Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this doesn’t count as a “hard life”

64 replies

HNY2022 · 01/01/2022 14:16

A comment my parents in law keep saying really annoys me so just wondering if I’m being unreasonable.

Both SIL and I were seriously ill when we were younger, years before we even crossed paths, and I was younger than SIL when I was unwell. We both had the necessary treatments which were very tough, both developed complications that nearly cost us our lives, and have both been in remission for many years.

SIL is now having marriage difficulties and my parents in law keep saying how sad it is, because she’s had such a hard life and she doesn’t deserve it. They then say to me “oh you too HNY, you’ve also had such a hard life”.

AIBU to find that very insulating and offensive? I have had a very privileged life, with my parents, education, career, etc and so to suggest I’ve hard a hard life because I was seriously unwell for a year is a slap in the face for those who have had real hard lives (ie those who struggle to get food on the table, DV, etc).

And that the same applies to SIL. As far as I’m aware, she’s just as privileged as me and her ill health was the only difficult thing she’s dealt with.

I’m probably being sensitive because after two weeks of staying at in laws, things they say are starting to generally annoy me but grateful for thoughts!

OP posts:
weebarra · 01/01/2022 17:25

It's a difficult one. I had stage 3 cancer in my 30's and while I'm not (mentally) massively affected by it, to some extent it does define how I see myself and how others, who knew me when I was ill, see me too.
I consider myself to have had somewhat a tough time (child illness, 2DCs with ASN, suicide of a close relative, but I also have material comfort, great friends and family and a job I like. It's all in your point of view.

HNY2022 · 01/01/2022 17:15

@Newyearoldyou

Unless other issues I think they are simply trying to be kind and treat you both the same.

You could kindly point out that it's all a state of mind but you don't see it that way.

??

You’re right, that is exactly what they’re trying to do. I’m being unnecessarily harsh!
OP posts:
Lolamento · 01/01/2022 17:15

@SpellBounds

YABU what an odd thing to get worked up about. You sound like a huge martyr about it all too.
This
Newyearoldyou · 01/01/2022 17:13

Unless other issues I think they are simply trying to be kind and treat you both the same.

You could kindly point out that it's all a state of mind but you don't see it that way.

??

HNY2022 · 01/01/2022 17:04

@LostForIdeas

I just view it differently and that colours my vision.

I was coming to say exactely that @HNY2022
When it comes to health, even with the exact same illness, people will deal with it differently.
There is nothing right, nothing wrong. Just a different path.

Thank you. I’m really not as heartless as people think I am.

Two weeks with the in laws and my illness being brought up a lot has simply been too much, so I was having a thoughtless moment.

And it’s two weeks because we live in different countries.

OP posts:
LostForIdeas · 01/01/2022 16:39

I just view it differently and that colours my vision.

I was coming to say exactely that @HNY2022
When it comes to health, even with the exact same illness, people will deal with it differently.
There is nothing right, nothing wrong. Just a different path.

ShaneTheThird · 01/01/2022 16:20

Cross post re childhood

ShaneTheThird · 01/01/2022 16:19

Yabu suffering a long illness especially in childhood is hard. Just because you don't feel that way about yourself doesn't mean you get to decide who can have the term hard life bestowed on them. Your sil does sound like she had a hard life it doesn't take away anything from you or your achievements or how charmed your own life is.

HNY2022 · 01/01/2022 16:14

Just to clarify, this wasn’t childhood illness. I was late teens and SIL was late 20s. We’re talking about 20 to 25 years ago, hence why I refer to it as being younger.

But I see I’m being unreasonable.

It's completely understandable to not want to be defined by your illness

I think this hits the nail on the head. Every single time I visit my in laws they always bring up me being unwell, how much I suffered, etc. When I have annual check ups, they go on and on and on about it when I’ve told them repeatedly I don’t want to talk about it. I think I feel that it’s in the past, my life has moved on, it’s not part of who I am anymore, hence why I don’t like it always coming up.

But reading the replies has made me realise my reaction is skewered by how I have dealt with it and how I feel about it. I am not devoid of emotion and empathy as some of you have very kindly claimed, I just view it differently and that colours my vision.

Thank you for the comments and helping me to see things differently.

OP posts:
ThatNameAgainItsMrPlow · 01/01/2022 16:13

@RobotValkyrie

Sounds like having had a hard life has seriously affected your empathy, OP. Good new year resolution might be to show a bit of compassion (including self-compassion)
This.
Sirzy · 01/01/2022 16:12

@catfunk

It's not a competition. Childhood illness can cause lasting trauma for families. It's great that you're over it but they might not be
This!
Cofifeefee · 01/01/2022 16:11

Honestly, some in-laws really can't win. They are caring about their family!

