Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Casual racism or AIBU

368 replies

Kooksadooks · 31/12/2021 13:19

Hello. I have a lot on my mind today but hope you are having a nice New Years Eve…
We (me, DP, MIL, FIL, DS ect) were sat around the TV over Christmas period.
The Channel 5 advert featuring Anne Bolelyn played by black actress Jodie Turner-Smith comes on and MIL starts complaining that she ‘doesn’t understand all this’ and ‘Anne Bolelyn wasn’t black’ and doesn’t understand ‘why white people cannot play black people’…
I bit my tongue, I appreciate that I am surrounded by people who agree with her and there’s no point in arguing with them about what I think, also not wanting to cause drama over Christmas but AIBU to feel uncomfortable at MIL’s comments?
I mentioned it to DP afterwards and he agrees with MIL HmmBlushSad

OP posts:
Lndnmummy · 31/12/2021 19:05

It is racist.

phishy · 31/12/2021 19:02

[quote RussianSpy101]@phishy jarring for who? I don’t think it is. It’s appropriate for the time.[/quote]
Jarring for me. Is that ok with you?

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 31/12/2021 19:02

Natalie Portman

Was the worst Anne Boleyn ever.
Including the Shakespeare plays when men dressed in drag.
Awful. Awful. Awful.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 31/12/2021 19:01

Plenty of them deeceecherry.
I've bothered to read the whole thread and read those many black voices, who pointed out the tokenism, emptiness and problematic nature of this casting.

You should too.
Or do you only listen to black voices who agree with you.

MaryBellingham11432 · 31/12/2021 18:58

I do not remember people getting annoyed with Natalie Portman portraying Anne Boleyn despite the fact Anne Boleyn was English and Natalie Portman is Israeli. Why is that?

DeeCeeCherry · 31/12/2021 18:55

So what.. we've had years of real life Black characters played by White actors, those same actors also wear stupid looking dark makeup to play Native American and Asian characters.

Im glad bonehead racists are wound up now, theyre not even worthy of long detailed discussion.

Has anyone come on here yet to claim 'Im Black/Mixed and I agree with your in-Laws?'If not they'll tap dance along soon

Nillynally · 31/12/2021 18:50

@TrishM80 he is of Indian descent actually, although fairly light skinned.

Lolamento · 31/12/2021 18:45

[quote Hippychicken1]@Kooksadooks

I think you got offended because your white and as a white person your told regularly even if you don’t realise it that you should be standing up against racism which everyone should be but not everything - ie mentioning what your MIL said is racist or about racism.

I actually get fed up of people - mainly white people being offended about stuff about my race that myself and probably a lot of black - mixed race people wouldn’t think for one moment that it’s racist .
People should be able to talk about this without automatically thinking it’s racist to say what your MIL said and shutting the conversation down

I’m black btw I’m neither stupid or racist and I agree with your MIL- 100 percent I couldn’t read anything racist in what she said .
She was factually correct AB was white not black
My white husband is a ex pro boxer
It would be like him wanting to play Mohammed Ali - if he could act 😂 the only thing they would have in common Is being able to box to a high standard and being male
If a white man say like the Sylvester Stallone played MA there would be an uproar as he would be seen as taking the piss and taking a part from a black actor

whereas Will Smith was excellent and I personally didn’t ever question his acting as it was a black man playing a black boxer which was factually correct[/quote]
Great post, Thanks for saying it.

EmpressCixi · 31/12/2021 18:41

@MasterBeth
Yes, it’s more problematic to portray an actual historical black person using a white actor, but it is still a problem to have a different race actor portray any actual historical person for whom we know for a fact what their race was.

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 31/12/2021 18:40

This is just something we have to all agree to disagree on. My family would all have different opinions. Personally, I say whatever promotes/celebrates diversity is the most important factor and who is the best actor/tress for that role regardless of what they look like- both ways.

Lolamento · 31/12/2021 18:35

@toddybell

I'm black and I agree with your MIL. Anne Boleyn wasn't Black so should be played by someone who factually represented who she was re: ethnicity . I'd feel the same if someone white came along and played Martin Luther King or Mary Jane Seacole or Harriet Seacole or Mahatma Ghandi, etc.
This
EmpressCixi · 31/12/2021 18:34

@Sunshinelover2

Everybody knows the difference between a documentary and a drama yes? The difference between fiction and non-fiction?

In fiction it is not required that events be represented factually.

Your MIL is being racist or stupid, both can come across quite similarly.

You think Anne Boleyn is a fictional character? She’s buried in the chapel in the Tower of London. She was a real white woman who lived and was brutally murdered by her husband who was an all powerful and egotistical monarch.
Hippychicken1 · 31/12/2021 18:10

@Kooksadooks

I think you got offended because your white and as a white person your told regularly even if you don’t realise it that you should be standing up against racism which everyone should be but not everything - ie mentioning what your MIL said is racist or about racism.

I actually get fed up of people - mainly white people being offended about stuff about my race that myself and probably a lot of black - mixed race people wouldn’t think for one moment that it’s racist .
People should be able to talk about this without automatically thinking it’s racist to say what your MIL said and shutting the conversation down

I’m black btw I’m neither stupid or racist and I agree with your MIL- 100 percent I couldn’t read anything racist in what she said .
She was factually correct AB was white not black
My white husband is a ex pro boxer
It would be like him wanting to play Mohammed Ali - if he could act 😂 the only thing they would have in common Is being able to box to a high standard and being male
If a white man say like the Sylvester Stallone played MA there would be an uproar as he would be seen as taking the piss and taking a part from a black actor

whereas Will Smith was excellent and I personally didn’t ever question his acting as it was a black man playing a black boxer which was factually correct

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 31/12/2021 18:10

I feel like Mumsnet needs a new deletion message:
This message has been hidden as the author was engaging in empty virtue signalling.

