Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to start my own 'working class Mumsnet'?

433 replies

shoplifteroftheworld · 31/12/2021 18:45

I see so many topics and conversations on here that just don't relate to my own life and experiences. Lots of well off women talking about their recent purchases from Boden or Uniqlo or some other place I can't afford to shop. Chat about dinner parties and holidays abroad. I'd like a site for mums and women on lower incomes as this site can leave a lot of us feeling left out of certain conversations.

OP posts:
Maverickess · 01/01/2022 13:32

For me it's not the 'First World' problems that are posted about like not being able to go on holiday number 4 because of covid restrictions or where to invest money that's not needed to live etc that bother me, I can avoid those threads, or read them to gain some insight into that type of lifestyle if I choose to.
For me it's the high(er) income solutions to low (er) income problems and a complete lack of attempt to understand why those solutions may not work, and then writing the poster off as not trying/working/aspiring hard enough, or the old favourite 'making excuses'.

If I were to go onto a holiday thread like described above, where the poster is complaining about the loss of quality of life because they're not getting their exotic holiday, and reply that I don't have exotic holidays ever because I can't afford them and nothing bad has happened, I'm still here, I'm still alive, I still have things to enjoy, that if it's ok for me to live like that all the time, then it's ok for someone to miss a few themselves - I'd likely be roundly told off for not understanding someone else's POV, that it affects them and how, and that if I want those things I just need to work harder. That I need some compassion etc, etc.

Yet threads from lower income posters with issues are full of suggestions that aren't workable, it's explained why they're not workable and then the "You're making excuses OP" starts. Or talk about how lower income means you're a taker and you should just get a better job.
The thread then turns to talk of takers and givers and personal responsibility rather than actually addressing the issue the OP posted about in the beginning.
It's almost like some posters think that their 'better' education/employment/financial status/access to opportunity, makes them a better person all round, and always right, with the attitude that they need to impart their wisdom to us lesser beings because all we lack is a work ethic and a bit of aspiration.

GrannytoaUnicorn · 01/01/2022 13:19

@WonderfulYou

In some ways this would be a good idea because most of MN literally don’t live in the real world.

I remember one thread about someone struggling and the replies were about getting a cleaner in a few hours a week, or buying a robot cleaner and someone said about asking the nanny to do some cooking, which I found hilarious!

It can be frustrating too as one family were ‘skint’ even though they were on 45k a year (not in London) and someone was in a predicament and they were saying to WFH that day like it’s a completely normal thing to do. And the person who was gifted £400K to buy a house even though they had a house and a holiday home 😰

Sometimes though I enjoy seeing how the other half live and the fact that they can be a SAHM with a husband earning £100K a year - but they are down to earth and think in a similar way as I would do.

I’ve never judged anyone poorer than me but I think I used to subconsciously judge those who are a lot wealthier but I don’t since being on here.

Jesus, this made me feel ten different kinds of poor...

I get a LOT of judgement as a (disabled) lone parent. I'm actually widowed but in everyone else's eyes, a single parent! I've been called on here:

"A scourge on society"
"Scummy single mummy"
"Benefit scrounging layabout"
"Single mums have made [my] their bed so should lie in it" - This comment was deleted by MNHQ but the others above were left to stand, despite my reporting!

I have MS and I'm still trialling medications. I have ZERO choice whether to work or not. The truth is that I spent years qualifying for my dream job, only to have it snatched from under me by this cruel disease and then the subsequent tragic loss of my husband. We started a family and were hoping to buy a house. The average family. Then suddenly I'm a 'single mum' and universally hated & judged. I do get it in every day life but I've had far, far, farrrr more of it on Mumsnet.

One person even went as far as to say (within context) "Why should I/we have holidays when [you've] not worked for it?" (This was whilst fully aware of my disability)
The 'holidays' in question were a few nights in a rented static caravan next to the sea with my little one. Only an hour away. Hardly a luxury all inclusive to the Bahamas!! Even one caravan stay per year takes every spare penny I have for half of each year due to school holiday price increases. I've just booked one for next august and will be totally broke until July now whilst I pay it off. How is that an unfair 'luxury?!' Anyway, I digress....

So yeah, the classism & snobbery is RIFE on here. I wholeheartedly disagree with anyone who says it doesn't exist on this forum. Yes, some more specific boards may be free of judgement & friendly but as a whole, it's rife.

NCNCoohlalaaa · 01/01/2022 13:16

@Alysskea

The posts about Boden being cheap on this thread just prove how little MN users understand working class experience and class in general. I'm so depressed by this.
I’m from a middle class background and agree this is so messed up. Boden is not cheap! Things are like £40 on sale. That is not cheap!

Low incomes really can’t buy things like that.

