Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

2k a year pay rise = £66 extra a month!

163 replies

missbunnyrabbit · 31/12/2021 15:11

I'm a teacher and was so excited to go the next point on the scale. Checked my pay today, the first pay with my new salary approved on it, to see I get a grand total of £66 extra a month!

2k sounds like such a lot! But it really isn't after everything is taken off.

Am I being ungrateful?Confused

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Cocomarine · 31/12/2021 21:12

@UniversalAunt

Is ‘career average’ worked over the x many years of service or average of the last three years of service?

Over a 40 year stretch is quite a thing.

I’m in a private company scheme, but to give you an idea… Each year I accrue another year at the salary for that year, so let’s say I earn 1/60th per year, and my salary is £30K - I’d have earned £500 per annum for life after retirement. Of course, in 20 years time, £500 won’t be worth what £500 is now. So each year, that £500 is increased by a factor that is linked to inflation. I say linked - it’s the higher of several measures, but has a cap as the company can’t have unpredictable liability if inflation spirals. The cap is 2.5% - it can be reviewed, but that’s the guaranteed maximum increase. So it is in theory protected from inflation.
UniversalAunt · 31/12/2021 21:09

@Goinghome20, so have I got this right?

If you take retirement at 60yo, you will have accumulated a total of 29 years service out of a potential 40 years (if this is the period time required to get full entitlement of x/y or 5/8ths of your averaged out pensionable pay?

Which by my ready reckoner is roughly 45% of the ‘average’ of your pensionable pay.

So it seems that the lower salary of your part-time hours & the fewer ‘years’ will take a lump crunch out of your projected pension.

Have you checked out the pensions scheme’s T&Cs? In your remaining 6 years, can you buy some extra years so that you can leave with closer to 40 years to get the full 5/8ths (?).

AVCs are a smart move as you get tax relief immediately into that investment vehicle.

As an aside, we should all seek to gain our own financial independence & that means getting to grips with the nuts & bolts of what we do with the money we earn.

My mum was a very hard working dedicated teacher, gifted at her subject & much admired. She got a severe kick in her teeth when she went to claim her pension to find that paying a married woman’s stamp all those years ago left her with the paltriest of pensions. She had to claim income support etc just to get by & she was ashamed of that as she had worked so hard. I learned my lessons about money from that.

If you have a public sector pension, make sure that you are making very good use of it & gearing it now to yield either an earlier retirement &/or a better pension. It is a valuable asset.

brieandbacon · 31/12/2021 21:03

@JinglingHellsBells

One issue that people forget is that in very few private companies do employees get an automatic pay rise simply for being in the job for longer. This tends to be a government/public sector 'perk'.

Most private companies review salaries on merit and performance and may give a cost of living annual increase but it's never guaranteed.

Exactly this! And to me that is a massive pay rise. I got £200 extra a year in my last payrise. After deductions I could just about buy myself a half of cider a week (or was it a month?) A lot of my colleagues got nothing at all. Used to be in the NHS and loved my incremental pay rises as well as a yearly cost of living one
HandScreen · 31/12/2021 20:49

@missbunnyrabbit

Thanks for all the replies. I've plugged everything into a few different calculators and there's some variance by 20 or 30 pounds. My NI is higher than it says on the calculators, but then I did the government one specifically for that and it came out right. Also my tax code is 1257L/0, but my tax paid matches the calculators so I'm guessing that's right.

Also I've had the backdated pay, that was included in last months, so this month's pay should be the correct salary.

Sadly it does all seem to be right. I'm just so disappointed!! Never ever thought I would consider touching my pension but....I am. Maybe. Shock

But it's £166 gross pay rise per month, it's fair enough that you get around £87 of this and more into your pension. What had you expected to get into your hand out of the £166?
UniversalAunt · 31/12/2021 20:48

Is ‘career average’ worked over the x many years of service or average of the last three years of service?

Over a 40 year stretch is quite a thing.

HandScreen · 31/12/2021 20:45

@Goinghome20

Well at 54yo I have found out that teachers pensions are actually not that great.

Been teaching for 23 years. 9 years FT, 14 years PT. If I retire at 60 I will get 6k a year and yes our monthly pension contributions have gone up a lot over past 4 years.

Lots of young teachers dont bother now as they need that money for rent, and I kind of wish I hadn't bothered either now.

But £6k a year is £500 a month - far more than you put in! What did you expect?
Gcandproud · 31/12/2021 20:41

@twominutesmore

Does anyone know whether the calculator projections on the Teachers Pensions site are in 'today's money' or take inflation into account? I rang and emailed and was told both times that it is in today's money but some posts here suggest otherwise.
Interesting. I have been told in clear terms on here that it’s not today’s money 🤷‍♀️
Gcandproud · 31/12/2021 20:35

@JinglingHellsBells

That lump sum does not make sense.

You are allowed a lump sum of 25% of your pension 'pot'. So someone with a £1M pension pot can take £250K max, tax free.

That sort of figure you're quoting, in today's income, applies mainly to anyone on a minimum salary of £100K with 45 years of pension contributions.

I know teachers with 45 years' work, full time, and their pensions are nothing like £50K.

Surely also depends on the rate of contribution? Members of TPS pay in about 25% of their gross salary per annum (10% from employee and the rest from the employer). So my contributions and therefore the size of my pension would be more than someone on a higher salary who paid in less. When I worked in private sector, my employer paid 3%
JinglingHellsBells · 31/12/2021 20:20

That lump sum does not make sense.

You are allowed a lump sum of 25% of your pension 'pot'. So someone with a £1M pension pot can take £250K max, tax free.

That sort of figure you're quoting, in today's income, applies mainly to anyone on a minimum salary of £100K with 45 years of pension contributions.

I know teachers with 45 years' work, full time, and their pensions are nothing like £50K.

ForensicAccountant · 31/12/2021 20:06

JinglingHellsBells

@GCAndProud So your pension will be 4/5ths of your salary of £50K plus a lump sum of £270K? I think you have miscalculated somewhere.

Yeah it does sound high but that is what came up and I did check quite carefully that I put in the correct info. Someone else is welcome to try doing the calculation using my details if they want to. I’m FT with no breaks, born in 1984 and earn 51000. I joined in 2013. I’ve not accounted for my salary increasing since I joined but I’ve equally not estimated any pay rises during that period.

The teachers' pension scheme changed in 2007. Although there was an automatic lump sum of 3x annual pension in the pre 2007 scheme, if you only joined in 2013 you do not have an automatic lump sum. Part of the annual pension can be commuted to lump sum at a rate of 1:12, i.e. giving up £1,000 of annual pension will give a lump sum of £12,000.

twominutesmore · 31/12/2021 19:56

Does anyone know whether the calculator projections on the Teachers Pensions site are in 'today's money' or take inflation into account? I rang and emailed and was told both times that it is in today's money but some posts here suggest otherwise.

ThinWomansBrain · 31/12/2021 19:23

listentotaxman.com/
is an excellent site for checking gross to net deductions; I'm an accountant, and it's always the first thing I use rather than wotking it out myself.

Just be thankful that you're not receiving universal credit - the marginal clawback on that is really punitive.

If you're in a gov't funded role, your salary comes out of everyone's tax and NI - makes it difficult to complain about it.

GCAndProud · 31/12/2021 19:13

Aha okay yeah I get the inflation point now, duh. From looking at it again, it would be more like 75k lump sum and 25k income in todays terms which is still pretty good compared to most in the private sector. It’s definitely worth the monthly payments now when you’re younger because you’re unlikely to find anything better privately if you lose out on the employer contribution.

KiloWhat · 31/12/2021 19:13

@CallmeHendricks

My niece is paying for a complete new kitchen refurb with her annual bonus.

No, she's not a teacher.

I bought a kettle with mine.

