Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Casual racism or AIBU

368 replies

Kooksadooks · 31/12/2021 13:19

Hello. I have a lot on my mind today but hope you are having a nice New Years Eve…
We (me, DP, MIL, FIL, DS ect) were sat around the TV over Christmas period.
The Channel 5 advert featuring Anne Bolelyn played by black actress Jodie Turner-Smith comes on and MIL starts complaining that she ‘doesn’t understand all this’ and ‘Anne Bolelyn wasn’t black’ and doesn’t understand ‘why white people cannot play black people’…
I bit my tongue, I appreciate that I am surrounded by people who agree with her and there’s no point in arguing with them about what I think, also not wanting to cause drama over Christmas but AIBU to feel uncomfortable at MIL’s comments?
I mentioned it to DP afterwards and he agrees with MIL HmmBlushSad

OP posts:
crochetmonkey74 · 31/12/2021 15:50

Also I dont see people saying about it being 'inaccurate'when it's a white person playing a different race.

SingingLeaf · 31/12/2021 15:49

Never noticed it all that much in British society tbh.

But people make SO much of virtually nothing now to "virtue signal" themselves into outa space. I think I find that more annoying.

Witness: Benny Hill is so "sexist" now you get warnings if you watch current re-runs. Yet the most abusive bestial kind of pornography gets a free pass!

The same with an actor or politician who touched a woman's knee under a table 20 years ago. Yet the worst kind of pornography goes uncommented on. In fact people think its cool to express and promote their "kinks" be it S&M, threesomes blah blah on MSM, even Mumsnet "Relationships" pages as kinda acceptable and cool (not vanilla which is the worst kind of sex, apparently!).

P.S. Anne Boleyn wasn't black. Anymore than women were blacksmiths in 17th century England. I think people should be more involved in creating the present than misrpresenting the past. Just sayin'

Magnited · 31/12/2021 15:49

Because it is a fictional account, I want to be inspired by the acting and so the colour of skin has already become irrelevant. The character becomes alive to me black, white or brown.

I watched a black female officer inspect recruits at a military passing out parade. I felt immensely proud. We have come a long way from the 'fuzzy wuzzies' having no senior place in our armies because we fought them - something said to me by an MP some years ago.

crochetmonkey74 · 31/12/2021 15:47

It's a leap into colour blind casting to move forward an industry that has been primarily white.
I like colour blind casting it feels modern and fresh.

Pebble55 · 31/12/2021 15:47

Not racist. Anne Boleyn wasn't black.
Can you imagine Brad Pitt as Nelson Mandela? Or the Jamaican Bobsled Team as four white blokes?

anon12345678901 · 31/12/2021 15:46

@sst1234

But Ann Boleyn wasn’t black. It’s historically inaccurate to have a black actor play Ann Boleyn. This is the same nonsense as having a female James Bond - he wasn’t written as a woman. It’s just embarrassing virtue signalling to do this sort of stuff. Have stories of real black people ceased to exist? Is it impossible to write a story starting a real female spy? It’s actually racist to give minority and female actors the crumbs off the table, because it implies their own stories are not worthy of being told. It’s not racist to call out this nonsense.
I agree. I don't think what MIL said was racist in anyway and I agree. It's historically inaccurate.
ittakes2 · 31/12/2021 15:45

I am mixed race and I also don't agree with it.
I think they should have been cleverer about it and have done a different spin - a black main character in a period drama or a mostly black cast or anything else that could have had a huge impact and got people thinking and challenging their own racist views. But to play a true character in history but cast her as black when she wasn't...to me actually is just a plain lazy way of trying to piggyback on the public's interest in challenging racist views. I actually find it a bit insulting - film challenging racial views (tick box). When really what you want is something thought provoking but instead what we get is what has happened in this thread - debate about whether a real character can be cast as a different race...not lets look at racism at the time or now.

Rrrob · 31/12/2021 15:44

I agree with your MIL, and would think the same if historical figures such as Martin Luther King were played by white actors. I don’t think (but happy to be corrected) that this is racist…

Tisaxon · 31/12/2021 15:42

In the 1961 film of West Side Story, Rita Moreno, who was the only actual Puerto Rican actor playing one of the Puerto Rican roles, was still put into darker-skinned make-up to reflect a particular blinkered view of the racial makeup of Puerto Rico — when she objected, the makeup artist asked her if she was ‘racist’. (That’s leaving aside the ‘brownface’ of Natalie Wood, George Chakiris and lots of others in the cast.)

I think what I’m saying is that you can be non-white, playing a role that is your own ethnicity, and still need to be tweaked to reflect your era’s stereotypical ideas about your race or racial mix.

I’m not sure that white actors playing other ethnicities has stopped being ok very long ago — Angelina Jolie played Marianne Pearl in 2007, Juliette Binoche played a Chilean woman in 2016.

Gonnagetgoing · 31/12/2021 15:40

I do find in some historical dramas made these days they have a lot of BAME actors so they’re represented which is great as these races were in western society in various ways.

However, I don’t agree with Anne Boleyn being black, if anything yes, a Mediterranean looking actress would be better as more believable. I can see why this actress was cast in the Anne Boleyn role but I just think it confuses people as not historically accurate and winds up the racists.

rwalker · 31/12/2021 15:40

I think there a massive difference between racial hatred and someone saying something isn't portrayed factually correct .

