Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Off-lead dog running over to my on-lead dog, other owner responds aggressively

108 replies

yellowleaves123 · 31/12/2021 16:13

For some reason I can't shake this so coming to AIBU.

I took my dog for a gentle walk this afternoon. He is recovering from an injury so was on a long-lead, to prevent him running but also so that I could communicate to other people that he doesn't want to say hi to their dogs today (I reel some lead in for this - it's not an annoying flexilead, it is a highly visible bright lead that you can't miss at all). This is what I did with other dogs I saw, whose owners respected this and didn't let their dogs approach.

We were in an empty field so he had a bit of lead with freedom to move around and sniff but could be shortened. Part of it got tangled in a branch that had been blown over so I was untangling it. As I did, an off-lead dog appeared out of nowhere and charged towards my dog. He was a few metres away from me as I was reeling his line in and it was stuck on a branch. I called to the owner "he is recovering from injury so is on-lead and won't want to say hello to yours". The man smiled and did nothing. After five seconds or so of looking super uncomfortable with a dog sniffing his face (which most dogs don't like anyway let alone when in pain), my dog asked the other dog to move. It didn't, so he chased it away (out of character behaviour because he is injured). He made a bit of noise whilst doing so but didn't make any contact - he wouldn't. By chase away, I mean he ran the couple of metres of his lead he had back to me and the dog happened to run alongside him.

The guy then shouts "FOR F* SAKE". I asked why he let his dog run up to on-lead dogs (there was another on-lead dog with me and a friend, that one was fine but is nervous so isn't let off), and he said "this is a woodland, your dog shouldn't do that". I told him that I have as much entitlement to walk my dog as he does his, and mine was on-lead, his shouldn't have approached or he should have recalled it.

He made a big scene of checking his dog over (fine to do - I witnessed the whole thing happen and my dog didn't touch his but did make some noise, as dogs do when communicating) and went on without saying anything. I did note that he put his dog on a lead afterwards. For some reason I can't stop thinking about it - I think because it's a normal walking spot for me and I don't want people to get the wrong idea about my dog. This was out of character for him due to recovering from an injury, and because his lead was around a big branch it was tight. My dog is generally comfortable with small dogs (which this was), doesn't like GSDs so we just avoid them.

I think I'm just a bit more flustered as the man got aggressive, usually people acknowledge that the other dog was on a lead.

YABU - you're in the wrong and should have apologised
YANBU - the man should have recalled his dog when you said yours was injured and on-lead, and not blamed you

I should add I work with dogs professionally so in terms of reading the incident etc I know that my dog did nothing but make a bit of noise to clear the other dog off. Feeling extra touchy over the last few days...aunt flo is due.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Darbs76 · 01/01/2022 08:57

The other owner is in the wrong. Off lead dogs should NOT be allowed to approach on lead dogs. Yet this happens again and again and again. I’m sick of irresponsible owners who allow it to happen and then try and blame you!! You can tell I’ve had experience of this, over and over.

yellowleaves123 · 01/01/2022 08:55

Thanks for all of your responses. Was feeling quite sensitive when this happened and the man's reaction threw me. I'm hoping we won't see them again even when my boy is better as clearly the dog has no recall and shouldn't have been off lead anyway. It was also really rude in doggy speak (charging over and getting in a dog's face) so I don't think mine will be the last dog to tell it off.

OP posts:
Runnerduck34 · 01/01/2022 00:56

If the man heard you say your dog was recovering from an injury he should have called his dog away. Your dog clearly growled and chased his dog which could be interpreted as aggressive but the man clearly overreacted and shouldn't have shouted and sworn.
For now I would keep your dog on a shorter lead just so he can't run and hurt himself and you can more easily keep him away from other dogs whilst he recovers .
It's just one of those things put it from your mind and move on.

Mochudubh · 31/12/2021 20:23

YANBU

I say this as a serial GSD owner. We once owned a very reactive BC "Bella", who was never off lead unless I could be absolutely sure there were no other dogs around. One boxing day, I, my DC and the dog were at our local park. DC sliding on a frozen pond and the dog on lead. I was aware of a woman repeatedly shouting "Timmy, Timmy" but it was fairly distant so wasn' t too bothered. Then DC wanted to go to play area so we headed off, only to have a little yappy poodly thing in a pink jacket keep coming up to "Bella", who kept turning round and growling at " Timmy" who wouldn't take the hint so she barked and lunged at him ( still on lead so didn't make contact). The woman came rushing up and I snapped ( don't think I farted) and told her to get her bloody dog on a lead.

She was very huffy and said "Timmy" wasn't used to such antisocial dogs. I responded that Timmy had invaded my dog's space and she was on a lead for the very reason that she was anti social and the woman was lucky Bella was a BC and not a bigger breed that would have Timmy's bloody head off.

She did a sort of "well, really"! Head toss and stalked off, but she did put the dog on a lead.

