Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick and tired of tired of people telling others to leave there DHs over silly things.

140 replies

LurkersConfessions · 01/01/2022 10:40

I’ve been lurking on here for a few weeks now reading posts I do enjoy it and find the advice very good. However I’m getting a bit sick and tired of some posters telling OPs to “LTB”, kick out or even divorce their DH over minor things. Like an OP complaining about their DH of 10+years saying a rude comment and some of the replies are saying the OP needs to get in contact with their divorce lawyers it’s getting a bit ridiculous.

To be fair it’s not exclusively MN I see it with so many other women giving relationship advice. They are so quick to tell others to leave their OH for doing what is sometimes minor actions but would never do the same the their own OH if they did the exact same thing.

OP posts:
LindaEllen · 01/01/2022 11:38

The problem is, nobody can tell a whole situation from one post (even if the OP gives details).

When I was ill with depression and anxiety I was a bitch to DP sometimes. He stood by me and I'm much better now, things are better than ever now I'm getting the help I need. If he'd posted on here, and I was the male partner, people would have said LTB and there's every chance I wouldn't be here now.

Also people have a talent for leaving out their part in the events leading up to whatever they're posting about.

Of course, some people are absolute dickheads and should be left. But on the whole LTB does seem to be the wrong answer.

NoNameHere12 · 01/01/2022 11:38

I believe the reason is due to the fact that the argument is based on the posters opinion so it’s fairly normal behaviour.

For instance, if Sandra said her husband hit their son I would say LTB because that is something that I myself, would absolutely not tolerate, where Kimberley might not be happy about her kids being hit by their father, may tolerate it. My husband could have an affair and I forgive him, but that’s something Sandra would absolutely not do, whilst I would but not tolerate my kids being hit.
It’s opinions and what people would and wouldn’t tolerate, so of course you will get people say LTB.

Lanique · 01/01/2022 11:38

I agree OP. While there is an awful lot of very depressing threads on here, there is also an awful lot of very black and white thinking.

NearlyAHoarder · 01/01/2022 11:37

@Liz1tummypain

I see where you're coming from and I also feel it a bit. On the other hand, there was a question asking " what was the final straw for you" sort of thing the other day and it's clear that so, so so many women will soldier on, martyring themselves in horrific abusive relationships. I don't know how much of the " leave him now" advice is reasonable.
This is a good point. The last straw is the last straw but if you told people about that last straw in isolation they might think you'd left for a silly reason. My x wanted to just earn the money and he wanted me to run a creche, launderette, hotel and restaurant. But I had to do it to his high standards. I wanted to buy a bigger saucepan once and he didn't sanction the expense. I was standing there in Robert Dias, asking for a saucepan and he said no. I think I did realise, I am a slave in that moment.
EarringsandLipstick · 01/01/2022 11:36

I had no sense of myself left.

Me too. It's 8 years on. As we had v small DC at the time, he's still able to exercise control. But less, of course.

But I'm only now beginning to get some sense of myself. To stop blaming & hating myself. To set higher standards for how I should be treated. I've been left really unsupported by my family (who are broadly good people & we're close. But they have been shockingly disinterested & uninvolved. They just don't get it), I've thrown myself into work at huge cost to me & my kids, and have put up with really shite treatment there.

I'm finally progressing my divorce. I feel guilty & stupid I didn't do it sooner - but I try to remind myself that I simply couldn't

I do feel a shift in myself that I can now prioritise and value myself. But it's very early days in that. For nearly 25 years (we met when I was 20) this man controlled me and eroded any sense of self. I feel like 2022 will see change, real change.

FredWinnie · 01/01/2022 11:36

MN was a lifeline for me too!!!!

I didn't LTB because it was an extended family member and it was a few years ago, but my God do I have better boundaries all round

And I was a silent lurker. I never posted a thing during my rough time, but I absorbed the advice slowly

Thank you MN posters who are kind enough to to post in order to help remove the scales from our eyes when it's needed Flowers

endofbluenight · 01/01/2022 11:36

There are a lot of women here with a lot of experience. They can spot the signs that someone is in a bad relationship. OP, I suggest you read the principles of a successful marriage by Gottman. He has something like an 80% success rate of predicting whether a relationship will survive or fail based on watching a 15 minute video of them discussing something they disagree on (like household chores), even if they are loved up newly weds. The warning signs are not over the issue being disagreed on, but over the way the couple are handling it.

And really, the take away message from the Relationships Board is not that too many women are leaving men at the drop of a hat, but that they have stayed with shit men because they haven't been able to read the signs that this relationship is a bit shit till way too late.

I do wish however that posters would have more understanding that not all women have the financial or practical means to leave a relationship without creating another set of extremely challenging life circumstances. Some women are making difficult choices to stay and they deserve support too, and certainly more than being scolded if they don't LTB.

I guess what I am saying is that we need more education and awareness of what a bad relationship looks like, and not just what criminally abusive relationships look like.

StationaryMagpie · 01/01/2022 11:34

What i hate, which to be fair you don't see so much these days (i've been around since 2006) is the habit of dog-piling on the women who continue to post, clearly NOT ready to leave yet.. because they've had the audacity not to leave the previous occasions they've posted about their spouse/OH.

It took me years to leave mine, i knew what he was doing was wrong, but i kept believing he could change.. and he made all the right noises, counselling, anger management.. i left once, went back.. it took me another 7 years to leave the second time.

Its not as easy as 'LTB' and i just wish the posters here wouldn't withdraw their support because they don't get the immediate response, which is what happened with me.

Yes my ex is a dick, yes he was emotionally/physically abusive.. i should have left him long, long before, but leaving him without the support of the forum because i didn't do it in their pre-agreed time scale was a lot bloody harder.

Its why when i post a 'ltb' i try and temper it with knowing how fucking hard it is.

WannaBeCatLady · 01/01/2022 11:34

Healthy relationships are able to express a full range of emotions.

I went on an excellent training course where the trainer (a leader in the field of attachment and trauma) asked us all if we've ever told our partners that we hate them. He said that if we've never felt hate and expressed that we hate in the moment then we're not in a healthy relationship.

We should hate our partners sometimes. We should be able to express to them how much they are annoying us. Then the humorous understanding and acceptance can occur.

I do think we can be quick to forget that we are all human and flawed. Sometimes we can say hurtful things on purpose to hurt our partners, sometimes we can all act in controlling ways, sometimes we can get so bogged down in arguments that our acceptance for the other person diminishes.

MN can be so helpful to women in abusive relationships. But not with acceptance of another flawed human. Acceptance, understanding and humour is what I believe a marriage needs. That isn't to say someone should put up with abuse, I just don't believe one argument that has got out of hand is abusive. I have told my dh to fuck off. He deserved being told to fuck off. That isn't great behaviour on my part, but it wasn't abusive. Technically I took my frustrations out on him in an unhealthy way, but there's no systematic abuse where I've made him feel less then, or controlled him, made him feel worthless. More radical honesty is needed in relationships so resentments don't build. You are allowed to have an argument in a relationship without it being abusive.

Nathlash · 01/01/2022 11:32

@NowEvenBetter

*their husbands Nah. Far, far too many women tolerate and accept and reproduce with absolute trash and inflict traumatic childhoods on their kids. The only acceptable level or instance of abuse is zero . Plenty of intelligent women use this site and can see the red flags a mile off.

You trying to police them, or get women to tolerate any degree of shit behaviour from a man is terrible. No one is going to leave their abuser due to words on a screen, but it could plant the seeds to them raising their standards and giving their kids a better life. We can hope.

This.
Liz1tummypain · 01/01/2022 11:32

I see where you're coming from and I also feel it a bit. On the other hand, there was a question asking " what was the final straw for you" sort of thing the other day and it's clear that so, so so many women will soldier on, martyring themselves in horrific abusive relationships. I don't know how much of the " leave him now" advice is reasonable.

IncompleteSenten · 01/01/2022 11:31

Oh, and if you can prove there's a woman ever on MN who left a happy, respectful and loving marriage between equals after being told to by mners because of a single unimportant 'silly' thing - I'll donate £5000 to women's aid.

BoudecaBains · 01/01/2022 11:31

It’s either A

Dollywilde · 01/01/2022 11:31

@welliesarefuntowear

There is a lot of advice on here that is designed to make women feel bad about their situation even if the probably would be happier if they LTB. This oh I feel sorry for your children. I find that genuinely upsetting to read. If you're in a situation which I have been where you genuinely have to leave then it takes absolutely everything you've got and I am still struggling to survive this. My ex isn't evil or even abusive but he made a series of extremely poor choices including an affair which wrecked our relationship beyond repair. I just had no idea how to fix it. The man he is now is a far easier person two years down the line. I do think people can change. A friend of mine, she discovered he'd husband had been unfaithful with many women. She chose to stay. They seem happy. Sometimes it does work out for the best.
I don’t know, I do sometimes feel sorry for the children. My mum convinced herself that we kids were better off with parents who were together. Instead she’s tied herself to a man who’s been rude to her for 30 years, given us kids a pretty confused idea of what constitutes a good relationship. They’re both bitter alcoholics now which comes with its own set of problems for us as adults. But she tells herself we had a better life because they stayed together. I think sometimes it can be useful to remind parents that staying together for the kids can be more harmful than splitting.
Boood · 01/01/2022 11:31

The “go NC” crowd is even more extreme and ridiculous (although I suspect there’s a lot of overlap). There was one the other day where people were telling the OP to ditch her entire family because her brother didn’t invite her to NYE parties.

NearlyAHoarder · 01/01/2022 11:31

that's the bench mark, when people post and say ''what you need to do is sit down and tell your h how much this is affecting you'' - then I know, they just have no idea what some women are enduring. NO IDEA.

Not every husband is open to hearing your experience. In some relationships (the ones women are miserable in, the ones women want to leave) there is one perspective; his.

You can't just ''sit down and talk' in every ''relationship'''. Because the other person likes the balance of power exactly how it is and will do anything to avoid a reasonable ''sit down and talk'' where they have to admit that they have more freedom, less responsibility. No. They will avoid a conversation at all costs, by shouting, pouting, sulking, deflecting, projecting, stonewalling, verbally abusing etc etc

The idea that somebody could come to mumsnet and post a long thread about their distress without having first tried to communicate that distress to their partner is so unlikely.

But posters do offer up the advice ''what you need to do is calmly sit down with him and let him know how you feel''.

NoSquirrels · 01/01/2022 11:30

I was thinking if some of those posters would leave their own DH if they said the same sort of thing.

How about the shocking notion that some people are with men who wouldn’t say the same sort of thing at all?

EarringsandLipstick · 01/01/2022 11:30

@NearlyAHoarder

You have nothing to worry about. By the time I posted a thread about my x who'd been abusive (financially, emotionally, verbally) for a good 5 years already, my denial was still not pierced.

I still thought that it was better to appear happy and normal than to be happy and sane.

So I posted a thread about him April 2007 and every single person (obviously) said leave, get away) and I did but not until July 2007. Which I know isn't fast enough for some posters!

But the notion that people are going to leave a partner because somebody online says leave him is ridiculous.

It takes a long long time for the denial and the anaesthetic that protects you on a day to day basis to wear off so that you have even moments of lucidity that allow you to see things for the shit show they really really are.

Women are so conditioned to be kind, work hard at their relationship, accept their loss of financial earnings, capability to save, their loss of respect in the relationship they're now stuck in because of their children, their loss of earnings, savings, and most of all, their loss of freedom that Thank Goodness there is ONE PLACE where the pendulum swings in the other direction and doesn't tell a woman to swallow back down her own need for freedom and respect.

What an excellent post. It resonates so much with me.

I'm glad things improved for you.

IncompleteSenten · 01/01/2022 11:29

Really?

Could you link some?

Only I've never actually seen a post where an op has described a 'silly', one off, unimportant incident in an otherwise happy, equal and loving relationship and been told to ltb

Oh, I tell a lie. There's the 'Been married 20 years and just found out my husband likes Bros, what do I do' joke threads. They get lots of ltb.

But not yet seen a 'my wonderful husband who contributes fairly in all ways, is hugely respectful and loving and has never let me down, said something unkind to me yesterday' threads with no updates from the op during the thread that describe times the husband she initially praised did in fact treat her or others like shit quite regularly that got a chorus of ltb,

But mn is a big place and I've possibly missed them so links would be helpful.

EarringsandLipstick · 01/01/2022 11:29

@NowEvenBetter

*their husbands Nah. Far, far too many women tolerate and accept and reproduce with absolute trash and inflict traumatic childhoods on their kids. The only acceptable level or instance of abuse is zero . Plenty of intelligent women use this site and can see the red flags a mile off.

You trying to police them, or get women to tolerate any degree of shit behaviour from a man is terrible. No one is going to leave their abuser due to words on a screen, but it could plant the seeds to them raising their standards and giving their kids a better life. We can hope.

👏👏👏

Well said.

I wish I'd known about MN years ago when I was in the throes of a very abusive marriage. I did eventually leave (well, got him to) and I wouldn't have finished it on MN advice obviously but reading the insightful, powerful commentary from posters who understood coercion, control & emotional abuse might have got me asking questions sooner.

I honestly spent years thinking it was me. My marriage ended in 2013. It wasn't till 2017 when reading about it on MN, and then a newspaper article, that I even heard of gaslighting. I knew he used to make me feel crazy. And I cried and cried for hours at night wondering if I was crazy or how he could say & do what he did. It has been such a relief to find out, belatedly, that it was actually abuse.

User135644 · 01/01/2022 11:26

far too many women tolerate and accept and reproduce with absolute trash and inflict traumatic childhoods on their kids.

And you get the threads full of women saying how much they love bad boys. It's not so much fun though when they've got kids to them and they're still a dickhead and not grown out of it.

Society would be a lot better off if all these scumbags didn't reproduce, but there's always a willing woman.

dottiedodah · 01/01/2022 11:25

I think some relatively small things are like the tip of the iceberg though .For example he never washes up.Becomes a bigger and bigger thing if you come home from work tired at the end of your shift, to start all over again.Many women may mete out this advice ,but the way society is arranged means that many women feel dependent in varying ways to their partner.Hopefully this will change gradually .Single Mums often seem to have the bulk of the care of DC as well . I always wonder if anyone does take this advice on board and how often

RainbowBridge21 · 01/01/2022 11:23

YANBU, I've seen many a responses that default to LTB. In some cases it's justified but in others I don't think it's a good attitude to encourage others to just give up without working through their problems. No one is perfect and no relationship never has any problems. Its a bit ignorant to just say LTB without knowing the whole story.

User135644 · 01/01/2022 11:22

The thing to bear in mind on here is you only ever get one side of the story.

You can read the situation outlined and say 'yeah leave them' but they're not there to defend themselves.

There's plenty of stories where the partner/husband is clearly an absolute shit and you wonder what they're doing with them in the first place.

welliesarefuntowear · 01/01/2022 11:21

There is a lot of advice on here that is designed to make women feel bad about their situation even if the probably would be happier if they LTB. This oh I feel sorry for your children. I find that genuinely upsetting to read. If you're in a situation which I have been where you genuinely have to leave then it takes absolutely everything you've got and I am still struggling to survive this. My ex isn't evil or even abusive but he made a series of extremely poor choices including an affair which wrecked our relationship beyond repair. I just had no idea how to fix it. The man he is now is a far easier person two years down the line. I do think people can change. A friend of mine, she discovered he'd husband had been unfaithful with many women. She chose to stay. They seem happy. Sometimes it does work out for the best.

Swipe left for the next trending thread