Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Casual racism or AIBU

368 replies

Kooksadooks · 31/12/2021 13:19

Hello. I have a lot on my mind today but hope you are having a nice New Years Eve…
We (me, DP, MIL, FIL, DS ect) were sat around the TV over Christmas period.
The Channel 5 advert featuring Anne Bolelyn played by black actress Jodie Turner-Smith comes on and MIL starts complaining that she ‘doesn’t understand all this’ and ‘Anne Bolelyn wasn’t black’ and doesn’t understand ‘why white people cannot play black people’…
I bit my tongue, I appreciate that I am surrounded by people who agree with her and there’s no point in arguing with them about what I think, also not wanting to cause drama over Christmas but AIBU to feel uncomfortable at MIL’s comments?
I mentioned it to DP afterwards and he agrees with MIL HmmBlushSad

OP posts:
Cheeseplantboots · 01/01/2022 16:34

Of course it’s not racist. Ann Boleyn wasn’t black. She’s not a fictional character, she was a real person.

It would be the same if a white actor played the part of a famous black person.

loislovesstewie · 01/01/2022 16:30

Men played women's parts because women weren't allowed to act as it was thought to be immoral to do so.

mustlovegin · 01/01/2022 16:28

I appreciate that I am surrounded by people who agree with her and there’s no point in arguing with them about what I think
I am an immigrant myself

Have you stopped to think why it is that most people around you are in agreement? Have you considered that perhaps you could be in the wrong given the context?

Also think about prominent historical figures from you birth country, would you like a British actor/actress to be cast for those roles? If you felt uncomfortable about that, would that make you prejudiced or just protective of your heritage?

mustlovegin · 01/01/2022 16:16

I consider my own opinion to be largely irrelevant given my white privilege

No, your opinion is not irrelevant, as the issue relates to white British cultural heritage (and how it's being distorted and disrespected by these 'productions').

Colour blind casting has been done many times. It's frankly lost it's edginess now and it's starting to become offensive for many.

Your MIL has a point OP. She is entitled to an opinion on how she would like her ancestors to be portrayed. She is unlikely to change her mind, irrespective of how many times you are intending to 'call her out'

It would also be interesting to know how your DP rates his life choices if he has to face his heritage and his DM being degraded constantly

Xenia · 01/01/2022 16:13

Certainly back to the times of Shakespeare men played women's parts and vice versa and pantomime had all that cross dressing and all boys' or all girls'' schools will always have had people of the wrong sex playing the other one - Mary in all boys' schools Christmas nativity plays will be played by a boy. I think my son was Mary one year - youngest in the class, although being white blonde with blue eyes he may not have been the best choice given the number of Jewish boys in he school who ethnically would have matched the mother of God better.

Sometimes programmes go over the top and it becomes too difficult to believe the story line - that's my take on it and that's a pity. I am now enjoying the New Dexter but the very first scenes made me feel like we had been moved for thos series to sa north Korean political education camp for a lecture rather than sitting at home enoying a show.As he's in Alaska I have no problem with his girl friend being native American and those tribal people being shown in the story - it is relevant interesting and part of it. However t put so many black African cops in there and then the man running the shop is gay and when the person without legs who works in the police station came on you are almost laughing at the ridiculousness of it. After the introduction of the cast of gay, black, disabled characters in the Alaskan village it has calmed down a bit and I have been able to get into the show but it just felt so very pretentious and contrived to start with. Midsomer Murders is another one - it suggests 50% of isolated English villagers are of BAME background from the vicars to the businessmen to the doctors. If it were inner London it would be more believable.

EmpressCixi · 01/01/2022 15:02

@AlbertCampion
Tokenism doesn’t diminish the talent of the actor or actress. Tokenism is purely about how it is literally a misuse of their talent and capability to be cast into/limited to only white historical figures as lipservice to diversity. As in saying, ok you’re good enough to be this white person, but we’d never do a film about anyone from your race because....booring....U.K. is centre of universe and only our history and historical people matter.

Black lives matter needs to come to the film industry. Where are the films showing all the past black lives that did matter? And showing history other than portraying black people as slaves...there’s thousands of years of rich history and fantastic lives to be celebrated that are simply ignored.

JakeyRolling · 01/01/2022 07:20

@fiveminutebreak

I think we have to remember that for decades nearly all films and TV shows were written, produced and directed by white men. It is getting better but still lots of room for improvement. My point is that for so long white stories have dominated and therefore opportunities for black actors have been far fewer than for white. So it's redressing the balance a little.
The way to address it is not to say "hey, there's no interesting black characters worth making anything about so here, we'll let you play a white person" and have everyone pay themselves on the back in the name of inclusion.

They way to address it is to write black characters and write about black historical figures.

Bloodypunkrockers · 01/01/2022 01:41

@Bluebluemoon

I don't think it's racist to think it's strange for a white historical figure to be played by a black actress. I'd find it strange and hard to believe if they cast a white actor as, say, Martin Luther king.

The problem is when you hold this opinion and people try to shout you down as being a racist, you don't necessarily change your view - you just keep your opinion to yourself in public. And that can be dangerous IMO.

The people here who say they are black/mixed race and don't find it racist - well their opinion is just as valid as those who do find it racist. My problem is when certain people try to shut down and silence others who hold a different opinion to them.
Sometimes there is no right or wrong, just difference of opinion.

Obviously the makers of this version of Anne Boleyn wanted to attract publicity and get people talking about it and it seems to have worked! Maybe it's just a very shrewd move on their part.

Very shrewd move. It certainly got the programme noticed
LittleRoundRobin · 31/12/2021 22:37

@My200lbLife

It’s patronising tokenism. I’m Black before you all start.

There should be more done on black stories - there are plenty. With black actors.

AMEN to that! ^
LittleRoundRobin · 31/12/2021 22:37

@MasterBeth

I find the ignorance on this thread depressing.

The reason why a white actor playing a black character is far more problematic than a black actor playing a white character is a centuries-old history of colonialism, enslavement, racism and discrimination.

Did no-one notice Black Lives Matter? At all?

Yes dear. Wink
Kooksadooks · 31/12/2021 21:49

I’m not disappointed no… I wanted people’s point of view and that’s what I got Smile

OP posts:
WhatIsAWeekday · 31/12/2021 21:44

@Lndnmummy You are a White woman, aren't you? Did you just join a Black woman to call Black and Mixed race women "tap-dancers" because they have a different opinion? And you think that doesn't make you racist?

This is what happens when some White people think they're part of the in-crowd - they think they can say anything.

The audacity! Don't you dare!

Let Black people speak for themselves. Rightly or wrongly, they don't need your help.

LittleRoundRobin · 31/12/2021 21:21

@Bluebluemoon

I don't think it's racist to think it's strange for a white historical figure to be played by a black actress. I'd find it strange and hard to believe if they cast a white actor as, say, Martin Luther king.

The problem is when you hold this opinion and people try to shout you down as being a racist, you don't necessarily change your view - you just keep your opinion to yourself in public. And that can be dangerous IMO.

The people here who say they are black/mixed race and don't find it racist - well their opinion is just as valid as those who do find it racist. My problem is when certain people try to shut down and silence others who hold a different opinion to them.
Sometimes there is no right or wrong, just difference of opinion.

Obviously the makers of this version of Anne Boleyn wanted to attract publicity and get people talking about it and it seems to have worked! Maybe it's just a very shrewd move on their part.

I agree with ALL of the above, except for the last paragraph, (about it being a shrewd move on their part.) I will NOT be watching this programme. Not with such a ridiculous move as getting a black actress to play a historical figure who was white.
riiichteeabiiscuit · 31/12/2021 21:21

I think that real people being portrayed should be played by actors of the same race.

I think fictional characters should be open to be played by anybody.

This doesn't make me racist I just think that real people should be played by someone appropriate to their race.

HTH1 · 31/12/2021 21:21

@pigalow

White actor Ben Kingsley won an Oscar for playing Mahatma Gandhi! - I think Ben Kingsley has dual heritage and one of his parents is Indian.
So not white then…
HTH1 · 31/12/2021 21:18

@Ionlydomassiveones

I don’t see what’s racist about saying something factual. Anne Boleyn wasn’t black and it’s quite jarring for those of us who like historical drama to have the facts distorted. Same with war movies made in Hollywood that always make the Americans the heroes.

This stupid overreaction to any opinion that isn’t 100% ‘right on’ is why we’ve got this insufferable woke cancel culture. YABU. Get a grip and move on.

This. I also find it jarring when there is an obvious physical mismatch (not necessarily racial) between the younger and older versions of the same character. I would find it offensive if a non-black actor were to play someone like Martin Luther King.

It’s not the same as an actor not being gay or a serial killer (or having any other invisible characteristic) in real life.

LittleRoundRobin · 31/12/2021 21:18

@Kooksadooks Of course YABU, and I bet you're disappointed with the poll result and some of the comments here. Wink

If a white person is not allowed to play a black person, then a black person cannot play a white person. Fact.

And yes, saying fact DOES make it correct.

Bluebluemoon · 31/12/2021 21:12

I don't think it's racist to think it's strange for a white historical figure to be played by a black actress. I'd find it strange and hard to believe if they cast a white actor as, say, Martin Luther king.

The problem is when you hold this opinion and people try to shout you down as being a racist, you don't necessarily change your view - you just keep your opinion to yourself in public. And that can be dangerous IMO.

The people here who say they are black/mixed race and don't find it racist - well their opinion is just as valid as those who do find it racist. My problem is when certain people try to shut down and silence others who hold a different opinion to them.
Sometimes there is no right or wrong, just difference of opinion.

Obviously the makers of this version of Anne Boleyn wanted to attract publicity and get people talking about it and it seems to have worked! Maybe it's just a very shrewd move on their part.

twelly · 31/12/2021 21:03

Historically it is inaccurate for Ann Boleyn to be portrayed as black, equally it would be historical inaccurate for Mary Seacole to be played as white.

sst1234 · 31/12/2021 21:00

[quote saraclara]@DeeCeeCherry have you actually read this entire thread? Or have you chosen to ignore, yes, the many black and mixed race voices on it?[/quote]
Of course they have ignored it. Because when black or any other members of a non-white ethnic group disagree about there being racism is something, they are conveniently ignored and the circus rolls in banging the drum about racism. It’s ironic and like a satirical sketch at the same time.

sst1234 · 31/12/2021 20:56

@DeeCeeCherry

So what.. we've had years of real life Black characters played by White actors, those same actors also wear stupid looking dark makeup to play Native American and Asian characters.

Im glad bonehead racists are wound up now, theyre not even worthy of long detailed discussion.

Has anyone come on here yet to claim 'Im Black/Mixed and I agree with your in-Laws?'If not they'll tap dance along soon

So you didn’t read the thread then. By the way you sound really angry. Something wind you up?
lap90 · 31/12/2021 20:47

[quote RussianSpy101]@lap90 of course it adds weight! Absolutely ridiculous to think that a black person doesn’t hold a valid opinion as to what constitutes racism towards black people.[/quote]
It's a good thing i didn't state otherwise. Like I said, there have also been people who have taken issue with the MIL's POV although whose to say what race they are as they have not explicitly stated so.

Slytherinprincess · 31/12/2021 20:46

I don't think the problem is about Anne Boleyn being playing by a black woman...as you have said other comments have been made.

That being said I do not agree with the casting of Anne Boleyn in this particular series. I think when it is a historical program based on history this should not be done.
With fictional works however unless there are specific details regarding a character then there should be no problem with whoever is cast.

Hippychicken1 · 31/12/2021 20:39

@RussianSpy101
lap90 of course it adds weight! Absolutely ridiculous to think that a black person doesn’t hold a valid opinion as to what constitutes racism towards black people

I think this is what I struggle with is that so many white people often assume they think they know what a lot of black / ethnic minorities would consider to be racist and often won’t accept that many BAME don’t consider a lot of the stuff that is assumed to be racist is racist .

I am showing my age now 😂 but I remember being at my birthday party when I was a kid and Boney M
“brown girl in the ring” was being played and I was in the middle of the ring dancing surrounded mby my friends all of us dancing .
When I told this story to a white friend she was horrified and went off in a long long rant about how racist my friends - who were probably about 10 years old must have been to have dances wrong me and sang that song and how did my parents even allow this and how traumatising it must have been for me 😂
I’m like it was a catchy song by a popular group at the time.
I was more traumatised by her endless ranting about it 😂

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 31/12/2021 20:26

It's also interesting how someone brought up the subject of a black Hitler.
In England Anne Boleyn is seen as a dividing figure, but her role as mother of our greatest monarch and her own much admired determination and charisma mean she is celebrated here.
However in many European countries she is still so hated they call her the great whore and burn effigies of her. She is not considered a sympathetic or neutral person of history there.
However, I assume this was a British production with a British audience. It does make me wonder whether the same casting decisions would have been made in a film.

Swipe left for the next trending thread