Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to start my own 'working class Mumsnet'?

433 replies

shoplifteroftheworld · 31/12/2021 18:45

I see so many topics and conversations on here that just don't relate to my own life and experiences. Lots of well off women talking about their recent purchases from Boden or Uniqlo or some other place I can't afford to shop. Chat about dinner parties and holidays abroad. I'd like a site for mums and women on lower incomes as this site can leave a lot of us feeling left out of certain conversations.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CSJobseeker · 09/01/2022 15:58

we need to beverymindful of the fact that the Internet affords thefantastistroom for exaggeration

100% agree with this.

CSJobseeker · 09/01/2022 15:57

No, but a board where WC people weren't routinely sneered at might be a start.

seekinglondonlife · 09/01/2022 15:54

The thing is that you will never get a forum where everyone has exactly the same experiences. The OP asked for a working class forum, where she can relate to people who can't afford holidays and other luxuries. I've seen loads of threads where people say they have 50p to last a week and they get lots of helpful responses, same with the Christmas on a budget threads. And for every "I spend 6 weeks in the Caribbean" every three months post there are 10 saying they haven't been on holiday since 1942 and it was to the end of their street.
And we need to be very mindful of the fact that the Internet affords the fantastist room for exaggeration.

CSJobseeker · 09/01/2022 13:58

@Lndnmummy

Surely, from the responses here its kind of proved OP's point? Many answers are so obtuse.
I agree. The recent thread where the OP asked to hear from average earners is another good example.

For whatever reason, some people obviously really resent (and react very badly to) being told that their experiences aren't necessarily relatable to WC people / people on lower incomes.

MedusasBadHairDay · 09/01/2022 12:05

@Lndnmummy

Surely, from the responses here its kind of proved OP's point? Many answers are so obtuse.
I'm not sure which are worse the sniggery snobbish "don't you mean netmums?" attempts to be funny? Or the "why don't you just shop in the Boden sales" ignorance?
Lndnmummy · 09/01/2022 11:19

Surely, from the responses here its kind of proved OP's point? Many answers are so obtuse.

downinaholeinchains · 09/01/2022 00:07

Atilla's crew are out in force I see

Freecuthbert · 08/01/2022 23:43

Fwiw, I am not saying Boden is extravagance, but 8k hats and weddings that cost over and above the average (so more than 30k in the UK).

Freecuthbert · 08/01/2022 23:41

@onlychildhamster

Oh do give over, you're the one who came on here all shocked that Boden and such is out of reach for many people, and that in your eyes those clothes aren't that expensive and even your mum on "below minimum wage" can afford them. I am pointing out the ignorance in that and then with every post you've been getting more ridiculous.

If you're in literal poverty, you cannot afford extravagance, not out of your own pocket. It's simply not possible. No I don't have access to their bank accounts, and neither do you by the way! But I have common sense.

Of course I know people are allowed to have savings on Universal Credit... I am on it myself. Deductions start at 6k savings and by 16k savings you have no claim for UC. And there are also lots of rules around deprivation of capital, which paying for an extravagant wedding would be classed as by the way, as would be buying an 8k hat. So people would have to commit benefit fraud and potentially money laundering to be able to purchase those things if they are on UC.

onlychildhamster · 08/01/2022 22:50

@Freecuthbert no actually I don't have a TV, a car or a tv license or sky. Never had a phone contract before. But I don't think the people who owns tvs, cars or have sky are necessarily richer than me, i just think they spend their money differently. I also didn't plan a big wedding, I saved the money so that we could buy our flat more quickly. I do know many people who have chosen differently, and they spent the little money they had on their wedding, which is fine as well. We are all different.

www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-4158597,00.html
I don't think ultra orthodox people who are in poverty want to spent a lot of money on weddings, but due to the ritual aspects and even if you just invite immediate relatives, it does end up costing quite a lot of money as big weddings are the norm- just on the kosher food alone! And yes parents do pay. Which is now ultra orthodox rabbis have put a limit on how much they can spend. And say even if feeding 1 person is £20 (which is overly optimistic for kosher food, its probably more like double), its £6000 for food alone for 300 people which is still a pretty big expense. Most uk weddings are pretty small so that already naturally cuts down expenses. I do think that a lot of uk weddings are extravagant nowadays because people marry later and other than the small minority of religious people, it tends to be more MC people who see the value in marrying!

My point wasn't that poor people on benefits in the UK are not suffering and are spending money on frivolous things. my point is that not all poor people lead similar lives, there are poor people who can and do have higher costs in terms of clothing and weddings etc. However, just because they have these costs, it doesn't mean that they aren't deprived in other ways and its their choice how they want to spend their money. Like I wouldn't dream of doubting that a poor person is in poverty just because he happens to have an Iphone or that a pensioner isn't poor because she happens to own a £1 million house (this is quite common in london due to property price inflation), I would not assume affording Boden would be completely crazy for someone on a low income. Particularly as we have discussed, Boden is far cheaper than suits, weddings for 300 people, fur hats. Of course it is probably more unusual for a poor person to prioritize Boden given that its just a brand rather than a religious obligation/cultural expectation!

How do you know that they are not paying for these weddings and hats out of pocket? Do you have access to their bank accounts? Even when you claim UC, you are still allowed to have savings (not exceeding £12k or something, i recall). And they would still be poor because the definition of poverty is based on your income. There is a minimum income standard determined by the Joseph Rowntree foundation and it is also area dependent i.e. inner london is higher.

www.minimumincome.org.uk/step1/

If you fall below the minimum income based on your area and your household size, you are poor. For a couple in inner london, they need to earn a combined income of £52k to not be poor. I don't even want to calculate how much it is for a family of 8, the minimum income standard only covers up to 4 children anyway. For a couple outside london, you need to earn at least 13k per person to not be poor. This doesn't include whether you have savings or not.

And this is why my MIL is the bottom 10% of the country cos she is still supporting an adult child and the minimum income for a single parent in Outer London with a teenage child is £33000. She earns around half of that, way below london living wage. And even when she had 4 little ones, she earned the same or even less and that was very very tight.

Freecuthbert · 08/01/2022 22:06

@onlychildhamster

So people in poverty in the UK are spending all their money on big flat screen TVs, going to the cinema, going on days out, travelling abroad and going away for nice holidays? What's next, they're splashing the cash on Sky packages and the latest iPhones? You do realise these are luxuries to many in the UK who couldn't even dream of ever going to America for big weddings! The price for flights for a family of 12 is unthinkable. And you can go for days out for free, that's what I and many people do.

Yes I appreciate many people on really low incomes have some small luxuries like smartphones and TVs. Which are far cheaper than these hats. My TV cost me £100! But many people are often stretched to their limits with phone contracts etc because they can't afford the upfront costs to begin with.

And I can't believe what you just said about weddings. Do you live in a fantasy world where money grows on trees? Average wedding costs are up 3000% since the 1950s. Just have a look here: www.weddingideasmag.com/wedding-costs-decades/

And that is average. Not people in poverty. It's ludicrous to think that the poorest can simply save up for a big lavish wedding costing tens of thousands plus several 8k hats.

There may well be some of these poor people you speak of having grand weddings and ludicrously expensive hats. But it is simply untrue that they are paying for this out of pocket. Otherwise they are not poor, are they? You are so out of touch and the mental gymnastics here to try and prove anyone can afford Boden is stupid.

seekinglondonlife · 08/01/2022 17:49

This is an interesting article on the Haredi. Interest free loans and hand-me-downs seem to be the answer:

en.globes.co.il/en/article-haredim-arent-as-poor-as-you-think-1001265187

I read the article you posted about Stamford Hill and povertyonlychild that states most of them are on full benefits. Interestingly the 2 years I was on full benefits (dc was sick) I had more disposable income than when I was working!

onlychildhamster · 08/01/2022 17:37

@seekinglondonlife how did people in the past pay for their weddings. In the past, everyone got married and the bride got a big poofy white dress. It would probably have cost thousands in today's money! Cheap compared to the average UK wedding today which is £25k! Wouldn't poor people have had to save for their children's weddings and would thus have spare money? the fur hat is worn after one gets married so I presume its part of the costs of marriage in these circles...

onlychildhamster · 08/01/2022 17:32

@seekinglondonlife they are poor because they prioritize torah study over working full time, they have many children and they don't have secular education. Even without the thousand pound hats, they would still be poor. They also live in metropolitan areas like London (and their neighbourhoods are not the cheapest) where housing costs are high but yet it is hard for them to move because their community is there.

Poverty often has more to do with the income/resources being lacking rather than the cost of living. If it was only to do with cost of living, cheap places in the north wouldn't have such a high poverty rate with all the related issues. after all, even if you scrimp, you still have to pay a minimum for heating, food, clothes. This is the UK, not Bangladesh, whether you are in the north or london, its going to cost you.

Some ultra orthodox have moved out to cheaper areas like Canvey Island and Prestwich but many of them have the same problems with poverty. The difference is that they have bigger houses for their growing families which would be impossible in London. What would really help them is not if they spent less on their religious obligations; but if they got qualifications and the men worked full time. Reducing the number of children would probably help too but its generally found that if both parents work, the birth rate naturally decreases anyway. Like with regular orthodox couples, the norm is 2-3, not 8.

onlychildhamster · 08/01/2022 17:23

@Freecuthbert Cash is tight in these communities so if there was a way to save money, they would. my MIL does buy long sleeve t shirts at primark and other similar shops! She is less religious than some of these women, i have never seen the more religious ones wear t shirts, they always seem to be wearing rather formal type dresses and full wigs.

But there are some things like formal shabbat clothes and suits and shtriemels that they have yet to sell at bargain prices at Primark! A lot of discount clothes tend to veer towards the 'casual' end.

onlychildhamster · 08/01/2022 17:18

@Freecuthbert . I guess they afford the suits and hats in the same way that unemployed men in 1920s america used to afford their expensive non mass produced suits (if you look at photos of pre war america and europe, everyone was wearing suits). There wasn't any other choice. We are used to cheap clothing but for most of human history, clothing wasn't cheap. people didn't go naked. we see this more in the ultra-orthodox jewish community because they are trying to live life the way their ancestors did in the polish villages when the polish nobility decreed they had to wear animal tails to humilate them and so they fashioned it into hats. I presume animal fur was a lot cheaper then.

On a side note, people in this community don't have TVs, they don't go to the cinema, the children are not exposed to social media so they don't have as many wants as a result. They don't really have days out . They don't travel much except to israel or maybe america (for weddings) and then they always stay with friends and family. my SIL and my MIL are not ultra-orthodox but they hardly ever had a vacation overseas where they did not stay with family or the accomodation wasn't covered by a jewish organization. my MIL paid for an airbnb for her daughter's wedding and that is the only time I have seen her stay in anything but a youth hostel. They eat very simply except on shabbat (DH absolutely hated the food in primary school).

seekinglondonlife · 08/01/2022 17:06

My point was that perhaps they are poor because they are obliged to buy these items. I don't think many could argue that a poor person with a spare £8k is actually poor.

Freecuthbert · 08/01/2022 16:59

It sounds unfathomable and a complete oxymoron to say someone is in poverty but has a £8k hat, but it seems priorities are very different and what would seem to most people frivolities are considered necessities.

There are people in poverty who can't afford to heat their homes, feed their children, buy the clothes on their children's backs. 400,000 UK children don't have a bed to sleep in because the upfront cost is too much for their cash-strapped parents. So yes it is oxymoronic to suggest people in poverty are buying themselves and their many sons an 8k hat each out of their pockets, simply because their priorities are different. If you can't afford the essentials to begin with, how on earth can you splash thousands of what you don't have on hats no matter their religious significance? Or do people go to food banks for the fun of it? Confused

seekinglondonlife · 08/01/2022 16:33

I have found your posts fascinating @onlychildhamster across various threads. I follow a few Jewish accounts on social media and there have been frequent mentions about the costs associated with being Jewish, particularly if you are Torah observant. It sounds unfathomable and a complete oxymoron to say someone is in poverty but has a £8k hat, but it seems priorities are very different and what would seem to most people frivolities are considered necessities.

onlychildhamster · 08/01/2022 15:55

@CSJobseeker they are made from real fur so why not.

Its a real target for crime: abc7ny.com/shtreimel-stolen-hasidic-jew-brooklyn-williamsburg/10418934/

This particular hat was worth 8k and owned by a 27 year old. There are hardly any 'normal' 27 year olds out there who have items costing 8k (most designer bags don't even cost that! chanel bags cost less). But this very poor community does. Majority of men don't work, learn full time and are on benefits! The women do have jobs but they also have on average 6-7 children so need to balance the jobs with childcare and housework and btw they don't go to university or have secular education.

CSJobseeker · 08/01/2022 15:20

Boden isnt totally inaccessible, but it's certainly not cheap. My mum lives on a state pension only, and she occasionally buys her grandkids clothes at same price point as Boden. But (a) they're kids clothes, so cheaper than the adult ranges, (b) she has no housing costs and a very cheap lifestyle, so her outgoings are minimal, and (c) she views those purchases as being for special occasions/gifts. She wouldn't ever buy more expensive than that.

CSJobseeker · 08/01/2022 15:16

8k hats. Fucking hell. Shock

Freecuthbert · 08/01/2022 14:50

Also I never said Boden and Uniqlo are completely closed off to low incomes. I have very clearly said it is ignorant to argue that of course people can afford to buy there, they just don't choose to.

Freecuthbert · 08/01/2022 14:49

@onlychildhamster

Absolutely no "very poor" people are buying 8k hats. Nope. But again you drip feed, apparently you can buy the hats for $600 now not just 8k. Hmm

onlychildhamster · 08/01/2022 14:31

@Freecuthbert

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-11823332
That hat is not the shtriemel, that is the normal hat they wear everyday..
They are very poor and they do buy them. my DH went to an ultra orthodox primary school so is more familiar with their circumstances and while some families can get help, not everyone does. my DH and his siblings qualified for free school meals but they still charged his mother full school fees (majority of ultra orthodox schools are not funded by the state as they don't teach maths and english and yes some parents have to pay or it would not be possible to run the school). They definitely would not fund everyone's expensive fur hats. The point about inheritance- just like someone who owns property in london generally cannot pass down a house each to multiple children (generally house is sold and proceeds divided), there are more children with each generation so there would be not be enough shtriemels from deceased grandparents to pass down! The ultra orthodox population is practically doubling with their high birthrate! It is why some of them have to move out of london because even though some might have inheritances to live in the area, there aren't enough houses or flats to go around.
And the prices has gone down a lot, i saw one on ebay for £1800 and apparently there are cheaper real fur ones from china which are £600-700. Still quite expensive. If you ask me off hand whether i could pay £600 for a hat, i would probably be shocked and say no, but then this is not my denomination, I do not prize hats! The women spend quite a lot of money on wigs, though its not as expensive as real fur and i don't think its a requirement as you can also cover hair with a scarf.

And only men wear them, so i guess most people don't have 12 sons.

forward.com/schmooze/401441/shtreimel-styles-are-ruled-by-trends-as-much-as-tradition-even-for-hasidim/

I am also saying it isn't clear cut what people can shop at. I would agree that yes generally poor people cannot shop at Chanel. But I think its a bit of a stretch to say that Boden and Uniqlo are completely closed off. It would be like saying an ultra orthodox jew would never be able to have a wedding for 300 people/have many children/buy a fur hat/buy a suit if he is on benefits just because some secular people feel they personally can't afford children or big weddings or expensive clothes (I have seen people on decent incomes on mumsnet say they can't afford all the above;I am also guilty of that which is why I am opting for an only child and not having a big wedding). And there are many ultra orthodox jews on benefits who have 5 children, had a wedding with their 300 immediate relatives etc and not all paid for by charitable individuals! Everyone has different circumstances