Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick and tired of tired of people telling others to leave there DHs over silly things.

140 replies

LurkersConfessions · 01/01/2022 10:40

I’ve been lurking on here for a few weeks now reading posts I do enjoy it and find the advice very good. However I’m getting a bit sick and tired of some posters telling OPs to “LTB”, kick out or even divorce their DH over minor things. Like an OP complaining about their DH of 10+years saying a rude comment and some of the replies are saying the OP needs to get in contact with their divorce lawyers it’s getting a bit ridiculous.

To be fair it’s not exclusively MN I see it with so many other women giving relationship advice. They are so quick to tell others to leave their OH for doing what is sometimes minor actions but would never do the same the their own OH if they did the exact same thing.

OP posts:
ZenNudist · 01/01/2022 11:21

LTB

NearlyAHoarder · 01/01/2022 11:21

And yes, absolutely @FlowerFlour they train you to believe that your account of the relationship being shit isn't reliable enough to act on.

The ONE place where you won't be told ''six of one, half a dozen of the other'' is so valuable.

AuntieStella · 01/01/2022 11:20

If you think the advice is wrong, then the solution is at your fingertips.

Post what you think is better advice on the thread in question.

thepeopleversuswork · 01/01/2022 11:19

Nah. I have rarely seen an unwarranted LTB.

The reality is that the whole of society pressures women to put up with it, to compromise, to “make it work”. Often at the cost of their mental health and financial security.

A small handful of opinionated women -many of whom have been through awful relationships and can see how much happier they can be alone - is a useful corrective to this.

If it weren’t for LTB comments it would probably have taken me a lot longer to leave my abusive husband. And I am bloody grateful for it.

NearlyAHoarder · 01/01/2022 11:19

Same. Thank God I posted.

Mumsnet didn't TELL me what to do. It brought back to life the part of me he had consciously suppressed for his own convenience.

DrSbaitso · 01/01/2022 11:18

@LurkersConfessions

Most of the time, as the thread goes on, you find that the initial incident the OP posts about is just the tip of the iceberg. People in happy relationships don't tend to post about minor squabbles that aren't actually a serious problem. And then what usually happens is the OP tells us we've got it all wrong, he's lovely really and a great dad, and disappears. Until the next time.

I completely agree with this, however a lot of the time it will appear on the very first page of the post without any backstory being said.

So what?

Honestly, so what?

Do you think a woman in a happy relationship will throw it all away because Woman1234 on Mumsnet said she should? When so many women stay forever with utter scumbags, making excuses for them and villainising anyone who sees them for what they are?

Do you think women aren't smart enough to know how they feel? That they're so weak and thick that they're chucking good men to the kerb because some anonymous MNers thought they should?

FlowerFlour · 01/01/2022 11:16

I actually did LTB after posting a mumsnet thread many years ago.

I was in an unhappy relationship with a financially and sexually abusive manchild. I felt trapped and depressed, but when I spoke to my real life friends about how I was feeling they just said non-committal things like "relationships are so hard" and "that doesn't sound good".

When I posted on AIBU about one shitty thing he'd done to me the post spiralled, got moved over to relationships, and I was almost universally advised to cut my losses and dump him. It kind of felt like I needed that permission to leave; that my relationship was 'bad enough'. I didnt have the confidence to act on my own feelings, and friends in real life didn't want to be blunt, but mumsnetters told me straight. That's exactly what I needed at that time.

So I'm a huge fan of LTB, everyone should do it!

NearlyAHoarder · 01/01/2022 11:16

I think the posts that sum up what happened are the most helpful.

eg

''So when you'd never needed him more than you did the day of your father's funeral, he left you alone to go out drinking''.

Sometimes the OP might have written this in 800 words but I think it can be helpful to see the absolute crux of the situation summarised and through the lens of another woman with a higher standard.

And yes! There is nothing wrong with being made aware that some women won't put up with this!

I used to wonder ''why me?''

PeeAche · 01/01/2022 11:13

I love my DH but he's a thoughtless turd sometimes. Like once he left my car in gear on the driveway and several posters said he was trying to kill me and I needed to divorce him. It wasn't even a thread about him doing it. Just an idle comment on somebody else's and everyone piled in.
I'm also a step mother and I'm frequently told that his ex divorced him for a reason, and I should too. I'm pregnant and because he was married before, I'm frequently referred to as a "breeder" because, sadly, only kiddos from the first marriage are real children and mine is just a "mistake". This one often actually makes me cry, I'm afraid. People don't realise how much their words hurt.

My DH and I had a row about Covid over Christmas and I was told to leave him immediately.

I don't need to leave my bastard but lots of women do and I do worry that it can dilute the point if we recommend it for every misdemeanour.

donquixotedelamancha · 01/01/2022 11:13

Far, far too many women tolerate and accept and reproduce with absolute trash and inflict traumatic childhoods on their kids. The only acceptable level or instance of abuse is zero

This is true but I don't think it's what OP means. There are loads of threads which get a lot of LTB/go NC/tell them to fuck off comments when the healthy, normal response would just be to speak to that person about your feelings.

At the same time the threads about women who are jealous get quite a lot of posters encouraging abusive and controlling behaviour towards the husband.

Anyone who actually acted on advice like that all the time would never be able to maintain any relationship.

NearlyAHoarder · 01/01/2022 11:12

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing completely agree that for some who aren't brave enough to take action, it's a convenient narrative ''oh mumsnetters say ltb at the drop of a hat''.

Women in abusive relationships do enough of these mental gymnastics to rationalise staying in a shit relationship already, they don't need more rationalisations.

I know. I used to stay, paralysed, asking myself ''but who is really happy anyway?''

'''Do I have some right to be happy?''.
''were my grandparents happy?''
''Would I be jumping from the frying pan in to the fire if I left?''
''Would loneliness be worse than being shouted at and controlled?''
''Would poverty be any better than this?''

So. We are all primed to do what we're doing if we are surviving because that is the goal. Survival.

We have to break through that hardwiring to take a leap of faith and leave.

Anybody who thinks that that hardwiring can be over written by a poster on mumsnet saying ''ltb'' is delusional.

It's the posts that validate your experience, it's the posts that make you feel seen, heard, understood, believed. They're the posts that will help a woman make the right decision for her.

But some posters who deeeeeeep down know that their h is an abuser-lite, they are going to like/need the narrative that mumsnetters tell all women to ''ltb'' at the drop of a hat. That must be a narrative that soothes their doubts.

LurkersConfessions · 01/01/2022 11:12

Most of the time, as the thread goes on, you find that the initial incident the OP posts about is just the tip of the iceberg. People in happy relationships don't tend to post about minor squabbles that aren't actually a serious problem. And then what usually happens is the OP tells us we've got it all wrong, he's lovely really and a great dad, and disappears. Until the next time.

I completely agree with this, however a lot of the time it will appear on the very first page of the post without any backstory being said.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 01/01/2022 11:11

@LurkersConfessions

I’m not gonna link the thread as I don’t want to single out people. There has been cases in which the OPs have said their OHs have told them to do something which we all agreed was just wrong, extremely rude and misogynistic however there was a few replies saying “LTB, “kick him out” etc. It could’ve been the first time their OH had said comments like this. I was thinking if some of those posters would leave their own DH if they said the same sort of thing.
Well, supposing the OPs of those threads decided that whatever this mysterious thing was that totally happened by itself in a vacuum, it was enough to make them want to end the relationship and not be in it any more. What's the objection?
TheCanyon · 01/01/2022 11:11

My dh is still drunk, infact i think he had wine/beer for breakfast. He's now away to bed. I'm now entertaining 3 out of 4 dc and a puppy.

He would be the absolute devil according to mn. I couldn't give a shiny shit, he's had a tough year and dd3 was chatting to him about his dm(died when he was 21) so he's a bit upset.

Dollywilde · 01/01/2022 11:10

@LurkersConfessions

I’m not gonna link the thread as I don’t want to single out people. There has been cases in which the OPs have said their OHs have told them to do something which we all agreed was just wrong, extremely rude and misogynistic however there was a few replies saying “LTB, “kick him out” etc. It could’ve been the first time their OH had said comments like this. I was thinking if some of those posters would leave their own DH if they said the same sort of thing.
If someone is the sort of person to make a rude, misogynistic comment to their partner, it’s unlikely to be the first time. In any event it won’t be the last. Holding views like that is a binary - you either do or you don’t. Doesn’t matter how often you manage to cover that up.
Branleuse · 01/01/2022 11:10

I think it can be OTT but theres often fair reason to criticise or work on an issue rather than jump to leaving.
I know that ive read things where i think " blimey, i wouldnt put up with that" but if i laid my relationship out for public scrutiny there would be things in mine that others would leave over and that dont bother me a jot.

grapewine · 01/01/2022 11:09

So many women on here put on with shocking behaviour from their partners. I wouldn't worry.

Dollywilde · 01/01/2022 11:09

Often you can’t see the wood for the trees, and an OP is an unreliable narrator, particularly in the context of relationship issues when they’ve already stayed a long time. My dad is emotionally abusive to my mum. Sometimes she will have a moan about something he’s done, and in isolation no one would tell her to leave him on the basis of that one occurrence. But being called useless, being disrespected, being ground down - over time, the pattern of behaviour is such that yes, you would tell them to leave over it. I know people whose relationships have broken down over what seems like a minor event, but it’s the straw that breaks the camel’s back. No one is going to LTB off the back of a forum response unless they already were in that headspace already.

FindingMeno · 01/01/2022 11:08

I agree.
LTB is fine if you have the means, but so so many women haven't.

LurkersConfessions · 01/01/2022 11:07

I’m not gonna link the thread as I don’t want to single out people. There has been cases in which the OPs have said their OHs have told them to do something which we all agreed was just wrong, extremely rude and misogynistic however there was a few replies saying “LTB, “kick him out” etc. It could’ve been the first time their OH had said comments like this. I was thinking if some of those posters would leave their own DH if they said the same sort of thing.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 01/01/2022 11:06

Most of the time, as the thread goes on, you find that the initial incident the OP posts about is just the tip of the iceberg. People in happy relationships don't tend to post about minor squabbles that aren't actually a serious problem.

And then what usually happens is the OP tells us we've got it all wrong, he's lovely really and a great dad, and disappears. Until the next time.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 01/01/2022 11:06

I do believe in working at relationships that are fundamentally sound so I wouldn't say LTB over something trivial.

However, quite often the trivial matter is the tip of an iceberg. As soon as people start raising questions something comes out that raises some serious red flags. e.g. DH thinks I spent too much on a night out turns out to really be DH resents every time I go out with my friends, will do what he can to sabotage it, sent me 14 messages when I was out for 3 hours and now expects me to account for every penny I spent.

If you just went off the original post then the later LTB would seem excessive.

WhatAHexIGotInto · 01/01/2022 11:04

I mostly agree. Sometimes we all fuck up and say something out of order to our partners because we're tired/hungry/whatever. It's human (although I suspect someone will come along to say that they have never uttered a anything other than love poetry to their partner ...). Most people acknowledge it, apologise, then move on.

I roll my eyes when I see someone post about their partner snapping at them over who was making the poached eggs or some other minor misdemeanor and the reply is 'he sounds controlling, LTB' when you know that the poster would never in a million years consider doing the same.

That does not in any way mean that I think people should put up with any old behaviour and in some cases on here, I read about women staying with partners who are clearly abusive to them and really should, LTB.

NearlyAHoarder · 01/01/2022 11:03

@NoSquirrels

A lot of people are putting up with absolutely shit relationships. They post because they know it’s wrong, they’re at the end of their tether and they need validation that yes, their relationship is absolutely fucking awful.

No idea what correlation that has in real life but on MN it’s a dynamic you see again and again,

No one leaves just because MN says LTB. But some people get their decision to LTB validated and the strength and advice on practical steps to follow through.

Yes, I had no sense of myself left. None. I needed to know that other people thought I deserved more. And luckily they did. My x had successfully trained me to believe that my ''account'' of anything was unreliable. You can't just tell an abusive man that you're leaving. He will not say, ok. He will tell you all of YOUR faults. As though it was a contest to see who is the worst, you, and the one who is the 'best' (Him) is the one who decides when the relationship is over.

It's far from easy to end a relationship with a man who has even a few abusive traits.

MatildaTheCat · 01/01/2022 11:02

It’s a mixture. A lot of posts are written by women who really are in terrible relationships which skews the balance. However the number of times people declare‘that’s a deal breaker for me,’ because someone’s partner has done some misdeed is unreal.

I’d be on DH no. 500 by now if I’d LTB every time he’d pissed me off and Frank he’s a pretty good egg, just human and flawed like most of us.

Swipe left for the next trending thread