Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick and tired of tired of people telling others to leave there DHs over silly things.

140 replies

LurkersConfessions · 01/01/2022 10:40

I’ve been lurking on here for a few weeks now reading posts I do enjoy it and find the advice very good. However I’m getting a bit sick and tired of some posters telling OPs to “LTB”, kick out or even divorce their DH over minor things. Like an OP complaining about their DH of 10+years saying a rude comment and some of the replies are saying the OP needs to get in contact with their divorce lawyers it’s getting a bit ridiculous.

To be fair it’s not exclusively MN I see it with so many other women giving relationship advice. They are so quick to tell others to leave their OH for doing what is sometimes minor actions but would never do the same the their own OH if they did the exact same thing.

OP posts:
endofbluenight · 01/01/2022 12:03

Lots of wise comments on this thread from women who have been there.

Been thinking about this and the problem is not those who say LTB.

The dangerous posters are those who say LTB but then attack the OP if she doesn't immediately agree to do so, accusing her of being a terrible mother who will destroy her children for life. These posters, with their faux concern for the children, do not actually care for the children at all. If they did they would be building OP up and supporting her, so that in time she was able to leave. Instead they make a broken women even more broken and alone as they chase her off the thread.

EarringsandLipstick · 01/01/2022 12:02

@anonanonanon123

Yep, I tend to think a lot of people on here are single and bitter or miserable and they want others to be too.
I think that's bollocks.

Posters do of course post trite or stupid comments - it's the Internet & people add here for all sorts of reasons, some not good

But I don't buy into the argument that many any? comments are made because a bitter poster wants others to experience the same pain

NearlyAHoarder · 01/01/2022 12:02

Flowers I was also goaded in to behaving in a very ''triggered'' way I now see. I would have said that my behaviour was terrible and felt badly about it once but now I understand that I was goaded and baited in to losing it. I forgive myself for being so reactive. Of course I was reactive. I had C-PTSD from 7 years of being ground down

Thank goodness we left those bastards.

OhWhyNot · 01/01/2022 12:02

There are some very over the top responses on here

From leaving the husband to cutting off the MIL over annoying issues that can be easily dealt with that are just part of family life

I have always found those that shout the loudest that they wouldn’t put up with xyz do they don’t feel strong in themselves put want portray to others that they are

QueeniesCroft · 01/01/2022 12:02

Very often, the issue in the OP is fairly trivial (perhaps because that's what the poster feels safe asking about), but it turns out that there is a much longer pattern of abuse, infidelity or generally awful behaviour.

I rarely post details of my marriage because I know it's awful, I know I should leave, and I also know all the reasons why I can't. The chorus of LTB would be deafening, but it wouldn't be wrong, it would just be impossible.

EarringsandLipstick · 01/01/2022 11:57

@NearlyAHoarder

that's the bench mark, when people post and say ''what you need to do is sit down and tell your h how much this is affecting you'' - then I know, they just have no idea what some women are enduring. NO IDEA.

Not every husband is open to hearing your experience. In some relationships (the ones women are miserable in, the ones women want to leave) there is one perspective; his.

You can't just ''sit down and talk' in every ''relationship'''. Because the other person likes the balance of power exactly how it is and will do anything to avoid a reasonable ''sit down and talk'' where they have to admit that they have more freedom, less responsibility. No. They will avoid a conversation at all costs, by shouting, pouting, sulking, deflecting, projecting, stonewalling, verbally abusing etc etc

The idea that somebody could come to mumsnet and post a long thread about their distress without having first tried to communicate that distress to their partner is so unlikely.

But posters do offer up the advice ''what you need to do is calmly sit down with him and let him know how you feel''.

Sorry to keep quoting all your posts Hoarder but you are hitting the point so much.

Absolutely all of this.

That's exactly what I used to do. Try to talk reasonably. I'd plan it all out. Rehearse it. I started knowing I wasn't wrong, about his spending, driving, lack of engagement, deceit ... and he would employ all of those tactics you mention.

His favourite was to act uncomprehending of what I was saying, wilfully 'misunderstand' every point, throw some irrelevant point at me related to something I may have done 15 years before. Eventually I would get angry, lose my temper etc. Then he would sneer at my 'rage', how 'hysterical' and 'crazy' I was. Once I moved to tears out of frustration & exhaustion, he'd really stick the knife in. He'd tell me how nobody liked me, friends, family. In this calm, faux-reasonable way. Over and over. When I was completely broken & in bits, he'd walk off, usually to switch on the TV & watch something like Friends, and start laughing. That final part was the worst of it. The laughing at a sitcom while I was in the next room, in bits.

Towards the end I had moments of such frustration & desperation, I might go back into the room like a madwoman, wailing like a banshee at him or ranting furiously. He used to laugh at me. And of course, I had portrayed myself as exactly the unhinged, crazy dervish he'd said I was ...

If I had described individual elements of this in an MN post, many may have said my behaviour was unreasonable (as it was) but I would also have hoped for wise, experienced posters who could have identified the abuse & starkly told me to LTB.

NoSquirrels · 01/01/2022 11:57

@LurkersConfessions

How about the shocking notion that some people are with men who wouldn’t say the same sort of thing at all?

Well I’m sure one of the OPs thought the same thing before their OHs said the comments which led them to put the post about it as well.

I’m not trying to excuse a lot of Mens awful behaviour. Just calling out the fact that are are some who expect other women in their relationships to hold up to a different standard they would never do in their own.

Without knowing what you’re referring to it’s hard to comment. But I’m not sure you’re right. Plenty of people have higher standards of their blokes than some of the stuff you see posted here. I don’t know how you can make a sweeping statement that other women are being hypocritical if you don’t know anything about those women’s lives and relationships.
HoardingSamphireSaurus · 01/01/2022 11:57

To be fair my MIL was and my DM is.

Sometimes familial relationships actually are utterly shite!

SummerBluez · 01/01/2022 11:55

And EVERY MIL or mother that has been fallen out with is a "toxic narc." Every one.

dworky · 01/01/2022 11:54

But why are you so angry at others (who may or may not have more experience than you) given opinion/advice?
The Op can surely make up their own mind.

FallonCarringtonWannabe · 01/01/2022 11:54

@anonanonanon123

Yep, I tend to think a lot of people on here are single and bitter or miserable and they want others to be too.
It doesnt occur to you that some people are in healthy relationship and want others to be too?

Because i often think the people who excuse shitty,abusive behaviours must have such poor relationships themselves they cannot see how bad it is.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 01/01/2022 11:54

@User135644

The thing to bear in mind on here is you only ever get one side of the story.

You can read the situation outlined and say 'yeah leave them' but they're not there to defend themselves.

There's plenty of stories where the partner/husband is clearly an absolute shit and you wonder what they're doing with them in the first place.

Erm, that's the point.

A woman having a safe space to voice her feelings

And they are far too often with him because of the slow boil. Something many women in that situation don't recognise for years.

Yes, posters over egg it but, as posters here have said, it helps. It provides support that can't be found elsewhere.

AlternativePerspective · 01/01/2022 11:54

Two things:

Firstly, there is a lot of projection which goes on on some of these threads from people who have been in abusive relationships and so automatically assume that everyone else is as well. And while in many cases that may be true, it’s fair to say that if you’re projecting your own experiences on to someone else’s situation, things might not be as you think they are either.

Secondly, people aren’t encouraged to post about positive relationship experiences here. Years ago I posted a thread about my then DH and was absolutely slated for daring to post a positive relationship thread when there are people on here who are in bad and abusive relationships, and how was that supposed to make them feel.

