Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Off-lead dog running over to my on-lead dog, other owner responds aggressively

108 replies

yellowleaves123 · 31/12/2021 16:13

For some reason I can't shake this so coming to AIBU.

I took my dog for a gentle walk this afternoon. He is recovering from an injury so was on a long-lead, to prevent him running but also so that I could communicate to other people that he doesn't want to say hi to their dogs today (I reel some lead in for this - it's not an annoying flexilead, it is a highly visible bright lead that you can't miss at all). This is what I did with other dogs I saw, whose owners respected this and didn't let their dogs approach.

We were in an empty field so he had a bit of lead with freedom to move around and sniff but could be shortened. Part of it got tangled in a branch that had been blown over so I was untangling it. As I did, an off-lead dog appeared out of nowhere and charged towards my dog. He was a few metres away from me as I was reeling his line in and it was stuck on a branch. I called to the owner "he is recovering from injury so is on-lead and won't want to say hello to yours". The man smiled and did nothing. After five seconds or so of looking super uncomfortable with a dog sniffing his face (which most dogs don't like anyway let alone when in pain), my dog asked the other dog to move. It didn't, so he chased it away (out of character behaviour because he is injured). He made a bit of noise whilst doing so but didn't make any contact - he wouldn't. By chase away, I mean he ran the couple of metres of his lead he had back to me and the dog happened to run alongside him.

The guy then shouts "FOR F* SAKE". I asked why he let his dog run up to on-lead dogs (there was another on-lead dog with me and a friend, that one was fine but is nervous so isn't let off), and he said "this is a woodland, your dog shouldn't do that". I told him that I have as much entitlement to walk my dog as he does his, and mine was on-lead, his shouldn't have approached or he should have recalled it.

He made a big scene of checking his dog over (fine to do - I witnessed the whole thing happen and my dog didn't touch his but did make some noise, as dogs do when communicating) and went on without saying anything. I did note that he put his dog on a lead afterwards. For some reason I can't stop thinking about it - I think because it's a normal walking spot for me and I don't want people to get the wrong idea about my dog. This was out of character for him due to recovering from an injury, and because his lead was around a big branch it was tight. My dog is generally comfortable with small dogs (which this was), doesn't like GSDs so we just avoid them.

I think I'm just a bit more flustered as the man got aggressive, usually people acknowledge that the other dog was on a lead.

YABU - you're in the wrong and should have apologised
YANBU - the man should have recalled his dog when you said yours was injured and on-lead, and not blamed you

I should add I work with dogs professionally so in terms of reading the incident etc I know that my dog did nothing but make a bit of noise to clear the other dog off. Feeling extra touchy over the last few days...aunt flo is due.

OP posts:
Soggymarshmellows · 31/12/2021 18:12

Ahh just remembered we recently had a bouncy dog run over in the park and take our dogs ball...pretty normal, and doesn't usually bother me. And we usually get it back of course. Except twatty male owner- bit of a hugh grant in the 90s type - couldn't get his dog to give it back or even get the dog back on lead to get it back. He didn't even say anything to us to acknowledge this, just looked away.. then in style of rom-com chased this dog for a good 10 minutes. Dog had zero respect for him and he even skidded over at one point (like the film Marley and me) trying to attach the lead. My dc were cracking up. In the end (he'd still not even said anything) our ddog was sitting there looking at it all with disdain. I shouted 'keep the ball ' put our dog on lead and went home.
Why on earth did he even have his dog off lead in a residential park?! He was another of the know-it-all/no nothing owners I seem to be encountering at the moment and probably similar to your one.
In the same park I had an owner get narky with me because her dog retrieved a ball she'd thrown and he brought it back to me and dropped it at my feet, so I kicked it. She shouted after me 'he's my dog!'. Flipping crazy...

Goawayangryman · 31/12/2021 18:11

My point about the faultless judgement is that I'm confident that my dog would not engage further if a dog shows signs of not wanting to engage at all. She will appraise from a distance and not approach if other dog looks unhappy. That accounts for most scenarios with reactive dogs, but not with those that are injured and may think they want to play, which is where the issue arises. And where I appreciate I have work to do in terms of better anticipating the problem ahead and clipping her on.

People and dogs make the occasional mistake and in that case a profuse apology is what's needed I think.

TheWernethWife · 31/12/2021 18:10

Our friends elderly female greyhound was bitten by a large mastiff type dog, not on a lead, it just ran over to her. She pulled her lead out of our friend's hand and bolted in terror.

yellowleaves123 · 31/12/2021 18:09

I don't like long lines as I think they are hazardous and my police dog handler trainer agrees. Also... How do they actually learn in this way?

Dogs can't practice meet and greet habits and can practice recall instead. They will avoid negative experiences with other dogs that don't want to say hi. Other dogs will also avoid negative experiences with greetings they weren't comfortable with.

OP posts:
Goawayangryman · 31/12/2021 18:06

I do understand the logic of longlines but I think our trainer's view is that you instead teach recall hard, fast and first, which is what we've been doing with her. The dog needs to make up it's own mind to do what you want and be amply rewarded for it, not be hauled back for infractions. I totally trust her method so I will be sticking with what she says, despite feeling edgy sometimes. She knows her stuff I think..

But to the OP.... it's not you. He was a dick.

RedHelenB · 31/12/2021 18:05

My dog is mostly on lead due to shocking recall if other dogs are present but he loves to say hello and round my way most people with dogs on lead let them say hello unless they are reactive or whatever.

liveforsummer · 31/12/2021 18:00

They learn on long lines because it's like being free but you have a safety net. Police may have different criteria but I don't know a single pet dog trainer who doesn't advocate them. Why does your dog need leeway if it's judgement is faultless?

Clymene · 31/12/2021 17:59

@Moonface123

This is precisely why l won' t get another dog. Dog walking has become way too complicated ,and takes all the fun out of it, when l was young we always walked our dogs miles off lead, never an issue, now totally different story, most dog owners look utterly miserable or very anxious when out walking their dog, and l am sure their dog picks up on it. You are now treated like a criminal for allowing your dog off lead, even if dog is elderly lurcher zero interest in other dogs or humans.
There is nothing wrong with having dogs off lead if they have excellent recall and will leave dogs on lead alone.

If your dog trots alongside you happily, ignoring all other dogs, you're not the problem.

A lot of people got dogs in lockdown which are poorly socialised and poorly trained. With incompetent owners.

Goawayangryman · 31/12/2021 17:58

Pup's dog-body-language skills are faultless. She would never try to greet a dog that was giving off fuck off vibes.

Querty123456 · 31/12/2021 17:57

My tuppence here is that in this sort of situation you need to be ultra clear about what you want. So I would have said at the top of my voice, “get your dog on a lead please”and then explained the situation after and thank them etc. it’s all to easy to misunderstand the situation, especially outside, with the wind blowing/ distracted etc plus lots of people with straight forward dogs are simply mooching along enjoying their walk, they’ve not got the hyper vigilance needed when you’ve got a injured/ sensitive one. So it’s best to be super clear, long sentences about injuries/ friendliness etc will often be misheard or misunderstood.

Goawayangryman · 31/12/2021 17:57

I don't like long lines as I think they are hazardous and my police dog handler trainer agrees. Also... How do they actually learn in this way?

liveforsummer · 31/12/2021 17:55

@Goawayangryman for now your friendly exuberant pup needs to be on a long line. Some dogs hate exuberant and it's a good way for yours to get hurt

Goawayangryman · 31/12/2021 17:53

Totally not unreasonable and your man was a prize plonker. I HATE men like this who just think they are always right and have to knock women down a peg or two, which is what he was trying to do. However...I'd plead for a tiny bit of leeway for a daft puppy who is still learning manners (mine) and totally over-friendly with everything that moves... I always, always put her back on lead if there is an elderly or infirm.person on dog, or a dog on any kind of lead. However... It's hard to proof a recall if you never ever go out of a comfort zone/enclosed area/place devoid of exciting other dogs.

I think it is also probably much easier if you have a dog that is standoffish with other dogs and humans, or naturally wary. If you've got an over exhuberant "greeter" type the odd slip up is embarrassing but inevitable. I would always apologise profusely though.

Soggymarshmellows · 31/12/2021 17:47

I am so happy to read this thread. Obviously not because of what happened but because my little gentle dog got attacked while on the lead about 6 weeks ago. Required vets etc. (Thats another story..apparently it was all my dogs fault according to the awful owner who also was nasty. She is a fluffy small dog and was on a lead and the other was a vicious lurcher and off lead and owner didn't have their dog in sight. Came out of nowhere and rolled mine. Took 2 men to pull it off).
Now my little dog is reactive on lead. Getting better but it frightened her a lot. When other dogs approach and she's on lead she growls. I've had so many people tut at me or comment that my dog is growling or try to get my dog to play or deliberately bring their dogs over during the last month. Been getting me down as it doesn't help at all. Have had to explain dozens of times that my dog was attacked and is still sensitive (she goes to dog walker and home day care and has been fine there with her doggy friends...just strange dogs esp. Big ones). I wish people would understand why dogs growl as a warning.
My dog is happier off lead in open spaces as she feels she can control her escape (but comes to hide by me now when big dogs approach). I hope with time she'll improve.

yellowleaves123 · 31/12/2021 17:40

he could bite a person or another animal.

