 02/01/2022 18:22

OP seems quite reasonable, and if anything, commendable trying to get the perspective from a broad number of people.

As other's have said, if you can afford it, sharing the nursery costs would be reasonable. It'll reduce at 3-4 yrs old due to gov contribution. Then at school ages sharing the breakfast club and after school club costs is reasonable too.

Hopefully as your child gets older you'll be able to have a bigger share of the care, as it's good for your child.

Swipe left for the next trending thread