Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For the Economy...

41 replies

Christmascardsontheshelf · 31/12/2021 18:53

I was just reading the second hand clothes thread and I came across a comment that comes up on mumsnet quite a bit:

The economy would come crashing down around us if we all started swapping and using only second hand.

I have seen and heard this argument loads.
Second hand is probably the only way we will get ourselves out of this mess. It really is. There is enough in the world for us all to live comfortably without making a single new thing again. I genuinely believe this. Should we carry on producing for the sake of the economy?

On a similar note, garden growing food, orchards and the like. If we all started growing a little and swapping with neighbours we would eliminate the need to mass farm food and fix the world essentially.

It has been proven that communities who grow together have decreased crime rates, which is a staggering thought when you think about it.

With so many people using food banks, receiving benefits and having to deal with increased food and energy bills, surely everyone should be moving to second hand and by extension, local home grown. (not saying poor people should buy second hand or grow their own food. I'm saying it seems to be the logical next step)

And if the economy does crash, well we will all be paying less for goods as the second hand market is cheaper than new, and our health would improve fixing the NHS and everyone could buy fruit and veg from their neighbours. Make jams and preserves, stuff like that. I just don't see how it hasn't happened yet. Is it because the rich can't get richer if the poor fend for themselves?

This is just idle thinking. Please don't scream at me via capslock. Thank you.

OP posts:
VladmirsPoutine · 31/12/2021 19:12

One of the main barriers you'd have to contend with whether or not your idea is good - is the extent to which people are wedded to capitalism. To shift the mentality of society wouldn't happen over night if ever at all. To put it another way a man the state broadcaster illustrated as superman during the pandemic is a literal billionaire who then stripped a £20 benefit uplift with next to zero consequence.

glimpsing · 31/12/2021 19:11

Well, we sort of have it. Except when we can't swap like for like we have this stuff called money which we can exchange for something else. And we don't just exchange with friends and neighbours but the whole world...Wait this is capitalism!Grin

For things to be different we would have to be happy giving stuff away without expecting anything in return and sharing stuff.

SofiaMichElf · 31/12/2021 19:07

If everyone swaps their products for other products and services, there'll be far less tax income.

Who's paying for public services then?

The NHS wouldn't be "fixed", it would be even more fucked.

Christmascardsontheshelf · 31/12/2021 19:06

lol @ilovesooty I was hoping thatd come up, I spent years in a high-rise and grew a fair amount. The problem really was the cost of compost. Gardens tend to come with free soil.

Also allotments are a serious game. They have become so popular since the start of the covid era.

But what about Facebook market place, shpock and vinted, depop, eBay, karot... there are loads of second hand sites. not to mention charity shops.

There is also a second hand children's clothes website which is presented really well, the clothes are photographed like a real website for clothes and it has good filters, delivers. its just as easy as second hand shopping and if you send them your old clothes you get a voucher to spend there. Its great. Too expensive for me, I prefer 50p charity shop bins but I have time to rummage. and lots of options for charity shops.

I don't know what I'm asking but I feel like the only people who would lose out on this arrangement are big hot shot millionaires.

We would need less truckers and packers and stuff, more local delivery people (bikes like the deliveroo) and sorters and collectors and growers and mowers and blowers and flowers
just don't get it.
lots of people buy online. it should be easy to move it online.

OP posts:
ArblemarzipanTFruitcake · 31/12/2021 19:05

I live in poor area I could run into a charity shop naked and still not find anything I’d want to wear.

Independent charity shops (such as hospices) in affluent areas tend to have the higher-end clothes.

Charity shops aren't the only option, though - eBay, Vinted or even Vestaire Collective if you want designer gear.

CurtainTroubles · 31/12/2021 19:04

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

EmpressCixi · 31/12/2021 19:03

You are describing a sort of pastoral utopia. Many have tried, all have failed. Yes crimes rates were lower, but that was more than offset by the people starving to death. Do you have any idea how hard and expensive it is to grow all your own food? Or how precarious an existence that is? One bad storm, one pest infestation, and your harvest is gone and you starve to death. Women would have to feed the first child that died to her other children just to survive.

And this
“And if the economy does crash, well we will all be paying less for goods as the second hand market is cheaper than new, and our health would improve fixing the NHS and everyone could buy fruit and veg from their neighbours.”

No, When economies “crash” hyper inflation happens to consumer goods as the currency crashes into worthlessness. Look at Turkey where the lira is crashing (again). Price of a loaf of bread up 1000%? Second hand actually becomes worth more when new is not available, and can even exceed what the new price would have been if it were being made when you reach shortage of supply vs demand. We saw this happen here just this year with the chip shortage meaning very few new cars of some models, and so the second hand market for these cars skyrocketed to prices above the usual, expected new price.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 31/12/2021 19:02

@ilovesooty

It all sounds lovely in principle. I doubt if someone chronically ill, working two jobs on a zero hour contract, or living on the 12th floor of a tower block is going to be growing stuff and swapping jam with their neighbours though. Real life for the people living in deprived urban areas isn't like an episode of The Good Life.
^^This
Akire · 31/12/2021 19:02

I really don’t get second hand thing though, I live in poor area I could run into a charity shop naked and still not find anything I’d want to wear. I’m no fashion expert usually leggings/jeans and plain tops. Charity shops rarely sale anything that’s not been really fashionable for 5min and then looks awful. Or a cocktail dress from 1985 or skinned tight flared purple jeans in size 6.

I’m amazed anyone can manage buy only second hand they just live in areas that are very well off. Plus if nobody buys anything new then there’s nothing second hand to buy!

I buy new but wear it to death for years and years then use as rags. Think that’s just as good as buying second hand. We can’t stop buying new all together.

SheldonesqueTheBstard · 31/12/2021 19:02

It does sound wonderful.

I am on the go 18 odd hours most days with work and care duties and I don’t know when I would ever find time to contribute to society.

I’m not sure how it would work for my reality.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 31/12/2021 19:01

So... what is my 3 year old son supposed to wear on his (wide) feet when every few months he goes up a size? How many times should the not-new shoes have been worn before they get to him?

Secondhand is fine, but for some things third, fourth and so on isn't. I would rather be the one putting items in the top of the funnel sometimes.

ilovesooty · 31/12/2021 18:57

It all sounds lovely in principle. I doubt if someone chronically ill, working two jobs on a zero hour contract, or living on the 12th floor of a tower block is going to be growing stuff and swapping jam with their neighbours though. Real life for the people living in deprived urban areas isn't like an episode of The Good Life.

Xogozil · 31/12/2021 18:56

Well said.

Christmascardsontheshelf · 31/12/2021 18:56

PS proof is in the TED Talk on Todmorden

OP posts:
Christmascardsontheshelf · 31/12/2021 18:55

ShhhhGrin

OP posts:
AnneLovesGilbert · 31/12/2021 18:54

IT’S A LOVELY IDEA Wink

Swipe left for the next trending thread