RussianSpy101 · 31/12/2021 18:08

@MasterBeth yet many of us from BAME families have said we don’t have an issue with the MILS POV

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 31/12/2021 18:07

@QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat

I think the issue is, why do we continue to make so many historical dramas about the Tudors? Why don't we make more black history dramas?

I don't have an issue per se in a dramatised play/drama with a black Anne Boleyn, but it isn't historically accurate and it isn't racist to point that out.

In fictional tv/film i think we should have wider diversity and would welcome female bond, black little mermaid and don't think that is virtue signalling.

I think AB story will always be popular, as it really is a key moment in our shared history. But as you say, there are lots of really good black and other origin stories that should be told. With the Little Mermaid, a black LM is fine, but as 'ginger' people are usually the butt of jokes, lack representation, it would have been nice to have a natural redhead play Ariel. But black Ariel is better than a well known blonde or brunette in a wig.

James Bond just an awful misogynistic character and I wish they'd retire him.

MasterBeth · 31/12/2021 18:07

I find the ignorance on this thread depressing.

The reason why a white actor playing a black character is far more problematic than a black actor playing a white character is a centuries-old history of colonialism, enslavement, racism and discrimination.

Did no-one notice Black Lives Matter? At all?

Arethechildreninbedyet · 31/12/2021 17:56

I will dispute the colour of Anne Boleyn’s skin wasn’t important. I think the reason she is so infamous is because she was the most powerful woman in England at the time, she was as close to the king’s equal as it got societally. The Mother of the future queen, potential mother of the future king etc. Wealthy, noble, white etc. She was in no way his lesser beyond her gender… he easily murdered his wife and could do it for the sole reason of her being a woman. I would argue Anne Boleyn is a very important historical figure, her race included, to exemplify how far gender equality and the collapse of autocratic monarchism has come.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 31/12/2021 17:46

Everybody knows the difference between a documentary and a drama yes? The difference between fiction and non-fiction?

In the case of Anne Boleyn, a lot of people believe 'facts' that are actually fiction.

Had a sixth finger(fiction, may have had a small fingernail-like defect)
Had numerous wens and warts(fiction, may have had one or two moles, but hideous deformities added after her death)
Guilty of incest(fiction, even contemporary enemies knew the allegations to be untrue. Myth has been furthered by the likes of Philippa Gregory.)
Extreme protestant (her views were more moderate, and a reaction against the corruption in the church)
Sexually deviant (myth, but this always gets pushed)

Ultimately she was a clever, ambitious and accomplished women of her time who died due to her status as both a 'commoner' and a women.

A lot of people get their history from TV. I wouldn't be surprised if in ten years time some people genuinely think she was black, just as most people genuinely believe Catherine of Aragon was a dark Spanish looking dowdy housewife.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 31/12/2021 17:42

I think the issue is, why do we continue to make so many historical dramas about the Tudors? Why don't we make more black history dramas?

I don't have an issue per se in a dramatised play/drama with a black Anne Boleyn, but it isn't historically accurate and it isn't racist to point that out.

In fictional tv/film i think we should have wider diversity and would welcome female bond, black little mermaid and don't think that is virtue signalling.

PuppyMonkey · 31/12/2021 17:35

@Sunshinelover2

Everybody knows the difference between a documentary and a drama yes? The difference between fiction and non-fiction?

In fiction it is not required that events be represented factually.

Your MIL is being racist or stupid, both can come across quite similarly.

There’s a lot of black people on this thread who completely agree with OP’s MIL - are they racist and stupid too?
Sunshinelover2 · 31/12/2021 17:26

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 31/12/2021 17:07

green as it was described many times in the books. I think Emma Watsons hair is justified as in the book, she uses something (might be sleeking potion) to smooth her hair.....and yes I am missing the point of the thread.

Hermione only uses sleekeasy hair potion for the Yule Ball and then afterwards, true to character confesses to Harry it's too much to bother with everyday.
Also misses point of thread. But a good example of a non race detail that annoyed most fans.

EmpressCixi · 31/12/2021 17:04

@My200lbLife

It’s patronising tokenism. I’m Black before you all start.

There should be more done on black stories - there are plenty. With black actors.

I agree completely. I would love to see stories of the many African emperors/empresses, kings/queens/princesses actually get funding and their history given the attention it deserves. I have been watching many historical films made by Nigeria’s film industry and they are incredible. To me, the way to redress the racism of Anglo-centric historical dramas is to widen it to be inclusive. There is no shortage of actors or actresses who could portray these real lived important black historical figures.
Ellowyn · 31/12/2021 16:59

@Lennybenny

I think a point can be made for just having actors play parts. That being said someone white playing MLK would be completely unacceptable. But as we don't really know the origins of a lot of historical figures(people assume they're white to fit in with racist ideals) we shouldn't just assume every figure was white.
It is a documented fact that during the (US) slave times many of the slaves looked white and could easily pass for white (one drop rule), but there would be outrage if white actors played American slaves in a movie.
Swipe left for the next trending thread