Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For the Economy...

41 replies

Christmascardsontheshelf · 31/12/2021 18:53

I was just reading the second hand clothes thread and I came across a comment that comes up on mumsnet quite a bit:

The economy would come crashing down around us if we all started swapping and using only second hand.

I have seen and heard this argument loads.
Second hand is probably the only way we will get ourselves out of this mess. It really is. There is enough in the world for us all to live comfortably without making a single new thing again. I genuinely believe this. Should we carry on producing for the sake of the economy?

On a similar note, garden growing food, orchards and the like. If we all started growing a little and swapping with neighbours we would eliminate the need to mass farm food and fix the world essentially.

It has been proven that communities who grow together have decreased crime rates, which is a staggering thought when you think about it.

With so many people using food banks, receiving benefits and having to deal with increased food and energy bills, surely everyone should be moving to second hand and by extension, local home grown. (not saying poor people should buy second hand or grow their own food. I'm saying it seems to be the logical next step)

And if the economy does crash, well we will all be paying less for goods as the second hand market is cheaper than new, and our health would improve fixing the NHS and everyone could buy fruit and veg from their neighbours. Make jams and preserves, stuff like that. I just don't see how it hasn't happened yet. Is it because the rich can't get richer if the poor fend for themselves?

This is just idle thinking. Please don't scream at me via capslock. Thank you.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Newyearnewme2022 · 31/12/2021 21:48

I’m now thinking about the tiny terraced house where I grew up in Croydon, gardens contained large barking dogs, screaming kids, mattresses or dismantled motorbikes, not a hope in hell of living ‘the good life’ there.

Newyearnewme2022 · 31/12/2021 21:42

I’m sorry op but I can’t see a busy single mother working full time but still hard up spending £10 out on compost to grow lettuces on her 9th floor flat windowsill that her kids will probably turn their noses up at anyway.

RudeAF · 31/12/2021 21:05

Give Prince Andrew something to do I suppose Grin

girlmom21 · 31/12/2021 20:51

@Christmascardsontheshelf

Who's saying a nurse has to hoe a field? a nurse is a nurse. I'm on about fucking off billionaires and millionaires.

Being deliberately obtuse isn't going to work is it

So do the billionaires hoe the fields?
toconclude · 31/12/2021 20:40

@Christmascardsontheshelf

Who's saying a nurse has to hoe a field? a nurse is a nurse. I'm on about fucking off billionaires and millionaires.

Being deliberately obtuse isn't going to work is it

Yet you are being thoroughly obtuse and failing to take into account the reality of people's lives. When the majority of the population lived by subsistence agriculture they had pretty shitty lives. Learn some history then come back to us with a bit less attitude.
anon12345678901 · 31/12/2021 20:31

I'm not sure your math is correct on small companies would pay more tax than companies who use legal loopholes to avoid it. Amazon paid £492m in tax for 2020, I don't think the local garden shop is ever going to do that in a year.

FindingMeno · 31/12/2021 20:22

I agree that we should all be as self reliant as possible and regain as much power over our own lives as we possibly can.

Akire · 31/12/2021 20:17

You do realise that if clothes shops shut tomorrow there would be no second hand clothes market? While I do think if you see something amazing second hand you should of course use it, please don’t do the smug well I can but all second hand thing because you can only do that IF SOMEONE ESE HAS ALREADY BOUGHT IT.

Dontgetyerknicksinatwist · 31/12/2021 20:16

Oh and I don’t have a garden to grow vegetables in. I’m sure lots of the wealthy yummy mummies in my town have plenty of garden space though (along with the time which I don’t have).

Dontgetyerknicksinatwist · 31/12/2021 20:15

@ilovesooty

It all sounds lovely in principle. I doubt if someone chronically ill, working two jobs on a zero hour contract, or living on the 12th floor of a tower block is going to be growing stuff and swapping jam with their neighbours though. Real life for the people living in deprived urban areas isn't like an episode of The Good Life.
Or have the time to go scouring through the charity shops. Some of us have to work full time as well as run the family home 🙄
Woeismethischristmas · 31/12/2021 20:12

I make jam with vast quantities of free fruit from olio. Participate in the local organic community growing group and the community orchard. I have a herb garden and grow food at home, chickens for eggs etc. Tbh it takes loads of time and except in summer/ autumn doesn’t contribute masses of food to the table. It’s nice but I think it only works in fairly well to do rural communities. No idea how it’d work in an urban area.