The other thing which astounds me is the regularity with which people advise posters to go NC with their family. I saw one the other day where the ILs bought the kids loads of Christmas presents and wanted to say they were from Santa, and a poster actually said she was clearly abusive and controlling and OP should “go NC.” Hmm

While there are obviously abusive families out there, if you read mn you could be forgiven for thinking that all families are abusive and that children should essentially go NC with their parents as soon as they leave home. What people seem to be forgetting here is that most of the people here are parents themselves, and run the risk that their own children will do the same when they’re older…

oakleaffy · 01/01/2022 11:53

When women do post after serious physical assaults, they are sometimes ambivalent about leaving,
It's only in these circs I ever type ''Please leave and don't look back''

But, as we know, it takes far more than strangers saying ''Leave him'' to make a woman leave a violent {or any} partner.

It's hard enough when a person we care about in real life is sticking with a violent partner.. and the person won't leave him despite repeated injuries {and young child/ren}

anonanonanon123 · 01/01/2022 11:48

Yep, I tend to think a lot of people on here are single and bitter or miserable and they want others to be too.

IncompleteSenten · 01/01/2022 11:48

@Boood

The “go NC” crowd is even more extreme and ridiculous (although I suspect there’s a lot of overlap). There was one the other day where people were telling the OP to ditch her entire family because her brother didn’t invite her to NYE parties.
Really? Because of a party?

Not because she also wasn't allowed to ever enter the house but was kept on the doorstep and not because she clarified that he has always been a user and not because she was being used for free childcare and treated like crap? Not because of an incident where he treated her daughter badly?
Not because of the fact that when they lived hours apart she was never invited to stay with them but they'd appear at hers uninvited regularly, expecting to be hosted?

If you're going to use a thread, then use it accurately.

This is the problem when people claim posters yell ltb / NC for trivial reasons.

They don't give the full story.

So yeah, go NC cos he didn't invite you to a party sounds ridiculous.

But go NC because of the actual truth - not really ridiculous at all.

Same for ltb.

People need to stop saying ltb for silly reasons. People don't say ltb for silly reasons.

Just like they don't say go NC for not getting a party invite.

FallonCarringtonWannabe · 01/01/2022 11:47

Women are so conditioned to be kind, work hard at their relationship, accept their loss of financial earnings, capability to save, their loss of respect in the relationship they're now stuck in because of their children, their loss of earnings, savings, and most of all, their loss of freedom that Thank Goodness there is ONE PLACE where the pendulum swings in the other direction and doesn't tell a woman to swallow back down her own need for freedom and respect

This. It is never just one rude comment. There is always a pattern of behaviour. Certain behaviours are known to lead to worse behaviours. Having strong boundaries early on is crucial. There are many posts this past few weeks from women early on in relationships noticing shitty behaviour and being unsure what to do. Only once. Only a couple of times. He is great the rest of the time. Ideal boyfriend when he isn't drunk and being abusive. Being firm with boundaries and self-respect at this point when there are no ties is ideal.

Age doesnt being wisdom, your distance from the problem does. It is easier to spot and know how to react when you are out of the situation and not clouded by misguided feelings.

So, YABVU. Society’s expectations of men are on the floor. Having a man who is an equal partner in the home or an equal parent is so far beyond many people’s experience it leaves them thinking abusive or lazy men are the standard
And expecting anything more is unreasonable. Let’s leave the higher expectations on mumsnet alone. Let's have one space where a father living with his children, acknowledging their existence and feeding them so they can survive isn't considered the gold standard of fatherhood.

dottiedodah · 01/01/2022 11:47

PeeAche Thats awful ,please dont take posters comments so much to heart.(Nothing on here should make you cry) Second (and first) marriages require patience and hard work . Just because one RL didnt work out doesnt mean a second one with someone totally different will end the same way! Just enjoy your lovely children (not mistakes!) and realise that some people posting arent in a perfect RL anyway (Who is FFS)!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/01/2022 11:45

@NearlyAHoarder my false narrative was “I’m just a very private person” - justifying to myself why I didn’t tell friends and family what exh was really like. No, I didn’t want them to know that my marriage was shit and ex was nasty and abusive.

I do agree sometimes that posts are heavy on the LTB and light on advice as to how to go about it- but usually someone comes along with useful practical advice.

KurtWildesChristmasNamechange · 01/01/2022 11:44

Whilst I doubt anyone has done it JUST because internet randoms told them to, it does open your eyes somewhat when you realise you're actually not crazy/psycho/whatever, and it IS in fact your DP/DH who's doing a number on your self esteem and confidence.

My own thread about exh 10 years ago had a lot of LTB comments. I didn't, because I just couldn't at that time. But I found that writing it all down, seeing the shocked comments on what I was living with on a daily basis, made me fully realise how abusive he was and no, I wasn't going mad and should leave - which I did when I could. Not because someone told me to, but because having seen it all written down the scales fell from my eyes and I realised how much I'd minimised his behaviour. It helped me immensely.

However, I fully agree that there are some really quite trivial things that get a LTB response, but I do wonder if there's a touch of lightheartedness in them tbh, or sarcasm.

What annoys me more is when posters give advice/say LTB and then get annoyed when OP doesn't seem to be complying!

SummerBluez · 01/01/2022 11:43

It's often repeat posters advising others to LTB at the drop of a hat.

I slammed (and I mean slammed) the car boot on my husband's head accidentally once, he shouted "you dickhead!"
Ten minutes later we were both laughing our heads off. We've been together 14 years and are very happy together. Yet so many posters on here say if your partner swears or raises their voice at you you should leave instantly. It's weird.

Clymene · 01/01/2022 11:43

I always think it's worth the OP'S of those threads reading reality's excellent pinned post: Right, listen up everybody. www.mumsnet.com/Talk/relationships/698029-Right-listen-up-everybody?msgid=14219935#14219935

I don't think I can ever recall a woman being advised to question her relationship (and that's what LTB is shorthand for) when the guy is a straight up bloke who forgot to wash up his mug before going to bed. It's always a pattern. The 'one off' comments are a symptom of a pattern of behaviour.

Like others have said, the bar is shockingly low for many men. And many OPs finish a long post laying out examples of lazy, entitled, abusive behaviour with 'but he's a good dad'.

I think if women telling other women their relationship is gash makes you feel uncomfortable, you should probably have a look at why that may be.

NearlyAHoarder · 01/01/2022 11:43

@EarringsandLipstick it's a long road to getting your self back.

I'm 14 years on and I feel that i stalled a lot in the early years. That stage where you obsess over what made him behave the way he did, I got stuck there and didn't move on to the next phase, asking myself why I accepted that for a long time.

Right now my project for January is to work my way through Kristen Neff Phd and Christopher Germer's work book on self-compassion.

I hope it's going to help me accept myself. I am doing ok but I still think that unfortunately there is something I carry around with me. Most people, 90% of people don't capitalise on it, but even in my extended family I am unfortunately emitting some scapegoat energy and I have been ejected from groups at work and in my wider family.

Something about my increased confidence but combined with residual radar/wariness to covert narcissism can put you at risk of the the covert narc in a group!

So. Working on overcoming my scapegoat energy right now. I will do it. I have been scapegoated for the last time.

EarringsandLipstick · 01/01/2022 11:43

@NoSquirrels

I was thinking if some of those posters would leave their own DH if they said the same sort of thing.

How about the shocking notion that some people are with men who wouldn’t say the same sort of thing at all?

This is also such a good point.

This may sound stupid, but reading MN has opened me up to the standards that many women do hold their partners to. Not the gushing 'my DP is amazing' threads that sometimes emerge but the way in which posters can articulate & demonstrate honest respectful relationships, where they can be brave enough (as it seems to me, though really they are just normal) to set boundaries, call out their OHs when needed & disagree with their partners without fear.

I don't know if I'll have another relationship I really hope I might. But I feel grateful to have learnt a lot about functional relationships through MN

LurkersConfessions · 01/01/2022 11:39

How about the shocking notion that some people are with men who wouldn’t say the same sort of thing at all?

Well I’m sure one of the OPs thought the same thing before their OHs said the comments which led them to put the post about it as well.

I’m not trying to excuse a lot of Mens awful behaviour. Just calling out the fact that are are some who expect other women in their relationships to hold up to a different standard they would never do in their own.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread