Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to start my own 'working class Mumsnet'?

433 replies

shoplifteroftheworld · 31/12/2021 18:45

I see so many topics and conversations on here that just don't relate to my own life and experiences. Lots of well off women talking about their recent purchases from Boden or Uniqlo or some other place I can't afford to shop. Chat about dinner parties and holidays abroad. I'd like a site for mums and women on lower incomes as this site can leave a lot of us feeling left out of certain conversations.

OP posts:
Popopopo · 31/12/2021 22:58

@coochyboochy - london/se house prices, incomes and lifestyles vary wildly...

idiotmagnet · 31/12/2021 22:57

@Alysskea

YANBU!!! Don't know why this has caused such a stir. You're right that so much of the site is aimed at well off middle class with absolutely no clue.

As making your own site sounds like a whole lot of effort we may need to settle for being more vocal on this version.

Yeah, lots of closet - or not so closet! - class snobbery here. So many people not understanding or wanting to understand what it is to struggle financially. No concept of an uneven playing field either.
LaChanticleer · 31/12/2021 22:56

I’m constantly amazed at how acceptable it is on MN to be rude or dismissive of any poster who appears to have money or class. So it’s OK to slag off the upper middle class, but heaven forfend we breathe a word of criticism about anyone working class.

onlychildhamster · 31/12/2021 22:55

@coochyboochy I thought the consensus on Mumsnet was that people in the north have a better lifestyle because they don't sink all their money into property like us londoners. The difference with why londoners might seem to have a more materialistic lifestyle is the ones who stay in London tend to have kids later and being older usually means having more disposable income. I am nearly 30 and married but am more focused on overpaying the mortgage now so I can afford a bigger flat and childcare and also working to increase my pay. In the north, maybe I would have a baby at a younger age given that I married at 22...

WinterDeWinter · 31/12/2021 22:51

Fucking hell just lost post.

It said:
call it 'NoSafetyNet'
and also that i am (precarious) middle class and my entire understanding of the reality of how having no safety net changes everything has come from Mn, and that I'm very grateful as it has transformed my politics and my worldview. And that it's imposs to overstate how strong the middleclass bubble really is - I didnt know anyone other than ones like me or reasonably well off tradespeople for about 40 years. Or at least not well enough to understand fuck all.
The older I get the more I hate it all. I never joke about class now and I am so far left now that Marxist Leninists are liberals.

coochyboochy · 31/12/2021 22:49

Should say *threads not breads! 🤣

onlychildhamster · 31/12/2021 22:48

@ssd You have to search for a long time in charity to find something good. Primark is fast fashion. Btw my cousin's wife loves primark and when she visited london for the first time, primark is the highlight of her visit! She lives in a 3 bedroom condo in Singapore with a tennis court, a spa, a karaoke room and swimming pools and she likes to have a lot of clothes, so cheap fashionable clothes that she doesn't mind discarding is preferred.

An influencer I follow on instagram was also proudly showing off her new fingerless gloves from Primark, which she paired with a dior handbag and a balenciaga hoodie. I get it with gloves because I always seem to lose mine so would never get expensive ones.

Therefore I associate brands like primark, boohoo and shein with teens that want to constantly refresh their outfits. ASDA seems to sell more functional basics. if I could only afford the cheapest clothes, I would buy second hand clothes on facebook/ebay or at charity shops with an emphasis on brands that are known for good quality so they would last. I would also stalk freegle; i gave away some clothes to a lady for free once using that site!

coochyboochy · 31/12/2021 22:48

I think a northern English Mumsnet would be nice! Or maybe just a non-London/SE one. I often feel very culturally adrift when reading breads about London house prices/incomes/lifestyles. We are comfortable and have a nice enough life but so many women here are in a different stratosphere.

BoopTheFloof · 31/12/2021 22:47

@ParkingDiagram WellI’m from one of the regions referenced in two of the names and lived for a long time in the region referenced by the other.

If you think that there is anything wrong with the words “Mam,”Maw” or “Ma” you’re the one who thinking working class means inferior not me.

WhoAre · 31/12/2021 22:44

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

elbea · 31/12/2021 22:42

@BiscuitLover3678 dresses in the Boden sale are £10, I’ll be able to sell them on for the same. Got a whole load of clothes from John Lewis for £2-3 clearance, I’ll probably make money on selling them when we are done. They are the same prices of supermarket clothes, the John Lewis things are cheaper.