He would not bite a person or animal. This was normal dog to dog communication to ask an in his face dog to go away. There was zero intent behind it. My dog has been attacked several times by other dogs and even in those situations has never made contact, just makes noise to ask them to get away. He is incredibly affectionate towards people. Dog to dog escalated communication can often sound a bit scary because we perceive any noises from dogs as attacks when that is how they talk if subtle communication is ignored.

OP posts:
FizzyTango · 31/12/2021 17:39

Story of my life. My dog is reactive so always on a lead and the number of dickhead dog owners that don’t understand they need TO RECALL YOUR DOG AWAY FROM A DOG ON A LEAD. It boils my piss. You aren’t in the wrong op.

LynxGiftsetAndSocks · 31/12/2021 17:37

@cansu

I also don't buy this idea that just because he is on a lead of some kind he is under your control. If he has a few metres and can chase off another dog, he could bite a person or another animal.
But he didn't

YOU could bite a person or animal. But don't .

LynxGiftsetAndSocks · 31/12/2021 17:35

Op

You were in the right.... it's your job. You know you were

Mumsnetters LOVE to make a wrong-doing out of nothing and will clutch at straws ( and pearls) to the end of time!

Hope your dog has a good recovery

yellowleaves123 · 31/12/2021 17:35

It sounds a little like your dog was on quite a long lead if he was able to chase the other dog!

It was a couple of metres, he just chased him away from my immediate area, no distance. Just made the dog clear off out of his face when he didn't after other communication hadn't worked.

OP posts:
cansu · 31/12/2021 17:35

I also don't buy this idea that just because he is on a lead of some kind he is under your control. If he has a few metres and can chase off another dog, he could bite a person or another animal.

ErrolTheDragon · 31/12/2021 17:35

if your dog is in danger of injury from other dogs you shouldn't take it out

That's the most ludicrous comment I've ever seen on a dog thread, I think.

My previous dog had his eye injured by a boisterous boxer - and thereafter wanted to take revenge on all of that breed.

My current dog is a nearly 16 yo dachshund. He doesn't go out much, but had a few excursions this summer - fortunately other dog owners were civilised and didn't really need to have it explained that a 'friendly' paw in the wrong place could be disastrous.

Anyway, of course YANBU, op. Don't worry about what people may think - if they've got any sense it will be 'that guy was well out of order'

Whammyyammy · 31/12/2021 17:34

@stevalnamechanger

Yesterday my friends on lead dog attacked another woman's dogs , who rushed up to him ... owner not in sight and started jumping all over him .

Owner had no recall and seemed to think it was the on lead owners fault

When will people bloody learn !

We had a similar incident, and police were involved as other owner said he had been bitten by our dog. Luckily we wear a body cam, which showed off lead dog bound 30 meters from its drive, down the lane to us and start on my dogs. It got pinned down and warned by my big boy, then came back for more and got bitten hard. Owner was nowhere near us or our dogs, he got aggressive but my husband is a big guy so ge backed down sharpish.

He called the police and said he got bit saving his on lead dog from ours. We showed the police the video of us walking our dogs on lead and his off lead dog coming up to us and owner nowhere near during the whole event. Police obviously didn't take any action against us and apologised but informed other owner his dog is not to be off lead in public again, which they ignore, but they soon put it on a lead if they see my dogs.

HikingforScenery · 31/12/2021 17:34

Those longline leads are annoying tbh. They don’t seem to enable the dog walker to have proper control. I’ve seen people holding leads with no idea of what their dogs are up to metres away so can’t intervene. What’s the point?

yellowleaves123 · 31/12/2021 17:34

You say you work with dogs professionally so this can't be he first time you've met an arsehole owner, shit happens, both dogs are OK so let it go.

Correct. I'm due on and feeling a bit sensitive. I think the aggression from the man triggered me more than it should have. If anyone else was telling me this happened I'd tell them not to worry.

He probably knew he was in the wrong, then when your dog gave his a fright, he reacted (like so many people do when on the defensive) with aggression.

Yes this makes sense

OP posts:
cansu · 31/12/2021 17:33

It sounds a little like your dog was on quite a long lead if he was able to chase the other dog!

He shouldn't have let his approach yours but it also doesn't really sound like you had yours under proper control either.