Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Second hand clothes

266 replies

parentpanic · 31/12/2021 18:17

Do you buy second hand clothes for your children and AIBU to ask why and how you feel about it?

OP posts:
Sn0tnose · 02/01/2022 23:25

I don’t have DC but I won’t buy second hand clothing or anything else. I don’t want it, even if I know where it has come from and I know their home is spotlessly clean. If I can’t afford it new, I just save until I can buy it. I’d rather go without than have second hand.

I would never in a million years judge anyone else for buying second hand, I’d congratulate someone on getting a bargain and I regularly donate stuff to charity.

VintageCookbook · 02/01/2022 19:36

@coochyboochy

I do just find second hand shoes beyond the pale. You can't wash out the traces from the previous wearer- they always carry the sweat et. It's just grim. Yes toddlers get dirty but I presume you still bath them to remove the dirt, we don't just leave kids dirty. I don't know why you would subject a child to that,
There's always one ...
OmgIThinkILikeYou · 02/01/2022 18:31

Yes and also buy second hand bundels on ebay for myself. I don't have any particular feelings about it. I just buy things I like.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 02/01/2022 18:29

Got a Christmas jumper and t shirt for Ds from school second hand sale and it’s reminded me how much I like second hand clothes! Would love to receive / buy more tbh. Our local charity shops do a better line in adults than children’s clothes.

MollysDolly · 02/01/2022 18:23

@DeepaBeesKit

I'm making enormous savings. You are paying full price. What your full price is, is kind of irrelevant, as for me to purchase the equivalent would be 80% cheaper.

You are making those savings if you believe the RRP and if you value the brand of what you buy. In many cases some of those items you are paying for prestige/brand, rather than intrinsic materials/goods etc.

Again, no I'm not.

Just because you wouldn't pay a high brand new price, is irrelevant. The point is, whether you buy something for £10 or £100, I'm buying it for 80% less. The fact you don't ever buy expensive items is neither here nor there.

I'm saving (on average) 80% on the things I buy. Whether that is a £1000 table you wouldn't spend £1000 on, that I get for £200. Or a £25 dress that you would buy, that I get for a fiver.

If you want to argue that a brand new £600 sofa from Argos is just as good as the handmade ones I have (£900 for both, I won't tell you the new price, lest you spontaneously combust), or your new £10 Primark dress is just as good as a Boden one I got for £4, then ok...

Simonjt · 02/01/2022 09:06

I do, most of my sons clothes are second hand (hes 6), shoes are always new as everyone had a different foot shape etc which does change the integrity of the shoe.

We’ve recently started buying things for when our little girl moves in, we’ve bought, washed and stored enough in the size ranges to clothe her for at least a year. We spent about £90.

FHmama · 02/01/2022 08:57

Yes. I buy second hand / shop in cheaper stores like primark for my son's clothes for nursery. Then generally stick to a few nice new outfits from river island / zara etc for the weekends.

maddiemookins16mum · 02/01/2022 08:52

Nope. Never. I don’t like the idea personally but I think that goes back to my childhood in the 70s when as the child of a struggling single parent I wore second hand and hated it. DD never had a huge wardrobe of clothes and wore a lot of inexpensive supermarket stuff too.

00100001 · 02/01/2022 08:15

@ForestLake

No. I just don't like second hand.
Why not?
VikingOnTheFridge · 01/01/2022 22:08

Yep, and hand me downs too. I've found buying clothes second hand costs me less than kitting out for new, and it's greener. I also like second hand for myself.

Puffalicious · 01/01/2022 21:35

@MollysDolly

People who claim it's more expensive have have obviously never looked (the super overpriced listings are promptly reduced). If they hate secondhand so much it's unlikely they have actual seen the sites or shops themselves.