We're back to GSDs now and while I know they're generally better natured than BCs, not everyone does, or even like dogs at all, so I keep mine away until I know otherwise.

You did nothing wrong OP.

WhoKnowsProbsNotMe · 31/12/2021 19:11

Also she is always off lead, however walks past other dogs like their not their and will take a wide berth if they are voicing that they aren’t keen on her 😂

WhoKnowsProbsNotMe · 31/12/2021 19:10

I wouldn’t worry about it these things happen and if you’re a dog owner you k ow there’s a BIG difference between a dog “shouting” at another dog to leave it alone and attacking another dog! My dogs really a people person, she’s totally fine in the company of other dogs and will happily let them chase her chasing her ball and pick up her ball but she will have something to say about a dog continuously jumping up at her face or god forbid trying to hump her 😂 but that’s how it works in the dog world she has never and would never actually bite another dog. It’s so strange anyone or any child regardless of age could do anything to her but she just won’t tolerate another dog jumping at her face and no other dog owner has ever had an issue with her reaction to their dog in face the opposite (especially with pups) where the other owner will say it’s a good thing for her to tell them off so they know what’s ok and what’s too much - also fyi she herself has been told off many times in her life and I’ve never had issue with it x

yellowleaves123 · 31/12/2021 19:08

Agree @liveforsummer the amount of times I have to ask people to call their off lead dog away from my toddler it's ridiculous. "Oh he loves kids" I literally could not care less. My dog loves children but I'd never, ever let him approach kids he doesn't know unless they asked if they could say hi and he seemed interested as well.

OP posts:
liveforsummer · 31/12/2021 19:00

The problem is there are odd lead dogs everywhere now. They are on our Cory paths weaving in and out of cyclists, families, approaching other dogs while their owners had a chat with their companion. My dog also has 99.9 recall however is always on loess on the path as she could change direction quickly and get in the way of a fast moving bike or a child who was scared of dogs. Sadly many don't seem to have the same consideration

Brigante9 · 31/12/2021 18:58

My adult dog dislikes untrained dogs banging up to him so we’re very careful to ensure he’s comfortable/occupied with retrieves. I’m currently training the 2 puppies to greet other dogs politely (sit, no stupidity) because I don’t want to be that arsehole owner that others hate. You absolutely weren’t unreasonable.

yellowleaves123 · 31/12/2021 18:58

The man was in the wrong however if you have a dog on lead I wouldn't take them to a place that has predominantly off lead dogs, not everyone has well trained dogs, we know that!

Mostly the dogs that walk here are elderly or on lead. It isn't a busy dog walking spot. If it wasn't my dog that told this one to scarper, it would be somebody else's.

OP posts:
gogohm · 31/12/2021 18:53

The man was in the wrong however if you have a dog on lead I wouldn't take them to a place that has predominantly off lead dogs, not everyone has well trained dogs, we know that!

My ddog is not keen on other dogs but he's got 99.9% recall and can be sent in different directions at speed (sheepdog) so I'm pretty confident but if he's on lead eg recently recuperating from surgery we walk in on lead areas eg streets or on a short lead

vivainsomnia · 31/12/2021 18:51

Mine was on a lead and his was not, I believe a lead constitutes control
A lead that was metered long that meant he could chase the other dog a couple of metres. That's not controlling your dog.

The guy was no doubt in the wrong should have called his dog back immediately but you should have been able to also get your dog next to you quickly and you couldn't because the lead was too long and tangled.

Xogozil · 31/12/2021 18:49

I’ve got an elderly lab, bit of arthritis so she plods along. If I see a lively dog around I slip her lead on and most dog owners see this, clock she’s an older dog and call theirs away, some even slip a lead on to keep their dog away. At least once a week she’ll get a young, bouncy dog ( is it Vizla’s that seem to be the latest in dog?) running at her, one even tried to mount her recently —— always a man on his own as the owner. 99% of the time they ignore their dog, ignore its behaviour.

WowIlikereallyhateyou · 31/12/2021 18:40

YANBU, i have been yelled at when telling off lead dog owners not to come to my reactive dog. The numptys usually say it is me who cant control my dog as it is on a lead. No WORDS for these kind of special fuckwits.Arrrrrrgggggghhhh.

liveforsummer · 31/12/2021 18:36

@BertieQueen

This annoys me so much! Unless a dog has 100% recall and doesn’t approach other dogs without being invited to it should be on a lead.

My dog is always on lead, she doesn’t like other dogs approaching her out of no where, I have lost count at the amount of times I have had to ask people to recall their dogs while we have been out for a stroll, the same old line ‘but they are friendly’ really boils my piss too! I don’t care how friendly you think your dog is, get it away from mine now. Angry

My response now to 'he's friendly' is to say well Mine isn't. Not entirely true she's friendly enough but just doesn't want jumped over by strange dogs who are frequently 4/5 times or more her size and weight
Whistleforthechoir · 31/12/2021 18:34

I don't have a dog. Don't like dogs. Dog owners like this guy drive me crazy. They let their pets come bounding up to people, children, other dogs and jump all over you; then get aggressive when you politely ask them to get them off.

