Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this doesn’t count as a “hard life”

64 replies

HNY2022 · 01/01/2022 14:16

A comment my parents in law keep saying really annoys me so just wondering if I’m being unreasonable.

Both SIL and I were seriously ill when we were younger, years before we even crossed paths, and I was younger than SIL when I was unwell. We both had the necessary treatments which were very tough, both developed complications that nearly cost us our lives, and have both been in remission for many years.

SIL is now having marriage difficulties and my parents in law keep saying how sad it is, because she’s had such a hard life and she doesn’t deserve it. They then say to me “oh you too HNY, you’ve also had such a hard life”.

AIBU to find that very insulating and offensive? I have had a very privileged life, with my parents, education, career, etc and so to suggest I’ve hard a hard life because I was seriously unwell for a year is a slap in the face for those who have had real hard lives (ie those who struggle to get food on the table, DV, etc).

And that the same applies to SIL. As far as I’m aware, she’s just as privileged as me and her ill health was the only difficult thing she’s dealt with.

I’m probably being sensitive because after two weeks of staying at in laws, things they say are starting to generally annoy me but grateful for thoughts!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MunroBagger · 04/01/2022 09:35

*@MunroBagger Didn’t realise an intention to offend is the underlying requirement for potentially upsetting someone. People can also be careless.

Thank you for the last few comments, and those that understand. I know I’m being unreasonable but it helps that others understand my point of view, rather than assuming I’m a heartless bitch!*

OP you asked if you were being unreasonable to be offended by their comment. I think you are as it is very clear that to offend you was the last thing they wanted to do. I often ask myself this when I am upset by a comment someone has made. If it is clear that there was no malice behind it or intention to upset or offend then I try not to be offended or upset.

I understand that people can be careless and I don’t think your in laws were particularly careless on this occasion. It sounds like they were just acknowledging that they appreciate that you have had a difficult time too. The comment about adoption on one of your later posts I would say is bordering on carelessness and your DP was correct to pull them up on this.

This is all just my opinion. I don’t think for one minute think you are a heartless bitch.

HNY2022 · 03/01/2022 18:08

I would say someone has had a ‘hard life’ of the majority of thier life has been continued hardship

That’s how I saw it too, hence why the comment bugged me. One year of hardship out of 40 years of a mostly comfortable and mostly stress free life isn’t a hard life in my book (doesn’t mean I haven’t had stresses). But everyone sees things differently and that’s what I didn’t appreciate.

OP posts:
HNY2022 · 03/01/2022 17:51

@MunroBagger Didn’t realise an intention to offend is the underlying requirement for potentially upsetting someone. People can also be careless.

Thank you for the last few comments, and those that understand. I know I’m being unreasonable but it helps that others understand my point of view, rather than assuming I’m a heartless bitch!

OP posts:
MunroBagger · 03/01/2022 17:10

Do you think it was their intention to offend you when they made the comment? YABU!

Tiredalwaystired · 03/01/2022 16:48

I went through a myriad of situations in my youth which if I talked to people about them (I never do) they would definitely tell me I’d had a hard life

Except I don’t particularly feel I did. Despite all the problems I actually felt like my childhood was pretty happy.

But I know if someone else reeled off a similar story I would say “Gosh, how awful”

I think the difference is that you see what happened as a part of your narrative alongside all the good stuff. If they didn’t participate in the good stuff then all they see is the dramatic bits. It’s a natural black and white view of someone else’s life where you only put yourself in their shoes for the tough bits.

I’d let it lie.

ThinWomansBrain · 03/01/2022 16:42

they're probably saying "and you too" so as not to negate your chilghood illness - that it was (and remains) traumatic for them as a family whilst you have risen above it is their misfortune.

Tal45 · 03/01/2022 16:41

I think they're just trying to be nice by including you and not keep saying how ill SIL was while appearing to brush over your illness. I can see how annoying it would be but I'd imagine it's well meaning.

BrieAndChilli · 03/01/2022 16:34

By thier reasoning then most people have had a hard life as most people will have had something happen in their life that was traumatic or hard to get through - I’ll health, trauma, violence, etc etc.
I would say someone has had a ‘hard life’ of the majority of thier life has been continued hardship. Things happen to people but if the rest of thier life (and it sounds like your SILs was otherwise fine apart from a period of ill health) then the majority of their life has been good.

WhoWants2Know · 03/01/2022 16:30

It would irritate me as I wouldn't like to have my whole life summed up in that way. I wouldn't want to feel as though I were defined by one aspect of my life.

georgarina · 03/01/2022 16:25

YANBU because as someone who also went through difficult experiences I'm the same, I hate pity and can find it quite patronising and othering.

But equally they probably mean it in good conscience to say the serious illness was a hard time, and are expressing their love and care for you.

