Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have we been cleverly fobbed off by Christian g.p g.p?

113 replies

Drinkwinewithme · 31/12/2021 20:29

Ran dd15 physical symptoms by G.p . She said bring in dd to have e.c.g and that she thought she could have p.o.ts syndrome.
ECG was fine, blood pressure low on standing but nothing to worry about..But she also said that we were to look up somatic. Is this the same then as hypochondria, if so why not just say! How do I cure the somatic ?

I asked if she had pots, should she have tilt test ? She said no as she was not passing out. So I'm confused. A.i.b.u being confused ?
Also above g.p's head, a framed Bible poster saying that those who believe in Jesus will see their health soar (like eagles wings). So belief will make her well? I'm sure there was some mention of once she has this diagnosis, she won't have to knock on medical doors (well what if she does need to consult, what is this about ?!) .

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ScreamingMeMe · 04/01/2022 23:27

A.i.b.u being confused ?

You and me both, dearheart.

PermanentlyDizzy · 04/01/2022 23:20

[quote RockinHorseShit]@PermanentlyDizzy

My experience was that everything was blamed on menopause, even before menopause p.

In fact I had other things going on making symptoms seem worse, sorting those out made everything much easier.

Low B12 is the one that affected me the most & it causes POTs, so makes existing pots worse. This article might be useful, I've found supplements & my B12 injections to be a godsend...

www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/317864

[/quote]
Same here - locum Neurologist told me two major blackouts, resulting in injuries and me being kept in after being taken to the AMU, were caused by the menopause - I was late 30s, had recently had a baby and only became peri at 50! He hadn’t even run any tests and I’d only been in there a couple of minutes. That was the one and only time my usually mild mannered dh lost his temper with a medical professional. He then managed to screw up arranging the tests he agreed to. I ended up giving up on Neurology at that point.

RockinHorseShit · 04/01/2022 10:08

@Drinkwinewithme

Does your DD suffer with anxiety?, I'm guessing she does given it's a POTS symptom... our flight or fight response is out of whack so we physically overreact to stress

If so & you're struggling to understand or get through & advocate for your GP, you can get help from MIND MH charity. I had to do this as one doctor refused to believe I was speaking for DD & saying what she wanted to say. A lovely lady from mind advocated for her a few times instead & it shut up the shit doctor who thought I was making it up & it was my words, not DDs

I'd also ask the school for assessment for exam concessions. It doesn't matter if they are doing okay in school or not, it's about meeting their full potential, so don't be fobbed off. They did that to us as DD was doing okay despite missing a lot of school etc, so at first they wouldn't believe she struggled & I had to argue that the school was meant to help DD to meet her full potential, so she needed assessment. The assessor who initially refused rang me to apologise, when she assessed DD, DD was found to be slow in processing slowly & needed significant extra exam time to have a hope of achieving what she was capable of & a quiet room away from the distraction of other kids. Being able to get the grades DD thought she should be able to get, did DDs confidence the world of good

RockinHorseShit · 04/01/2022 09:55

@PermanentlyDizzy

My experience was that everything was blamed on menopause, even before menopause p.

In fact I had other things going on making symptoms seem worse, sorting those out made everything much easier.

Low B12 is the one that affected me the most & it causes POTs, so makes existing pots worse. This article might be useful, I've found supplements & my B12 injections to be a godsend...

www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/317864

blubberyboo · 03/01/2022 00:24

And if she does bring up religious quotes don’t be afraid to strongly stress that you haven’t come for a religious opinion, you want a medical explanation in layman’s terms

blubberyboo · 03/01/2022 00:21

I understand what you are saying OP

You basically took your daughter for a medical opinion.
this poster implied to you that your GP has an opinion around using belief as a way to heal or have better health.
She then didn’t offer a diagnosis or treatment and sent you away to Google a word that led you to believe the GP thought it was a mind over matter issue.
Putting the two together it has made you think that she was encouraging you to use faith to make your daughter feel better. I don’t blame you for thinking this as many a person would have the same thoughts.

The GP should have explained the term to you and why she thought it was relevant to your daughter. It was very dismissive and unsatisfactory to leave you with more questions than answers. You should phone her for clarity and say you’ve googled it and don’t understand the relevance to your DD

PermanentlyDizzy · 02/01/2022 23:52

@Drinkwinewithme Professor Lesley Kavi, the chair of PoTS UK, has released a new article designed as guidance for GP’s to help them assess and diagnose PoTS.. I thought I’d post a link it here, as it might be useful to take it with you when you go back. It specifically mentions the possibility of low blood pressure/vasovagal syncope to happen as well as PoTS. It also explains how to the the active stand test properly, including lying down quietly for 5 minutes before starting the test.

ilssagain · 02/01/2022 21:50

@Drinkwinewithme

So are you able to see another GP for a second opinion?

Drinkwinewithme · 02/01/2022 20:54

Thank you so much to those who clearly wanted to help me understand and have taken the time to do so. I still feel that my daughter was fobbed off , and i am not articulate enough (as a few posters seem to pick up on (fsad) ) . I respect anyone's faith but still do not find it appropriate when trying to focus on medical discussion ; i want to believe that the g.p will be able to help manage symptoms and refer to specialists or at least invite back after a reasonable time to discuss medication, not highlighting religious quotes.

OP posts:
saraclara · 01/01/2022 13:05

@Funnylittlefloozie

The poster is a red herring. What is the difference between a poster on the wall and a turban on the GP's own head? If the poster had a quotation from the Buddha, or from the Dalai Lama, would you worry equally?

Whatever is up with your daughter, I hope you and she get some answers soon.

The difference is that the poster exhorts the patient to look to Jesus. A turban simply signifies the doctor's own faith.
Beautiful3 · 01/01/2022 12:50

She's told you her diagnosis. She cannot find a reason/cause for these symptoms. All Doctor's are allowed a faith. Her faith is not stopping her from performing her job.

Funnylittlefloozie · 01/01/2022 12:36

The poster is a red herring. What is the difference between a poster on the wall and a turban on the GP's own head? If the poster had a quotation from the Buddha, or from the Dalai Lama, would you worry equally?

Whatever is up with your daughter, I hope you and she get some answers soon.

PermanentlyDizzy · 01/01/2022 12:26

@RockinHorseShit, so sorry you have been through the wringer with it all too. I was diagnosed in my 40s. I was under neurology for well over a decade and told I had every thing from MS, to Lupus, to epilepsy, before they finally said ‘it’s probably CFS and Fibro, but we don’t do those’ and then left to fend for myself. Shock [anger]. My GP at the time told me it was anxiety and I just needed to go for a walk in the fresh air! Angry

When I went to the GP and suggested I may have PoTS, first response was ‘what’s that’ then ‘oh, well you couldn’t possibly have that, it’s extremely rare’. I insisted on a stand test, which they did very badly, but thankfully still showed I clearly met the criteria. They then agreed to do a private referral for me and I was diagnosed first via a properly executed active stand, then a TTT.

I’m now having fun with the menopause badly affecting my PoTS. Incidentally, I was also told I would be miraculously cured by the menopause, whereas my new specialist admitted they don’t know what will happen, because no studies have been done on menopausal women who have PoTS and the earliest diagnosed cases from the 90s are only just starting to go through the menopause now. They also said they are seeing a few cases like mine, where the PoTS goes haywire throughout perimenopause though.

My son was seen twice by Community Paeds in infant and junior school, but left with no clear diagnosis. At 13, despite multiple atraumatic dislocations, the paediatric Rheumatologist wouldn’t even diagnose JHS’, but thankfully other doctors in the same hospital disagreed and diagnosed HSD under the new criteria. He was referred to adult Rheumatology by his PoTS specialist when he turned 16 and they easily diagnosed hEDS based on the 2017 criteria. I haven’t bothered getting a diagnosis for myself, as I doubt it will benefit me treatment wise. If my younger dc’s hypermobility gets bad enough for a diagnosis they already have ds as a first degree relative, although my dm was diagnosed when ds was first assessed, but they were not interested in a clear family history. My PoTs specialist is nagging me to accept a Rheumatology referral, but it would be a historic diagnosis at this point, as my joints are now painful and stiff and I can’t face another battle if it isn’t going to benefit me treatment wise.

RockinHorseShit · 01/01/2022 11:58

@PermanentlyDizzy

We had similar issues. DD diagnosed with Joint Hypermobility by a paediatric Rheumatologist who didn't believe in hEDS, POTs or PA & was unprofessionally arsey when I took DD for a second opinion to see a Hypermobility specialist doctor. This Rheumatologist even accused me of munchausens by proxy for getting a second opinion... & full proper diagnosis & wrote to our GP saying so... GP showed me the letter & told me to complain

I had similar with my diagnosis too. I was incorrectly diagnosed with fibromyalgia & M.E. Asked for referrals after DDs good consultant said she could see I had hEDS & POTs too. Thankfully our GP is great & listens, but 3 different practice nurses did my active stand test wrong & didn't like my interfering & asking if that was right as I'd read differently. GP had to do it herself I the end & it showed POTs as did my TTT I. Hammersmith. I was in my 50s & had also spent my life being told I had friggin anxiety when I tried to get help

PermanentlyDizzy · 01/01/2022 11:19

@HoppingPavlova

-Sadly, the vast majority of PoTS patients, especially teenage girls are told it’s either anxiety, mh issues or somatic before eventually getting their diagnosis. Things are improving, but it’s taking a long time for PoTS to be properly recognised understood by many doctors and shockingly, there are still those that don’t even believe it exists and will jump to the aforementioned assumptions rather than making appropriate referrals.

I don’t believe it’s because most HCPs don’t believe it exists but rather they recognise that orthostatic issues are common and transitory in teenage girls and that for most it will resolve as they progress out of teenage years. If every teenage girl who exhibited symptoms was in referred it would be chaos.

I say this as a mother to a daughter who was diagnosed as a teenager (via tertiary paed cardiac/neurology services, and who also has ED and a shedload of other medical issues) and as a HCP.

@HoppingPavlova I didn’t say ‘most HCPs don’t believe it exists’. I said it’s taking a long time to be recognised and understood and that there are those who still don’t believe it exists. I know of plenty of cases where this is what people have been told, myself included, even after both my son and I were both diagnosed. PoTS UK are doing an outstanding job of raising awareness, but it’s taking a long time for the information to be absorbed, passed on and used effectively.

Things are definitely much better than they used to be. I spent most of my life not having a clue what was wrong with me - 30 years of being fobbed off, told it was all in my head, that I would grow out of it etc, whilst being too sick to work or participate properly in life.

Of course there’s is no need for every teen that exhibits symptoms to be referred, as GPs and General/Comm Paeds should know enough to perform an active stand test properly and refer if the patient meets the baseline criteria. Sadly so many either don’t know or don’t bother. Even with me being diagnosed and a clear family history of other comorbid conditions gen paeds, told us my ds didn’t have PoTS and if he did, his bp would drop on standing. They hadn’t even heard of an active stand test. Thankfully a Cardiology referral had already been made via another specialist, but even then he was bumped twice within Cardiology until they found someone who had any knowledge of PoTS and this is at a well known and respected children’s hospital. At the multi-GP practice we attend, there is not one GP who understands PoTS and after almost a decade, they still refuse to prescribe ds and my medication. Every appointment starts with the GP stating ‘I don’t know anything about PoTS’.

Similar situation with EDS, where we were told straight by the Paeds Rheumatologist my son was referred to, that, ‘I do not believe hEDS exists’. So he didn’t get diagnosed until he moved to adult care, at which point the Rheumatologist was aghast that he’d been refused a diagnosis, as he clearly met the criteria and is badly affected with lots of medical issues relating to it.

CovidCorvid · 01/01/2022 08:14

Dd has EDS and POTS. Her POTS was diagnosed by a consultant rheumatologist without a tilt table test. Iirc she is supposed to be on a waiting list for one (not sure why as she had a diagnosis already) but that was two years ago and she’s not had one. Though possibly he just talked about the tilt table test and decided against it. No idea, Dd had just turned 18yo so had to go by herself into the appt due to covid so I’ve only ever had a garbled half account of it all.

JustUseTheDoorSanta · 01/01/2022 08:06

I can't understand what's happened. @Drinkwinewithme can you write down exactly what the doctor actually said? If you can't remember and are worried then best to go to another GP for a second opinion.

noworklifebalance · 01/01/2022 08:00

I don’t understand much of OP’s post but I don’t think the poster should be there. I am atheist and wouldn’t have understood the meaning of that poster especially if I saw it in the context of 5-10min consultation. All I would been able to take from that is that it’s a religious quote and this should not be in a doctor’s office/medical practice unless in specially designated areas such as a hospital chapel.
The meaning or sentiment of the quote can be expressed with other non-religious messages.

HoppingPavlova · 01/01/2022 06:19

-Sadly, the vast majority of PoTS patients, especially teenage girls are told it’s either anxiety, mh issues or somatic before eventually getting their diagnosis. Things are improving, but it’s taking a long time for PoTS to be properly recognised understood by many doctors and shockingly, there are still those that don’t even believe it exists and will jump to the aforementioned assumptions rather than making appropriate referrals.

I don’t believe it’s because most HCPs don’t believe it exists but rather they recognise that orthostatic issues are common and transitory in teenage girls and that for most it will resolve as they progress out of teenage years. If every teenage girl who exhibited symptoms was in referred it would be chaos.

I say this as a mother to a daughter who was diagnosed as a teenager (via tertiary paed cardiac/neurology services, and who also has ED and a shedload of other medical issues) and as a HCP.

Meowwwwwww · 01/01/2022 05:37

@Viviennemary

Your post is very confusing. Never heard of pots.
If you haven’t heard of it why would that be relevant to the OP’s question? I suspect OP was looking for responses from people who can relate or share some advice or info, not checking to see if you Viviennemary have personally heard of a well-known health condition. Are you also one of those people who answers questions about Amazon products by saying “I don’t know, I haven’t opened it yet”?

www.nhs.uk/conditions/postural-tachycardia-syndrome/

I googled it for you so now you’ve heard of it.

www.nhs.uk/conditions/postural-tachycardia-syndrome/

Hydrate · 01/01/2022 04:46

I know if I were not confident in the doctor's diagnosis I'd get a second opinion.

whitewashing · 01/01/2022 04:41

….then you say ‘what does somatic mean doctor?’ before you leave the surgery instead of asking a bunch of people on MN who are more interested on a picture in the surgery.

Zotter · 01/01/2022 04:06

Ps I agree with push for a referral to a specialist in dysautonomia.

Zotter · 01/01/2022 04:05

Look at NASA 10 Minute Lean Test

“Orthostatic intolerance (OI) is an umbrella term used to describe abnormal autonomic nervous system response to orthostatic challenge. Orthostatic hypotension (OH), neurally mediated hypotension (NMH) [or neurogenic hypotension] and postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (PoTS) are terms used to describe variants of this response”

batemanhornecenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/NASA-Lean-Test-Instructions-1.pdf

Mummyoflittledragon · 01/01/2022 03:55

POTS is not well understood in the medical profession. And your GP was wrong. My dd has a medical condition and saw a paediatric cardiologist privately, who specialises in this and POTS. He did the standing tilt test at the same time as the consultation. If you can afford this, I would recommend you do so. You could probably get the answer for a one off consultation fee.

Swipe left for the next trending thread