Alysskea · 01/01/2022 12:57

The posts about Boden being cheap on this thread just prove how little MN users understand working class experience and class in general. I'm so depressed by this.

onlychildhamster · 01/01/2022 12:07

@ssd almost all the posts on how to manage on 100k a year are in London/SE.. maybe they should post in the London section but then they wouldn't get enough traffic.

I think that is a problem with the site. I have posted in the holidays section but I hardly got any replies. Which is why people post in chat. I guess op would not be spending lots of time in the holidays section so would be better if they posted there. S & B would always have a bias towards less affordable brands; not that poor women can't like fashion but a lot of women who are really into it tend to devote lots of £££ to it, like Carrie Bradshaw buying vogue instead of dinner. I had the same issue with skincare, cannot afford to spend £100 on a face serum so left the Caroline Hirons skincare FB group I was in (though a lot of women there really were far from rich!)..

But yes OP might find Mumsnet more relatable if people posted their issues about clothes/holidays in the designated sections not in chat..and if there were separate sections- budget fashion and fashion.

ssd · 01/01/2022 11:29

Actually i think a section on mn would be good for this.

MidnightMeltdown · 01/01/2022 11:29

This thread is confusing class and money. They aren't the same thing. You don't suddenly win the lottery and become middle class. These days there are plenty of working class people with money, and middle class people without.

Working class people typically have different tastes to middle class people. Even if they have money, you're unlikely to see them shopping in joules or Boden. They're more likely to shop at places like ted baker in my experience.

Ted baker isn't cheap, but I think that most middle class people would consider it pretty naff, in just the same way as working class people consider joules or boden to be twee.

I think that most middle class people without money would rather buy quality second hand than go to Primark.

This of course is a huge generalisation (not every middle class person shops at joules, in the same way that not every working class person likes Ted Baker), it's just a general observation.

ssd · 01/01/2022 11:27

Anyway its not about class, that's missing the point. The op wants a site similar to mumsnet with people like herself, instead of people complaining they can't get their usual 3 holidays a year, or asking how to manage on 100k a year or discussing clothes and restaurants and food she can't afford.
That's all. She wants like minded folk. Birds of a feather flock together and all that.

CSJobseeker · 01/01/2022 08:59

@saleorbouy

My OH shopped at Boden for our DC, we're not rich. It worked out cheaper than getting clothes on the high street as the quality was such that my DC could wear them and then they could be sold on for over 50% of the original price when they grew out of them. Most high street clothes were in poor condition after a few months and gas jobs resale value.
In order for this to work, a skint person needs to be happy for a large chunk of their money to be effectively tied up in clothes at any one time.

It's great if you can afford the initial investment, but doesn't work if you can't.

TheVolturi · 01/01/2022 08:45

I actually think mn has people from all walks of life. I am totally working class and don't feel out of place. I love mn the way it is.

coochyboochy · 01/01/2022 08:39

I've posted this on another similar thread and wonder if anyone else identifies with it?

You can be intelligent, eloquent and educated and still be working class and have a strong regional accent. They're not mutually exclusive. You can also be proudly working class (which I am) and have a desire to progress in your career (which I have). I also do not aspire to be middle class and would staunchly reject ever being classified as middle class. It can be deeply ingrained and cultural too. It's definitely how people identify themselves as well as how people judge you.

merrymelodies · 01/01/2022 08:22

Surely the social concept of class in the UK is something apart from income?

Seymour5 · 01/01/2022 08:08

What an interesting thread. Old white woman here, experienced all sorts of financial situations, apart from being well off! IMO, class in the UK is about so much more than money and wealth. Behaviour, speech, education, appearance are all markers.

DH and I never earned much above the national average between us, but our main aim was to not live on the kind of council estate he grew up on, where the lack of a strong local dialect was not popular! Our DC, born in the 70s, have achieved so much more educationally and materially than us, as have their partners, neither of whom started with much. There were so many opportunities then. As working adults they have never (unlike us) had to worry about having no coal, or only beans in the cupboard for their child’s main meal.

Although we are now retired and on a fairly low income (not all baby boomers have gold plated pensions) our speech, values, tastes etc are similar to those of our DC. We live in a very ordinary small house that we own, they have large homes, one owns land, one has a second property that is rented out. Are we different class?

sandgrown · 01/01/2022 07:35

@furbabymama87 because benefits are meant to be a safety net and not a way of life . If you are able to work and not sick or disabled Universal Credit will top up low wages and you stay in the job market and set an example to your children.

lololololollll · 01/01/2022 07:18

Never heard anything more twatish than the hideous people saying off you go to Netmums. Awful people who deserve bad things

onlychildhamster · 01/01/2022 06:36

www.theguardian.com/society/2020/jul/01/nearly-half-of-bame-uk-households-are-living-in-poverty

Based on these stats, only 20% of British white households are in poverty compared to 50% in some other groups in the BAME community.

I don't know the penetration rate of Mumsnet in the BAME community. It might not be very high as I can imagine that Mumsnet is not the best place to seek advice for someone living in a multi generational household (Mumsnet can be very anti MIL and often posters tell people to go NC or LTB), for religious people (BAME tend to be more religious on average and Mumsnet posters can be critical of organized religion). One often has to explain different cultural expectations to Mumsnet i.e. a poster once asked why couldn't the OP's 65 year old overseas MIL work instead of relying on OP's financial support, forgetting that in other countries, there are often no pensions/welfare state and it can be perfectly legal to say 'applicants above the age of 38 need not apply', hence the cultural expectation that one has to support one's parents.so I can imagine that there are other forums which have more like-minded women who would not require such explanations.

I know there is a black Mumsnetters section but that was set up fairly recently. It does follow that if Mumsnet users are overwhelmingly white, the vast majority would not struggle financially, would have different lives. Hence the cognitive dissonance.

I was just thinking about it, and reflecting that white women of childbearing age are probably one of the groups most likely to have a university degree which does increase the likelihood of earning more as a whole. While single mums are one of the most likely to be in poverty, white women probably aren't the most likely group to be heading a household;at least that's not the case in the USA.

Goatinthegarden · 01/01/2022 06:09

Op, I see a wide range of threads across this board that don’t always match my experience or interests but that’s why I come here. Sometimes I find threads I identify with and others I don’t.

I think Mumsnet has opened my eyes to different struggles, privileges and viewpoints of others. People talk about things here that they wouldn’t necessarily say out in the real world. It reminds me that we never truly know what life is like for anyone else.

onlychildhamster · 01/01/2022 04:59

@RunningInTheWind and yes i was a bit shocked when I searched usernames. I don't always do so but this is a reminder that I should check before replying. We all struggle in our own ways but we should be understanding of each other. You are dealing with so much that I cannot begin to understand how to deal with!

onlychildhamster · 01/01/2022 04:50

@RunningInTheWind Might be missing the point yet again but i really do hope you find peace in your life with your health, kids etc. Sending you flowers.

RunningInTheWind · 01/01/2022 04:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Veeveeoxox · 01/01/2022 03:57

The snobbishness about being married is a bit strange . There was a thread recently about a working class single mother some posters were saying she should have been married Confused . That's all well and good when a man has money if he doesn't have any theres really not much point. The Mumsnet bubble never seizes to amaze me.

Andtheyalllookjustthesame · 01/01/2022 02:35

No provi woman, but I look out the window to check who it is before going to the door to see if it's bailiffs or not, always have and always will

Andtheyalllookjustthesame · 01/01/2022 02:31

If you have people over for spaghetti and it's not spaghetti hoops you're middle class. Also anyone who eats ketchup on every meal is WC by default. That is my class distinction, and I am sticking by it. As good as any I've seen on here

WinterDeWinter · 01/01/2022 02:30

I'm also as as ever at people thinking that the issue is whether Boden is or isn't affordable, and feeling attacked if they shop there.

The point isn't Boden, the point is, some people know that if they fall they'll be caught, and some people know that if they fall they'll keep on falling till the ground hits them.

Have some - i dunno, nuance? The middle classes, by this example, are thick as fuck.

Starcup · 01/01/2022 01:51

[quote onlychildhamster]@Starcup It would be different in America which is solely based on income/job but yes you are born into it in the UK. Its why there is the American Dream- a conviction that no matter who you are or where you come from, anyone can achieve their dreams and own a nice house with a picket fence and their children would have better lives. There is no British dream. People define themselves by whether they grew up on a council estate or their postcode, whether they listen to classical music, whether they went to university.

But increasingly even in America, income doesn't solely define someone's situation in life. This is because the value of assets have far outstripped someone's earning capability. A bin man with an inheritance is in a far better position to buy property in London or New York or San Francisco than a junior doctor. Someone who inherits a london house and didn't need to pay for care can inherit up to a £1 million tax free. How long would it take for an average doctor to save up £1 million? This is why BAME communities in the UK/USA are poorer as they have lower home ownership rates than white british people and so they are on unequal footing to start with.

This is why the divide is no longer working class vs middle class; the divide is those with assets and those without. There are some very well paid jobs (generally in London) which enables people to buy assets using earned income i.e. investment banker, magic circle lawyer but a person is rich primarily through ownership of assets. While most millionaires do not inherit their wealth, they are usually from families which give them a safety net. Johnnie Boden for example faced difficulties with his business early on, but his wife Sophie and her family supported him while the credit cards were bouncing all over the place.[/quote]
Yeah I do agree with a lot of what you say.

You often find it happens the other way around as well, where by a clearly privileged person try’s to make out they are from the ‘streets’ and from an impoverished background, when in reality mammy and daddy are facilitating their ‘dosser’ lifestyle.