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 31/12/2021 15:39

@RosesAndHellebores

I watched the first episode and didn't think it was particularly good. I was surprised at the casting and read up on it. Ann Boleyn whilst white was a product of the French court rather than the English Court and was therefore different and in some ways othered at the time. Her views about protestantism were also radical.

I could understand the rationale behind the casting having read that and thought it was cleverly metaphorical and presented a thoughtful representation about the obstacles faced by people perceived as different.

I see where you're coming from but I don't think it's a good metaphor as it suggests that racism can be compared to coming from a different court. It can't as is much more damaging, has caused the murder of many millions of people of colour and continues to shape out societies in awful ways. I think the comparison minimises racism.
ThymeTravel · 31/12/2021 15:39

I agree with your MIL. It's like when someone says James Bond should be a woman and someone disagrees because James Bond is a man, is that sexist?

Your MILs comment was absolutely not racist, that term is thrown around too much these days.

Sadly, a black woman would never have been queen in that century.

MargaretThursday · 31/12/2021 15:38

I agree mostly with colour blind casting.
But not where either it is based on a real person, or if it would make a different story due to it. If you've got a character like, for example, Anne of Green Gables (red hair), who has some important feature that has limited ethnicities then it would change the story not to have that. Hermoine Granger, I can totally buy into her being a different ethnicity as the only features we're told about is "bushy" hair and sticking out teeth, and it wouldn't change her character in any way.

I think there are a lot of stories where you could change the ethnicity of a character without it being an issue. What if the Famous Five weren't white, for example? Is there anything that says they should be white. Anne is traditionally fair, but I'm not sure it says so in the books. So could they be non-white? They're clearly a middle class family in the 50s, so likely to be white-Caucasian, but not exclusively so. Aunt Fanny's family have clearly been there for centuries, so again that increases the likelihood of being white, but I think you could get away with it.

My biggest concern is that if you have that way round, what about white actors portraying non-white roles? That will come-perhaps with less of a fanfare.
Then you get the decision that it really didn't work well having the non-white actor portraying a white character, but not the other way round. So you now get the white actors having the full choice of roles whereas the non-white actors having no more roles and having to compete with white actors for their traditional roles.

I feel the same about casting women in traditional male roles. It may be great for those first few women, but ultimately it will probably work out negatively for women.

LaurenKelsey · 31/12/2021 15:37

It really depends on whether your MIL has made other seemingly racist comments. I find it distracting in historical programmes when the actor somehow doesn’t fit the role.

Lennybenny · 31/12/2021 15:37

I think a point can be made for just having actors play parts. That being said someone white playing MLK would be completely unacceptable. But as we don't really know the origins of a lot of historical figures(people assume they're white to fit in with racist ideals) we shouldn't just assume every figure was white.

RosesAndHellebores · 31/12/2021 15:37

I watched the first episode and didn't think it was particularly good. I was surprised at the casting and read up on it. Ann Boleyn whilst white was a product of the French court rather than the English Court and was therefore different and in some ways othered at the time. Her views about protestantism were also radical.

I could understand the rationale behind the casting having read that and thought it was cleverly metaphorical and presented a thoughtful representation about the obstacles faced by people perceived as different.

NinaDefoe · 31/12/2021 15:36

@Ellowyn

I really couldn't get into a movie if Tom Hanks was playing Martin Luther King.
This too!
FruitMelange · 31/12/2021 15:36

I agree with your MIL in that Anne Boleyn's ethnicity - and quite a lot about her appearance - is known. Accuracy in historical writing/depiction matters to me, as far as it is possible

I completely agree. I would be similarly disappointed with a white actor playing Mohammed Ali.

terrywynne · 31/12/2021 15:36

However, I would personally prefer to see more stories of actual black British people than another yet retelling of Anne Boleyn. Can even be Tudors if we have to stick with that period just not Anne!

Ellowyn · 31/12/2021 15:35

I really couldn't get into a movie if Tom Hanks was playing Martin Luther King.

NinaDefoe · 31/12/2021 15:35

I've loved adaptations of Wuthering Heights and Oliver Twist with black characters but because they're fiction the characters could easily be any ethnicity.

Portraying historically white people using a different ethnicity is tokenism. Personally I'd rather hear the stories of historical black figures - there was a good Harriet Tubman film recently for example

Very well put!

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 31/12/2021 15:35

Because her breast size was relevant to the story.
Henry's love letters to her reference her little duckies. People were dismissive of her beauty in her own time because she defied the convention of red or gold hair, pale skin and curvaceous.
As a slim dark eyed beauty she was different at the time.
So yes, breast size matters.

Hippychicken1 · 31/12/2021 15:35

@TyrannosaurusRegina I agree with you - I’m black
I tend to find with stuff like this the black / mixed race people are a bit like
WTF - when I did history AB was white 😂
And the white people are oh it’s fine it’s great it’s inclusive - virtual signalling that it’s all cool 😂
She may be a great actress for is it actor now if I’m being non binary 😂
But it isn’t accurate of factual history and as a black person I actually find it a bit insulting

NinaDefoe · 31/12/2021 15:33

@toddybell

I'm black and I agree with your MIL. Anne Boleyn wasn't Black so should be played by someone who factually represented who she was re: ethnicity . I'd feel the same if someone white came along and played Martin Luther King or Mary Jane Seacole or Harriet Seacole or Mahatma Ghandi, etc.
I agree! It would be absurd for a white man to play the part of the above.

Another example: Barak Obama played by Colin Firth ... Well they’re both 60 but it would be utterly ridiculous.