Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Casual racism or AIBU

368 replies

Kooksadooks · 31/12/2021 13:19

Hello. I have a lot on my mind today but hope you are having a nice New Years Eve…
We (me, DP, MIL, FIL, DS ect) were sat around the TV over Christmas period.
The Channel 5 advert featuring Anne Bolelyn played by black actress Jodie Turner-Smith comes on and MIL starts complaining that she ‘doesn’t understand all this’ and ‘Anne Bolelyn wasn’t black’ and doesn’t understand ‘why white people cannot play black people’…
I bit my tongue, I appreciate that I am surrounded by people who agree with her and there’s no point in arguing with them about what I think, also not wanting to cause drama over Christmas but AIBU to feel uncomfortable at MIL’s comments?
I mentioned it to DP afterwards and he agrees with MIL HmmBlushSad

OP posts:
WorriedMumsDontSleep · 02/01/2022 14:08

Well, if we're going to be historical about it he's from Turkey.

But we tell children he's from Lapland so a white father Christmas isn't out of place. Not that he can't be anything else. He can, I'm sure he reflects the cultures he appears in.

BigFatLiar · 02/01/2022 13:41

Wasn't Father Christmas central European though.

All this shouldn't matter as these are entertainment, however for a lot of people its how they learn their history. People watch docu-dramas on the TV and consider that history.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 02/01/2022 09:53

Like a polar bear lol.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 02/01/2022 09:51

@brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

Point out the inevitable northern European looking white baby jesus on a xmas card
Least popular Christmas card design. Mil likes th though, although this year's was more middle eastern looking but that might have just been because it used 'nighttime setting'. Can't get worked up about multiracial father Christmas although he should look like a native inhabitant of the north pole.
brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 02/01/2022 09:42

Point out the inevitable northern European looking white baby jesus on a xmas card

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 02/01/2022 09:16

Having an actress who physically stood out from the majority surrounding her could have been a more deliberate directorial tactic (sorry not correct word, can't think of it) than just colour blind casting?

I'm sure that was the rationale they used, but it doesn't work because it adds in an important dynamic that was wasn't there. Ditto adding in lesbian overtones.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 02/01/2022 09:14

There was an interesting series on BBC about her father, Thomas Boleyn, being so determindly pushy to get position and influence at Henry's court and how he used his children to further that ambition.

He wasn't unusual I'm this by any stretch. The Seymour's and the Howard's both did the same.

I think that the reason people keep going back to Anne is that she was a charismatic and complicated enough character, she was the first queen executed (ever I. England, although this action had consequences well down the Tudor line and beyond) and her marriage destabilised British religion and class so much we saw many reforms until it resettled.

Yes Anne was clever. So was Catherine of Aragon. Yes she was an outsider at court from living in a foreign court. So was Anne of Cleves. Yes she was learned. So was Catherine Parr. Yes she was betrayed. So was Catherine of Aragon, Catherine Howard and Catherine Parr.

She had a very interesting life. But it was her death and her role as the mother of Elizabeth that keeps her in the national consciousness.

SantaClawsServiette · 02/01/2022 03:41

[quote username1987a]@SantaClawsServiette I was talking about TV shows and shows on streaming services such as Netflix. I don't agree with historical inaccuracy. What I'm saying (not very well) is that we need to invest in stories from black and brown people. We need more Michaela Coels writing and directing their stories. I don't think the OPs MIL is racist with what she said. People can have opinions on things I hope and she has a good point. We need black and brown people writing and directing, we need more diversity in that respect. (And more women's stories too but I don't want to digress).[/quote]
There is absolutely more room for writers and directors from a variety of backgrounds. Though I'm not sure that's about the entertainment industry so much as other demographic forces in the workforce, so it may change over time as that changes.

It's also pretty normal though when you watch any nations film and television output, that they typically have content that reflects their cultural and national history. I don't see that as in itself problematic.

tomorrowalready · 02/01/2022 03:15

I admit I did not watch the programme being discussed though I did read some discussion about it at the time. But having read the points here about historical accurate representation, it occurred to me maybe the programme makers wanted to make a strong point about how disruptive Ann Boleyn was to Henry's court and to English history. As others have said the story is so well known and has been retold so many times to bring a fresh viewpoint is very difficult.

The story of Henry Viii and Ann Boleyn is so important to English history and also so grounded in the physicality of being a royal ruler (the struggle to have a living male heir, the development of Henry's appearance and character as he aged) that to have Boleyn represented by someone who looks different from other courtiers but is at the same time intimately enmeshed in the life of both the court and the country may have been intended to provoke thought about her role beyond what we tend to assume we know already.

There was an interesting series on BBC about her father, Thomas Boleyn, being so determindly pushy to get position and influence at Henry's court and how he used his children to further that ambition. Ann had spent quite a few years in France , one of the accusations against her when she fell was that she had too much foreign influence in herself and on Henry. Having an actress who physically stood out from the majority surrounding her could have been a more deliberate directorial tactic (sorry not correct word, can't think of it) than just colour blind casting?

DixonD · 02/01/2022 00:24

I do agree that we need far more historical or fictional dramas on television that focus on black characters.

DixonD · 02/01/2022 00:22

@WhoAre

I agree that they wouldn't even blink if it was the other way around!
Well I’m white, and I don’t think a white person should play a black person, or the other way around.

When they cast a black actress in that drama, I felt it was simply to make a statement rather than for genuine artistic purposes. She should have been played by a white actress for historical accuracy.

I would feel the same way if a white actor was cast to play a black historical character.

It’s not about racism, but making accurate historical portrayals.

Ionlydomassiveones · 01/01/2022 23:21

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

username1987a · 01/01/2022 21:58

@SantaClawsServiette I was talking about TV shows and shows on streaming services such as Netflix. I don't agree with historical inaccuracy. What I'm saying (not very well) is that we need to invest in stories from black and brown people. We need more Michaela Coels writing and directing their stories. I don't think the OPs MIL is racist with what she said. People can have opinions on things I hope and she has a good point. We need black and brown people writing and directing, we need more diversity in that respect. (And more women's stories too but I don't want to digress).

SantaClawsServiette · 01/01/2022 21:49

@username1987a

As pp have said, this is very common in theatre. I saw a play based on the life of Anne B where the king was black. Anne was played by a white actor.

What is needed is a big investment in black and brown writers who are writing their own stories. There are plenty of them about but they need to get produced. It's laziness really although there are initiatives about. When people talk about a female Bond, I'm thinking write her story! Produce it and get it out there. There needs to be more diversity.

I think theater and film often function quite differently.

The problem with getting anything other than established film types made is a bigger problem I suspect. For high end films they are so expensive no one wants to do anything but Marvel, Star Wars, Bond, etc. It isn't really a good thing for anyone, even actors who I am sure are bored out of their minds.

username1987a · 01/01/2022 21:39

As pp have said, this is very common in theatre. I saw a play based on the life of Anne B where the king was black. Anne was played by a white actor.

What is needed is a big investment in black and brown writers who are writing their own stories. There are plenty of them about but they need to get produced. It's laziness really although there are initiatives about. When people talk about a female Bond, I'm thinking write her story! Produce it and get it out there. There needs to be more diversity.

BendicksBittermints4Breakfast · 01/01/2022 21:29

@Ionlydomassiveones

I don’t see what’s racist about saying something factual. Anne Boleyn wasn’t black and it’s quite jarring for those of us who like historical drama to have the facts distorted. Same with war movies made in Hollywood that always make the Americans the heroes.

This stupid overreaction to any opinion that isn’t 100% ‘right on’ is why we’ve got this insufferable woke cancel culture. YABU. Get a grip and move on.

Bravo and good luck.
Brigante9 · 01/01/2022 21:16

But there’s hell on if a white actor plays a character who was black. Anne Boleyn wasn’t black so how is this ok?

Tal45 · 01/01/2022 21:16

I think this sort of thing can work fantastically or fail miserably, if it's just sticking in a black person to appear woke it's just pointless, why not write a decent part for a black woman instead? If it done and cast very cleverly to play with the dynamics or turn things on their head or because it works really well in some way then fair play.

The best Tybalt (male character Romeo and Juliet) I ever saw was played by a black women at The Globe, blew me away, fantastic casting by the crazy but brilliant Emma Rice. The worst casting I ever saw was Hermione in The Cursed Child. All the other actors were really obviously chosen to resemble the cast from the film - except Hermione who didn't seem to bear any resemblance in any of her mannerisms. It seemed she'd been shoe horned in to make the cast more acceptably diverse and didn't work at all IMO.

SantaClawsServiette · 01/01/2022 21:15

Not really.. actors are acting. I conclude that the only logical objection is racism. And I don't think that is unfair or a stretch. It is the racist making it an issue. So yeah.. racism. Not really another logical explanation. Actors do not need to be 'historically accurate ' in their ethnicity. They are acting

That's very much your opinion. Lots of productions work hard at historical realism, including in casting. You might not care but some people do, including some non-white actors. This is why you get people upset when Angelina Joli was cast as a Hispanic woman, or Samuel Jackson unhappy that black British actors were cast as black Americans.

There are other people who prefer blind casting, but even they won't suggest that they get a white man to play Desmond Tutu, even if he can be convincing in the role.

Disagree with them by all means but are you really calling them racists?

Sandinmyknickers · 01/01/2022 21:10

@Pinkrose1111

Tbh I'm black and I agree with your MIL. I think it's ridiculous they keep trying to make period figures black or other ethnicities. It's like trying to rewrite history. If they want more black represented period dramas, They're better off making series about actual black monarchs in Africa or the Moors or Egypt or something. Rather than black facing over English monarchs. It's kind of embarrassing imo and just wish they stopped doing it.
No one is "trying to rewrite history " or claim that famous historical figures were black. What they are saying is that actors can portray them regardless if they look like them. I think the "I am black so...." is not valid. You are one individual
Livpool · 01/01/2022 21:05

I agree with your MiL - it was jarring. I think it was a tokenism case - which I find a bit insulting.

There were black people in Tudor times

  • let us hear their stories. Or other black stories that ARE accurate; Mary Seacole, Harriet Tubman, Rosa Parks. Why don't we get the stories of strong, black women.

And I couldn't care less if a fictional character is played by anyone. They aren't real!

I think it matters a lot less in the theatre too as you are expected to suspend reality anyway due to sets etc.

Sandinmyknickers · 01/01/2022 21:05

@SantaClawsServiette

This is something people can have totally different opinions about without any of them being racist.

Lots of people are not all that crazy about historical figures being played by people of other races because they don't find it credible in a realistic drama.

Others think it is a problem in terms of representation.

And some people feel that there is a double standard operating in the performing arts and that doesn't sit right with them.

It's possible to disagree with any of those things without thinking the only reason people might think them is that they are racists.

Not really.. actors are acting. I conclude that the only logical objection is racism. And I don't think that is unfair or a stretch. It is the racist making it an issue. So yeah.. racism. Not really another logical explanation. Actors do not need to be 'historically accurate ' in their ethnicity. They are acting
Sandinmyknickers · 01/01/2022 20:59

So you disagree with your MIL but didn't have the guts to call her out....yabu

SantaClawsServiette · 01/01/2022 20:34

And I also think in the case of this production, while they may not have planned to cast across race, they are very purposefully using it for publicity. So they have an interest in trying to push buttons with it in their advertising and they've done so very carefully.

SantaClawsServiette · 01/01/2022 20:31

I would assume that there were no actors available to play the role in amateur dramatics.Far fewer people willing to do unpaid amateur roles and so the role goes to whoever is available.Watched a production of avenue q which, due to the location, was an all white cast."Everyone's a little bit racist" was a bit cringe in that performance (but I think op should change her ringtone to it!)

That may well be the case, but perhaps they didn't look. But then, why should they, if colour blind casting is perfectly ok?

To me that's the issue. Most people are not spending hours thinking about theeries about casting. But they are hearing all kinds of people saying it's really bad to cast people who are not x. y, or z in certain roles, and at the same time that it is ok to do the same casting in the reverse way.

It tends to put people's back up a little. And then they also mix it up with their own personal preferences about realistic or non-realistic casting, and even ideas about making up actors to play other ethnicity which has become taboo.

None of it is really logical and that makes people more reactive in my experience.

Swipe left for the next trending thread