I’m always happy to pass around / accept bags of 2nd hand clothes but like a pp children’s shoes should be properly fitted.

DoctorTwo · 31/12/2021 19:52

It won't work mid or long term for our economy, which has been set up as consumer led. But it does work for ecological reasons, which is better long term for our descendants. Good luck selling it to the arseholes who'd rather have the short term riches over a planet that is sustainable.

Xmasiscancelledagain · 31/12/2021 19:33

@ilovesooty

It all sounds lovely in principle. I doubt if someone chronically ill, working two jobs on a zero hour contract, or living on the 12th floor of a tower block is going to be growing stuff and swapping jam with their neighbours though. Real life for the people living in deprived urban areas isn't like an episode of The Good Life.
Quite.

It's easy to say all of this when your only career prospects aren't a zero hours contract in the service industry.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 31/12/2021 19:30

Ahh taxes. beautiful taxes.
yes I didn't think about that but I mean, not everyone can pay taxes and not everyone wants to. Jimmy carr and amazon, I'm looking at you! A small garden shop is going to pay more tax than a massive company who moves their money and exploits loopholes to pay no or little tax

No it doesn't. I'm pretty sure the income tax and national insurance contributions from the wages of everyone who works for Tesco adds up.

Shoes are terrible quality. I could afford to buy myself a good pair of clarkes shoes after I moved to second hand. And they lasted years. Never needed replacing. I just didn't know before.

Well, then you still need Clarks to be making shoes. And Grenson, Solovair, and Start-Rite. You cannot just stop manufacturing something like shoes which will eventually disintegrate.

XenoBitch · 31/12/2021 19:30

I do grow stuff, but it still works out a ton cheaper to buy from a shop. I tend to only grow things that are hard to find in shops anyway.

Christmascardsontheshelf · 31/12/2021 19:28

Who's saying a nurse has to hoe a field?
a nurse is a nurse.
I'm on about fucking off billionaires and millionaires.

Being deliberately obtuse isn't going to work is it

OP posts:
Lolamento · 31/12/2021 19:27

When I was in high school many girls left with hippies to live like this. Actually, they became slaves in these places had many kids and regret their choices. So yes it has been tried many times before so you are either too young or not sure what to say.

Christmascardsontheshelf · 31/12/2021 19:26

@user1497207191 I agree with reuse reuse reuse

OP posts:
Christmascardsontheshelf · 31/12/2021 19:25

@Maverickess

I do generally shop second hand because I can get stuff that lasts longer for a similar or cheaper price (or free when stuff is being given away) but I just don't have the time required for growing things that need time to tend and learning how to manage these things while I'm meeting the financial demands I have so therefore working a lot. I do have space and could learn, but I don't have a great deal of understanding or time to develop that (apparently I'm a whizz at growing weeds though!) I haven't always had the space though.

And the 'economy' isn't really a faceless object, if we stop producing things then there's the people reliant on that income - what do they do? How do they earn enough to live on, because even buying second hand and growing your own food requires money to support it and to start it off.
And that's before you get to the people who have deep interests in continuing to make sure we buy things and increase what we buy and spend. They have a lot of influence over policies and how things happen because they have a lot of power and the more money they make, the more power they acquire. Money and power are everything to many people, they're not going to give that up willingly, but really it's those who need to start the change and it will cascade down through society, I can't see it rippling upwards if I start growing my own potatoes and stop buying them from the supermarket.

I don't know, I think it is rippling upwards. The pandemic literally caused people to drop their city flats and move to the countryside. its innate.

Ahh taxes. beautiful taxes.
yes I didn't think about that but I mean, not everyone can pay taxes and not everyone wants to. Jimmy carr and amazon, I'm looking at you!

A small garden shop is going to pay more tax than a massive company who moves their money and exploits loopholes to pay no or little tax.

A pumpkin grows itself, you plant it and it grows, water 💧 potatoes, same. Beans, same
easy peasy. garlic, fuck I don't think we have ever watered garlic.
Herbs and lettuce can be grown in small pots on windowsills. we all got a pot for Xmas (roses or quality street)
its so easy I really think we have been brainwashed into accepting a broken world so the rich can stay rich.

I was watching don't look up last night can you tell?

PS I am aware that I'm on a phone made by a rich rich rich. but you know, its not all or nothing, it never has to be all or nothing.

Shoes are terrible quality. I could afford to buy myself a good pair of clarkes shoes after I moved to second hand. And they lasted years. Never needed replacing. I just didn't know before.

