Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU saying no to daughter?

109 replies

newterritory · 01/01/2022 11:18

DD turned 15 in October. She has good levels of freedoms, attends lots of parties with school friends until after mid-night so she is not wrapped up in cotton wool. However, I have said no to the following plans as I am not comfortable with it.

She wants to go round the house of a boy she has met one time, very briefly in a park. This boy does not go to her school but is apparently friends with one of her friends who went to primary school with him.

Since meeting him briefly in the park she has been chatting to him via social media and has been invited round today for the day. Think she has been chatting to him for about a month.

She says his parents will be home (I don't know them at all obviously) and I just said, no I am not comfortable with it. I've offered for him to spend the day at our house instead. She is not happy.

AIBU?

OP posts:
bloodyhoodedeyes · 01/01/2022 17:30

I have teenage boys, my question is why won't you just speak to the parents of the boy and see if the values all align? Just say you're not happy for them to be alone, not happy for doors to be closed etc?

I'm not sure what is stopping you having that conversation with the boys parents? It's seems really odd to me.

I'm happy for my sons to have girlfriends over I have the same rules as you, not when we are out of the house, check in on them and doors open.

I agree with the other poster, she's allowed to parties past midnight but can go and sit in a boys room? Very strange as she would potentially be more at risk of older men and older boys approaching her.

She sounds like her head is screwed on? So why not let her go and chat to the parents?

PinkSyCo · 01/01/2022 17:19

I’m going to go against the grain here OP and say I think your DD deserves your trust for the simple reason that she was truthful with you when she could have easily lied about where she was going. If you don’t let her go what’s to stop her from going behind your back another time, denying you the chance to see where he lives and meet his parents?

PegasusReturns · 01/01/2022 16:39

If this was a grown woman very briefly met the person once, would people be suggesting she then go on a date to the guy’s house? Of course not

If they had mutual friends and there were other mixed sex adults in the house no one would be suggesting that there was a risk to her safety. They might suggest not going as it’s a lazy date for an adult man and/or hints strongly at a hook up, but you surely understand that they dynamics are entirely different for for teens?!

It’s very difficult. When we went into covid I had a fairly naive recently turned 16yr old who went to an all girls school and had not had a boyfriend.

I now have an adult daughter who has friends with their own flats, drives and pretty much does her own thing. Most of the past 22 mths has been spent under lockdown of some sort and in many ways she (and her friends) have gone from 0-60.

My DD has handles it well but not all over her peers have. I wish there’d been more opportunity for hanging out in teen boys bedrooms before they moved straight to nightclubs and staying out for the night.

Roaringlogfire · 01/01/2022 15:52

I have been in your position exactly but my DD didn't ask. I caught her out on Snap Chat location. I could see she was in the house of a boy she'd met through mutual friends. I drove there immediately. His mum came to the door and told me my DD had told her I knew she was there.

I spoke to both my DD and the boy about my concerns and asked the mum to make sure they left the doors open. She seemed nice and assured me they would. They have been dating now for about 8 months. He's a nice boy from a nice family but she didn't want to invite him to ours initially because she was embarrassed and there was more to do at his.
Just be very honest about your concerns when you meet the parents. Not sure what you do if you get a bad vibe though. I had no choice and luckily I hot a good vibe.

StopStartStop · 01/01/2022 14:52

Don't let her go. You've made a sound decision, OP.

Maybe not all teenage boys are rapists. Maybe they don't have a bunch of friends ready to come round for a gang session. Maybe their dads don't all want to join in. But just in case, don't go. It only takes one.

As a teenager, one of my friends was dropped off at a young man's house by her mum, all seemed fine. He locked her in, kept her three days, invited his friends round. They let her go eventually, after she'd been repeatedly gang raped. Just don't take the chance.

334bu · 01/01/2022 14:27

YANBU.

TorySteller · 01/01/2022 14:26

If this was a grown woman who had met someone on an online dating site and very briefly met the person once, would people be suggesting she then go on a date to the guy’s house? Of course not.

You’re completely right OP. Even if his parents are there, you have no idea who they are. It’s the right call.

BlueRabbitWasNaughty · 01/01/2022 14:24

The reality is lots of teens do conduct friendships over social media nowadays and that not all teen boys are rapists!

Sorry, this was a quote by a pp.

BlueRabbitWasNaughty · 01/01/2022 14:23

The reality is lots of teens do conduct friendships over social media nowadays and that not all teen boys are rapists!

I have boys the same age so perhaps they are slightly less vulnerable than girls. However, I agree that this is how teens now make friends and it's a good thing when online friends cross over into real life.

If they have a friend in common and you are able to meet the parents, I would be happy with this but you understandably aren't....

