Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Casual racism or AIBU

368 replies

Kooksadooks · 31/12/2021 13:19

Hello. I have a lot on my mind today but hope you are having a nice New Years Eve…
We (me, DP, MIL, FIL, DS ect) were sat around the TV over Christmas period.
The Channel 5 advert featuring Anne Bolelyn played by black actress Jodie Turner-Smith comes on and MIL starts complaining that she ‘doesn’t understand all this’ and ‘Anne Bolelyn wasn’t black’ and doesn’t understand ‘why white people cannot play black people’…
I bit my tongue, I appreciate that I am surrounded by people who agree with her and there’s no point in arguing with them about what I think, also not wanting to cause drama over Christmas but AIBU to feel uncomfortable at MIL’s comments?
I mentioned it to DP afterwards and he agrees with MIL HmmBlushSad

OP posts:
FatFredsFriedEgg · 31/12/2021 20:16

Nothing to do with Russia. Really? Chernobyl had nothing to do with Russia?

Well it wasn't in Russia at the time and It's still not in Russia, so what does it have to do with Russia? USSR yes, Ukraine yes, not Russia.

RussianSpy101 · 31/12/2021 20:13

@lap90 of course it adds weight! Absolutely ridiculous to think that a black person doesn’t hold a valid opinion as to what constitutes racism towards black people.

LondonWolf · 31/12/2021 20:08

[quote VladmirsPoutine]**@LondonWolf* I'm aware of that. The good sis @DeeCeeCherry* has had it with wayward opinions on race threads on MN for a while now! Wine[/quote]
Wayward. So there’s only one way to think of you’re a POC? The way you think?

Got it 😊

LondonWolf · 31/12/2021 20:06

film about Chernobyl has nothing to do with 'Russia' or 'The Russians'.

Nothing to do with Russia. Really? Chernobyl had nothing to do with Russia?

lap90 · 31/12/2021 20:06

[quote RussianSpy101]@MasterBeth yet many of us from BAME families have said we don’t have an issue with the MILS POV[/quote]
There have also been people who have taken issue with the MIL's POV although whose to say what race they are as they have not explicitly stated so in the hope to add some 'weight' to their opinion!

VladmirsPoutine · 31/12/2021 20:00

@LondonWolf I'm aware of that. The good sis @DeeCeeCherry has had it with wayward opinions on race threads on MN for a while now! Wine

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 31/12/2021 19:59

I think it's.pretty insulting to assume there are no black stories worth telling.
Even in the early modern period, some parts of the globe where black people were in the majority were far more advanced than their white counterparts. Medicine is one area for example where Europe was literally stuck in the dark ages for a long time and were outshone their visiting black doctors.

FatFredsFriedEgg · 31/12/2021 19:55

@XelaM @LondonWolf etc. - a film about Chernobyl has nothing to do with 'Russia' or 'The Russians'.

Ukraine, formerly part of the USSR but not part of Russia since 1917.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 31/12/2021 19:54

And Henry would need to be over 6ft athletic and strapping at the beginning and then have a progressive fat suit/ make up added.

The thing that makes his story more sharp is that he started out such a promising, liberal prince and ended up a tyrant.

Grendalsmum · 31/12/2021 19:42

I'm with worriedmumsdon'tsleep l think it would have been better if all the cast, Fat Henry and all, were black. As it was it made it look as if racism was a part of Bolyn's fall - which it obviously wasn't, instead of class, which very much was.
I'd like to see black women's stories being told, rather than having black actors shoehorned into wornout narratives to give them a bit of oomph. A series about Josephine Baker for example, she had an amazing life!

Keke94LND · 31/12/2021 19:40

@LostForIdeas

The problem I have with white people pay white characters and black people play black characters only is that most of the classics, books etc… have all been written about white people by white people. Most of the important characters in history are white etc…

So that doesn’t leave a lot of space for black people to play important/recognised parts and characters iyswim.

There are loads of important characters/people from history who are not white, would probably be good to share some of their stories and create films/shows about them!
WorriedMumsDontSleep · 31/12/2021 19:39

Theatre, film and television ask the audience to suspend disbelief to very different degrees.
A cardboard set works on stage, not on screen.

A blonde Anne Boleyn would be inaccurate. It's integral to her story. A clumsy AB, fat AB or stupid AB all wouldn't work because it erases part of her character intertwined with the story.
A black Anne Boleyn changes the possible motivations for her downfall which were political, religious and gender based. As previously said, an all black cast would cancel this out. I'd definitely watch that.
I'm not watching an Anne Boleyn who is so far removed from the truth it would literally change history if she'd been queen. It whitewashes the struggles of people at that time and since. Pretending that a black woman could have had the rank that ab had denies the racism at the time and since.
And I think ignoring the black voices on this thread and accusing them of being 'white' is fairly racist in itself.

LondonWolf · 31/12/2021 19:38

@VladmirsPoutine

When it comes to racism I'll go out on a limb here and say yes, only the opinion of one race matters.
And yet even opinions of people of that race have been derided on here by @DeeCeeCherry.
AlbertCampion · 31/12/2021 19:28

So was it tokenism when the immensely talented Lucian Msamati played Salieri in Amadeus at The National? His was the finest performance I have ever seen of the role. Surely we can't diminish that by saying his casting was tokenism?

Or what about Joan Iyiola in The Duchess of Malfi at The RSC - a performance which moved me to tears. The part wasn't written to be played by a black woman, but she made it more real than any other performance I have seen.

I worry that by calling these casting decisions tokenism, we insult those wonderful actors who got the roles because they were the best people for the job. Couldn't that just be the case with the Anne Boleyn casting? Perhaps talent is more important than skin colour.

pigalow · 31/12/2021 19:27

White actor Ben Kingsley won an Oscar for playing Mahatma Gandhi! - I think Ben Kingsley has dual heritage and one of his parents is Indian.

VladmirsPoutine · 31/12/2021 19:25

i.e. the people from race in question.

VladmirsPoutine · 31/12/2021 19:25

When it comes to racism I'll go out on a limb here and say yes, only the opinion of one race matters.

saraclara · 31/12/2021 19:23

@DeeCeeCherry have you actually read this entire thread? Or have you chosen to ignore, yes, the many black and mixed race voices on it?

Arethechildreninbedyet · 31/12/2021 19:23

@DeeCeeCherry

So you’re not only saying that the opinion of only one race matters but then dismissing and ridiculing the opinions of anyone who disagrees with you?

You sound delightful.

supermoonrising · 31/12/2021 19:22

I think it’s perfectly reasonable for choosing someone who doesn’t bare much physical resemblance to the historical figure to play the role as long as you have an actual reason for doing so. A valid reason might be:
A) an amateur production of some kind, where you have a talented performer who would otherwise be deprived a major role (to the loss of the audience etc). This would often happen in local theatre groups, schools plays etc.

B) in plays and films where artistic license is also being taken with the story in other regards.

If on the other other hand it’s being done “just because”, at the expense of equally talented actors who bare a closer resemblance to the historical figure in question - well that seems rather pointless.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 31/12/2021 19:19

Being white isn't like original sin.
I would tag the many people who have said this but what would be the point when you couldn't even be bothered to read them yourself.
Pathetic virtue signalling at its finest.

DeeCeeCherry · 31/12/2021 19:15

WorriedMumsDontSleep
*Plenty of them deeceecherry.
I've bothered to read the whole thread and read those many black voices, who pointed out the tokenism, emptiness and problematic nature of this casting

Many Black voices?!🤣

Sure

You're amongst many White voices bleating because a Black Woman played Anne Boleyn. Enjoy it🙂
Happy New Year

RussianSpy101 · 31/12/2021 19:13

@phishy in what way?

EmpressCixi · 31/12/2021 19:10

@MaryBellingham11432

I do not remember people getting annoyed with Natalie Portman portraying Anne Boleyn despite the fact Anne Boleyn was English and Natalie Portman is Israeli. Why is that?
Nationality and religion is completely different from race, Natalie Portman is white. I don’t think historical accurate casting should extend to same religion. Besides Natalie Portman is a dual US and Israeli citizen. Before her family emigrated to Israel from America, they had previously emigrated from Poland, Austria, and Russia- all majority white countries.
Lndnmummy · 31/12/2021 19:07

@DeeCeeCherry Grin they sure have. We didn't even make it past page 1 Grin

Swipe left for the next trending thread