I would just explain how you feel if it bothers you.

MagpieSong · 03/01/2022 16:22

I'd say, if you're not keen on it being mentioned - totally fair as you want to move on and past it - I'd mention it gently. It's likely they don't realise, but isn't that pleasant for you.

Also, I think you can have a 'hard life' for many reasons. None of them are exclusive. Trauma (which facing a serious illness can cause) is one, poverty another - and there are many other issues that can make it 'hard'. I totally understand your reaction too though.

HNY2022 · 01/01/2022 21:46

@Ozanj

I think it depends on the illness really. For example most childhood cancers are much, much easier to treat the younger you are and the youngest kids won’t get ptsd / depression / have been scared by well meaning doctors or parents. So it’s very possible you had it much much easier than her if you got that illness earlier.
I was diagnosed with stage 4 cancer when I was 18, I had a 5% chance of survival and ended up critical in intensive care at one point, with a possibility that I wasn’t going to recover from the infection.

My SIL had stage 2 of a different cancer.

So even though it was different stages, it was also different cancers so can’t really compare our treatments.

OP posts:
HNY2022 · 01/01/2022 21:43

@CharlotteRose90

Are you scared to become unwell again? Is that why you don’t like them using those words. You did have a hard time and so did your sil. Speaking from experience someone being seriously ill effects the whole family. Mine was 4 years ago and to this day it still effects my parents especially if I become sick with something they worry. Your sils parents will worry for the rest of their lives that their child will become sick again. I can’t even contemplate what my parents went though despite me being in my 20s going through all the scans with me, treatments with me and being told I had a 20% chance of making it. It’s a lot and you don’t forget it. Maybe you’ve blocked it out op like I have but most don’t .
I do, of course I do. Especially now that I have my own family. My approach at the time was to keep smiling and look my best, and that was my coping mechanism, to act like everything was normal. I just want to forget about it all, not in a denial type of way, but in the sense of I’ve moved on and I want to focus on the future.

And I do remember the impact it had on my parents, and that was with them putting on a brave face for me. So I see that, my in laws are still understandably traumatised, which is why they still talk about it.

OP posts:
Ozanj · 01/01/2022 21:39

@HNY2022

Just to clarify, this wasn’t childhood illness. I was late teens and SIL was late 20s. We’re talking about 20 to 25 years ago, hence why I refer to it as being younger.

But I see I’m being unreasonable.

It's completely understandable to not want to be defined by your illness

I think this hits the nail on the head. Every single time I visit my in laws they always bring up me being unwell, how much I suffered, etc. When I have annual check ups, they go on and on and on about it when I’ve told them repeatedly I don’t want to talk about it. I think I feel that it’s in the past, my life has moved on, it’s not part of who I am anymore, hence why I don’t like it always coming up.

But reading the replies has made me realise my reaction is skewered by how I have dealt with it and how I feel about it. I am not devoid of emotion and empathy as some of you have very kindly claimed, I just view it differently and that colours my vision.

Thank you for the comments and helping me to see things differently.

PCOS? Mine was caught at 30 and by then my ovaries had been destroyed. If it had been caught in my teens there would have been minimal damage as it could have been treated with the pill. Ditto with rheumatoid arthritis - my friend whose RA was caught in her 20s is now disabled. The one who had it caught in her teens has full mobility and minimal symptoms because the meds worked.
Ozanj · 01/01/2022 21:35

I think it depends on the illness really. For example most childhood cancers are much, much easier to treat the younger you are and the youngest kids won’t get ptsd / depression / have been scared by well meaning doctors or parents. So it’s very possible you had it much much easier than her if you got that illness earlier.

HNY2022 · 01/01/2022 21:31

Thank you @blablablablablablablabla. That is a good approach, as is the advice given by everyone else.

I definitely have been too sensitive about it, and realise it’s not about resilience but approach - my approach was and has been to move on with my life and forget about it, whereas their approach is to talk about it.

There was another comment my MiL made about half an hour beforehand, which rubbed me up the wrong way which is what I think contributed to my ranty post. It was NYE so she was talking about how much she loves having us around and grandchildren, and then she said she really feared we would have to adopt. When DH asked her what she meant, she responded that she was worried about my medical history and my fertility, but we’ve given her grandchildren so it’s ok. So that irritated me, which sounds like is me being sensitive again, but that, combined with my hard life, just made me think arghhhhh! Hence my rant here!

