Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to start my own 'working class Mumsnet'?

433 replies

shoplifteroftheworld · 31/12/2021 18:45

I see so many topics and conversations on here that just don't relate to my own life and experiences. Lots of well off women talking about their recent purchases from Boden or Uniqlo or some other place I can't afford to shop. Chat about dinner parties and holidays abroad. I'd like a site for mums and women on lower incomes as this site can leave a lot of us feeling left out of certain conversations.

OP posts:
onlychildhamster · 01/01/2022 01:49

@Starcup well you own assets other than your primary residence so I think that while you identify as working class which you definitely can do, you aren't disadvantaged by being working class! If you have assets you can sell easily if you are in a tight spot, if you have spare money to invest, then by 21st century standards, you aren't part of the precariat. The precariat live hand to mouth, they usually rent (but some do own), they have no inheritance or help from family, the only thing they have at their disposal is their labour. Hence the term 'working class'.

Starcup · 01/01/2022 01:44

And to add, literally never heard if the shops OP mentioned. That makes me the epitome of working class 😂 love it

onlychildhamster · 01/01/2022 01:44

@Starcup It would be different in America which is solely based on income/job but yes you are born into it in the UK. Its why there is the American Dream- a conviction that no matter who you are or where you come from, anyone can achieve their dreams and own a nice house with a picket fence and their children would have better lives. There is no British dream. People define themselves by whether they grew up on a council estate or their postcode, whether they listen to classical music, whether they went to university.

But increasingly even in America, income doesn't solely define someone's situation in life. This is because the value of assets have far outstripped someone's earning capability. A bin man with an inheritance is in a far better position to buy property in London or New York or San Francisco than a junior doctor. Someone who inherits a london house and didn't need to pay for care can inherit up to a £1 million tax free. How long would it take for an average doctor to save up £1 million? This is why BAME communities in the UK/USA are poorer as they have lower home ownership rates than white british people and so they are on unequal footing to start with.

This is why the divide is no longer working class vs middle class; the divide is those with assets and those without. There are some very well paid jobs (generally in London) which enables people to buy assets using earned income i.e. investment banker, magic circle lawyer but a person is rich primarily through ownership of assets. While most millionaires do not inherit their wealth, they are usually from families which give them a safety net. Johnnie Boden for example faced difficulties with his business early on, but his wife Sophie and her family supported him while the credit cards were bouncing all over the place.

Starcup · 01/01/2022 01:43

First time I’ve wrote 2022 I mean lol

Starcup · 01/01/2022 01:42

@onlychildhamster

So basically I’m working class and my kids are middle class? My parents were very much working class and couldn’t help me at all financially, but I’ve been to uni, my husband is what would be considered a middle class professional, own a detached house in the leafy suburbs, own a separate property outright that we rent out, car each, savings etc…

I absolutely consider myself working class, always have always will, as does my husband, as we both came from impoverished backgrounds, so it’s interesting to see the ‘definition’ in 2022. First time I’ve wrote the year.

saleorbouy · 01/01/2022 01:35

My OH shopped at Boden for our DC, we're not rich. It worked out cheaper than getting clothes on the high street as the quality was such that my DC could wear them and then they could be sold on for over 50% of the original price when they grew out of them.
Most high street clothes were in poor condition after a few months and gas jobs resale value.

Starcup · 01/01/2022 01:33

born

Starcup · 01/01/2022 01:33

So basically you’re both in to it and a job or career doesn’t define someone. Not entirely sure I agree with that concept.

What if the bin mans parents lost their fortune and were penniless? That complicates that scenario 😂

onlychildhamster · 01/01/2022 01:06

@Starcup there are many definitions: www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2021/may/23/readers-reply-what-do-the-terms-working-class-and-middle-class-actually-mean

But I agree the most with the below definition

'The defining characteristic of being middle class is the presence of a safety net. You can be a middle-class bin man or van driver if you have friends or family who can help you out when things go wrong or you can be a working-class doctor or lawyer if you have no one behind you to catch you when you fall. The upper class live above a permanent safety net. Losing a job or a failed business makes no difference to your life outcome. The trust fund sees to that.'

So its not about your job, its about your safety net. There was a time after university when I earned nothing, had nothing. But I have rich parents so even if tomorrow I earned £0, I wouldn't be working class. I do think that at a certain point, high earnings does ensure a safety net by default; its very hard to imagine someone with a £100k base and a £60k bonus would be out on the streets if he got retrenched even if he was feckless (and society would have very little sympathy for him if he was).

I have a friend who was earning below minimum wage as a paralegal in London but he is now a solicitor and his parents helped him buy a house in London. at no point have I ever considered him poor or working class or in need of money; before his parents bought him a house, he lived with them and paid no rent, wanted for nothing. This would not be an option for a working class kid; they may have no space for an adult child or no inclination to support him/her.

onlychildhamster · 01/01/2022 00:55

@ruthydoodles24f Nothing. Uniqlo is meant to be an affordable brand in Japan btw! I think they are better quality in Asia, I don't know why but all the stuff I bought in uk were crap, but the stuff I bought in my home country were cheaper and lasted longer.

ruthydoodles24f · 01/01/2022 00:46

We don't have a Waitrose Boden or John Lewis or Uniqlo or whatever it's called here ?

What does that say about my city I wonder

Starcup · 01/01/2022 00:41

What jobs do people on here define as working class?…..

ohfook · 01/01/2022 00:40

Hello I earn £24k a year, buy second hand, tend to holiday in caravan parks in the U.K., don't have dinner parties and do like to go out to clubs and stuff still. Id be interested if you started a thread for us like minded folk!

saraclara · 01/01/2022 00:39

@saraclara

I must admit I'm not getting the sexism thing though. It's women that come out with this tripe to each other, in my experience. I've never heard a man say 'be kind' or stick kindness memes all over their FB page.
AAArgh!!! Wrong thread Blush
saraclara · 01/01/2022 00:38

I must admit I'm not getting the sexism thing though. It's women that come out with this tripe to each other, in my experience. I've never heard a man say 'be kind' or stick kindness memes all over their FB page.

Starcup · 01/01/2022 00:38

Well I’ve never heard of the places you’ve described…. Wtf doesn’t that make me?! 🤣

What’s the definition of middle class here these days?…

RussianSpy101 · 01/01/2022 00:30

Laughing at the thought that people doing physical work earn “little money”

Many qualified tradesmen earn at least double what nurses, teachers and other university qualified professionals do.
My DHs company has allowed us to send our DD to private school. He’s from a council estate in a northern city and his parents have never worked. He is working class but he doesn’t fit the description posted up thread.

My parents were both born on council estates in Liverpool. My father was a paramedic for 30+ years as my mother was a senior finance manager for local government.
So sad to think people are judged for the rest of their lives based on where they’re born or what class 🙄 they’re born in to.

massiveblob · 01/01/2022 00:29

I echo other pp. in some ways the posts from others give me an interesting insight into worlds that I just can't access eg Eton or an other
But state schools are overall deemed as second choice by most. But other topics I also find massively skewed. Massive distrust of men round children.. maybe I should lurk on other boards 😂

onlychildhamster · 01/01/2022 00:25

*gap year

onlychildhamster · 01/01/2022 00:25

@Mummy1232016 my DH's colleague, a VP in an investment bank says he is working class cos he likes greggs; also owns a 4 bed house in Chelmsford that he bought on 1 salary. I once had a colleague who was taken on so many ski holidays as a child that she worked as a ski guide on her gap who said she was working class because she is from birmingham.

working class is an identity, not someone's income. A plumber who lives in a Kensington flat on the same road as Princess Diana's bachelorette flat can identify as working class because he never went to university and grew up in an ex mining town.

Mummy1232016 · 01/01/2022 00:21

@fallfallfall

please explain, some working class people earn 6-7 figure incomes...or do you think they don't work?
Ay?

working class
noun [ S, + sing/pl verb ]
UK /ˌwɜː.kɪŋ ˈklɑːs/ US /ˌwɝː.kɪŋ ˈklæs/
(UK also the working classes)

a social group that consists of people who earn little money, often being paid only for the hours or days that they work, and who usually do physical work

MeredithGreyishblue · 01/01/2022 00:21

Happy new year, BTW! I'm having a knock off Baileys in my Tesco pyjama bottoms but I have got naice ham for tomorrow Grin

onlychildhamster · 01/01/2022 00:20

@awesomekilick I am intrigued, what working class drivel do you see? On tv, families always live in 4/5 bedroom houses with gardens that would cost £1.4 million where i live and they are supposed to be average. Women always have full makeup on and dressed nicely. And this is supposed to be an average family.

I once read that people like watching elevated versions of themselves so that is what is portrayed. like in outnumbered, we are supposed to believe that a teacher and a wfh admin assistant could afford a 4 bedroom house in Chiswick (which apparently was expensive even in those times).

ErrolTheDragon · 01/01/2022 00:19

John Lewis has a Boden dog print shirt reduced from £55.
(Shown with some exceptionally ugly trousers but they're not boden).

www.johnlewis.com/boden-relaxed-jersey-dog-print-shirt-ivory-greyhounds/p5786588

MrsWooster · 01/01/2022 00:17

I’m fritefly middle class and extremely poor. Total household income in the low £20ks of which a lot is tax credits. I buy clothes from supermarkets AND second hand quality lot off eBay for the same price. We are lucky that we have no mortgage (which was £500/month) since 2019, if losing both our parents counts as lucky?
I’m here because the majority of the concerns I share with the (mostly) women on this site transcend class and income.