Completely agree. DTwins had gorgeous Moncler snowsuits, £565 (I think) each. Except I paid £70 each. One had only been worn once, and I had both dry cleaned, so when it came to put them on, they were new for all intents and purposes. DTwins wore these almost daily last winter. Superb quality and looked awesome. I sold them this winter for £120 each. So, my two had £1000 odd, of brilliant quality snowsuits, that I ended up being paid £100 for them to wear.

But, you know, I could have been "smart" and bought them both a brand new one from River Island for £50 each. Because who would spend £70 on a snowsuit.

The only issue is that Moncler use real fur...
DeepaBeesKit · 01/01/2022 21:28

DTwins had gorgeous Moncler snowsuits, £565 (I think) each. Except I paid £70 each. One had only been worn once, and I had both dry cleaned, so when it came to put them on, they were new for all intents and purposes.

The "price when new" is irrelevant because most people simply do not believe those items are worth paying that much for.

Your example is neat in that it happened you were able to sell those on for more but that isn't always possible and you take ths risk of having spent £140 on children's snow suits. You can get an excellent Columbia down one for £35. I think most people will agree that more money spent doesn't always equate to a commensurate rise in quality, often what you are paying for is a fashion brand and many people value those less highly than you.

DeepaBeesKit · 01/01/2022 21:22

I'm making enormous savings. You are paying full price. What your full price is, is kind of irrelevant, as for me to purchase the equivalent would be 80% cheaper.

You are making those savings if you believe the RRP and if you value the brand of what you buy. In many cases some of those items you are paying for prestige/brand, rather than intrinsic materials/goods etc.

speakout · 01/01/2022 21:13

*ForestLake
No. I just don't like second hand.

So no antiques? vintage? Always brand new houses? Do you ever stay in a hotel? Sit in a train? Eat in a restaurant? Go to hospital?

Sleepyteach · 01/01/2022 20:47

I buy a lot second hand and then sell on after. Partly for environmental reasons and partly because I like nice brands but I’m not prepared to pay full price. I also try not to buy fast fashion where I can help it, I’d rather spend three quid on a good quality, second hand t shirt on Vinted or ebay that’s been made in ethical conditions than a brand new one from primark that’s been made in a sweatshop and is only fit for rags by the time it’s grown out of.

BigGreen · 01/01/2022 20:42

@Aria999

I also went through a phase of doing knee patches but DS destroys them faster than I can sew, so there is a growing' weds mending' pile in the cupboard.
I got fed up and turned my boys' holey trousers into shorts!
MollysDolly · 01/01/2022 20:40

People who claim it's more expensive have have obviously never looked (the super overpriced listings are promptly reduced). If they hate secondhand so much it's unlikely they have actual seen the sites or shops themselves.

Completely agree. DTwins had gorgeous Moncler snowsuits, £565 (I think) each. Except I paid £70 each. One had only been worn once, and I had both dry cleaned, so when it came to put them on, they were new for all intents and purposes. DTwins wore these almost daily last winter. Superb quality and looked awesome. I sold them this winter for £120 each. So, my two had £1000 odd, of brilliant quality snowsuits, that I ended up being paid £100 for them to wear.

But, you know, I could have been "smart" and bought them both a brand new one from River Island for £50 each. Because who would spend £70 on a snowsuit.

BigGreen · 01/01/2022 20:37

Yes of course, for Dcs and for me. Currently loving Vinted for clothes. Many Christmas toys and general household and furniture stuff gets bought (and often sold again) on Facebook marketplace. See if you've got a local parents selling group.

mrkramps · 01/01/2022 20:09

@MollysDolly

All that stuff you buy second hand costs more than the stuff I buy brand new. Honestly couldn't bring myself to spend 800 quid on a TV unit, never mind a second hand one.

Well no, it doesn't all cost more, does it. You aren't buying new dresses for £2. Or a new cot, changing unit and wardrobe, all for £80.

What you mean is, you've picked one of the two examples of items (where I've saved thousands and thousands) and suggested that because the amount paid is higher than a cheap new item, that this means it is expensive compared to your new items. Which is logically, nonsense. Because whether I'm saving £8 on something that would have cost £10, or £800 on something that would have cost £1000, I'm paying 20% of the new price.

Saying "oh, well I'll only pay £100 for something new, so your stuff is more expensive" actually equates to "I'll only pay £100 for something, which you'd buy second hand for £20." You're comparing apples and pears.

I'm making enormous savings. You are paying full price. What your full price is, is kind of irrelevant, as for me to purchase the equivalent would be 80% cheaper.

You're essentially saying, "I know you've just bought that £100k Aston for £20k, but I've just got a brand new Fiesta for £15k, who's the smarter shopper eh?".

You're totally right. Plus it's not just price, it's about reducing waste and having an environmental conscience.

People who claim it's more expensive have have obviously never looked (the super overpriced listings are promptly reduced). If they hate secondhand so much it's unlikely they have actual seen the sites or shops themselves.

Good on you for getting a bargain, getting good stuff secondhand is so rewarding.

speakout · 01/01/2022 19:43

ForestLake
No. I just don't like second hand.

Do you use nothing second hand?

MollysDolly · 01/01/2022 19:36

All that stuff you buy second hand costs more than the stuff I buy brand new. Honestly couldn't bring myself to spend 800 quid on a TV unit, never mind a second hand one.

Well no, it doesn't all cost more, does it. You aren't buying new dresses for £2. Or a new cot, changing unit and wardrobe, all for £80.

What you mean is, you've picked one of the two examples of items (where I've saved thousands and thousands) and suggested that because the amount paid is higher than a cheap new item, that this means it is expensive compared to your new items. Which is logically, nonsense. Because whether I'm saving £8 on something that would have cost £10, or £800 on something that would have cost £1000, I'm paying 20% of the new price.

Saying "oh, well I'll only pay £100 for something new, so your stuff is more expensive" actually equates to "I'll only pay £100 for something, which you'd buy second hand for £20." You're comparing apples and pears.

I'm making enormous savings. You are paying full price. What your full price is, is kind of irrelevant, as for me to purchase the equivalent would be 80% cheaper.

You're essentially saying, "I know you've just bought that £100k Aston for £20k, but I've just got a brand new Fiesta for £15k, who's the smarter shopper eh?".

ForestLake · 01/01/2022 12:13

No. I just don't like second hand.

Gonnagetgoing · 01/01/2022 12:11

@Classicblunder

I recently discovered that you can put fabric shoes through the washing machine and they come out really nice!

I agree with the points about gait/developing feet though - what I do is buy one pair of new shoes but use second hand ones as spares (for when the usual pair is very muddy or wet etc)

@Classicblunder - good point re second hand shoes to use as spares.

For info - I and my mum have bought nephew (3.5) boots and fabric shoes/trainers from Tu Sainsbury’s and they’re excellent especially for park etc.

Gonnagetgoing · 01/01/2022 12:07

I wouldn’t buy second hand clothes for kids I don’t know well (eg other niece and nephew) unless I asked their parents as some might not want second hand clothes.

Gonnagetgoing · 01/01/2022 12:06

@showersandflowers

Yes, and I plan to until she's old enough to decide her own style/ want particular clothes. I actually get bundles of clothes free off Facebook market place (surprising how many people just want to get rid of baby/toddler clothes without wanting any money for them) and give them a hot wash. Not all items are winners but I just use those on "home days". I must have saved thousands in some cases! They grow so quickly!
@showersandflowers - I’ve found loads of bundles of eg shorts for nephew, one of his favourite striped jumpers is a Tu Sainsbury’s one and I’ve got mini Boden jumpers there too. His mum prefers Zara kids clothes but I said if she fancies selling new kids clothes there which ones sell on well and which ones to buy.

I do buy him new clothes but lots of brands new like Matalan, Tu Sainsbury’s, Tesco’s, John Lewis as he grows quickly. Certain items like long sleeved T-shirt’s are great too.

Hand me downs are great and I hope are kept for his cousins or another child.