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 31/12/2021 19:23

@Akire

I really don’t get second hand thing though, I live in poor area I could run into a charity shop naked and still not find anything I’d want to wear. I’m no fashion expert usually leggings/jeans and plain tops. Charity shops rarely sale anything that’s not been really fashionable for 5min and then looks awful. Or a cocktail dress from 1985 or skinned tight flared purple jeans in size 6.

I’m amazed anyone can manage buy only second hand they just live in areas that are very well off. Plus if nobody buys anything new then there’s nothing second hand to buy!

I buy new but wear it to death for years and years then use as rags. Think that’s just as good as buying second hand. We can’t stop buying new all together.

If more people donated to charity shops rather than threw things away, there'd be more choice for others to buy.

And, it's not just charity shops. There are also dress agencies which usually have a much better range/choice of clothes.

Then there's also ebay. We've bought and sold loads of clothes on ebay second hand. I've sold a leather jacket, numerous dresses, a coat, and various tops/trousers, and bought lots of similar items. I've also bought lots of things for hubby to wear (work shirts & trousers, jeans, etc). Then there's local facebook groups, etc.

Charity shops really aren't the only option.

Personally I think the "recycle" craze is wrong. We should be concentrating on reducing and reusing what we have rather then virtue signalling by recycling, much of which ends up in landfill anyway. The 3 "R" message needs to become the 1 "R" - i.e. reuse!

EmpressCixi · 31/12/2021 19:20

Why are you all poopooing utopia?

Because it was the fantasy of an opium addict and has led to millions of dead as various idiots try and implement what is literally an (opium) pipe dream.

EmpressCixi · 31/12/2021 19:18

There are also many essential professions you cannot do while growing all your own food. If you’re a nurse or doctor...you don’t have the time to be hoeing and weeding your fields. The NHS would collapse due to no one being available to be a doctor or nurse. And who would be the delivery person for post or all this second stuff you’re ordering online? No can do the 150 deliveries a day and grow their own food, make jam, and boil chicken bones for stock.

Sorry but your idea is crap. It’s been tried. Look up history of attempts at self-sufficient communes. They all failed. They all also fell back into oppression of women too, so this would fuck equal rights for women.

girlmom21 · 31/12/2021 19:14

@ArblemarzipanTFruitcake

I live in poor area I could run into a charity shop naked and still not find anything I’d want to wear.

Independent charity shops (such as hospices) in affluent areas tend to have the higher-end clothes.

Charity shops aren't the only option, though - eBay, Vinted or even Vestaire Collective if you want designer gear.

It's not just about high end. It's about nice looking, good quality, efficient and affordable clothing.
Christmascardsontheshelf · 31/12/2021 19:14

Why are you all poopooing utopia? It doesn't have to be all or nothing, but we definitely don't need the likes of primark or h and m who use basically slave labour to give us cheap shit. then they have their 'we are good for the earth' greenwashing campaigns and its just shit.

You can grow lettuce on a windowsill in a pot. I grew enough on my windowsills to feed a family of 5 salad for almost the whole year. The cost? maybe 5-10 pounds. on seeds and compost.

And look on YouTube about the people who have allotments or grow stuff in their backyards. So many people trying to share how they grow 200 courgettes and 15 pumpkins etc.

Thats another thing, pumpkins are delicious, store well (whole) and can be eaten all throughout winter but nobody knows this. I wonder why. how does that knowledge die out?
you have to grow things suited to your climate but inside on a windowsill is fine too.

OP posts:
Maverickess · 31/12/2021 19:13

I do generally shop second hand because I can get stuff that lasts longer for a similar or cheaper price (or free when stuff is being given away) but I just don't have the time required for growing things that need time to tend and learning how to manage these things while I'm meeting the financial demands I have so therefore working a lot.
I do have space and could learn, but I don't have a great deal of understanding or time to develop that (apparently I'm a whizz at growing weeds though!) I haven't always had the space though.

And the 'economy' isn't really a faceless object, if we stop producing things then there's the people reliant on that income - what do they do? How do they earn enough to live on, because even buying second hand and growing your own food requires money to support it and to start it off.
And that's before you get to the people who have deep interests in continuing to make sure we buy things and increase what we buy and spend. They have a lot of influence over policies and how things happen because they have a lot of power and the more money they make, the more power they acquire. Money and power are everything to many people, they're not going to give that up willingly, but really it's those who need to start the change and it will cascade down through society, I can't see it rippling upwards if I start growing my own potatoes and stop buying them from the supermarket.