Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not get DPs family gifts?

64 replies

HangingOver · 31/12/2021 13:20

I'm a bit torn....DP is rubbish at remembering to get people gifts. He doesn't ever remember to get his family anything on time for Xmas and wouldn't know what to get them anyway, so usually ends up just putting some money in their accounts for them to get stuff for their kids. They give us not particularly expensive but obviously carefully thought-out gifts each year (the longer we've been together they've more obviously clearly chosen with me in mind too) and it makes me uncomfortable that we never get them anything nice/thoughtful.

On the one hand I love giving gifts and want to pay back their kindnesses but on the other hand there are three couples and seven kids, and two parents and steps... And I feel like it isn't my job. I do try to help with discussions as in the weeks leading up to Xmas he'll invariably say to the air around him a few times, 'I wonder what I should get X, Y and Z' but I just know if I get too involved I'll end up doing it all. My own family get their gifts carefully chosen wrapped and sent on time each year, as do our friends kids, all with DPs name on the cards...

AIBU to leave his family to him even though they clearly choose lovely gifts with me in mind too?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rosebel · 03/01/2022 00:51

Going back to when I first got together with DH I used to buy and wrap for his family and my family. Then I became a SAHM and it was easier for me to buy gifts as I had more time.
First year I went back to work I nearly killed myself trying to get everything done and told DH from then on to buy for his own family.
We tend to book a shopping day in December when we buy family gifts but it's still down to him to make sure everyone is brought for. Do you think he'd up his game if you did something like this?
Whatever you do don't fall in to the trap of buying for them. It's up to him to sort, if that means they get money then so be it.

Sn0tnose · 03/01/2022 00:46

We do a bit of a joint effort which works out at 50/50. There are a couple of my family members he’s picked up gifts for while he’s been out shopping and seen something they’d like and I’ve bought a couple of gifts for his family members if I’ve seen the right thing when I’ve been shopping. Never in a million years would he expect me to do anything for his side.

I think, if you’re embarrassed at how little thought he puts into his gifts and you want to help him, you could sit him down, tell him he’s lazy and he’s letting himself and his family down. Tell him he needs to ask parents what the kids want and he needs to think what the adults like and buy according. Tell him you’ll help him by telling him whether something is a good idea or not. And tell him that you’re only doing offering to help because you feel sorry for his family.

Do not do it for him though.

underneaththeash · 03/01/2022 00:34

If you're married maybe - not a partner's job.

Abcdefu · 03/01/2022 00:33

If you take over the gift buying for all can he take over a different routine task (with maybe less thought) like getting the kids uniforms,shoes,coats,schoolbags bought in Summer?

HunterGatherer · 03/01/2022 00:28

One of my DSs buys the most amazingly well thought out and generous gifts. However we hardly ever see him and he would be the last person on earth I'd ask yo help with anything oractical.
Our other DS is helpful and caring on a daily basis but when it comes to buying gifts he truly hasn't a clue, I got some socks with "Jeep" written on them and some Ferrero rocher this year. Hmm
I agree with the people saying work as a team and play to his strengths. Not because you are a woman but because it is obviously a strength of yours. Get him to pick up dome extra task in return.

2022HowDoYouDo · 02/01/2022 21:20

In our family my husband is rubbish at remembering gifts etc which I am good at. He can and does fix anything in the house and does techie stuff and all gardening so I just do the gifts for both sides is that all you do then?

Sometimeswinning · 02/01/2022 00:25

I had an argument with dh overtime tonight, how he had zero input into anything connected with our family or christmas. His reply is I'm a complete control freak over it and wouldnt let him anyway.

This Christmas we shall be shopping together and he can choose gifts for his children, nieces and nephews. It will be a first in the 12 years we've had children to buy for!

MojoMoon · 01/01/2022 23:52

@GiveOverIrene

I wonder if there's a man on the planet who feels guilty about not choosing, buying, wrapping and delivering gifts for his wife's family? Why is this still a thing in 2022 that if you have a vagina you must take on this responsibility for a man? He's more than capable so let him get on with it.
100pc this

Caitlin Moran said the way to define sexism was "are men doing it?"

Men are not worrying about the quality of Xmas gifts for their wife's family.

It is societal and cultural sexism that makes women believe they need to be doing the careful choosing of gifts and will be judged if they do not.

Dadsnet is not having this conversation

Holly60 · 01/01/2022 23:28

The thing is, OP has mentioned that these people buy her nice, thoughtful gifts. I couldn’t receive nice thoughtful gifts, year after year and not reciprocate. Take her partner out of it because actually the gift giving relationship, as it were, is actually between OP and the individuals who buy for her. Either she delegates that reciprocity to her husband (and accepts that he will do a poor job), works with her partner to buy nice gifts, gets them herself, or just says to the individuals that she’d rather not exchange gifts at christmas.

That’s how I see it anyway.

With my DH we discuss what to buy for whom and I get some bits and he gets others, depending on what our strengths/interests are or who is going to what shop etc. So I would probably buy for someone who would appreciate a nice expensive bubble bath for example, and he would think of/ buy someone a bit of tech for someone. We then sit and wrap everything together. When we had young children we would share the buying for them too. It always felt like a partnership though.

SickAndTiredAgain · 01/01/2022 22:58

@luckylavender

Going against the grain here, we all have strengths & weaknesses. I would do the gifts as you'll clearly be better at it and let him play to his strengths.
I’d generally agree with this, but OP has said her husband doesn’t even remember Xmas presents. That’s not forgetting a birthday, or not really knowing what present to get, no one forgets Christmas is coming up. DH and I generally buy our own family‘s presents but I’ll get something for an in-law if it’s something I think they’ll like, and DH will do the same for my family. I wouldn’t be impressed if he claimed to forget that Christmas involved presents though. It seems more “can’t be bothered” than “trying but it’s really not a strength”.
Crazycrazylady · 01/01/2022 21:23

Honestly op
In our family my husband is rubbish at remembering gifts etc which I am good at. He can and does fix anything in the house and does techie stuff and all gardening so I just do the gifts for both sides
Honestly think it's a bit petty not to buy anything for his side when you could easily do it.( I agree you shouldn't have to but if your dh pulls his weight otherwise) I'd let this go but that's just me

DebIr · 01/01/2022 21:20

@luckylavender

Going against the grain here, we all have strengths & weaknesses. I would do the gifts as you'll clearly be better at it and let him play to his strengths.
Completely agree! No wonder there are so many unhappy families. We’re all different.
luckylavender · 01/01/2022 20:16

Going against the grain here, we all have strengths & weaknesses. I would do the gifts as you'll clearly be better at it and let him play to his strengths.

ChubbyMorticia · 01/01/2022 20:09

My MIL had very firm ideas about wifework. She called shortly after we were married, and wanted to dictate a list of family birthdays (her siblings, in-laws, DH's cousins), phone numbers and addresses to me. I thanked her for the thought, but said that DH had been on his own for almost two decades before I met him, so I was certain he had the information he needed to keep in touch.

The only thing I've done is kept his birth siblings on my FB, so he could wish them happy birthday, etc, since he didn't have FB until recently.

PussInBin20 · 01/01/2022 20:07

I’ve fallen into this trap and I can’t quite remember how! I suspect like you that my MIL probably got me nice presents and I felt bad for not reciprocating. So now I do all the presents for both sides and all the wrapping and all the cards!

I do hate it but I don’t want to be embarrassed when she gives us thoughtful presents and not give a gift back. I know MIL really appreciates it because she gets nothing from her youngest son - not even a Birthday card, which I feel is poor. I also send his kids cards/vouchers and always have done but my DD gets nothing.

Now I’m about 18 yrs in so I can’t stop now.

On the plus side, although I do all the food shopping for Xmas, my DH has cooked all meals over the Xmas holidays including for my DM and Xmas/Boxing Day so I feel like it’s teamwork really.

Doesn’t stop me moaning to myself each year though as I rack my brains trying to figure out what people would like.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 01/01/2022 19:51

@DebIr

Seriously life is too short to make dramas where there aren’t any. Worry about sexism where there are real issues like in many workplaces in the UK or gross injustices in other countries.
Accepting these kind of 'little things' is what allows the bigger things to do the damage to which you are referring. IMHO people should worry about everyday sexism. There is no real drama - if the OHs family object to not getting presents, they can take it up with him. No need for drama.
Rrrob · 01/01/2022 19:48

I’m in the same situation. DH misses every birthday of his family without fail. Half of them have received xmas presents (we didn’t see them over xmas). He announced today its his step mum’s big birthday in a couple of weeks and I’m wondering whether to sort a card at least.

SpankyPankhurst · 01/01/2022 19:43

I gave up buying for DH's family several years ago. It always made a hole in my pocket and was not remembered.

mrsed1987 · 01/01/2022 19:41

Interestingly I end up doing my dh's family but he often will buy bits for my parents! (we aren't close to his family but are to mine). If I didn't do it, his side of the family wouldn't get anything

sjxoxo · 01/01/2022 19:37

Can you make a list of people to buy presents for & leave it out hanging in kitchen etc. Say ‘I’m doing xyz, you can do abc’ and see what he says to that. The truth is he can’t be arsed to deal with choosing or organising gifts, and he does not care about the ‘shame’ that comes as a result of not giving a gift either. To him it’s not important. You are right his family will notice and his lack of effort will hurt some peoples feelings; he also doesn’t care about that. It’s shit and it’s just not on his radar.

This year we’ve not seen family due to covid restrictions and so we’ve done very little gifting but will get them at a later date when we are seeing them all. I’ve noticed how much less stress this year is for me- and I’ve also realised that my step-FIL, my BIL, and my grandad, have never, ever, bought me a gift. Or any of the other women in the family. I’ve realised it’s just us women who are organising all these gifts every year and there’s these ‘hanger-on-ers’ who are getting nice gifts every year but without contributing F all to the Christmas effort. Honestly next year I think I’ll get the women lovely gifts and the blokes nothing. They can’t even be arsed to sign Christmas cards. When we get cards all I see is the handwriting of women I know, signing their husbands name for them. Honestly it’s shit but I think they do not care about Xmas one jot. Next year shall we do a women only Xmas 🤣 they can only join in the festive spirit if they’ve bought and wrapped at least 5 gifts and 5 cards!! Xo

DebIr · 01/01/2022 19:25

Seriously life is too short to make dramas where there aren’t any.
Worry about sexism where there are real issues like in many workplaces in the UK or gross injustices in other countries.

SickAndTiredAgain · 01/01/2022 06:41

If you’re better at choosing presents then why not just do it?

She’s not better at choosing presents, she’s just not completely lazy. No one “forgets” Christmas every year, he just can’t be arsed. That doesn’t mean he’s bad at choosing presents, that means he’s too lazy to even try.

If someone posted on here “I forget Christmas every year, I’m rubbish at remembering to buy presents! AIBU to expect my husband to just buy everything for my family, leaving me to my incompetence?” all the responses would be people saying “wtf do you mean you forget Christmas? No you don’t! Don’t be so lazy.”

DifferentHair · 01/01/2022 06:14

Sexist bollocks.

Since you don't mind doing it, I would make it offical but swap it for a chore you don't enjoy that will now become his sole responsibility.

Eg from now on he is solely and completely responsible for ironing for something.

I don't accept that men are incapable of remembering birthdays and buying presents. I think we've all been conditioned to facilitate this laziness on their behalf.

SoftSquishy8 · 01/01/2022 05:43

I started buying DH's family Christmas gifts when we married. We'd have a big family get together on Boxing Day and I'd feel embarrassed not turning up with anything.

It was stressful and an additional job I realised I'd given myself, so I told DH (with plenty of notice) I wouldn't be doing it anymore.

For the past 10 years he's given zero gifts to any family, zero. Nothing for Christmas or birthdays, even for his neices. Of course that meant presents for us stopped too (thankfully really) but then the invitations stopped too.

Now he just doesn't really speak to anyone. They weren't close before but it definitely drove another wedge - but it's his family, his choice. Not my responsibility to facilitate a relationship with them and remind him about Christmas/Birthdays.

GeorgiaGirl52 · 01/01/2022 05:42

@sweeneytoddsrazor

You are married, you are a team. Ok technically they are his family, but they obviously consider you as family also. How would you feel if they just got gifts for your DH because he is family and you aren't?
This is what I see marriage as being. You recognize thee effort they put into choosing things with you in mind so you make the effort back. DH can pick up the slack somewhere else.