Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do we decide 'social class'?

133 replies

badspella · 31/12/2021 08:09

I have been reading one or two threads about 'social class', and it reminded me that I am really confused about the whole notion of social classification (the labels we use, rather than stratification itself).

For example, I know a family who are farmers. They own a good few acres of prime land, and live in a large listed house. However, the house is falling to pieces (holes in the roof, rotten floorboards and so on) and the grandfather left school before receiving any formal qualifications. The son (who now farms the land) completed secondary education. All the family speak with a strong regional accent. The farm is worth well over £1 million.

What class are they?

Then, there is one of my friends who has a masters degree and PhD, is a university lecturer. She was brought up in a large detached house, but, she lives in a rented council house.

What class is she?

I must state that I do not spend my time trying to fit people into little boxes, but I do wonder how 'class' is 'decided', especially when contexts are so complex.

OP posts:
supperlover · 31/12/2021 09:17

There's the classifications sociologists would use- A,B etc. There's occupations and professions but, when I was young, and still in certain social groups, the real give away is attitude, taste, manners and subtle messages conveyed by language. The truly upper classes never say, toilet,settee, living room pardon etc. Always lavatory or loo,sitting room or drawing room, sofa , what not pardon etc. Nancy Mitford called it 'u' and ' non u' and in the 80s Jilly Cooper's book, Class was very funny but accurate as was Grayson Perry's series on class some years ago.

Magnited · 31/12/2021 09:15

Working Class - you and your ancestors had to work to live.

Middle Class - you use other people to provide your means of living. You can move down but not up.

Upper Class - your distant ancestors killed other people to amass capital so that neither you nor your more recent ancestors had to work for a living.

daisymade · 31/12/2021 09:13

Money is irrelevant of class - there are plenty of rats with gold teeth with millions in the bank who will always be working class.

MasterGland · 31/12/2021 09:13

Money is not a class signifier. Nor is having to work. Almost all the middle classes have to work.
Many in the upper classes do have a different attitude to money, though. They seek to maintain wealth, which is essentially money NOT spent. Hence the crumbling old country piles and holey cardigans stereotypes. The middle classes use money as a class signifier, which means it has to be spent, so that everyone can see it: cars, houses,kitchens, designer clothes etc.

UserBot99 · 31/12/2021 09:10

Yes, it's embarrassing. I'm Irish and you never see threads about class on Irish parenting sites. I don't think you would see these threads on German, French, Scandinavian parenting sites!

Why do British people buy in to a labelling system that puts 90% of them at the ''bottom''.
Reject it.

DrSbaitso · 31/12/2021 09:07

Whence this MN obsession? And why?

CouldThisReallyBe · 31/12/2021 09:04

I've never got my head around the class system (didn't grow up in UK) but how it was explained to me once (about 20 years ago) was that manual/unskilled workers and tradesmen are considered working class and tertiary educated/professionals are considered middle class. Sounds absolutely bonkers to me and I'm sure that's changed in the last 20 years.

I think ignorance is bliss TBH as I have no idea whether I'm being judged for using the right word for items (as an aside...WTF is that about??)

OhdearOhdearOhdearIndeed · 31/12/2021 09:01

I don't think there is a clear system. People are complicated. The more I've become aware of this and the facade some people project, the more judgements based on perceived class feel irrelevant. You can never tell.

Some people on the surface are very wealthy and would be judged as middle class, but would be in danger of losing it all very quickly with some bad decisions, so I think it is a very superficial way of evaluating someone's norms and values.

I tend to judge people on the way they treat other people in the first instance. Some decent people will have a very healthy bank account, but it would not be very obvious as they lead a very simple life.

rainbowandglitter · 31/12/2021 08:58

@Fairyliz

I don’t know because this is something I’ve only ever read about on MN where people seem obsessed with class. In real life I have never had a discussion about someone’s class and I’m in my 60’s.
Same here. I've never heard anybody at all mentioned class outside of mumsnet.
Elodeastar · 31/12/2021 08:56

I don't understand the obsession with labelling people into classes though, why do people care so much?

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 31/12/2021 08:55

If in doubt re class, it’s always helpful to check if the parents use a dummy on the baby.

MasterGland · 31/12/2021 08:53

I quite like ruminating about class. I recommend Grayson Perry's series "All in the best possible taste', but it is essentially as @Malariahilaria describes above.

In modern Britain there is a huge middle class now, and a smaller working class than before. The upper classes stay pretty static as you can only really access it by birth or marriage.
The upper classes are exceptionally self assured, and have no need to prove their position in the hierarchy. Working classes are usually quite proud and also have an assuredness about their place in society, usually with stronger community ties. The middle classes are where all the action is. Many want to be seen as upper class, and definitely not working class. This drives a lot of the consumer behaviour we see. It is not just consumerism though, as can be seen recently with some threads on here about baby names and jobs. Everything must be 'respectable'.

pilates · 31/12/2021 08:52

I’ve never really thought about it.

If my husband and I didn’t work we wouldn’t be able to live so I’m working class which I imagine is the majority of people.

Kanaloa · 31/12/2021 08:49

Realistically you don’t decide because the vast majority of people are working class. In my experience the only people who go on about class are a specific type who are working class but think they’re ‘better than.’ They look down on things they associate with the ‘working class’ to kind of imply that their own taste is superior.

MintJulia · 31/12/2021 08:48

For me, real class is a mix of good manners, value placed on education, tolerance and the ability to get on with almost anyone.

Some people obviously have a headstart depending on their family history but anyone can achieve it.

hugr · 31/12/2021 08:48

@Bouncer500

It isn't real.

There are rich people and poor people. Plenty of people with piles of money have no class and plenty of people who have been poor for generations are full of class.

Working class, middle class, upper class is silly crap. People either have class or they don't and it isn't related to money or housing.

Having "class" and the class system are different things.
TopCatsTopHat · 31/12/2021 08:47

@WhiteCatmas

We don’t because it is silly. Get on with your life OP.
It's just a conversation, no need to be scathing.
TopCatsTopHat · 31/12/2021 08:46

Then they're is social mobility so your class isn't fixed all your life anyway. Though that used to be more possible to achieve than it is these days.
I was poor growing up and now I'm comfortable but not well off, father was a labourer I have a profession, so if day I was working class but now I'm middle class. But I never ask someone what they do for a living when I meet them, such a tedious way to start a conversation, and I judge people by how they treat others above anything else.

WhiteCatmas · 31/12/2021 08:45

We don’t because it is silly.
Get on with your life OP.

PodcastFunFair · 31/12/2021 08:45

Traditionally it was based on educational attainment and occupation but its much more layered and complex now.
I personally think its quite fluid and decided by other peoples point of view. Depending on who was viewing me I could be very much working class or middle class.

Waspsarearseholes · 31/12/2021 08:45

Very few people are upper class. For example, the Middleton family are firmly middle class. The farming family, regardless of assets, will be working class. The university lecturer would, on paper, be middle class.

magicstars · 31/12/2021 08:45

I consider class to be fading out to an extent. Many more people are 'middle class'.

For me is class, education, job type, social awareness & understanding, sometimes earnings.

I'd say the farmers are middle class, the educated person in the council house is also middle class.

Most Non Brits tend not to be classified by class by Brits.

girlmom21 · 31/12/2021 08:43

In the UK, anyway. Apart form those desperate to prove they're better than someone else.

girlmom21 · 31/12/2021 08:42

People don't care about class anymore.

Bluntness100 · 31/12/2021 08:39

Op. Class isn’t about how much your house is worth or what you earn, or the condition of your house.

Technically both are middle class, one runs a business, the farmers, they do much more than farm the land as labourers, and the second is also in a skilled role.

Class covers many factors, but generally the key indicators are unskilled Labour working for a wage is working class, skilled and salaried is middle class, business owners would be skilled generally, clearly not possibly soneone who sells body lotion on a pyramid scheme, but something like owning and managing a large farm would be.