There are way too many selfish pricks that live near me who think their dogs' rights trump everybody else's. Makes my blood boil.

BertieQueen · 31/12/2021 18:27

This annoys me so much! Unless a dog has 100% recall and doesn’t approach other dogs without being invited to it should be on a lead.

My dog is always on lead, she doesn’t like other dogs approaching her out of no where, I have lost count at the amount of times I have had to ask people to recall their dogs while we have been out for a stroll, the same old line ‘but they are friendly’ really boils my piss too! I don’t care how friendly you think your dog is, get it away from mine now. Angry

SoupDragon · 31/12/2021 18:27

I am so fed up with dog owners allowing their off led dogs to bound up to my on-lead one. They really don't give a shit.

curlymom · 31/12/2021 18:23

I have two puppies who are impeccable behaved as I have made training a priority. The boy does get excited when he sees other dogs so stays on lead most.y and the girl just stays by me like glue. An off lead dog came up to my girl while she was on lead in summer and scratched her face. I was furious. The owner laughed and said that’s what dogs do so I told him to disappear using not such polite language. Sometimes doge do the wrong thing but we need to apologise. As I am a total dog lady I now ignore the idiot owners and communicate to the dog myself. A shot sharp NO on approach will stop them in their tracks. Then tell owner to act. Sometimes they apologise which is great. If they don’t, they can get lost. I tell them.
I hope your dog is ok x

yellowleaves123 · 31/12/2021 18:23

The thing is people think socialising is about letting them play (or be told off), it isn't - it's teaching them to ignore other dogs unless invited not to. It's not fair on an older dog to have to socialise a young puppy to their own distress. It's the humans job

I agree completely. My general advice for socialisation is to teach dogs to be calm around other dogs, to be able to ignore dogs, and to spend time around puppy tolerant adults so that they can see how they communicate with each other and learn social skills. My dog doesn't want to be jumped all over by puppies (many don't) and it's not beneficial for either adult or pup for anyone to have to be told off.

OP posts:
Janeandjohnny · 31/12/2021 18:22

You are totally in the right but he was a dick so would not listen. Its always hard with off lead dogs. I probably would have blocked the other dog more and made it move myself. Could you have got a stay or sit on yours and then moved the other? Awful.

Stellaris22 · 31/12/2021 18:22

One of the best things we did for our dog was introduce her as a puppy to older dogs (with owners permission). It's great because the older dogs told her off when she was too much (all puppies are a pain) and she learned doggy interaction from those older dogs.

She'd now pretty much bomb proof with all dogs. Owners of nervous dogs remark on how calm she is around their dogs while she loves full on playing with more confident dogs.

I really think socialisation as young as possible is important, so then you don't get 'rude' behaviour like jumping all over other dogs that aren't ok with it.

liveforsummer · 31/12/2021 18:19

@yellowleaves123

Pup's dog-body-language skills are faultless. She would never try to greet a dog that was giving off fuck off vibes.

That's great and becoming more and more rare as dogs aren't being socialised with puppy tolerant adult dogs, just other puppies who can't read dog body language, so nobody learns from anyone.

The thing is people think socialising is about letting them play (or be told off), it isn't - it's teaching them to ignore other dogs unless invited not to. It's not fair on an older dog to have to socialise a young puppy to their own distress. It's the humans job
liveforsummer · 31/12/2021 18:17

@Goawayangryman

My point about the faultless judgement is that I'm confident that my dog would not engage further if a dog shows signs of not wanting to engage at all. She will appraise from a distance and not approach if other dog looks unhappy. That accounts for most scenarios with reactive dogs, but not with those that are injured and may think they want to play, which is where the issue arises. And where I appreciate I have work to do in terms of better anticipating the problem ahead and clipping her on.

People and dogs make the occasional mistake and in that case a profuse apology is what's needed I think.

My dog would completely ignore yours in that circumstance though . She'd only react if it ran straight up to her after deciding she was friendly because no dh lad being given off . She 100% wouldn't hurt her but she certainly sounds like she might she's probably fighter you and your dog and would further make mine dislike stance boundy dogs . Another dog might not just be all noise though. If your recall is so solid and methods effective you for need leeway. Until then a longline doesn't emergencies is wise ...
yellowleaves123 · 31/12/2021 18:16

Pup's dog-body-language skills are faultless. She would never try to greet a dog that was giving off fuck off vibes.

That's great and becoming more and more rare as dogs aren't being socialised with puppy tolerant adult dogs, just other puppies who can't read dog body language, so nobody learns from anyone.

OP posts: