Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance

315 replies

anonforpost · 01/01/2022 18:45

I pay my x 570 PCM for child maintenance as per CMS calculator. AIBU to expect not to pay anything on top of the amount. I believe 570 should be enough to cover all expenses of my 2 year old child.

OP posts:
ancientgran · 03/01/2022 14:02

@Excitedforthefuture

How do you know the background?
Why do you think a NR mother shouldn't have to pay maintenance for their child?

Why would I pay someone to bring up their own child? That is a totally bizarre idea.

My son pays a contribution as he did when the child was with the mother but both parents are responsible. His mother was expected to provide for him over and above what my son was paying or do you think mother's have no responsibility for their children?

Thank you Jessie75, I'm relieved that not everyone has such low expectations as ExcitedfortheFuture.

Excitedforthefuture · 03/01/2022 13:51

How do you know the background?

Jessie75 · 03/01/2022 13:44

@Excitedforthefuture If somebody was doing me the enormous favour of raising my child for me when my sorry arse couldn’t I would fully expect to pay child maintenance I would also fully expect that the person would receive money from both parents and the state. The fact that @ancientGran feels she can’t go to the CMS to enforce this because it would damage the relationship between mother and son frankly says all we need to know about the daughter-in-law in this situation.

Excitedforthefuture · 03/01/2022 13:41

[quote liveforsummer]@Excitedforthefuture I think she's saying that as a grandparent who now cares for the dc she is getting the same amount in maintenance from dil that dil previously received when she cared for the child and complained about not being enough. What isn't clear is why her son isn't also contributing[/quote]
So did @ancientgran pay the dil when the dil had the child?
Unlikely

So @ancientgran expects contribution from her DIL along with presumably contribution from her son

So I’m totally with her DIL on this

Jessie75 · 03/01/2022 13:31

The process of enforcement is the issue, obviously nobody expects to receive child-support if the other person has been made on employed diaries or like kind of thing but it’s the fact that it’s so easy for people to get away with not paying it when they are in full health that’s the problem.
My ex-husband is currently employed PAYE but I fully expect before my son turns 18 that he will give up work and live off the cash in hand income business that he and his wife are currently building up in order to avoid child-support. It literally breaks his heart every month to handover anything. I’ve reported them both to HMRC they are receiving in cash more than most people earn in a year. HMRC quite simply have bigger fish to fry, got no interest

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 03/01/2022 13:20

@HugeAckmansWife

To say an RP should not rely on maintenance is a sad indictment of te system. Of course any income earned by anyone is not guaranteed but we can't structure our lives permanently around such a possibility. You can put insurance in place ec but ultimately nothing is bulletproof. However. It ought not to be the case that an nrps contribution is so unlikely to be reliable that an RP should see it as a bonus extra or savings for the future. Again, a flaw in he system that should be fixed at source instead of expecting RPs to just cope with or without benefit help.
Well it is flawed but how can you pay if you're incapacitated or dead? I'm not sure there's a solution and no, I don't think insurance (at a cost to one parent) is the solution.
HugeAckmansWife · 03/01/2022 13:15

To say an RP should not rely on maintenance is a sad indictment of te system. Of course any income earned by anyone is not guaranteed but we can't structure our lives permanently around such a possibility. You can put insurance in place ec but ultimately nothing is bulletproof. However. It ought not to be the case that an nrps contribution is so unlikely to be reliable that an RP should see it as a bonus extra or savings for the future. Again, a flaw in he system that should be fixed at source instead of expecting RPs to just cope with or without benefit help.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 03/01/2022 12:26

[quote Piggyk2]@Getyourarseofffthequattro we have been through this already. I absolutely agree with that. Please try and see my view point as this is a public forum.

If I died tomorrow my child would most likely go and live with his dad and that would mean his dad would have full parental responsibility as well as finicially. So no your not wrong but I think SOME of us can rely on CMS... not to the extent of living in a mortgage or more expensive rental no. But anything could happen to us at any given time.

Your situation isn't everyone's.[/quote]
Well my situation isn't anyone's because I don't receive maintenance Confused I'm just pointing out that anything can happen. If you believe none of this things can reasonably happen well then good for you.

HugeAckmansWife · 03/01/2022 12:26

quattro In my case and sadly as the stats quoted by a pp show, many nrps do choose to be very little more than (and often not even) a financial support. Not all, not you apparently. But many. I'm sorry you don't like it but it is a demonstrable fact. And yes, why on earth should anyone other than adult directly affected 'suffer' for their loss of income? If they physically can work more, longer or drop other personal expenses, that absolutely should come before the cms reduces. Only in cases of genuine illness or disability should that not be the case. They don't get to ring up the bank, utility company or council and reduce their outgoings there do they? Why is Ms a moveable feast, especially if is the result of a choice.

Piggyk2 · 03/01/2022 12:15

@Getyourarseofffthequattro we have been through this already. I absolutely agree with that. Please try and see my view point as this is a public forum.

If I died tomorrow my child would most likely go and live with his dad and that would mean his dad would have full parental responsibility as well as finicially. So no your not wrong but I think SOME of us can rely on CMS... not to the extent of living in a mortgage or more expensive rental no. But anything could happen to us at any given time.

Your situation isn't everyone's.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 03/01/2022 12:10

[quote Piggyk2]@Getyourarseofffthequattro you keep shouting down at people saying how it is not reliable. Personally my payments are reliable just because my child's father could have a loss of income at any point I don't deem that my payments are not reliable Confused

In some cases CMS payments may well be sparodic but not all.[/quote]
Ah right so is he immortal then? Unable to get sick? Couldn't possibly ever be made redundant or sacked?

I'm not saying he'll stop paying because he's a twat ffs

Piggyk2 · 03/01/2022 12:06

@Getyourarseofffthequattro you keep shouting down at people saying how it is not reliable. Personally my payments are reliable just because my child's father could have a loss of income at any point I don't deem that my payments are not reliable Confused

In some cases CMS payments may well be sparodic but not all.

liveforsummer · 03/01/2022 11:57

Oh I know it's a lot of money, it's more than 6x what I get for 2 dc. Doesn't mean I don't rely on that measly sun though and base my outgoings around it as I have no choice

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 03/01/2022 11:54

@liveforsummer

It would be lovely to be able to view child support as extra and not rely on it. A luxury not afforded to many sadly. OP's partner may well rely on the current amounts to be able to work and pay her mortgage. If she can't afford either of those any longer then it's detrimental to the dc
But in that case you could say well she's chosen to do x job which doesn't pay enough and it's detrimental to her child.

Of course nobody would ever say that but when it's a man it seems okay to judge them for not earning enough.

The thing is it's NOT reliable. Even if you have the nicest ex in the world, it's not reliable. Yes you might have to rely on it but under any circumstance I would advise trying your absolute best not to.

It's still a lot of money. It's not like he's gone ah you know what I'm quitting my job I'm paying nothing.

liveforsummer · 03/01/2022 11:51

It would be lovely to be able to view child support as extra and not rely on it. A luxury not afforded to many sadly. OP's partner may well rely on the current amounts to be able to work and pay her mortgage. If she can't afford either of those any longer then it's detrimental to the dc

Jessie75 · 03/01/2022 11:49

I totally agree just save the child-support and then if it ever disappears you will never build in your life around it. Although I have to say that caused me problems when I applied for a mortgage because I had to explain that yes I did get child-support, no it is not court ordered because courts don’t do that any more, no I did not want that counted in my affordability calculation and yes I was weird and no I didn’t anticipate the support stopping. Neither the broker nor none of the banks get their heads around it.

ancientgran · 03/01/2022 11:48

@Mellowyellow222

Also if your son knows you are out of pocket why isn’t he contributing more?

Yes his mother should be also contributing her fair share - but why is your son standing back letting you raise his child and suffering financially for it?

His mum seems have issues, but your son also sounds like a disappointment as a parent

My son does contribute, he contributes more than she does although she earns considerably more.

They are both disappointments believe me.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 03/01/2022 11:46

I'm not "happy" with it but it's at least workable, which your idea is not. I don't agree that someone should work two jobs and therefore barely see their child just so that their ex doesn't have to make any compromises. And you're going to say it's not about the ex, but it is because it's them in charge of the money. If I for instance got say 750 a month, reduced to 550 it wouldn't make a bit of difference to my child because their well-being wouldn't rely on it. The day to day costs are simply nothing like that much. Would I prefer my ex to work two jobs to put hundreds in a bank account for my child every month or would I rather him see him more? For me there is no contest. But then I would do my absolute best not to rely on maintenance having had a dad myself who didn't pay any.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 03/01/2022 11:43

@HugeAckmansWife

quattro if an NRP chooses to reduce his income and passes that reduction on to the RP with no benefit in terms of reduced childcare costs or more child free time so they can work themselves, that is clearly wrong. You are raising a totally different scenario where the nrp is in reduced circumstances not by choice. In that scenario I would expect them to bust a gut and reduce all other outgoings as much as possible before cutting cms and not, as any do, just cut it and leave the RP to pick up the slack or have the child lose out (which they rarely see the consequence of as they aren't the ones on the spot). As for 50% costs, Ive agreed there are practical difficulties in that but the current situation, with cms so low in most cases is also unsatisfactory. You seem happy with current unfair status quo. I'd rather see one that is fair, but if thats not possible, I'd absolutely rather the nrp was pinched than the RP and child. If it can't be fair, les have it unfair to the grown adult who can work two jobs if needed, not the child or the adult who is keeping everything spinning.
It's not clearly wrong if their financial situation changes though, is it? Where do you expect him to find the money?

Ah I see you expect them to suffer but nobody else to. Got it.

This is it with you, the nrp is nothing more than at ATM.

Mellowyellow222 · 03/01/2022 11:41

Also if your son knows you are out of pocket why isn’t he contributing more?

Yes his mother should be also contributing her fair share - but why is your son standing back letting you raise his child and suffering financially for it?

His mum seems have issues, but your son also sounds like a disappointment as a parent

Mellowyellow222 · 03/01/2022 11:40

Ancientgran I hope your son has a very good reason for not being there for his son?

I can’t think of a reason that would be good enough to be honest.

His son clearly needs him - why on earth isn’t he there for him?

ancientgran · 03/01/2022 11:29

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Jessie75 · 03/01/2022 11:25

@ancientgran Take it up with the CSM then absolutely fantastic they won’t hesitate to slap an attachment of earnings on it

ancientgran · 03/01/2022 11:23

@Mellowyellow222

I was wrong it shouldn’t be less - sorry - fuzzy logic
Sorry just saw your update.

I do think it confuses people when mother and father are both responsible for paying for child maintenance. In my case, and others I've heard of, the formerly RP doesn't seem to think they have an equal responsibility.

ancientgran · 03/01/2022 11:22

[quote Mellowyellow222]@ancientgran I assume it is a very difficult and sad situation for the child of neither parent is able to care for him and only parent can contribute financially.

As others have said in normal circumstances both parents would be paying you child support so the mothers contribution would probably be less than your son used to pay.[/quote]
Why would she pay less support than his father paid her? They were both responsible for his financial support then and are both responsible for his financial support now. If what his father gave her wasn't covering 50% of his costs why would them both giving me that amount suddenly be more than 100% of his costs now?

Swipe left for the next trending thread