Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Casual racism or AIBU

368 replies

Kooksadooks · 31/12/2021 13:19

Hello. I have a lot on my mind today but hope you are having a nice New Years Eve…
We (me, DP, MIL, FIL, DS ect) were sat around the TV over Christmas period.
The Channel 5 advert featuring Anne Bolelyn played by black actress Jodie Turner-Smith comes on and MIL starts complaining that she ‘doesn’t understand all this’ and ‘Anne Bolelyn wasn’t black’ and doesn’t understand ‘why white people cannot play black people’…
I bit my tongue, I appreciate that I am surrounded by people who agree with her and there’s no point in arguing with them about what I think, also not wanting to cause drama over Christmas but AIBU to feel uncomfortable at MIL’s comments?
I mentioned it to DP afterwards and he agrees with MIL HmmBlushSad

OP posts:
crowsfeet57 · 31/12/2021 14:21

White actor Ben Kingsley won an Oscar for playing Mahatma Gandhi!

Ben Kingsley's real name is Krishna Pandit Bhanji and he is of Indian descent on his father's side.

WhatIsAWeekday · 31/12/2021 14:21

I'm Black. Blackity Black. If a film is about a real person, I don't think someone of a different ethnicity should play that person. So for a Black person: Anne Boleyn? No. James Bond? Yes.

Although I side-eye people spouting "Woke" at any opportunity or those who say things like "what if white people played a black character..."
We all know it's been happening and why: Whitewashing. So that's not the rebuttal some people think it is. It's rightfully being called out.

I loathe that Black people are being shoehorned in history films, playing a different ethnicity, as if doing them a favour. New fictional films can be written (period pieces, etc) with Black people as lead and many black people in the film (not just have one token Black person), if it's truly about diversity and representation. I'm not seeing that yet, so I don't buy these quota-filling gestures.

Genderwitched · 31/12/2021 14:21

Yes, I agree, there have been many magnificent portrayals of Shakespeare's characters by black actors. Characters which are based on white people such as Macbeth and Hamlet. Out of all the colour blind casting this has been the only one that has jarred a bit for me and I think it is probably because Anne Boleyns appearance has always been a quite strong part of her character for me. The sallow skin and black hair, making her such a contrast to Jane Seymour. Agree that her story has been told enough now.

ChristmasHost21 · 31/12/2021 14:21

@jellyxat

Are the people here complaining about a black Anne B also anti-Hamilton?
I was just coming on here to say "wasnt Alexander Hamilton white...and Hamilton is one of the most powerful amazing productions out there...more like this please
bonetiredwithtwins · 31/12/2021 14:18

I agree with your MIL

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 31/12/2021 14:18

TV adaptions do have power-and that can change public perception of the historically so radically they become a different person and changes the dynamic.
Catherine of Aragon was a pale English rose. No really. Her portraits and lineage confirm it. She was also very decisive, powerful and strong.
But decades of a dark Spanish looking subservient Catherine have changed her profile in the public consciousness. A great loss, as she was so much more than the long suffering wife.

saraclara · 31/12/2021 14:17

In itself, it's a perfectly reasonable thing to say, and in this thread there are black and mixed-race people who agree. A portrayal of someone who lived, should be played by someone of their ethnicity where at all possible. Fictional people, even if their ethnicity was mentioned in the original book, I don't see a problem with casting however one wants.

But of course if there's a back story to these people's attitudes I can see why hackles would rise. I wouldn't choose this comment to pick a fight with them on though.

KenAdams · 31/12/2021 14:16

Also agree with @toddybell and I'm BAME.

I want to see a factually accurate representation if real people are being portrayed.

However, if its fiction, casting should be colourblind unless the story dictates a reason for it not to be (nobody would want to play a black Hitler I'm sure, unless it was a Black Mirror episode!). Bridgerton for example works beautifully, without them doing the "aren't we wonderful for our casting" stuff that you often see.

Eleganz · 31/12/2021 14:16

@Shade17

I can see both sides to the argument, I couldn’t get into Chernobyl because I just couldn’t get past the English language and British accents, totally jarring and for me unwatchable.
So you would have preferred it to be in Russian with subtitles? I can see that would be more authentic, but I suspect it would have hit the ratings quite a lot. I really enjoyed Das Boot and also Barbarians where everyone spoke the native language of their character (or a close modern equivalent).

I'm quite happy to have English language used in such dramas as long as it doesn't use the stupid cod accents that you used to hear.

I really enjoyed "The Death of Stalin" for example and I thought that the use of the various English accents and colloquial language was actually quite effective at bringing you closer to the characters. Of course it was a satirical comedy not a supposedly accurate historical drama though.

MoodyMooToo · 31/12/2021 14:16

@Lacedwithgrace

It's racist, they wouldn't give half a shit if a white actor played the role of a black person. My ILs are the same, and I'm black 🙃
It’s not racist, it’s a fact. As for the other comment then I’d assume she has been raised where blackface wasn’t a big deal, so rather than biting your tongue perhaps you should have raised the point and helped her understand that in this day and age it’s not acceptable and why
loislovesstewie · 31/12/2021 14:14

@LondonWolf yes, a complete lie as well.

TrishM80 · 31/12/2021 14:13

@BigFatLiar

In some ways it's a problem in others no. She was acting so in a drama it doesn't matter. It may not have been accurate but perhaps a good point to that would be to highlight it was a story. Sadly many take these sort of dramas as truth.

Perhaps next we get a black princess Di. A white Martin Luther.

Martin Luther WAS white!
BigFatLiar · 31/12/2021 14:12

In some ways it's a problem in others no. She was acting so in a drama it doesn't matter. It may not have been accurate but perhaps a good point to that would be to highlight it was a story. Sadly many take these sort of dramas as truth.

Perhaps next we get a black princess Di. A white Martin Luther.

RedWingBoots · 31/12/2021 14:08

[quote Genderwitched]@doadeer

But Anne Boleyn is not a character like James Bond, she was a real person.[/quote]
Any dramas about her will be historically inaccurate so it doesn't matter who plays her especially as dramas involving the Tudors have been done to death.

LondonWolf · 31/12/2021 14:07

@loislovesstewie

Neither was McBeth fictional.
No, but Shakespeare’s account was…
StarbucksSmarterSister · 31/12/2021 14:06

£The difference is that they’re fictional characters*

Well Bond is obviously, but MacBeth was a real King of Scotland (although Shaky, as with Richard III, took liberties with the story).

LondonWolf · 31/12/2021 14:06

@Shade17

I can see both sides to the argument, I couldn’t get into Chernobyl because I just couldn’t get past the English language and British accents, totally jarring and for me unwatchable.
Hmm, we’d have been waiting a long time of we’d waited for The Russians to broadcast any remotely accurate account of Chernobyl.
Notjustanymum · 31/12/2021 14:05

@newname12345, I’m curious about your comment. I do think that she could have played Dennis Nielsen, certainly on stage - I played male characters at school, for example, as it was an all-girl school and so half the characters cross-dressed/acted (this was in the ‘70’s and no one batted an eyelid!)
I did think, though, when making my initial comment, that using my argument, might lead to less conflict with family members than insinuations of racism.
Sadly, after I posted my comment though, OP has admitted that it was racist, and shockingly, that her DP agreed with MIL.
So sorry you’ve had to experience this, OP.

loislovesstewie · 31/12/2021 14:04

Neither was McBeth fictional.

Shade17 · 31/12/2021 14:02

I can see both sides to the argument, I couldn’t get into Chernobyl because I just couldn’t get past the English language and British accents, totally jarring and for me unwatchable.

doadeer · 31/12/2021 14:02

[quote Genderwitched]@doadeer

But Anne Boleyn is not a character like James Bond, she was a real person.[/quote]
Yes I understand this. I actually have a Masters in Early Modern History 🤣

For me... If an adaptation has been done to death like the Tudors have been... Having a different interpretation that is historically inaccurate is fine. Look at how many black actors do Shakespeare plays at the Globe. It's an adaptation. Most series or films about the period are littered with inaccuracies anyway! From costumes to accents - it's entertainment not a documentary.

sadpapercourtesan · 31/12/2021 13:59

I agree with your MIL in that Anne Boleyn's ethnicity - and quite a lot about her appearance - is known. Accuracy in historical writing/depiction matters to me, as far as it is possible.

I am autistic which may be a factor; my obsessive interest is early modern history. I did my degree in it and have written a couple of historical novels. I have wasted spent huge amounts of time researching all the portraits and sketches of Anne Boleyn (and various other figures) and trying to work out which is the most accurate. I have Holbein and Hilliard portraits on my walls. I didn't like The Tudors either, because Jonathan Rhys-Meyers is all wrong for Henry VIII (and not just in his appearance). I don't like The Other Boleyn Girl, because it's so cavalier with the facts that it might as well be a completely fictional story that just borrows names from history.

I suspect there are a LOT of people who wince at the casting in this drama but wouldn't say so IRL, because they don't want to be considered racist.

LondonWolf · 31/12/2021 13:59

I agree with your MIL.

However I hear Denzel Washington is playing MacBeth and I cannot wait to see it. Supremely talented and one of my favourite actors in my favourite Shakespeare play, just brilliant. I also think that Idris Elba would have been a fantastic Bond too. The difference is that they’re fictional characters and anyone can and should play them..

Stichintime · 31/12/2021 13:59

I totally agree with LaBellina.

TrishM80 · 31/12/2021 13:58

My apologies, I wasn't aware of Kingsley's Indian heritage! As a pp said though, they did bronze him up for the role. Still a great movie though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread