Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to think that 'Single Ladies' is garbage?

169 replies

TheValeyard · 31/12/2021 21:17

Just watching some crap on TV, and a bunch of people are saying about how Beyonce's Single Ladies is all about female empowerment. This seems to be utter bollocks - the line 'put a ring on it' is one of the worst, most demeaning song lyrics ever, and referring to women/a woman as 'it' is the least of it's problems??

Sorry, but i f-ing HATE that song...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
KiloWhat · 02/01/2022 09:00

Put your hands UP

Uh uh oh oh

GladysTheOstrich · 02/01/2022 08:59

@Margotshypotheticaldog

I love The Monkees too. Despite being manufactured, they were real musicians and took the band in new (and weird) directions.

The false 'manufactured v real' dichotomy is brilliantly illustrated by the story of Motown. Berry Gordy wanted a production line, but a music one, so he wrote/got HDH to write tunes, got the Funk Brothers to play, and picked singers from obscurity. It was totally manufactured, but the best pop music ever made.

HikingforScenery · 01/01/2022 23:38

Love it!

Notbeforemycoffeeplease · 01/01/2022 22:17

Catchy back then when it came out but anyone claiming to be empowered by this song needs help. There’s nothing empowering about Beyoncé at all, most overrated singer going.

FestiveMelts · 01/01/2022 22:00

I have no feminist stance on it, just came on to agree it's a bloody AWFUL annoying boring song that gets me straight off any dance floor. It's cack.

TrainspottingWelsh · 01/01/2022 21:56

@GladysTheOstrich I don't think Girls aloud are awful in the way eg the spice girls are, but their songs aren't a patch on gossip or skunk anansie for bands with lead female singers, not just in terms of my personal taste but as a vessel for utilising the singers ability.
However my dc are 18 and 20, so I'm undoubtedly unfairly biased because I had to listen to Girls aloud far more than is healthy for anyone. I could probably still quote every lyric from memory Grin
Despite being a big fan, for the most part Amy winehouse music isn't my thing, but her voice was so enthralling I only really noticed I wasn't particularly keen on the style of music when I heard a cover. Whereas on the other end of the scale I didn't become a fan of slipknot because I was moved by the vocal talent. I suppose my taste splits into two groups, does it make me want to dance and sing or mosh, and if not does the talent blow me away so the latter doesn't matter.

I mainly like rock, grunge and metal, but also love some Blues, some dance music, and there's stuff like Motown I would never own or play but think are brilliant live or as a night out. My current Spotify mix list has everything from Nirvana, to Metallica, queen, the prodigy and the black eyed peas on.
My taste just happens to mean bands are generally less likely to be modern manufactured, rather than because I think it matters either way. And nobody would be more delighted than me if the charts were suddenly flooded with rock bands, manufactured or not.

doadeer · 01/01/2022 21:54

I hate how women are constantly referred to as girl.

A very different song but the lyrics to Let it Go from Frozen really jar me - if she was a male ruler it would be about embracing her strength or be the man you were born to be. Not about being a good girl Hmm

SpankyPankhurst · 01/01/2022 21:51

Nah, Adele and Taylor Swift have relatively weak voices.

"I Was Here" is a powerful song. I defy anyone not to be moved a little bit by the lyrics.
m.youtube.com/watch?v=i41qWJ6QjPI

debbrianna · 01/01/2022 21:34

The last Full on pop mudic Beyonce has done was I am Sasha fierce and it was 2008. Everything else after that has been completely different.

There is a category of people who love to question her talent becuase she sang single ladies, or caters to the top 40 hits. However, everything before after the album 4 has not been promoted commercially since 2010. But these groups are always happy for Adele and Taylor swift or another white male to be handed awards that we all know it should have gone to Beyoncé.

Margotshypotheticaldog · 01/01/2022 21:14

I don't see 'manufactured' versus 'real' - it doesn't make any difference to the quality of the musical aesthetic.
This is interesting and I haven't really considered modern manufactured music like this before. Personally I absolutely love the music of The Monkees, especially Micky Dolenz on vocals and they were a completely manufactured boy band. But I am extremely disparaging about modern pop, particularly the talent show stuff. So I'm kind of a hypocrite! I shall have to think on this more....

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 01/01/2022 20:56

Not just me then- I can't stand that song!

GladysTheOstrich · 01/01/2022 20:55

@TrainspottingWelsh

Interesting that you brought up Girls Aloud, they're a favourite subject of mine! I think you're drawing a false dichotomy between what is perceived as 'commercial' music and 'real' music, where no distinction exists.

Girls Aloud were a vehicle for a production/songwriting team: Xenomania. They were clearly manufactured, but the original songs (not the covers) were truly phenomenal. Biology, Call the Shots, No Good Advice, The Show: full of light and shade, interesting structures, sparkling production. They were truly the greatest British group of the 2000s, creatively and image-wise. I loved them, and I think they're underrated (although the critics also loved them).

My musical tastes are quite eclectic: The Smiths, Motown, The Specials, ESG, Beastie Boys, Blondie, Duran Duran, Desmond Dekker - you name it, I've got the album/best-of Grin I don't see 'manufactured' versus 'real' - it doesn't make any difference to the quality of the musical aesthetic.

SpankyPankhurst · 01/01/2022 20:55

I really liked Beyoncé in the film about Cadillac Records, where she played Etta James. Damn, can she act and sing.

I dislike her own music, though. But it's no worse than Lady Gaga's or Miley Chris's. It's just not been a brilliant last 20 years for pop music.

m.youtube.com/watch?v=jZVQD9piv7A&t=210s

TrainspottingWelsh · 01/01/2022 20:25

@GladysTheOstrich she does have a fantastic voice, but for me it's almost secondary to the shite she's wasting it on! Similar to how I perceive Adele, amazing talent but wasted on tedious wailing ballads.
Akin to trying to appreciate the talent of Skin or Beth Ditto if you had them as members of girls aloud. Sure they'd still have ability but you wouldn't see it in the same way as you can with their bands/music.

CoffeeWithCheese · 01/01/2022 17:42

It serves the function of really pissing DH off when he constantly loses his phone and it's on silent and our response is to start singing "if you liked it then you shoulda put a ring on it"

flashpaper · 01/01/2022 16:56

@Realityisreal

I don't dislike the song or Beyonce but hadn't previously listened to all of the lyrics, I did think it was supposed to be a bit of a feminist anthem but looking at the lyrics posted earlier in the thread I've changed my mind.

Don't treat me to the things of the world
I'm not that kind of girl
Your love is what I prefer, what I deserve
Here's a man that makes me then takes me
And delivers me to a destiny, to infinity and beyond
Pull me into your arms, say I'm the one you own
If you don't, you'll be alone
And like a ghost Ill be gone
All the single ladies, all the single ladies

These lyrics make it a song about giving 'him' yet another chance and so much for empowerment, she's saying she'll go back to him if he says he OWNS her.

Was reading through to see if anyone would say this. She's literally saying "if you put a ring on my finger I'll be back with you". How is this empowering???
rookiemere · 01/01/2022 15:39

Wasn't there a thing about Single Ladies that if you play it backwards it's about Satan and it's because she's big in the illuminati. Clearly tosh but the music does sound as if it's being played the wrong way.

KiloWhat · 01/01/2022 15:33

Put your hands UP

debbrianna · 01/01/2022 15:10

It is catchy. Stop being obtuse

feistymumma · 01/01/2022 14:47

@Kittykat93

It's a shit song. Don't think it's catchy at all. Beyonce is overrated..yeah I said it.
This! 💯
feistymumma · 01/01/2022 14:46

Complete garbage

SunshineOnKeith · 01/01/2022 14:40

You think she's misinterpreted the song.
I don't. Others don't. There's no one certain definition, despite you being so convinced there is

Fair enough. I personally think the context of the lyrics and the pointing to her finger when she says 'ring on it' implies pretty strongly that she's referencing her finger rather than referring to herself as 'it'. As do most others on this thread. And the OP has also acknowledged her comment about the lyric being the most offensive is inaccurate. It's good that some of us are happy to acknowledge our errors/misunderstandings/agree to disagree and move on

However, you're perfectly free to cling to your beliefs that the 'it' refers toBeyoncé herself, and thus that it's the most demeaning lyric ever to women - you've clearly given it a lot of thought and are perfectly entitled to your opinion Grin

I'm interested in the psychology of people who challenge arrogantly without fact checking easy things. I wonder if they do it in real life. Applies to you in this case, nothing personal.

Glad to be of service! Not entirely sure what you aimed to learn about my psychology by demanding an apology and 'shaming' me though for mishearing a word though? Doesn't seem the most constructive approach, but then you clearly know much more than I do Wink

EinsteinaGogo · 01/01/2022 14:23

[quote SunshineOnKeith]@EinsteinaGogo
Because I'd misheard them. That does happen you know. And as you've RTFT, you'll see I acknowledged that

Do you also think the OP owes us all a personal apology as She misunderstood the lyrics and thought the line 'put a ring on it' refers to a woman, when in fact it refers to the finger (pointed to in the dance for clarity)

She also seems to have misunderstood the female empowerment aspect of the song and claims it is the 'the worst, most demeaning song lyrics ever'
Or is it just my errors you're personally policing? [/quote]

You think she's misinterpreted the song.
I don't. Others don't. There's no one certain definition, despite you being so convinced there is.

I'm interested in the psychology of people who challenge arrogantly without fact checking easy things. I wonder if they do it in real life. Applies to you in this case, nothing personal.

SalveVagina · 01/01/2022 14:14

@KiloWhat Fair enough - I don't know anything about her private life.

I do know the song, though, and it's terrible.

Realityisreal · 01/01/2022 13:59

I don't dislike the song or Beyonce but hadn't previously listened to all of the lyrics, I did think it was supposed to be a bit of a feminist anthem but looking at the lyrics posted earlier in the thread I've changed my mind.

Don't treat me to the things of the world
I'm not that kind of girl
Your love is what I prefer, what I deserve
Here's a man that makes me then takes me
And delivers me to a destiny, to infinity and beyond
Pull me into your arms, say I'm the one you own
If you don't, you'll be alone
And like a ghost Ill be gone
All the single ladies, all the single ladies

These lyrics make it a song about giving 'him' yet another chance and so much for empowerment, she's saying she'll go back to him if he says he OWNS her.

Swipe left for the next trending thread