Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child maintenance

315 replies

anonforpost · 01/01/2022 18:45

I pay my x 570 PCM for child maintenance as per CMS calculator. AIBU to expect not to pay anything on top of the amount. I believe 570 should be enough to cover all expenses of my 2 year old child.

OP posts:
KiloWhat · 02/01/2022 07:20

The childcare is the key thing here.

Also when are you going to be seeing your son more? Have you agreed this?

Piggyk2 · 02/01/2022 07:19

@Mellowyellow222 yes I absolutely agree with you. But I think maybe posters are quick to jump sometimes. It's not just money and it does seem to me that mum and OP can come to an arrangement if he's willing to do childcare. I don't think my suggestion is unfair to the mum do you?

Piggyk2 · 02/01/2022 07:17

[quote 3mealsaday]@Piggyk2. Why is it not realistic for a father to pay half of his child's costs including childcare? Especially if he is a higher earner than the mother?[/quote]
Did you miss the part where OP stated that he wanted to do a day in the week? Another poster suggested that the mum would save on nursery costs.
Or a you looking purely from a finical point of view only?
As a single parent myself when I need a break I would take LESS money so I can have a break and a social life over trying to get the maximum amount of money.

Mellowyellow222 · 02/01/2022 07:16

Once again I am depressed by how low most women will set the bar for men.

@Piggyk2 most people don’t get £570 because this man earns more than average. His child shouldn’t get the bare minimum. He should contribute fairly so the cost of raising that child.

It’s odd he doesn’t know how much childcare costs for his own child. Surely he was involved in the decision about which childcare to send the child to?

He want to see his child more than every other weekend! If a mother said that no one would say she was reasonable - everyone would say she is a rubbish parent who should be caring for her child 50% of the time.

The double, sexist standards are shocking.

3mealsaday · 02/01/2022 07:06

@Piggyk2. Why is it not realistic for a father to pay half of his child's costs including childcare? Especially if he is a higher earner than the mother?

Piggyk2 · 02/01/2022 05:16

@3mealsaday

570 isn't plenty for a child in full-time childcare. Round here the cost for a full-time nursery place is around 1300-1500 per month. So it does depend on whether the ex receives the childcare element of UC (and how much of her childcare that covers) whether it is fair or not.

The CMS amount in no way reflects what is fair to the other parent or child if a parent genuinely wants to meet their fair share of their child's expenses. The question to ask isn't how much would a hypothetical child cost, but how much does your child reasonably cost? For example, if you could drop to a 4 day week and do one day's childcare a week, that would reduce your child's nursery costs and justify a lower payment.

Your right. But this is not realistic. Most people won't get £570 each month. OP has stated he would like to see his child more too so I think he's reasonable.
hibbledibble · 01/01/2022 22:57

As maintenance, Anna I can guarantee that half nursery costs for an under 3, plus half living expenses, is more than the OP is currently paying.

AnneLovesGilbert · 01/01/2022 22:08

plus a contribution towards day to day expenses

On top of maintenance?

hibbledibble · 01/01/2022 21:47

As a teacher, it's unlikely any/much of her nursery costs are covered by universal credit.

Nursery for an under 3 is eye wateringly expensive: often over £80 a day. I'm surprised you don't know how much your child's nursery costs. It's pretty easy to find out.

If you can afford it, it would be reasonable to cover half the nursery costs, plus a contribution towards day to day expenses.

HugeAckmansWife · 01/01/2022 21:36

If your more flexible job means you are going to see him more, do a couple of school runs a week, only use 4 dad a week if childcare etc then great, but if you've done it to suit yourself and your ex or child is going to see no benefit to them, why would you expect her to support your choice to contribute less? The actual figures involved are irrelevant. Cms is the minimum. It's right that you should offer half of the nursery costs (or the % she pays not covered by UC) and most will charge for holidays too, regardless if she needs them or not.

UpDownRound · 01/01/2022 21:25

@LethargicActress

It is more about the principle. My choices shouldn't affect our son.

Of course your choices will affect your son, you are his parent! I’m sure she wouldn’t complain if your choice to get a higher paying job meant more money for her.

I think considering she has to use childcare, you need to make it your business to know how much that costs, bearing in mind it will be term time only if she’s a teacher, and taking into consideration any help she gets for childcare costs. You need to make sure that your CM pays half of the childcare cost and a contribution to your child’s living expenses, but other than that your priority is definitely to spend more time with your son during the week so you have done the right thing by going for more flexibility in your job. Then as your son gets older, he will need his own room when he stays with you so you’ll need to think about how you can provide that too.

Not all nurseries offer term time only contracts and those that do often charge a comparatively higher daily rate.
3mealsaday · 01/01/2022 21:03

@carolsforxmas

I'm genuinely not judging the amount against what I have received and deeming it enough as it was more, and I recognise the system is skewed in that childcare costs are not considered in the calculation.

I just get the impression from the OPs posts that he isn't out to screw over his ex or leave her struggling, and it's not unheard of for a woman to keep expecting more with no thought for what they can do to manage their outgoings first.

