Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Casual racism or AIBU

368 replies

Kooksadooks · 31/12/2021 13:19

Hello. I have a lot on my mind today but hope you are having a nice New Years Eve…
We (me, DP, MIL, FIL, DS ect) were sat around the TV over Christmas period.
The Channel 5 advert featuring Anne Bolelyn played by black actress Jodie Turner-Smith comes on and MIL starts complaining that she ‘doesn’t understand all this’ and ‘Anne Bolelyn wasn’t black’ and doesn’t understand ‘why white people cannot play black people’…
I bit my tongue, I appreciate that I am surrounded by people who agree with her and there’s no point in arguing with them about what I think, also not wanting to cause drama over Christmas but AIBU to feel uncomfortable at MIL’s comments?
I mentioned it to DP afterwards and he agrees with MIL HmmBlushSad

OP posts:
Theluggage15 · 31/12/2021 14:47

Well Eddie Redmayne apologised for playing a trans woman recently.

endofbluenight · 31/12/2021 14:47

Citation needed or is it the usual MN trans shoehorn?

Don't you read news of any sort? How on earth can this have passed you by?

WhatIsAWeekday · 31/12/2021 14:47

I'm beginning to think industry executives make these decisions in order to generate more buzz (therefore more views, more money) for the films than they would've gotten. In other words, dangle Black people as bait and capitalise on the controversies it will inevitably cause.

It really isn't about caring to represent ethnic minorities. If money isn't to be made, it won't happen.

PuppyMonkey · 31/12/2021 14:46

I’m not black or mixed race but the thing that jars a little for me is that casting a black actor in a role portraying, say, the English upper classes in, for example, the regency era to me just skates over and rewrites the very real situation/struggle of many black people of that era, eg the slave trade.

Isn’t it really insulting to infer that a black person at that time could live a life of luxury in England as the Duke or Duchess or Princess of Whatever where no mention was ever made of their heritage because everyone was really accepting and colour blind then?

endofbluenight · 31/12/2021 14:46

The problem I have with white people pay white characters and black people play black characters only is that most of the classics, books etc… have all been written about white people by white people. Most of the important characters in history are white etc…

Well, most of the important characters in Europe perhaps.
Maybe the problem is more that we have films made of quite a narrow range of subjects/ settings/ times. Maybe we need to focus on expanding what topics films are made about and the roles within them, if we want to expand diversity. Like someone else said, we don't need a female James Bond, we just need more good roles for women.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 31/12/2021 14:44

@endofbluenight

Your MIL is expressing an opinion that actors should be of the same ethnicity or 'identity' of the characters they play, which is actually a very popular opinion among people who describe themselves as leftwing and progressive.
Citation needed or is it the usual MN trans shoehorn?
endofbluenight · 31/12/2021 14:42

Your MIL is expressing an opinion that actors should be of the same ethnicity or 'identity' of the characters they play, which is actually a very popular opinion among people who describe themselves as leftwing and progressive.

Starcaller · 31/12/2021 14:41

The 'if it was the other way round it wouldn't be allowed' shit is a false equivalency as white people haven't been systematically oppressed and abused by black people throughout history. If you can't see the difference then there's no helping you, really.

LostForIdeas · 31/12/2021 14:41

The problem I have with white people pay white characters and black people play black characters only is that most of the classics, books etc… have all been written about white people by white people.
Most of the important characters in history are white etc…

So that doesn’t leave a lot of space for black people to play important/recognised parts and characters iyswim.

Diaryprovinciallady · 31/12/2021 14:40

I doubt it would have mattered to your MIL if they'd cast a woman with different hair colour to the historical Anne Boleyn or some other feature that wasn't historically accurate. It just seems like her objection to a black person playing the role implies that skin colour is the defining thing that 'matters'. That said, if a white person played someone who was known to be black, I wouldn't be comfortable with that. Not very consistent but that's how I feel about it. If we lived in a world with total racial equality then it wouldn't matter, but we don't.

whiteroseredrose · 31/12/2021 14:40

It depends on how realistic we expect films and programmes to be, whether we are happy with some creativity, and how far it goes.

Paintings are no longer aiming to be just like photographs - we embrace the Impressionists and cubists for example and enjoy them for what they are.

Bridgerton was fab IMO and the diversity of the cast made it more interesting. And the families shared an ethnicity.

At the beginning of lockdown I watched The National Theatre's Twelfth Night. The cast had different ethnicities but the twins playing Viola and Sebastian were the same ethnicity so it worked.

In contrast The Royal Exchange did Streetcar Named Desire and Stella and Blanche were different ethnicities - which felt odd for a play set in the Deep South at that period in time. I wasn't sure if there was a hidden message.

Similarly The Royal Exchange's Macbeth had a woman in the title role, described as mother not father. It seemed bonkers when she started the speech 'Am I not a man...' well, no, you're not actually!

Starcaller · 31/12/2021 14:39

YANBU.

We don't seem to care about historical accuracy in plenty of other TV shows that are to entertain us. And I'm pretty sure most people can stretch their brains to work out Anne Boleyn probably wasn't black, just like we manage to watch plenty of other things where the person playing a character in the 1500s has perfect teeth. But let's not consign BAME people to any more years of having to play slaves or servants because they are disbarred from playing interesting historical figures just due to skin colour.

Hand in hand though is the real issue that we should be making more TV about people of colour generally so their own stories can be told so they don't have to go through this shite every time they want to take an interesting role.

JustAnotherPoster00 · 31/12/2021 14:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted as it quotes a deleted post.

asfuckedascanbe1224 · 31/12/2021 14:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

sadpapercourtesan · 31/12/2021 14:33

I would add to my comment that anyone who

a) whines about immigration
b) thinks white people should play black characters as some sort of gotcha
c) thinks it's all PC gawn maaaaaaad or "the woke brigade"

is probably a fucking tool.

VladmirsPoutine · 31/12/2021 14:31

Grin reverse racism?

The world's gone mad

This is what people say when they abruptly find themselves no longer able to air their racist views without any pushback.

MasterBeth · 31/12/2021 14:31

It’s outrageous that Jodie Turner-Smith played Anne Boleyn.

History tells us that Anne Boleyn was between 5’ and 5’3” tall. Pandering to political correctness by casting anyone over that height, like the 5’8” Turner-Smith, is offensive and wrong.

Said no-one ever.

It’s all make believe. If you are offended by cross-racial but not cross-height casting, ask what that says about you? Why can you cope with someone of a different height pretending to be someone else but not cope with someone of a different skin tone pretending to be someone else?

FrippEnos · 31/12/2021 14:30

BigFatLiar
Perhaps next we get a black princess Di.

Casual racism or AIBU
WhatIsAWeekday · 31/12/2021 14:30

[quote Kooksadooks]@Notamaidenname I am concerned about DP. He also shared his views to me about immigration not long after MILs comments and honestly I am shocked, this is the first time he has shared views like this to me and in the past has said the opposite. I am an immigrant myself and I think a pile up of ‘small’ comments has led me to feeling this way.[/quote]
Your issue is a lot more than a single comment about Anne Boleyn, which is why I didn't want to say I agree with your MIL. Besides the single line of 'Anne Boleyn shouldn't be played by a Black woman because she was a real white person', the rest of what she says and the undertone I got from it isn't someone I want to be on the side of. The typical 'anti-woke/anti-pc' brigade. I have no time for such people as they usually have a hidden agenda.

As for your DP, I think it's a day of reckoning for you. You may want to have important conversations and ask important questions to know where you both stand on values. These are things people should know about each other in relationships.

CMZ2018 · 31/12/2021 14:29

It’s casting a white person with a black actor for the sake of it

JackTheHack · 31/12/2021 14:28

@toddybell

I'm black and I agree with your MIL. Anne Boleyn wasn't Black so should be played by someone who factually represented who she was re: ethnicity . I'd feel the same if someone white came along and played Martin Luther King or Mary Jane Seacole or Harriet Seacole or Mahatma Ghandi, etc.
I agree. It's almost reverse racism, like trying too hard. Real black people should be played by black actors, Chinese should be played by Chinese actors, white should be played by white actors. We need more fictional plays, movies, soaps etc that just have different races in them. It's simple. You can almost predict in adverts now, the family will be black dad, white mum and two mixed race children. There's never an Asian Mum and a black man. Or a Chinese couple, or Polish couple yet I know more couples like this!! There are more same sex couples which is good, but even the BT advert depicted them in bed! The world's gone mad
Shade17 · 31/12/2021 14:27

So you would have preferred it to be in Russian with subtitles?

That’s exactly what I’d have preferred. Like Narcos, that would have been terrible if Pablo Escobar had spoken English with an American accent.

BigFatLiar · 31/12/2021 14:25

Sorry @TrishM80 missed the King - Martin Luther King the minister and rights campaigner

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 31/12/2021 14:22

Hamilton imo is awful. Awful man, awful show.

XelaM · 31/12/2021 14:22

I agree with your MIL. It's nonsensical to have a black actress play Anne Boleyn.

Swipe left for the next trending thread