Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother in law relationships

112 replies

parentpanic · 01/01/2022 06:58

AIBU to wonder why this relationship is so often difficult and strained for so many?

OP posts:
FriteFuaite · 01/01/2022 10:57

YABU to ask and then piss off.

Is this another article you're writing?? How did you get on with the secondhand clothes one?

pinksunday · 01/01/2022 10:56

My MIL is a psycho!

We were no contact for a couple of years as I just couldn't deal with her nonsense - i had heart palpitations when I had to deal with her. They stopped when I went NC.

We agreed to try again last year for my husband's sake as we had a particularly stressful year.

We lasted a year until my husband had a stroke and she couldn't stand me being the next of kin and "in control" of things. She hates that the hospital update me and not her. It's absolutely ridiculous. She complained about the nurse in charge of the ward the first week he was in which was a great start! The nurse hadn't done anything.

The messages and texts I have had from her during this time are shocking - she's very nasty. All at a time when we don't know how well my husband will recover or what our future will look like.

She thinks I'm jealous of her relationship with her son but he doesn't enjoy time he spends with her or speaking to her - it's a chore to him - she's so deluded.

It has taken her 12 weeks to ask to see her grandchildren - who haven't been able to see their Dad due to covid restricting visiting and whose worlds have been turned upside down by their Dad being hospitalised and badly affected by his stroke.

I've now blocked her on all phone/social media etc because I don't have the strength to deal with her shit. Even my simple texts asking straightforward non-aggressive questions get twisted and she complains about me to my poor husband in hospital who really doesn't need her shit right now .

I could write a book about all the things she's said and done.

godmum56 · 01/01/2022 10:53

I think its kind of skewed research......people with calm happy family lives, "normal" in laws and so on don't post

AnnaMagnani · 01/01/2022 10:47

Mine asked 'Will it last?' on the day of my wedding.

She then announced I should call her Mum which I felt was tactless given my much loved Dad had died only 2 months before and me and my actual Mum were reeling.

As a final straw she then told me all the wifework I had to do now I was married sending cards to all DH's relations.

We were never going to be close but she basically shot the relationship in the foot. 10 years on she's OK and means well but OMG, if she'd just backed off in the beginning it would have been fine.

Perrymenopausal · 01/01/2022 10:39

My mil preferred my husbands first wife (she couldn’t stand MIL but played the game)

She is tricky and DH has spoken to her on several occasions, she blames me thinking it comes from me (it doesn’t)

She was slagging me off at a family/friend gathering and my teen daughter overheard and corrected her in front of MIL’s friends (mil was saying I won’t let Dd spend time with her, when in fact Dd didn’t want to spend the day with mil because it was her mates birthday). Mil thought Dd should have spoken in private but Dd said she didn’t want people thinking badly of me.

whenwillthemadnessend · 01/01/2022 10:37

My mil was ok but we had some issues

She did like to gossip and I felt I was victim of that at times.

SHe always saw the kids though and the last 10 years of her life were easier for me.

It was hardest when we had the first child but I guess we both adapted a bit and got used to each other.

I think both parties need to be able to give a little and not sweat the small stuff so much.

She has passed now and I think she was grateful by the end of all I had done for her.

My ex's mother was fab. I loved her She would Be a great mil

Newyearoldyou · 01/01/2022 10:31

Hettie definitely.

Many treat adult sons like babies. My Mil said about two years ago when dh was on his phone at the table (trying to find a recoding of dd singing for them) "oh on the phone at the table, I guess he's allowed to do that at home" 🤣🤣🤣

40 years old man Grin

Newyearoldyou · 01/01/2022 10:29

Gosh lots of reasons, why do you think op and why are you asking?

Two women thrust together in close quarters who may never have got on!
Sometimes Mil sees the son as a replacement dh if she's unhappy with her dh.
Childish, jealous, competitive, controlling, no work so bejng in charge is her main role.
No self esteem so clings to her role etc.
Won't take any feedback or advice from learning about sick gc or nappy /potty training.

RedRobyn2021 · 01/01/2022 10:26

My mother in law is nice. I think sometimes it's just different personalities maybe clash.

hettie · 01/01/2022 10:25

I wonder if it's a generational thing? Perhaps current mil's come from a time when less of them worked out the home or if they did worked very part time and men were in charge of so much. So the mum role was a bigger part of their identity? I also think having a crap relationship can lead to women focusing on the kids......But then of course they grow up. Many women seen to struggle with their children becoming autonomous adults I've noticed. What would their role be if not a mother to their children? Add in a daughter-in-law for good measure and you've got the perfect person to blame/get shirty with.

ChocolateCakeYum · 01/01/2022 10:24

Mine is a manipulative, backstabbing, drunk. I don’t want her around my son so she isn’t. I cut her off and my husband (her son) soon followed

wtfisgoingonhere21 · 01/01/2022 10:24

Thankfully don't see mine much now mainly due to dh and fil not speaking but we've had to endure watching his abisive and controlling ways towards her for years and dh has had it his whole life.

She has some strange ways and ideas and has overstepped the line many times where dc are concerned.

I disassociated myself from them along time ago but dh found it a struggle As he always felt sorry for her but his eyes have been opened a lot this last year and his tolerance level is non existent now finally.

She pops over once a week for a couple of hours and that's it.

They used to just turn up every friggin day whenever they felt like it and never took it when told no so it's been a relief for him and for me not having to deal with his stress and frustration every time they've been here.

Eslteacher06 · 01/01/2022 10:19

Interesting people say it's after the first child is born. That's exactly what happened to me. I got on with her fine before having a kid, but she became unbearable after.

I'm no contact with her now after years of her trying to undermine me. I've been accused of stopping her seeing my family, but she fails to realise that I was the one who used to encourage my husband to see her and that's stopped now.

My life is now infinitely better not hearing her backhanded nasty remarks.

MrsKDB · 01/01/2022 10:19

Mine didn’t / doesn’t see me as a person in my own right, imo, merely an enabler for her son’s sparkling career and provider of grandchildren. As a result I keep my distance and so does her other SIL. She’s from a generation where women were sidelined and put upon domestically to their own detriment which explains but does not excuse it. I will not make the same mistake.

marsdon · 01/01/2022 10:13

I don't like my MIL she acts too nice !
So you cannot say anything against her as she likes to be seen as being helpful all the time !
She is very nosey too wants to know everything and likes to dictate from afar and is a know all !
She is a bit argumentative with her own Husband he keeps quiet he is a lovely guy I sometimes feel sorry for him
It's my DP second marriage she is quite two faced too she didn't like the ex-wife and ex -wife didn't like her as she had a argument years ago about the way she was interfering with the children telling her how she should bring them up so after that she didn't see much of her grandchildren and when I came on the scene the DSC didn't really have a good word to say about my DP family because of the fall out .
The MIL said to me once before I got marriage to her son his ex-wife will always be seen as the DIL as she had the Grandchildren which I thought was a very odd thing to say to me being he had divorced her and it was all a very messy stressful divorce for her son .

LittleBipper · 01/01/2022 10:07

My MIL is great but I do wonder if my mum is the MIL from hell to my SIL. She moans to me about what SIL does wrong, I push back and I just hope she doesn't say it to SIL's face.

Cocolapew · 01/01/2022 10:03

Mine is a nasty, shit stirring, vindictive bitch. Its not just my relationship with her that's in tatters, her own son and granddaughters don't speak to her and the majority of her family don't either
She spent her life being pandered to, everyone seemed scared to confront her and to call her out on her bad behaviour. I had no such qualms and she hated me for it.
She was under the impression that I would do what she wished and made a big deal about me'stealing' her son away. I never understood that bit because DH and her didn't have anything like a good relationship, it's like she has some scenario in her head and that's the truth whether it actually is or not.

Breeblebree · 01/01/2022 10:01

My mother in law was my best friend, my mentor and a second mum. She died suddenly this summer and I miss her so much. My own mother is great, and we love each other dearly, but we are very different people. My mother in law was probably the person who understood my soul most in the world. We spoke every day, sometimes for hours. We worked in the same field and she cheerleaded and supported me without question. She was who I turned to first when I needed advice, and who I told first when I had good news. She taught me what it feels like to be loved absolutely unconditionally and to be valued just for being for who I was by another woman. She saved me, and I owe a huge part of everything I have and am today to her. She was loved by so many people, she worked so tirelessly to make the world a better place, and now she is gone and I don’t really know how to face the rest of my life without her.

Velvian · 01/01/2022 09:59

@ChubbyMorticia has a good point about the promotion that has been withdrawn. Many MILs are the staunchest upholders and enforcers of the patriarchy.

I guess these women have been bottom of the pile and followed the rules and expectations up until now, but they have power of their son and their son should have power over his wife. She is her DIL's boss's boss and is due respect and authority.

MalFunkshun · 01/01/2022 09:58

I think insecurity plays a huge part. My MiL has put a huge amount of effort into making an Instagrammable life (before it was a thing) and I think when I came along, as first DIL, two things happened:

  1. DH stopped going along with the Instagram aspects and opted out of a lot more - this was seen as me preventing him, rather than me giving him a much desired out!
And 2. I’m quite different to my mil and have made a lot of different life choices. I suspect on some level she thought DH would pick a wife more like her and she sees it as a bit of a slight that he hasn’t.

These have caused a lot of snide comments and tears from her over the years. As a result, I’m perfectly friendly, but I keep my distance and don’t overly engage with her.

Enko · 01/01/2022 09:55

Loved mine to pieces miss her dearly and honestly more than I do my own mother. Mil was involved and engaged with our loves my mother kinda disinterested.

Mil was a funny woman who loved fiercely. Had lost her youngest at age 20 and got through that to still be there for her family. She passed 3 years ago and oh I miss her.

If I can be half as good a mother in law to my children's partners I doubt they will have complaints

EnglishMuffins · 01/01/2022 09:54

My first MIL was horrid, adore my MIL now, she’s wonderful. But I think relationships become strained when a child is brought into the mix. The line between it being their grandchild but your child gets blurred and some old fashioned practices you maybe don’t agree with creep in and when it concerns your own DC then it can become a bit more fractious.

Frazzledmum123 · 01/01/2022 09:51

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

idontshareprimula · 01/01/2022 09:50

Mine is fine as long as she's getting her own way.

She's got too many opinions though. 'Wouldn't having three children be odd?' Etc

Headwhirling · 01/01/2022 09:47

I’ve never had one! But I am one, (my daughter is married).

I really like my SIL but we don’t see a huge amount of each other. We’ve had a few tense moments over the years but I think we get on ok on the whole.