You weren't around when their daughter was sick, you don't know what it was like for them and just because you think your illness isn't something to dwell on doesn't mean everyone is able to deal with things as well as you can.

catfunk · 01/01/2022 16:10

It's not a competition. Childhood illness can cause lasting trauma for families. It's great that you're over it but they might not be

Magicalmattressesinthesnow · 01/01/2022 16:05

I don't think they mean it in a bad way. You don't agree as that is testimony to your resilience. Personally I think you have had it hard as your health is your wealth OP . Children shouldn't get sick.💐

SpellBounds · 01/01/2022 16:04

YABU what an odd thing to get worked up about. You sound like a huge martyr about it all too.

GiveYourHeadAWobble · 01/01/2022 16:02

Ouch. That was quite unpleasant to read.
I think YABU. Illness is very difficult. It’s difficult for the person going through it and it’s difficult for the parents. I had a life-threatening long-term health problem in childhood and it affected my parents and myself for a really long time.
Re having food on the table etc is basically like saying anyone who has money cannot find any aspect of their lives difficult.

Exasperatedhousehunter · 01/01/2022 16:02

If you were young when you were ill, maybe you didn’t fully appreciate the seriousness. It sounds a bit flippant to say ‘yeah, I nearly died but I’m so privileged, there are people who have suffered DV’. Why is DV an automatic hard life when serious illness is not? I’d have thought that having a child nearly die due to illness is incredibly stressful for a parent.

And how do you know that it doesn’t affect her now? I know people who have developed PTSD after cancer treatment for instance, even if they are in remission now. It sounds like you are massively downplaying what was an incredibly difficult event. That’s your choice to do so but I can absolutely see why they think she has had it tough.

EmpressCixi · 01/01/2022 15:59

There are many kinds of hard. And for everyone who has had hardship, there is always someone who has had more hardships. I think you are thinking that because it wasn’t the worst it could have been, it wasn’t hard at all. I don’t really agree with that.

RobotValkyrie · 01/01/2022 15:55

Sounds like having had a hard life has seriously affected your empathy, OP.
Good new year resolution might be to show a bit of compassion (including self-compassion)

CityMumma78 · 01/01/2022 15:41

YABU - that is their daughter!!! They would have spent sleepless nights worrying about her health when she was younger and would have been there through the entire process from consultation appointments, procedures, recovery and follow ups! Not to mention the anxiety in between waiting for results. Anyone who has had to go through this with a loved one would have empathy and considering you went through something similar you seem devoid of emotional understanding!!!
Having a hard life isn’t just about the financial and material!!

RitaFires · 01/01/2022 15:34

I think serious illness in childhood does make a hard life. Having questions of mortality on your mind when all your friends are out playing can change your whole world view. One of my siblings was seriously ill as a 6 year old and had a surgery with a 50/50 chance of survival, they were lucky and survived but it was incredibly stressful for us all to witness let alone for them going through it. We are all still a little bit traumatised by the experience, your SIL and her parents may well still be too.

It's completely understandable to not want to be defined by your illness but your inlaws are trying to be kind and compassionate when they say that about you and they may well be telling the truth regarding SILs ability to cope with stress being affected by her experience of being so unwell when she was younger.

ThrobbingToothacheOfTheMind · 01/01/2022 15:17

A bit ironic you’re acting so hard done by right now.

You don’t know if your SIL has an easy or hard life. She might struggle mentally more than you with her various problems. YABU to speak about how easy or hard someone else’s life is. You don’t know.

greenlynx · 01/01/2022 15:08

So the big chunk of her life was affected by a serious illness, maybe there were a lot of missed opportunities along the way, now she’s got marriage trouble. How old is she? Has she got a chance to enjoy her life at all?
And they are her parents so of course they want her to be happy. I’m sure that they accept that minor problems are the part of the life but her problems sound above average.

DeadGood · 01/01/2022 14:58

@DrSbaitso

They're trying to be sensitive to you and acknowledge your past troubles. They're trying to make it clear that your SIL's difficulties don't mean they've forgotten about what you went through.

They don't mean your life is shit and unenviable. They mean that they respect the fact you had hardships in the past.

Agree with this. Time to head home OP!
Magnited · 01/01/2022 14:50

YANBU.

Shit happens. You both got good treatment. Probably free? You survived when others did not. You went to school. Had food on the table. Clothes. A warm house. That's not a hard life. A hard life is being constantly unable to break out of poverty in so many way: food, fuel, housing, clothing and health. A hard life is when you have the will and commitment to change but be denied the tools to make it happen.