Could you take dd to his house, say hi and drop them both into town for shopping and Macdonalds. Pick them up a couple of hours later and drop him back home? It would give you (and her) a chance to see what he's like before seeing him again.

emuloc · 01/01/2022 14:13

@newterritory

I just think allowing a 15yr old to go to a persons house for the day that she has met very briefly on one occasion sends the completely wrong message about keeping yourself safe.
You are right. Do not allow your Dd to make you feel bad. You are doing what a parent should do, regarding this situation.
Waftypants · 01/01/2022 14:13

I also don't really share your anxiety, I think meeting his parents briefly at the door and making sure they're going to be at home is reasonable. Just set a time limit and go and pick her up, she can always ring if she needs you earlier than the agreed time. However now youve said no, it might be damaging to your parental role to let her talk you round on this occasion.
I'd be more interested in why there is such resistance to him coming over to your house.

Chasingaftermidnight · 01/01/2022 14:12

You couldn’t being less unreasonable!

HacerSonarSusPasos · 01/01/2022 14:08

@SeasonFinale

The reality is lots of teens do conduct friendships over social media nowadays and that not all teen boys are rapists!
Not all are rapists, but some are and you don't know which, so you need to be warry of all. Sounds like a good strategy to me 🤷‍♀️
PegasusReturns · 01/01/2022 14:04

she has met very briefly on one occasion sends the completely wrong message about keeping yourself safe

I disagree. She won’t be alone, they have a mutual friend, they’ve been talking for a month.

This is a great opportunity to point out the difference between the safeguards that exist in this scenario and a truly random and an unsafe meet up (in the park, stranger who you’ve never met/ seen, at night, without telling your parents).

If you say no to everything it makes it harder for teens to distinguish between different scenarios.

jackstini · 01/01/2022 14:04

I would be slightly more worried about what happens at the parties tbh - easier for things to happen in the dark, drinking...

If you can meet the parents at the door and go over rules I would be ok with it (dd was 15 in March so similar age and she has recently been to her first teenage party - with parents there)

Have you asked her what rules she thinks there should be if she goes there? Talk about it, sound her out

Floralnomad · 01/01/2022 13:41

Has she given you a reason why him coming to you is not good enough .

sweetbellyhigh · 01/01/2022 13:37

As the mother of a teenage boy I make it very clear to parents of female visitors what the house rules are eg. they need to be in living areas, not bedrooms.

I expect the parents to be equally vigilant and discourage his friendships with kids whose parents who do not check up on basic safety issues.

I would be the mother saying invite her here and we can talk it through. I would expect that doorway conversation.

So I think what you are doing is fine but I would also encourage you not to shy away from open conversations with other parents.

ShrinkingViolet9 · 01/01/2022 13:35

Have you confirmed that there really is a mutual friend?
Are the lad's parents planning to be in all day? Can you be certain of that?
What are DD's objections to his coming to your house for a few hours, rather than her going to his house for the day, when she's only met him briefly once before?
Could you suggest he picks her up at yours and they go out for a coffee and a pizza for a few hours - a whole day is a long time to spend at his parent's house if she decides she doesn't like him very much, after all.

FawnFrenchieMum · 01/01/2022 13:33

@sparepantsandtoothbrush yes because I know that I’m home, I know that his room is on the same floor as our living room. I know what they are up to while they are here. I couldn’t judge that at someone else’s house. I wouldn’t like him going to their house without knowing some of the above.

@newterritory I wouldn’t have an issue with being asked any of those questions on my doorstep, it shows your a caring responsible parent.

AngelicInnocent · 01/01/2022 13:26

If it helps, my DD and her friends informed me when they were 17 that I had always been a really cool mum because I was always a mum and never cool! Go with your gut.

SeasonFinale · 01/01/2022 13:23

The reality is lots of teens do conduct friendships over social media nowadays and that not all teen boys are rapists!

Flumo · 01/01/2022 13:22

@mbosnz

To add, I wish my parents had been as caring as you are. . .
Was literally just thinking it!!!
newterritory · 01/01/2022 13:21

I just think allowing a 15yr old to go to a persons house for the day that she has met very briefly on one occasion sends the completely wrong message about keeping yourself safe.

OP posts:
bcc89 · 01/01/2022 13:17

It's wonderful that your daughter feels like she can be honest with you about where she is going and who with. Try to hold onto that. She is only 15, but I would try to give her a bit of freedom, like the way you do with the parties and letting her go to the park with friends.

I would encourage her to keep communication open and to not end up upstairs with a boy she doesn't know.

PegasusReturns · 01/01/2022 12:54

Agreed these things can and do happen and the absolute best thing we can do for our daughters is to give them the tools to manage these situations that will come up regardless of how hard we try to shield them. Sometimes that means allowing them the experience in as safe an environment as possible.

The chances of a 15 year old boy attacking a 15 year old with whom he shares mutuals in his home whilst his parents are there is tiny.

He might want to kiss her or more and she may or many not want to. That environment, without drink, or peer pressure, whilst other adults are home is actually one of the best ways to explore adolescence. It gives her a chance to say no or remove herself from a situation in relative safety.

When my teens were that age I’d text them shortly after they arrived saying “I need you to call me urgently”. They could call on that text at any point during their day/evening and I would know it was because they needed out of the situation.