OP posts:
CharlotteRose90 · 01/01/2022 21:28

Are you scared to become unwell again? Is that why you don’t like them using those words. You did have a hard time and so did your sil. Speaking from experience someone being seriously ill effects the whole family. Mine was 4 years ago and to this day it still effects my parents especially if I become sick with something they worry. Your sils parents will worry for the rest of their lives that their child will become sick again. I can’t even contemplate what my parents went though despite me being in my 20s going through all the scans with me, treatments with me and being told I had a 20% chance of making it. It’s a lot and you don’t forget it. Maybe you’ve blocked it out op like I have but most don’t .

blablablablablablablabla · 01/01/2022 19:11

I understand you OP. It hits a nerve with you I think.

You want to get on with life and don't want your illness to define you.

I think this colours how you see the comments.

I wish my in laws acknowledged that I've had tough times. People always minimise what I've been through and go through. It would mean a lot if someone said that to me and acknowledged my pain.

But I'm not you. I think it's really kind of them to remember your suffering when talking about their daughter, especially.

However I totally see it from your point of view too. You have dealt with your situation a certain way and it's not helpful to discuss it this much.

It sounds like you've tried to tell them not to talk about it so much. Maybe a really open hearted discussion would help.

Dear MIL and FIL, I really appreciate how supportive you are about my struggles and how much compassion you have shown me. But it really makes me sad to be reminded of what happened to me and to be defined by it. I want to forget about it, because I'm well now and it scares me to keep talking about it. It makes it feel present for me and the way I deal with it, is to make it the past. Please let's not talk about it so much. That would really help me feel safe.

Is that how you feel deep down ? I'm just guessing ? Them bringing it up could be stirring up fears of you becoming unwell again ?

RedHelenB · 01/01/2022 18:18

Yabu to try to pick fault with your inlaws yes. If they hadn't included you no doubt you'd have moaned that they hadn't acknowledged your early trauma.

NaughtyNata · 01/01/2022 18:13

I can understand it being annoying if they go on relentlessly but I do agree with previous posters that at least they acknowledge it- and as you say your views are affected by your experiences, theirs are affected by their daughter's, and their own worries about her.

This isn't aimed at you OP as it's not what you've alluded to in your thread at all but I do hate the misery Olympics so often seen on MN. Everyone deals with a myriad of shitty circumstances in different ways and what may be manageable for one person isn't the same for another. I don't feel that I've had a 'hard life' as such but I feel like being abused by my ex, with the pandemic happening almost immediately after I managed to leave him, has left a massive scar on me that will never quite heal. It's all been cumulative too- one thing after the other makes it all feel too much.

Sorry that's rambling but i know what I mean just not very articulate!

Butchyrestingface · 01/01/2022 17:54

I think this hits the nail on the head. Every single time I visit my in laws they always bring up me being unwell, how much I suffered, etc. When I have annual check ups, they go on and on and on about it when I’ve told them repeatedly I don’t want to talk about it. I think I feel that it’s in the past, my life has moved on, it’s not part of who I am anymore, hence why I don’t like it always coming up.

If they go on about it relentlessly, I can understand it becoming very wearing very quickly.

I suffered severe injuries as a youngster and was left with a mild disability, but it IS mild and it would probably get on my tits if relatives produced the violins whenever I came for a visit.

Not sure how to handle it though if you've told them you don't want to talk about it and they're still in full on Oliver Twist mode.

Are they not very resilient more generally?

Nowayoutonlydown · 01/01/2022 17:42

I wouldn't take it to heart to be honest, I think its lovely that they're considering what you have been through in your life.

I say this from a polar opposite situation (v hard start in life which means I'll never live without the ramifications of it and my marriage is the causation of a lot of ongoing problems) and PILs truly believe I've landed the lottery with their son.

Just try to enjoy that their hearts appear to be in the right place

MadMadMadamMim · 01/01/2022 17:39

I think you're massively over sensitive, personally. I could understand you being offended if they said in an offhand fashion, Oh you've had it really easy all your days with your wealthy parents and your privileged life.

Not the other way round.

Bluebluemoon · 01/01/2022 17:34

My dm does this kind of thing a lot - it's like a reverse competitive misery or something, like "who's had the hardest life?"
But I realise she doesn't mean it in a horrible way or with the intention to hurt. It's just that we are very different people - I am a very forward-looking, positive kind of person who doesn't like to dwell on unpleasant things, whereas she seems to like talking about health issues/past bad experiences etc - I think she just doesn't have much to talk about as her life experience is very limited so she brings up things from the past a lot. Or something! It's hard to explain really but I do understand how annoying it is to be around people who you feel "drag you down" when you like to remain in a positive place. It can feel insulting or like they are trying to put you down and put you in your place by reminding you of bad things that happened in the past that you'd rather not be reminded of.

Rubyupbeat · 01/01/2022 17:31

They see her illness in a different perspective, as a parent. To see a child suffer and nearly die must be traumatic. So maybe your silly doesn't feel shes had a hard life, but her parents do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread