Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Casual racism or AIBU

368 replies

Kooksadooks · 31/12/2021 13:19

Hello. I have a lot on my mind today but hope you are having a nice New Years Eve…
We (me, DP, MIL, FIL, DS ect) were sat around the TV over Christmas period.
The Channel 5 advert featuring Anne Bolelyn played by black actress Jodie Turner-Smith comes on and MIL starts complaining that she ‘doesn’t understand all this’ and ‘Anne Bolelyn wasn’t black’ and doesn’t understand ‘why white people cannot play black people’…
I bit my tongue, I appreciate that I am surrounded by people who agree with her and there’s no point in arguing with them about what I think, also not wanting to cause drama over Christmas but AIBU to feel uncomfortable at MIL’s comments?
I mentioned it to DP afterwards and he agrees with MIL HmmBlushSad

OP posts:
WorriedMumsDontSleep · 01/01/2022 20:23

@SantaClawsServiette

But they’re not ‘making period figures black’, they’re just casting colour blind. No one at the RSC is claiming Henry V was black. As Shakespeare only wrote about two non-white roles, a major National institution whose work is overwhelmingly based on his plays either chooses colourblind casting or opts to be whites-only as regards actors.

Some people really dislike colour blind casting, or they dislike it in more historical type settings. Look at someone like Samuel Jackson complaining that the wrong type of black person was being cast in certain roles - not American.

I find that people often see television in general quite differently from the theater, unless it's a very non-realistic setting. That's not an unfair thing, television and film often go to a lot of trouble to immerse the viewer in a setting that feels realistic. Unlike theater where there is less realism and also a long tradition, especially in small theaters, of roles being played by whomever was avialable.

But it's also not like people are consistent. There was a big kerfuffle in the city I lived in when a small theater production of The Mikado, using very traditional costuming and setting, had European actors in the roles. Keep in mind that I live in a place with a very small Asian population, and an even smaller Japanese population. So no race blindness there even though it would be totally historically accurate for the play and also just realistic in terms of a small city theater production.

People feel like, it's ok to complain about and ultimately shut down a small production of TM because of ethnic representation, but Anne Boleyn should be played by anyone, (maybe even a man!) It doesn't create goodwill.

I would assume that there were no actors available to play the role in amateur dramatics. Far fewer people willing to do unpaid amateur roles and so the role goes to whoever is available. Watched a production of avenue q which, due to the location, was an all white cast. "Everyone's a little bit racist" was a bit cringe in that performance (but I think op should change her ringtone to it!)
Confiscatedpopit · 01/01/2022 19:50

Agree completely with your MIL. My cynical side actually thinks it’s to get people talking about the programme and gain attention (good or bad)- pretty piss poor and deplorable to use the issue of race in this way if this is the case.

SantaClawsServiette · 01/01/2022 19:45

But they’re not ‘making period figures black’, they’re just casting colour blind. No one at the RSC is claiming Henry V was black. As Shakespeare only wrote about two non-white roles, a major National institution whose work is overwhelmingly based on his plays either chooses colourblind casting or opts to be whites-only as regards actors.

Some people really dislike colour blind casting, or they dislike it in more historical type settings. Look at someone like Samuel Jackson complaining that the wrong type of black person was being cast in certain roles - not American.

I find that people often see television in general quite differently from the theater, unless it's a very non-realistic setting. That's not an unfair thing, television and film often go to a lot of trouble to immerse the viewer in a setting that feels realistic. Unlike theater where there is less realism and also a long tradition, especially in small theaters, of roles being played by whomever was avialable.

But it's also not like people are consistent. There was a big kerfuffle in the city I lived in when a small theater production of The Mikado, using very traditional costuming and setting, had European actors in the roles. Keep in mind that I live in a place with a very small Asian population, and an even smaller Japanese population. So no race blindness there even though it would be totally historically accurate for the play and also just realistic in terms of a small city theater production.

People feel like, it's ok to complain about and ultimately shut down a small production of TM because of ethnic representation, but Anne Boleyn should be played by anyone, (maybe even a man!) It doesn't create goodwill.

SantaClawsServiette · 01/01/2022 19:31

@loislovesstewie

No, I am not confused. The Ptolemaic dynasty was Greek which is what I am saying. They intermarried and never became Egyptian. The rest of the country was Egyptian and most of those were darker skinned. And the term 'Moors' was at one point applied to people who were Muslims no matter what their skin colour. Nothing, but nothing, is simple.
You said the pharaohs, that includes a lot more than the Ptolemies, which was my point. Most of the dynasties were not Greek. So we are agreeing, and also about the Moors. Making those exclusively non-white roles doesn't really make a lot of sense in most cases.
Nathlash · 01/01/2022 19:25

@Pinkrose1111

Tbh I'm black and I agree with your MIL. I think it's ridiculous they keep trying to make period figures black or other ethnicities. It's like trying to rewrite history. If they want more black represented period dramas, They're better off making series about actual black monarchs in Africa or the Moors or Egypt or something. Rather than black facing over English monarchs. It's kind of embarrassing imo and just wish they stopped doing it.
But they’re not ‘making period figures black’, they’re just casting colour blind. No one at the RSC is claiming Henry V was black. As Shakespeare only wrote about two non-white roles, a major National institution whose work is overwhelmingly based on his plays either chooses colourblind casting or opts to be whites-only as regards actors.
logsonlogsoff · 01/01/2022 19:15

I like colour blind, and gender blind casting, ( female Hamlet etc) or like in Bridgerton. I think it makes old stories more interesting, gives a modern twist and couldn’t give a shiny shit if Anne Boleyn is played by a non- white actor in a made up tv series.
Not sure it’s racist for someone to say they’d prefer it to be more historically ‘accurate’- just shows a lack of imagination. It’s not like the dialogue and scenes are going to be ‘accurate’ -

LittleRoundRobin · 01/01/2022 19:15

@DeeCeeCherry You sound very angry. Are you OK? Flowers

loislovesstewie · 01/01/2022 19:13

No, I am not confused. The Ptolemaic dynasty was Greek which is what I am saying. They intermarried and never became Egyptian. The rest of the country was Egyptian and most of those were darker skinned. And the term 'Moors' was at one point applied to people who were Muslims no matter what their skin colour. Nothing, but nothing, is simple.

SantaClawsServiette · 01/01/2022 19:09

@loislovesstewie

Oh and you do know the pharaohs were Greek, don't you? So any depiction of them should be Greek and their servants would be, well, Egyptian looking? (The pharaohs intermarried, usually brother/sister etc so that their line was preserved)
I think you are a bit confused there. The dynasty Cleopatra belonged to was Greek, which makes the tendency to want to push non-white people into that role in the theater as if that's a natural choice seem rather silly. It's often a little silly with roles that are supposed to be Moors as well.

But the ancient Egyptians overall were African, in the older period those living closer to the Med were lighter skinned and probably more mixed, those closer to Nubia more dark skinned, but later there was too much mixing to differentiate.

But the theater overall is a bit different than film productions, as the latter in some cases are going for realism in a way the theater doesn't so often.

SantaClawsServiette · 01/01/2022 19:04

@DeeCeeCherry

All this is laughable.

Just because a Black Woman played Anne Boleyn.

After decades of...Tarzan🤣king of the jungle
White man in blackface "pharoahs" but somehow all the Black people around are slaves.

White man mudface makeup playing Native Americans

Various African queens portrayed by White as the driven snow actresses.

It goes to show how delicate, deluded and frankly ludicrous White privilege is.

You're rankled hecause it's your turn and it serves you all right

If Jesus a middle-eastern man and his family showed up during this festive season seeking shelter, you'd clutch your pearls until you choked with eyes bulging

Farcical folk

That's kind of the point though for many people.

They've been told, and maybe agreed, that these things were not good, and that it's really important to think they aren't good and change things.

Now sudden;y it's ok, or different when you reverse it.

People feel it's not a good change or reveals a certain disingenuousness.

SantaClawsServiette · 01/01/2022 19:01

This is something people can have totally different opinions about without any of them being racist.

Lots of people are not all that crazy about historical figures being played by people of other races because they don't find it credible in a realistic drama.

Others think it is a problem in terms of representation.

And some people feel that there is a double standard operating in the performing arts and that doesn't sit right with them.

It's possible to disagree with any of those things without thinking the only reason people might think them is that they are racists.

FurryAntiWaxer · 01/01/2022 18:56

Surely there is a point where an actor is so incongruent from an historical or historically significant character it becomes impossible to suspend disbelief and just seems odd and pointlessly distracting.
Failing that, I'll sit back and wait for a remake of Gone With then Wind with Marcus Rutherford playing Scarlett O'Hara. Because, why not?

loislovesstewie · 01/01/2022 18:43

Oh and you do know the pharaohs were Greek, don't you? So any depiction of them should be Greek and their servants would be, well, Egyptian looking? (The pharaohs intermarried, usually brother/sister etc so that their line was preserved)

AlbertCampion · 01/01/2022 17:47

@EmpressCixi I completely agree that there should be more diversity in theatre in terms of writing. But I also think that where theatre companies such as the RSC are concerned, where the great majority of their work is Shakespeare or renaissance works, then to exclude actors from roles in these plays, simply because their heritage doesn't match that of the original characters, is wrong. I have many actor friends who are deeply offended when it is suggested that their casting was simply an act of tokenism, rather than because they were the best person for the role. They are insulted by the suggestion.

Pinkrose1111 · 01/01/2022 17:46

Tbh I'm black and I agree with your MIL. I think it's ridiculous they keep trying to make period figures black or other ethnicities. It's like trying to rewrite history. If they want more black represented period dramas, They're better off making series about actual black monarchs in Africa or the Moors or Egypt or something. Rather than black facing over English monarchs. It's kind of embarrassing imo and just wish they stopped doing it.

Isitsixoclockalready · 01/01/2022 17:40

If one is looking for historical accuracy then clearly one wouldn't be racist by merely saying that a black person playing a person who was white is not an accurate portrayal but I'm confused by her saying that there is no reason that a white person can't play a black person. In what context? If the part requires a character who is black then it would be ridiculous to say that it should be played by a white person.

Of course when one considers the accuracy of historical/traditional portrayals of Jesus as a white European then maybe an argument could be made that it doesn't matter that much anyway!

Bluebluemoon · 01/01/2022 17:40

After decades of...Tarzan🤣king of the jungle

You have some valid points but Tarzan was supposed to be white. Are you saying there shouldn't be a fictional character who is white and king of the jungle?

I think that's pushing it a bit! Maybe write your own book about a black fictional king of the jungle?

Magnited · 01/01/2022 17:39

@DeeCeeCherry

All this is laughable.

Just because a Black Woman played Anne Boleyn.

After decades of...Tarzan🤣king of the jungle
White man in blackface "pharoahs" but somehow all the Black people around are slaves.

White man mudface makeup playing Native Americans

Various African queens portrayed by White as the driven snow actresses.

It goes to show how delicate, deluded and frankly ludicrous White privilege is.

You're rankled hecause it's your turn and it serves you all right

If Jesus a middle-eastern man and his family showed up during this festive season seeking shelter, you'd clutch your pearls until you choked with eyes bulging

Farcical folk

Quite!
DeeCeeCherry · 01/01/2022 17:34

All this is laughable.

Just because a Black Woman played Anne Boleyn.

After decades of...Tarzan🤣king of the jungle
White man in blackface "pharoahs" but somehow all the Black people around are slaves.

White man mudface makeup playing Native Americans

Various African queens portrayed by White as the driven snow actresses.

It goes to show how delicate, deluded and frankly ludicrous White privilege is.

You're rankled hecause it's your turn and it serves you all right

If Jesus a middle-eastern man and his family showed up during this festive season seeking shelter, you'd clutch your pearls until you choked with eyes bulging

Farcical folk

mustlovegin · 01/01/2022 17:26

And I’d be happier to see black people playing ‘white roles’ whilst we all get used to a new ‘order of things’

Would you care to elaborate what this new 'order' is and who has dictated that we need to get used to it?

The UK is a majority white country, hence it is to be expected that period dramas that people want to see are related to our own very prominent historical figures (which happen to be mostly white). It would be different in other countries, obviously

mustlovegin · 01/01/2022 17:21

I worry that by calling these casting decisions tokenism, we insult those wonderful actors who got the roles because they were the best people for the job. Couldn't that just be the case with the Anne Boleyn casting? Perhaps talent is more important than skin colour.

Really? How can you tell that someone is the best actor for the role and nobody could have done it better? Is there an objective measure for this?

StarbucksSmarterSister · 01/01/2022 17:14

Midsomer Murders is another one - it suggests 50% of isolated English villagers are of BAME

That must be fairlt recent since I've rarely seen any non white characters. I did give up when Jones left though. Smile

psydrive · 01/01/2022 17:05

@Xenia

Certainly back to the times of Shakespeare men played women's parts and vice versa and pantomime had all that cross dressing and all boys' or all girls'' schools will always have had people of the wrong sex playing the other one - Mary in all boys' schools Christmas nativity plays will be played by a boy. I think my son was Mary one year - youngest in the class, although being white blonde with blue eyes he may not have been the best choice given the number of Jewish boys in he school who ethnically would have matched the mother of God better.

Sometimes programmes go over the top and it becomes too difficult to believe the story line - that's my take on it and that's a pity. I am now enjoying the New Dexter but the very first scenes made me feel like we had been moved for thos series to sa north Korean political education camp for a lecture rather than sitting at home enoying a show.As he's in Alaska I have no problem with his girl friend being native American and those tribal people being shown in the story - it is relevant interesting and part of it. However t put so many black African cops in there and then the man running the shop is gay and when the person without legs who works in the police station came on you are almost laughing at the ridiculousness of it. After the introduction of the cast of gay, black, disabled characters in the Alaskan village it has calmed down a bit and I have been able to get into the show but it just felt so very pretentious and contrived to start with. Midsomer Murders is another one - it suggests 50% of isolated English villagers are of BAME background from the vicars to the businessmen to the doctors. If it were inner London it would be more believable.

Xenia, you have said stupid fucking things in the past but saying that including black gay and disabled characters in a TV program is like living in North Korea is idiotic even for you.
WorriedMumsDontSleep · 01/01/2022 16:42

Midsomer Murders is another one - it suggests 50% of isolated English villagers are of BAME
You should watch famalam
They have a sketch called midsummer moyherfukxing murders and it's hilarious.

mustlovegin · 01/01/2022 16:37

I am now enjoying the New Dexter

It's a shame they've done this. The first series was ingenious. By your description the 'new' version will be tedious, and politicised i.e. another unwatchable on the list

Swipe left for the next trending thread