Obviously NRPs should cover 50% of the costs for their DC but RPs should make sure they are being reasonable and fair too.

Childcare costs as an outgoing can't really be 'managed' though. They are what they are, unless the other parent has selected a particularly expensive nursery. So any maintenance payment which doesn't at least cover 50% of childcare costs is never really going to be fair.
carolsforxmas · 01/01/2022 20:59

I'm genuinely not judging the amount against what I have received and deeming it enough as it was more, and I recognise the system is skewed in that childcare costs are not considered in the calculation.

I just get the impression from the OPs posts that he isn't out to screw over his ex or leave her struggling, and it's not unheard of for a woman to keep expecting more with no thought for what they can do to manage their outgoings first.

Obviously NRPs should cover 50% of the costs for their DC but RPs should make sure they are being reasonable and fair too.

3mealsaday · 01/01/2022 20:59

If your new job is less pressured, any chance of compressing your hours into 4 days so you can do a day's childcare a week? That would let you spend more quality time with your DC and cut £200-300 off the nursery bill each month so your ex might be ok with substantially lower maintenance.

timeisnotaline · 01/01/2022 20:58

I would offer to split childcare. It’s that or you take him for some weekdays with your newly flexible lesser paying job. That amount of money a month would not quite pay even half of the childcare fees for one of our children and I’d personally fully expect dh to have them 50/50 or pay half of childcare costs if he didn’t.

Sowhatifiam · 01/01/2022 20:53

Dunno. At one point I was paying £1,200 a month on childcare so £570 Wouldn’t have touched the sides. Can’t be made to pay more, however,

Twillow · 01/01/2022 20:51

Sorry, just realised I wrote her children. Of course, I meant that a decent standard of care at her home is beneficial to your child - the child of you both. Not explaining this well!

Twillow · 01/01/2022 20:49

The CMS is the minimum, sure, and over and above that depend on a lot of things in my view. I am in the situation where my ex resents paying the CMS amount (even though it is below half of yours) so refuses to contribute anything towards what I would consider reasonable extras - ie school trips, orthodontic treatment etc.
He could afford this. So as a result the relationship between us is bad - non-speaking terms. Clearly that is not good for the children. So my advice would be, be honest and reasonable. Don't take the attitude that your ex just want money to improve her own living conditions, because what she really wants (speaking for myself of course) is to provide a decent standard of care for her children. It's not going on Prosecco and lipstick. Be prepared to extend the minimum when you can afford it for reasonable extras. But you shouldn't have to maintain whatever you paid before when your income is now lower.

MissTrip82 · 01/01/2022 20:47

Well presumably in deciding to have your child more you worked out a budget for that, so you know roughly what it costs for childcare per hour, food, clothes, shoes, rent, electricity etc.

Your own budget and the costs you’re paying for directly will help guide you.

CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 01/01/2022 20:43

@3mealsaday

It's bizarre that people think the OP would be justified in not meeting his fair share of his child's expenses just because there are some truly shit parents out there who never see their kids and pay £25 per month.

I don't think it is the OP's intention to compare himself to those parents - he's scaled down his work to be more involved in his child's life and wants to know based on that what a truly fair financial contribution would be. So he's clearly setting the bar a bit higher for himself than being a shit, uninvolved parent who pays the bare minimum. So hardly useful to compare him to the £25 a month brigade Confused.

Some people on here think it's a race to the bottom though. Happens on every thread about maintenance.
3mealsaday · 01/01/2022 20:41

It's bizarre that people think the OP would be justified in not meeting his fair share of his child's expenses just because there are some truly shit parents out there who never see their kids and pay £25 per month.

I don't think it is the OP's intention to compare himself to those parents - he's scaled down his work to be more involved in his child's life and wants to know based on that what a truly fair financial contribution would be. So he's clearly setting the bar a bit higher for himself than being a shit, uninvolved parent who pays the bare minimum. So hardly useful to compare him to the £25 a month brigade Confused.

georgarina · 01/01/2022 20:41

How much time do they spend with the child?

Mellowyellow222 · 01/01/2022 20:36

@ Getyourarseofffthequattro it was purely illustrative.

3mealsaday · 01/01/2022 20:35

570 isn't plenty for a child in full-time childcare. Round here the cost for a full-time nursery place is around 1300-1500 per month. So it does depend on whether the ex receives the childcare element of UC (and how much of her childcare that covers) whether it is fair or not.

The CMS amount in no way reflects what is fair to the other parent or child if a parent genuinely wants to meet their fair share of their child's expenses. The question to ask isn't how much would a hypothetical child cost, but how much does your child reasonably cost? For example, if you could drop to a 4 day week and do one day's childcare a week, that would reduce your child's nursery costs and justify a lower payment.

JustUseTheDoorSanta · 01/01/2022 20:34

The 30 hours will kick in the term after turning 3, so offering to split childcare on top of living expenses until then is fair. As others have said, you need to consider a small 2-bed soon enough so your DS has a room at your home too, but spending time with him is most important.

Swipe left for the next trending thread