ParkingDiagram · 31/12/2021 22:42

This thread is turning into an actual parody of itself as offended middle-class MNers compete to post about how they or someone they know are really poor. However, acceptably poor in MN world means they work 18 hours a day cleaning the house of an MC MNer but don’t claim any benefits.

ArblemarzipanTFruitcake · 31/12/2021 22:38

@ssd

The only people i know who shop in charity shops are people who can easily afford Boden etc. Its fine buying the odd cheap 2nd hand item if you know you can go into john Lewis the next day and spend a few hundred on your barbour jacket and hobbs dress. Maybe the folk shopping in primark and asda actually want something new that no one has worn before them, as thats all they're getting??
I'm sure there are charity shoppers like that, but I'm not one of them. I very rarely buy anything new - on the odd occasion I have it's from the sale rail at Tesco - I think I got a denim skirt for £5 there last spring and that's about the only new thing I remember buying this year, apart from underwear.
WinterDeWinter · 31/12/2021 22:37

@SawdustAndHay

A specific place on Mumsnet might be be a start. Call it Peasants’ Corner.
proper lol. ask 'em.
Turnitupto11 · 31/12/2021 22:36

I'm with you OP. Uniqlo IS expensive for me, I only shop on Ebay or in charity shops. Unable to work due to chronic illnesses and a bit fed up of some of the topics on here from some very privileged people. But I do just ignore them if I spot them. Just before Christmas there were a lot of questions about how much to tip the cleaner etc Hmm

Anotherlovelybitofsquirrel · 31/12/2021 22:35

@SawdustAndHay 🤣

OvaHere · 31/12/2021 22:33

Money doesn't always buy you style. I have friends on lower incomes who can make bargain finds/Primark clothes look a million dollars. I can afford more expensive clothes but my innate fashion sense is shite. Grin

PartyPrawnRingGames · 31/12/2021 22:32

Wealth isn't directly related to class, if you want an example I have just been watching the Two Fat Ladies cookery show on YouTube. Both the ladies had difficult periods in their lives when they had very little money and had to work as cooks. But you only had to hear them speak for a minute to know they were upper class, posh as Alexander de Pfeffel Johnson, and acceptable at any fancy shooting party or soiree. Class is like your culture, it's to do with your background, your family and friends and how you were raised, how you talk and behave, the things you like or dislike. You can change class, but it's not as simple as how much money you have.

ParkingDiagram · 31/12/2021 22:31

[quote BoopTheFloof]@ParkingDiagram WTF?[/quote]
You were one of the people I quoted who appeared to be taking the piss out of working class MNers by posting a series of regional names for mothers.

RainbowZebraWarrior · 31/12/2021 22:29

@KiloWhat

Have you tried starting threads about your own life experiences?
I think she just did
FindingMeno · 31/12/2021 22:28

I definitely can't afford Boden or John Lewis but I love a good charity shop.

ssd · 31/12/2021 22:26

The only people i know who shop in charity shops are people who can easily afford Boden etc. Its fine buying the odd cheap 2nd hand item if you know you can go into john Lewis the next day and spend a few hundred on your barbour jacket and hobbs dress. Maybe the folk shopping in primark and asda actually want something new that no one has worn before them, as thats all they're getting??

Phrenologistsfinger · 31/12/2021 22:22

I grew up economically in the underclass - a struggling single parent on benefits, with chaotic lifestyle, frequently homeless or lacking sufficient food. I am culturally middle class - radio 4 and libraries were free- and Oxbridge educated (only through sheer grit) and we are a high earning household. I don’t belong anywhere but I find some people on MN I can identify with and many others I cannot. I am struggling with infertility so the pregnancy and parenting boards are just off limits right now (even the conception board) - I cannot imagine being annoyed by a crying baby, something I so desperately want, like many normal mums are - but I find my people on the infertility board, and various others. YABU to judge everyone here by fairly superficial factors like where they shop. I have boden clothes, bought secondhand. So what?

FindingMeno · 31/12/2021 22:19

@onlychildhamster actually thinking about it, the last dress I bought for a wedding was £3.99 in a charity shop. It was gorgeous and a perfect fit!

Bralessandfree · 31/12/2021 22:16

I might start my own mumsnet but only for gingers. I'm fed up of there never being any threads about it and all you middle class, shall I name my baby Tarquin or Lord Farquar types that you all are, no exceptions, you're all the same and I'm definitely not generalising, can stay here and stealth boast to your hearts content. Over on gingenet we will mock you and congratulate ourselves on being better than you. Ha.