Also not a teacher.

CallmeHendricks · 31/12/2021 19:10

My niece is paying for a complete new kitchen refurb with her annual bonus.

No, she's not a teacher.

Hyenaormeercat · 31/12/2021 18:56

I'm in retail , I got promoted..Great..but my pay rise was eaten up by commute cost...no better off after that and deductions...

Kite22 · 31/12/2021 18:55

It clearly states average pay there.

....yes, but the English language uses the word "average" in different ways - from 'typical' through the 'mean, median, mode' definitions. I think the pp was stating that most teachers don't get paid that amount.

JinglingHellsBells · 31/12/2021 18:48

&That’s a good point as I’m retiring in 30 years. It’s still pretty great compared to private sector I reckon!*

You're still missing the point.

That is allowing for 30 years of inflation. £40K in 2052 will not be what £40K is today.

JinglingHellsBells · 31/12/2021 18:46

@GCAndProud You are confused :)

GCAndProud · 31/12/2021 18:46

@spanieleyes

That's what you would get in 20 odd years time, with inflation and index linking added on. It's not the current rate.
That’s a good point as I’m retiring in 30 years. It’s still pretty great compared to private sector I reckon!
GlassHalfFullView · 31/12/2021 18:46

@GCAndProud

And here is the result which does look pretty high to be fair. I’d be happy with less btw.
Is that in todays money? Ie c50k value today which when you retire will actually be a lot more than this (but so will everything else)

Or is it c50k pension when you retire which might only be 30-40k in todays terms (sorry, I didn’t note ho along you have until you retire)

Hopefully it’s the first in which case that’s great

BarkminsterBlue · 31/12/2021 18:45

[quote mnahmnah]@BarkminsterBlue

But without taking on further TLR, senior leadership etc surely you should be able progress with pay if you are achieving and exceeding performance management targets? Year on year? I’ve been on exactly the same pay for ten years. I get some of, if not the best results in school every year. The Head describes me as one of his best HODs. But I will never be laid another penny. I love being a HOD. I would hate to be SLT. But as a bloody good HOD shouldn’t I be able to progress in pay?![/quote]
If you were an NHS doctor and decided that once you reached the level of consultant you did not want to progress further and did not want to take on teaching, or management, or clinical excellence awards, then your salary would progress no further.

If you were a police constable at the top of your band and decided you did not want to go for a sergeant role, your pay would progress no further.

See also civil service, nursing etc.

JinglingHellsBells · 31/12/2021 18:44

Ever heard of a private sector bonus?!

@jts19 Oooh no! What's one of those? Xmas Smile Do tell.

And you know they aren't guaranteed and are performance or company profit linked?

Cocomarine · 31/12/2021 18:44

[quote mnahmnah]@BarkminsterBlue

But without taking on further TLR, senior leadership etc surely you should be able progress with pay if you are achieving and exceeding performance management targets? Year on year? I’ve been on exactly the same pay for ten years. I get some of, if not the best results in school every year. The Head describes me as one of his best HODs. But I will never be laid another penny. I love being a HOD. I would hate to be SLT. But as a bloody good HOD shouldn’t I be able to progress in pay?![/quote]
No, I don’t think so. That’s why both public and private sector tend to have salary bands - so you can reward someone who is progressing at the same job level. But say you’re 10/10 amazing (I should probably say “outstanding” 😉) in your 10th year in the job - why should you get paid more than someone 10/10 outstanding in their 5th year? Would you in your 5th year feel a bit annoyed at a colleague not better than you getting more money for the same job?

100problems · 31/12/2021 18:43

@mnahmnah do you not get a TLR as Head of Dept? All our middle leaders get one the value of which increases depending on the size of their dept eg Science gets more than RE. We also have teachers that receive TLR3 for additional projects. We also have lead practitioners that are salaried on the leadership scale.

I concur teaching salaries are not comparable with private sector and teachers should receive better pay, but there is money for additional responsibility.