Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to start my own 'working class Mumsnet'?

433 replies

shoplifteroftheworld · 31/12/2021 18:45

I see so many topics and conversations on here that just don't relate to my own life and experiences. Lots of well off women talking about their recent purchases from Boden or Uniqlo or some other place I can't afford to shop. Chat about dinner parties and holidays abroad. I'd like a site for mums and women on lower incomes as this site can leave a lot of us feeling left out of certain conversations.

OP posts:
Waxonwaxoff0 · 08/01/2022 14:23

@DeepaBeesKit

non drivers are hated.On mumsnet.

Not true but there are things people say that annoy. 1) saying you "don't" drive when what you mean is you can't drive i.e. have no license (I appreciate some people can drive but don't, that's not who I'm talking about). These are the people who are often dismissive of the importance of it as a skill, and when questioned it emerges they rely on many drivers in their life and don't even realise it.

I can't drive. It is not an important skill FOR ME. I live in an area with good public transport and get everywhere I need to using that or my own 2 legs. Don't have a partner and no one drives me around.
Freecuthbert · 08/01/2022 14:13

@onlychildhamster

You are incredibly foolish to accept at face value that people on very low incomes can afford 8k hats for each of their 12 children. These would be already within the family and passed down, donated by the community, etc. If you want to insist they can afford to buy these hats in such dire straits, then they are not poor. But I would think they are not the ones buying them. It comes across like you are saying, if these low income people can afford 8k hats, then of course low income people can afford to buy the same brands I buy. I am not saying oh every single poor person cannot afford H&M or whatever brand, what I am saying is it's ignorant and crass to assume anyone on a low income can afford to shop at certain places.

onlychildhamster · 08/01/2022 13:36

@Freecuthbert most students in London do not live in 1 bed flats with their grandparents. This is his third degree so I don't think he qualifies for student loans based on the rules..he undeniably has v low income...

Oh that community is known for their deprivation. It is very well documented that they are poor..and yes there are some rich donors but they can't support everyone and each family has 12 kids, how do they have a fur hat to give to each son! The men generally get the fur hats when they marry and they marry young. I don't pretend to understand the economics of this community. I am Jewish (but liberal), I do know the added expenses of a Jewish life (buying in a Jewish area;also the costs of kosher food; even though I am not strict, I do buy kosher occasionally and it's more like Waitrose type prices). I think it's all incredibly expensive and I have asked many times how non professional people afford it but many Jewish people on low incomes clearly do! While you personally cannot afford h & m, it doesn't mean that some poor people might not be able to afford it. Just like a PP can afford Uniqlo and the ultra orthodox afford their suits, fur hats and their weddings for 300 people (that's just their immediate relatives) and no there is no infinite supply of kind rich people sponsoring everyone's weddings!

Freecuthbert · 08/01/2022 13:22

@onlychildhamster

You have got to be fucking kidding me if you think anyone can just afford a $8000 fur hat, religion or no religion Confused clearly if they are that poor they are not the ones funding those hats, use some bloody critical thinking! Do you think money grows on trees, or that those who have to buy clothing bundles on ebay are just frittering their money elsewhere? Clearly these are being given to them by their community, by their families, inherited or something. You are literally not poor if you have a spare 8k you can splash on a hat. Ridiculous.

Before you made out this guy had to move in with his grandma because he was on the bones of his arse. Now the story is that he's a student and he moved there by choice because of his religion. Talk about drip feed!

You also do realise right that people on such a range of incomes can be on benefits. And some benefits aren't means tested.

You also do realise I am not "struggling", we manage, but if I clothed my family in H&M then we'd bloody struggle alright Confused? Honestly the sympathy from you and @MidnightMeltdown is actually patronising while insisting I must be especially dirt poor to not afford H&M! Shock

onlychildhamster · 08/01/2022 11:58

@Freecuthbert ultra orthodox jewish community is extremely poor and many of them wear suits. I am sure some of them get charitable donations/gifts but not everyone who is poor probably would get them! a Shtriemel in the satmar community ( a fur hat) is probably worth 8000 USD and they all need one, its part of their religion. So many of them are genuinely struggling but I wouldn't say they are not poor just because they wear suits and have an expensive fur hat!

But of course i do think their lives are a lot harder than many non ultra orthodox jewish poor people because they have such restrictive clothing requirements.

onlychildhamster · 08/01/2022 11:47

@Freecuthbert I am sorry to hear you are struggling. I am not saying its the norm, i was just sharing my experiences of people I am close to who are on really low incomes but spend more or a similar amount on clothes (not in total amount but on individual items).

I was surprised about my DH's friend. No he isn't working at all, he is studying. He is sharing a 1 bedroom flat with his grandma. it is definitely assisted living. I think it may be off the books and that development may not check; my youngest SIL was helping out this old lady who has unfortunately passed on and she coincidentally lived in this same development as my DH's friend's grandma (my SIL lives a few streets away). my SIL used to stay nights a few times a week (and that was fine). Of course she wasn't living there but it also wasn't formal care in the slightest (she wasn't paid the usual amount you pay for a carer, it was more of a favor than formal work)- more like a sleepover where she massaged the old lady's feet, made her cups of tea, helped her to the bathroom and listened to her stories.Maybe the old lady is making out her grandson provides a similar service but every night. Her grandson chooses to live there instead of his parents' house because he has become religious and his parents are not religious (they don't have a kosher home and apparently they are disapproving of his choices), his grandma is probably more supportive. I don't think he inherited any of the clothes as they are quite specific to that community in terms of style and his parents didn't belong to that community. They wouldn't totally look out of place in the City though!

MidnightMeltdown · 08/01/2022 11:27

@Freecuthbert

I'm sorry to hear that things are hard for you at the moment, but I don't think you can argue that yours is the typical working class experience. When I was growing up, my dad was a factory worker, and later a lorry driver - hardly middle class jobs with middle class salaries, but we could afford H&M, New look etc.

Everything is relative. In comparison to Boden, H&M is extremely cheap. Historically, clothes were more expensive, and people would have spent a much higher proportion of their income on clothing, so also by historical standards, H&M is cheap.

Also, producing clothing is not free, it is labour intensive, so in order for for H&M, Primark etc to sell clothing at this price, it's obvious that somebody is being exploited. This isn't meant as a criticism of anyone who shops there, it's all that some people can afford, but I don't think that you can argue that H&M aren't cheap for clothing.

With respect, I don't think that your issue is not being able to shop in 'middle class' shops (Boden etc), it seems that you cannot afford to buy new clothing full stop, and that is something quite different.

Also, someone mentioned upthread that they are on benefits and shop in Uniqlo - so this isn't about people being 'ignorant', there is contradictory information. Clearly some people on low incomes can afford to shop at Uniqlo.

Freecuthbert · 08/01/2022 04:50

@onlychildhamster

People can talk about what they want, I didn't say people can't talk about things. But I can still call out ignorance.

Freecuthbert · 08/01/2022 04:47

@onlychildhamster
Genuinely, why is it so hard for you to actually admit that many people simply cannot afford good quality/expensive/certain brands of clothes? Do you really think someone on the absolute bones of their arse is swanning around in £100 suits? Perhaps this man owned these suits prior, perhaps they were gifted to him, who knows. Perhaps if he's working full time and not contributing to rent and bills at his relative's, all of his income is now disposable income. But really, I'm surprised this grandmother has been allowed to move a young relative into her assisted living flat as there's usually lots of rules around this. I hear of people inheriting these flats from late parents/grandparents and yet still not allowed to live there.

Yes I am aware that people can own fewer clothes, I am one of them! But it's ignorance if you think poor people are simply choosing to buy lots of clothes for the fun of it instead of fewer nice quality pieces, when they are often only buying the amount they need in the first place, and some of these people have 0 leftover in the budget for clothes after paying the rent, bills and food.

onlychildhamster · 08/01/2022 04:39

@Freecuthbert I am always saying I can't afford a car.. but to be fair, there are people on national minimum wage who have a car. There are probably people on UC with cars. Our disposable income is probably higher. What I mean is that I do not value a car enough (+ I live in London and have to pay tube fares to go to work) to pay the £2k annual costs that an average UK motorist spends on his/her car (people always underestimate the costs and never factor in depreciation). Maybe if I was a multimillionaire, £2k would be like £200 to me and maybe I would get a car but for now I prefer to overpay my mortgage (which is hard enough, I overpay by £1k per month and it has only gone down to £308k from £334k ). Slow and steady I suppose. Also, I was even more convinced of it after my DH's manager who is a director in an investment bank went car free, she said she tried taking Ubers whenever she liked instead of driving and it worked out cheaper! So i thought it was even more unjustifiable for me to get a car...

But I don't think that people on Mumsnet shouldn't talk about cars just because I can't afford a car.

onlychildhamster · 08/01/2022 04:19

@Freecuthbert I did reiterate that my MIL's house was bought in 1997 and then remortgaged to pay her ex out..this does mean that she has an advantage over younger people paying private rent. Hence while her income is really low and when you put the figures in IFS, it does come out as bottom 10% of the country. On paper she is much wealthier than me and DH because I have a £330k mortgage and she has a lot of equity in a £750k house (this is a 3 bed terrace in London btw so nothing fancy and when it was bought, it was right next to a drug dealer)...but from a cash flow perspective, there is more cash coming in for us and that is generally what influences spending decisions. It's also why someone who rents with a higher income is also more able to spend more on clothes as there could possibly be more money left after rent. I did say that my MIL may be out of touch with the cost of living for younger people who were not as lucky to buy a London house for 100k (though she still has a mortgage of a few hundred pounds a month). Also my MIL has never paid for childcare in her life despite having 4 kids, she just worked from home while looking after them; and I think these are the two big contributers- most working class jobs are in person and so childcare is needed and if the mum is a single parent, then childcare is needed which erodes any disposable income.. she also doesn't have a car (I can often get a Uber for cheaper than bus fare for two where I live using discount codes) and public transport is very accessible and she is lucky to have her health. A lot of poverty is exacerbated by ill health.

People's financial circumstances are not straightforward.1 thing about my SIL is that she is single. She has no dependents. She was doing a degree and qualified for maintenance loans and grants but then claimed UC after graduating for about a year. When she got her unpaid internship, she also qualified for grants from the organization but of course as the grants are paid later, she still had to pay for the air fares and taxi and covid tests out of her savings. I do wonder how she manages! But we have lent her a total of £1500 for the past few months (we converted the money for her as she is having problems with currency exchange) and she has always managed to pay us back even if there was some delay. I hope that means she is managing well!

I am not saying this is representative of all people of low incomes. I mean, firstly, what do you mean by 'shop at boden'. If you buy a dress there every week at full retail price, I bet a lot of women on £100k probably can't afford that if they are also paying childcare and a big mortgage. If you buy on sale very rarely, that's a different story... People can also own fewer clothes, my MIL has been known to wear her dresses until it gets dirty.. my DH has a friend who is so cash strapped he is living with his grandma in an assisted living 1 bed flat but he wears a suit everyday! A nice looking one too. He is religious and everyone in his community dresses that way, most of the men don't have jobs. His suits are probably more expensive than any Boden dress I have ever bought (I only buy on sale;so far I have bought 2; I have 3 joules dresses). How does he manage it? I have no access to his accounts; all I can say is that not everyone on low incomes would buy their entire wardrobe from the supermarket.

Freecuthbert · 08/01/2022 03:36

The ignorance in this thread is depressing. £20-£25 an item is out of reach for many. Comparison to H&M prices as if everyone just simply knows H&M is cheap... do people genuinely think those on low incomes are clothing their families in H&M? I certainly can't afford to shop there and I'm not on the bread line.

And another PP on this thread thinks £10 an item for baby/toddler clothes, and even better at £2-£3 per sale item is an absolute bargain and no-one has an excuse not to shop at John Lewis/Boden/whatever. Meanwhile I buy second hand bundles that work out pennies per item. I feel posh when I buy new baby clothing in Primark or George!

Oh and don't get me started on another PP whose family members are on "below minimum wage" yet "willing" to spend more on clothes and opt for natural fabrics while living in a 600k house. Sorry but all the will in the world doesn't afford poor people expensive clothing. And apparently someone only on a few hundred pounds a month travels to London regularly, wears lovely H&M outfits, buys lovely birthday presents, can travel abroad during the pandemic, go by taxi everywhere, all of which is paid out of pocket and no debt, while living in an expensive city which she laughs off as not even that expensive. It's sheer ignorance to think that these people, who supposedly roll their eyes at claims of food insecurity in this country, are representative of the "bottom 10%". Meanwhile in the UK, 400,000 children don't have a bed to sleep in and 2.5 million people received help from a food bank this past year. But sure, it's all exaggerated.

I do know that class =/= income by the way before people fall over themselves to provide links and educational resources, but it is true that generally most poor people are working class and wealthy people are middle/upper class, with people on average incomes split between working and middle class. Yes there are people who don't fit neatly and I am one of them, but let's not act like it's the world's biggest fucking mystery why many working class people can probably not afford to shop at Boden or Joules no matter how much you protest your whole family earn £3 an hour while claiming benefits and still manage to buy £35 dresses.

I'm not even going to comment on the number of people who think they're so clever sneering about Netmums.

Maybe I ruined the tone of the thread, but it's painful for me to read this ignorance and keep my mouth shut, especially as all of it is proving OP's point entirely.

Anyway, I do like the idea of a section on Mumsnet for low income families suggested by a PP.

WrittenInGold · 08/01/2022 00:49

I want to join CraicNet!

thegreylady · 07/01/2022 22:45

I grew up on a council estate in a NE pit village (working class) and got a degree, became a teacher, married a University lecturer ( middle class) but I am still me. I am not defined by labels.

MidnightMeltdown · 07/01/2022 14:22

I don't shop at Boden or Uniqlo, but just had a quick look at the websites.

Uniqlo has many jumpers and dresses under £25, and some under £20, not even in the sale. These are H&M prices. Aside from perhaps Primark, where on earth are people shopping that is cheaper than that?

Boden isn't really my style, but I prefer it to Uniqlo, where the dresses all appear to be boring shapeless sacks that would suit nobody. Boden dresses look like they are cut to flatter a more mature figure, which is why I suspect that they are popular.

MidnightMeltdown · 07/01/2022 13:17

@DeepaBeesKit

non drivers are hated.On mumsnet.

Not true but there are things people say that annoy. 1) saying you "don't" drive when what you mean is you can't drive i.e. have no license (I appreciate some people can drive but don't, that's not who I'm talking about). These are the people who are often dismissive of the importance of it as a skill, and when questioned it emerges they rely on many drivers in their life and don't even realise it.

I expect that lot of people can't afford to drive. It's expensive - driving lessons, car, insurance, maintenance etc etc.

the80sweregreat · 07/01/2022 11:48

I'll join your working class group !

Lifeisnteasy · 07/01/2022 11:42

@Blueeyedgirl21

Why are people obsessed with boden. It’s literally only good for under 8s. The women’s clothes look like oversized kids clothes. Funky knitted cardi. Nope
I agree 😬 like overgrown toddler clothing
VelvetChairGirl · 07/01/2022 11:24

@Blueeyedgirl21

Why are people obsessed with boden. It’s literally only good for under 8s. The women’s clothes look like oversized kids clothes. Funky knitted cardi. Nope
Under 8s? only if you have a whole gaggle of kids to pass it down to, the speed they grow out of clothing, all my kids stuff comes from primark except the school uniform that came from asda, except the last one two they came from M&S because the council keep giving me vouchers
onlychildhamster · 07/01/2022 11:24

@Bluesarestillblue they do petite sizes! not a lot of brands do! having said that, i only have 2 dresses from there. My favourite brand at the moment is gudrun sjoden which is £££ but I buy second hand and sale items.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 07/01/2022 11:14

Why are people obsessed with boden. It’s literally only good for under 8s. The women’s clothes look like oversized kids clothes. Funky knitted cardi. Nope

RoyalFamilyFan · 07/01/2022 11:10

Shop wherever you want, no one cares. What people care about is the assumption that something is cheap if it costs £30 or £40.

VelvetChairGirl · 07/01/2022 11:07

@LondonQueen

Also didn't realise that working class women can't shop at Boden or host dinner parties? Do you have to specify your income to shop at Boden, I don't remember doing so...
i dont know why anyone shops there the dresses all look like grandmas curtains.

i am on benefits and I shop at uniqlo, I wasnt aware I wasnt meant to be in there, guess I'd better go back to primark and buy cloths for half the price that fall apart within 3 months.

VelvetChairGirl · 07/01/2022 11:00

First off there was one its called netmums not sure if its still about but I used that when I had mine it was the only place you could talk about formula without the breastappo getting involved/arsey.

and secondly you could just try posting here, I am single mum on full benefits raised in a council place, now in a private landlord place.

RoyalFamilyFan · 07/01/2022 10:52

YANBU OP.
Before joining MN I would have said I don't care what class someone is in. But the sheer snobbery and judgements of working-class people on here have astounded me.
Even some of the comments on here like go to Netmums then Hun.
It makes me want to join Class War (do they still exist?) and spray paint Eat The Rich on the windows of the Joules shop.