Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What is the problem with the phrase 'Be Kind?'

242 replies

Fatandfifty49 · 31/12/2021 23:21

To me, it means think of others, consider their feelings. Don't be an arsehole under the guise of 'saying it how it is', 'telling the truth', 'not mincing your words.'

Largely, I think it is something very positive that has come out of the COVID pandemic and was often used in the context of how essential workers should be treated. It is absolutely a change for the better that I have personally witnessed.

It is a phrase that is used to say 'it is not OK to abuse me because you are having a bad day' and empowering for those who want to take ownership of their own wellbeing as well as that of others.

What do you all think?

OP posts:
ShiftingSands21 · 01/01/2022 09:10

I would have probably said the pandemic has made people nastier, not kinder.

MimosaFields · 01/01/2022 09:09

I find it patronising. An adult should not need to be told to be kind. It's something you tell children when they are learning. And as an adult, I don't want people telling me lies or treating me like an idiot just to be kind. It depends on the situation, but in general, I only ever want to hear the truth, even if a bit unsavoury

Elodeastar · 01/01/2022 09:05

@mynameiscalypso

But it didn't come out of Covid at all did it? It came out of the death of Caroline Flack and pre-dates Covid.
I don't think this is true - her death made the phrase more popular, but I saw that phrase long before that sad event. To me it just means to stop and think before I say or do something, how would I feel if the 'thing' was said or done to me, and it is really necessary to do it. It never means to let others walk all over you, or to never think of yourself. I always say that 'be kind' includes to yourself, a lot of folk forget that and are far too harsh on themselves (often over things they cannot control). In the spirit of kindness, Happy New Year and all the best for 2022. :)
ElftonWednesday · 01/01/2022 08:49

@itsgettingweird

I also have issues around the fact that Caroline Flack, whose post it was, was awaiting trial for DV. I can't imagine people co -opting a male celebrities last post as inspiration if they were awaiting trial for DV charges. Though I do also accept the problem of online trolls needs actual action.

I've always said that I have an issue about the fact it derived from a woman accused of committing DV.

Often the response I've had from people in RL is to just "be kind" as we don't know what she was going through that night.

Very few will even discuss if that was a male no one would be taking the same stance.

I'm very pro woman's rights. But I'm also very realistic we can't bring men down to raise up woman. We have to raise woman up to where men are in society and that means equal rights means equal expectations.

So I absolutely agree in principle with the statement "just be kind".

But I really don't like the way it's used by a large part of society to silence others opinions.

This, all day long.
SnoopyLights · 01/01/2022 08:48

I don't like the way "be kind" is being used now. As many posters have said, it's used now as a way to either bully and silence someone (almost always women and girls who are setting a boundary) or as a way for someone who has done wrong to claim victimhood or insist they not be held accountable for their own actions.

Someone on here shared this image a while ago, I think she had drawn it herself and at the time she said she was happy for it to be shared, so hopefully it's okay to share it again. It sums up exactly my feelings on the way "be kind" is used to silence people.

What is the problem with the phrase 'Be Kind?'
speakout · 01/01/2022 08:46

Doesn't do it for me.

I come from a family where women were expected to be nice, kindpolite, quiet, folllow the rules, don't make a fuss, donlt question men's authority.
Deep diving would call this his part of "The Mother Wound".
Done partly for protection this patriarcial wound lingers, women are still expevted to budge up and be kind - to men usually.

Being humane and fair is good, but "being kind" is too loaded and greasy a term for me.

MarshmallowFondant · 01/01/2022 08:44

Be kind is used to mean "don't say anything I disagree with". "Don't call me out on bad behaviour". If you do disagree with me, or call me out, that's bullying.

TheGoogleMum · 01/01/2022 08:41

I agreed with be kind when Caroline Flack died. Then I saw it being used to shut women up and heard how it is used on young girls clothing (but never boys). Once I realised 'be kind' is only expected of women I became a lot less keen on it.

crazyjinglist · 01/01/2022 08:39

Being kind is a wonderful thing. Telling people (usually women) to be kind is not. The best way to get people to be kind is to lead by example.

The modern instruction 'be kind' is, as other posters have said, almost always (empty and often hypocritical) virtue-signalling or a way to shut people down if you don't agree with them. It's not really even a useful instruction to give to children imo, as it's not specific enough.

hesbeen2021 · 01/01/2022 08:34

Its highly unlikely that if I'm behaving like a cunt and some stranger utters a stupid phrase it will change the way I behave
I'm highly unlikely to change the way I think, behave, feel because some faceless person tells me to
I hope I'm 'kind' when it's justified
I also hope I can be assertive and call out bad behaviour
Someone I know recently got married and banged on and on about 'being kind', when she gave her speech. She is one of the most self centred and selfish people I know

Turtles4543 · 01/01/2022 08:30

I think when my friend died it felt like it was saying if I’d just been kind she wouldn’t have killed herself. But I was kind, and that wasn’t enough.

Grumpyosaurus · 01/01/2022 08:28

'Be kind' all too often means 'shut up and be a doormat'.

I think I'm a fairly kind person - I'm helpful and friendly and so on - but I grew up with a father who wanted me to be a doormat so... Nah, not going to happen.

Helmetbymidnight · 01/01/2022 08:26

do you think nasty people hear 'be kind' and change their ways?
i dont.

Lipsandlashes · 01/01/2022 08:22

I’m kind most of the time but I won’t be silenced. I’ve also found that the biggest ‘be kind’ advocates on social media are those I know to be the biggest arseholes

2022willbebetter · 01/01/2022 08:22

It's hard to argue with the principle of being kind but it is a message mostly aimed at women to get them to be quiet and allow themselves to be walked all over, in that we should always allow others to take priority because that is the kind thing to do.

Be fair is better I guess in that it suggests some equivalence in the relationship, not that I should just do what you want me to.

I prefer be respectful of others. People may not agree with me and that's ok, but they don't have the right to trample on my boundaries or insist that I do things their way.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 01/01/2022 08:19

I hate the phrase TAKE CARE.

Even worse is “Stay safe everyone”. Translates as “Look how much I CARE” Hmm

BrightYellowDaffodil · 01/01/2022 08:18

I think the pandemic did foster a shift in attitudes and the Be Kind phrase was used a lot at this time when it hadn't really been mainstream before. Personally, seeing this in print around shops felt very empowering to me as a retail worker in that we mattered, too, and we were all human.

I’d have more empathy with this if it worked both ways. If there hadn’t been a retail worker in one of the few shops open who used to stand at the door and shout at people who dared use their own hand sanitiser, and police what people should and shouldn’t be buying (despite the fact that all stock was available for purchase), while standing next to a sign about “being kind to retail workers”.

Where was HER be kind, and HER understanding of what other people were going through?

Pretty much since it began, “be kind” has just been a platitude for bullies to hide behind.

Mammyofasuperbaby · 01/01/2022 08:16

The only people I see using "be kind" are the ones who are anything but kind.
Genuinely kind people don't advertise it, they just are. Those who use this phrase, as far as I've seen are, rude, self riotous (sp?), racist, angry, Sebastian and so far up their own backside they can see daylight.
Unsurprisingly many of these people I know are God fearing Christians. The irony

Bogeyes · 01/01/2022 08:07

I hate the phrase TAKE CARE.

Pottedpalm · 01/01/2022 08:03

I fund it childish. It’s the motto of nurseries and primary schools, such as the one Prince George and Princess Charlotte attend.

Lolalovesmarmite · 01/01/2022 07:22

I only know one person who uses this phrase. She says it to shut down criticism and try and silence perspectives that she doesn’t want to hear. It rarely seems to mean ‘be kind’, more just ‘be quiet’.

itsgettingweird · 01/01/2022 07:14

I also have issues around the fact that Caroline Flack, whose post it was, was awaiting trial for DV. I can't imagine people co -opting a male celebrities last post as inspiration if they were awaiting trial for DV charges. Though I do also accept the problem of online trolls needs actual action.

I've always said that I have an issue about the fact it derived from a woman accused of committing DV.

Often the response I've had from people in RL is to just "be kind" as we don't know what she was going through that night.

Very few will even discuss if that was a male no one would be taking the same stance.

I'm very pro woman's rights. But I'm also very realistic we can't bring men down to raise up woman. We have to raise woman up to where men are in society and that means equal rights means equal expectations.

So I absolutely agree in principle with the statement "just be kind".

But I really don't like the way it's used by a large part of society to silence others opinions.

Kudupoo · 01/01/2022 07:06

I don't think being kind is a very sustainable state. It's a giving emotion where you go the extra mile. It's very welcome and laudable and I think it's an important approach to consider when people test you or you see suffering.
I don't like that it's become 'kindness' to not be rude or abusive. Your NHS worker for example, it's not kindness to be appropriate to them, it's common decency. I think it's more important to be respectful to others. It's a fair and decent way of operating that doesn't coerce you to give more if yourself/prevent disagreement/lack boundaries. It's a sustainable baseline attitude to others that should really be a bare minimum.
If not trolling/abusing/bullying is "kindness' then it feels like something over and above bestowed on others as an almost gift. I don't want to live in that world.
I think being brave is often more important than being kind and we never tell girls that.

Youngstreet · 01/01/2022 05:27

I put 'be kind' in the same category as 'smile'
or cheer up.'
It's usually said by people who think they have a right to tell others how to behave. And they would never say it to a man.

HomeTheatreSystem · 01/01/2022 05:20

Agree! I know many very kind and compassionate people who've never used this phrase in their SM. The ones who do use it might have many positive qualities but kindness most definitely isn't one of them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread